Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
alexdgr8 · 05/12/2021 01:05

@StopGo

What I object to is the two tier charging policy. Care/nursing homes locally charge between £1000 and £1300 per week to privately funded clients. The same beds/rooms are ‘sold’ to social services for £550 per week. Self funders subsidies the rest. So so wrong.
but what's the alternative, without a whole-scale reform. you can't have the publically funded clients live in a shed in the garden of the care home. ?threadbare sheets/blankets. diet of gruel. work picking oakum. that was tried, re the deserving poor. the undeserving got nothing.
onlychildhamster · 05/12/2021 00:06

@Mellowyellow222 But your parents would have the ability to pick their care home if they pay for it themselves. A luxury people whose care is covered by the state don't have.

Its the same argument as with council vs private housing. For a council tenant in London vs someone who buys or rents privately in the next street. The council tenant would only need to pay subsidized rent, gets a stable place to live and can even decorate. The person who buys often has to work really hard to save up a huge deposit and takes on financial risk i.e. if the mortgage can't be paid for whatever reason, all the person's life savings could be lost. So you could say the person who buys a property is an utter mug because he or she is working so hard for a roof over their head when you could potentially get a council house by working fewer hours or not working at all. But what the person who buys is paying for is Choice- he can buy whatever he or she likes in whatever location and also often with the desired number of bedrooms (while the council tenant is left with whatever he or she is allocated). So not many people would be envious of the council tenant; just like I wouldn't be envious of the person without money to pay for care and is left in whatever care home the government sticks him or her in.

onlychildhamster · 04/12/2021 23:57

I think its because not everyone would need care.

I read a stat that 1 in 10 people would end up in a care home. The rest wouldn't. But if they get cancer or a stroke (and die of it), their treatment is 100% free. So its luck of the draw whether you will get dementia or cancer in your old age.

LuluBlakey1 · 04/12/2021 23:42

Would any of these help to make anything feel fairer.

  1. A benefits cap across a lifetime for each person- not sure how it could be made to work but worth a thought.
Get rid of the £86,000 rule and make it a tax instead on those who require social care. Either:
  1. A % of a property, (sold after death if necessary), that went towards social care eg anyone requiring social care at any stage in life who owned a property - or whose parents do- is required to hand over 20% of the value of the property (valued at the time they enter social care) as a contribution to their care. So if a house is valued at 200,000, it's £40,000, if it's valued at 1000,000, it's 200,000. It would be 20% of every property owned at the point a person entered social care. If you are married your 20% is of half of your property value each.
  2. If you don't own a property but have savings it would be 20% of savings given as a lump sum when you entered care.
  3. NHS would not issue prescriptions to anyone for anything you can buy in a chemist not on prescription. eg painkillers, eye ointment, dry eye drops, calpol, etc. And make more medicines available over the counter not on prescription
6.We pay a £10.00 charge for every GP appointment or pay £100 a year to GP practice.
Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 23:30

@ronniz. To clarify, what I meant when I agreed with you about the wealth tax is that everyone should pay more towards elder care, not just the self-payers currently in care homes. My Dad (and your parents from what you've said) could afford to pay a wealth tax that would help to support those needing care.

alexdgr8 · 04/12/2021 23:15

@RandomMess

People want it both ways, they don't care for their parents and still inherit 🤷🏽‍♀️
and what of those who do do the daily care of their parents, all of it, and still end up homeless, never mind any inheritance.
Mellowyellow222 · 04/12/2021 22:49

What bothers my parents is they worked hard all their lives and paid taxes.

They could have to sell their home to pay for care, when someone who was either unemployed, or spent their money rather than bought a house, will get he same level of care for free.

In my parents generation there is a lot of bitterness about the welfare state and how much they perceive people on benefits get.

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 22:31

The only way to spread it fairly across society is a wealth tax which would mean some elderly people would have to pay more.

I personally think that’s reasonable.

H0tJarSpicy · 04/12/2021 22:22

I haven't read all the thread

Some people also have an emotional attachment to property, its contents & memories. Especially, if the property was a forever home.

You could have someone who had lived somewhere for 70, 80 years.

There is a difference between selling a property before someone has passed & after they have passed.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 22:21

@Cameleongirl from April 2022 there is a NI increase so say you earn 50k a yr you will pay an extra £550 a yr in tax. From 2023 that changes to a health & social levy and older people working but not paying NI will also have to pay it. It's quite a significant tax increase particularly as the tax bands are frozen for a few years. Employers NI contributions are also increasing.

The only way to spread it fairly across society is a wealth tax which would mean some elderly people would have to pay more. Younger generations won't have the same housing wealth hence the new levy.

Figmentofmyimagination · 04/12/2021 22:14

The divides between nhs care in a hospital setting, “social” care in a residential care home, and “nursing” care in a nursing home are entirely artificial and political - a political decision based on how long illnesses last, the recognition that most people needing this kind of care do not recover, and the understanding that you can persuade enough of the electorate that the nature of illness and suffering changes once you leave a hospital.

I would rather see social and nursing care funded by an aggressively policed and far more expansive inheritance tax, so that everyone with property contributes through property taxes, rather than just those who suffer an illness that leads them to need long periods of care. We wouldn’t accept this for care provided in a hospital, so why does it suddenly become acceptable just because someone is in a nursing home. The risk of long term illness should be shared by everyone with property - not just those who fall ill and their families.

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 22:12

I haven’t lived in the UK for years so I’m not familiar with the current tax codes, I’m sure you know more, @ronnitz.

My point is that the current SS vs. self-payer fee structure seems odd and surely there must be a better way to spread the cost of elder care across society. Getting a pool of self payers to pay significantly more doesn’t seem the most logical way to do it, it’s unreliable for a start.

turnaroundtime · 04/12/2021 22:10

@Chely

Many sign their houses over to their children to avoid this. Work hard and pay taxes for most of your life then have to sell your assets to pay for care. A person who paid little to nothing gets the same care free of charge because they have no assets.
So people save hard all their lives and think they are more virtuous than those on benefits but at the end of the day they are exactly the same and expect the tax payer to fund their old age. Somehow they don't seem to think they are receiving benefits but a state funded old age is still a tax payer financed benefit Hmm
ronniz · 04/12/2021 22:08

The new health & social care bill will help fund things I assume as from 2023 it applies to everyone earning regardless of age.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 04/12/2021 21:59

Money gets you into a better/nicer care home!

Money gets you into a prettier care home, but please don't assume that equates to better care.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 21:49

I think it would make more sense to spread the cost across the whole of society though. Just like education, state pensions, etc.

But some of it is as many people pay CT for example. And when you say spread across all do you mean only those working?

Cameleongirl · 04/12/2021 21:44

But its not really a burden on them is it? They have reached a point in their lives where their assets are of no further use to them, so what harm is being done to them if that asset funds care?

@5128gap. I think it would make more sense to spread the cost across the whole of society though. Just like education, state pensions, etc.

Increased inheritance tax is another way of funding elder care. That way, my great-aunt who died at 102 without going into a home would have contributed far more to someone else’s care, IYSWIM.

MrsBobDylan · 04/12/2021 21:35

I listened to a radio phone in on this topic and one caller said her parents had been frugal all their lives, worked hard, lived in a nice house but had always wanted to go on a cruise.

Then, in their 80s, they both needed care and their entire estate went to pay for the care. And no cruise.

It was weird, as though having to pay for care in their 80s had robbed them of going on a cruise, when they had in fact, had 40 years and enough funds.

I think if you are genuinely not invested in the idea of inheritance (and I'm not) then the idea of all your parents money going on care seems quite practical.

chickenpie1984 · 04/12/2021 21:30

I think if you can afford to/ have assets you should pay towards your care but I think it should be capped. However my dsis is a SW in adults social care and does lots of care assessments. People who have been on benefits and never worked get their care for 'free' and it's automatic, but someone else who has worked and owned their home (which most people want to pass on to their family) have to go through rigorous assessment, sometimes taking months and then end up paying for their care- which is so high, here it is £800 per week standard. We live in an area where homes cost £100-200k, so we're not talking about millionaires.
I don't know what the solution is but it seems grossly unfair.

Comedycook · 04/12/2021 21:25

So you can think of one person who was an alcoholic and claimed benefits and that's enough to convince you that all the amazing, hard working, tax paying home owners shouldn't have to sell their homes to fund their care? Righto...

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 21:25

@Intercity225
So you fundamentally believe some people deserve dignity and care in old age and others don’t. Because of their life choices, or becoming ill.

Interesting. You Sound like a nice person.

Intercity225 · 04/12/2021 21:22

I don't get your point...my dad was an alcoholic. It killed him. He never claimed a penny in benefits and when he died we paid over 200k in inheritance tax. I have no idea why you have chosen alcoholics as your example...those people are ill...not scum.

As I said, that was one person I was thinking of, and while your DF may have never claimed benefits, the person I am thinking of did. I never said they were scum!

I was also thinking of two other couples - one did fritter their money away, and the other scrimped and saved. Just because you haven't come across it, doesn't mean to say, I am imagining it!

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 21:18

But why shouldn’t the LA get a bulk discount
That’s capitalism

You can’t have capitalism for the good bits where you win. And socialism for the bits you don’t want to pay for.
That’s not how it works.

Intercity225 · 04/12/2021 21:16

Where are the facts that the self funded pay triple those of LA funded? Anyone got a link

No, but the figures I quoted in my earlier post came from a talk I attended last week, by the Director of Adult Social Services here, at a conference. Iirc, he said they pay £549 per week for an elderly person in a care home, while self funders pay £1,000 - £1,200 per week, so the real cost of a place is likely to be £549 + £1,200, divided by two - about £850. (he actually said £862).

Comedycook · 04/12/2021 21:08

@Intercity225

Not everyone who rents is a feckless layabout who has frittered away their cash...what a weird thought process.

I didn't say everybody; but I am thinking of some real people, who are not products of my thought processes! One of whom is an alcoholic! Do you agree that some alcoholics are likely to lose everything through their addiction - their house, marriage, family.....?

I don't get your point...my dad was an alcoholic. It killed him. He never claimed a penny in benefits and when he died we paid over 200k in inheritance tax. I have no idea why you have chosen alcoholics as your example...those people are ill...not scum.
Swipe left for the next trending thread