Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
crossstitchingnana · 05/12/2021 07:46

It's not fair if one person pays as they have a house and another person doesn't. Simple.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 05/12/2021 07:39

What I hear more is the guilt that we can't look after Regen ourselves

THEM not Regen. How the hell did it autocorrect to that?

gofg · 05/12/2021 07:37

Equally if she goes into a home, when her house cash runs out she will be moved to a cheaper one

You have got to be kidding!! Is this how it works in the UK? Where I live, when the cash runs out the government take over the payments and you stay in the same home.

Figmentofmyimagination · 05/12/2021 07:33

itisthecause thanks for writing about the reality of long-term costs for degenerative illnesses. I sometimes think about this when eg NICE announces the funding for a new amazing NHS drug at £thousands a dose, or we hear about the cost of each hospital bed or even each stay in prison. Not paying for your dad’s Parkinson’s care is a political choice that is enabled by the ability to engage in cheap arguments that appeal to people’s tabloid sense of ‘what is right’.because they can never imagine it happening to them or their families so they can drone on from what they imagine to be the moral high ground like the OP. This is a cost that should be shared through taxation by everyone who can afford to pay, not just those who fall ill with long term illnesses and their families.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 05/12/2021 07:32

@Thatldo

You speak from my hear.I also was not born in Britain,but live here for many many years.I absolutely agree with every word you said OP.It must be the children's greed or entitlement to an inheritance.maybe very so often it would be worth mentioning:you can spend your money when you are dead,so you might as well spend it for decent care.nothing lasts forever!
I'm sorry but I don't understand why people are able to make such sweeping statements. Exactly what statistically sound research are you and OP basing these claims on? Everyone I know is accepting of the fact that our parents' homes will be sold to pay for their care. What I hear more is the guilt that we can't look after Regen ourselves. Whilst of course there are some people who are greedy and entitled, in my experience these are in the minority.. I find your claims really offensive to be honest.
itisthecause · 05/12/2021 07:25

I don't think it's necessarily greed or entitlement of children's parts - parents want to leave something to their children.

My Dad is 'happy' to pay but that doesn't mean he wouldn't have liked to leave his grandchildren something from his assets, which is very unlikely.

Thatldo · 05/12/2021 06:55

You speak from my hear.I also was not born in Britain,but live here for many many years.I absolutely agree with every word you said OP.It must be the children's greed or entitlement to an inheritance.maybe very so often it would be worth mentioning:you can spend your money when you are dead,so you might as well spend it for decent care.nothing lasts forever!

yoyo1234 · 05/12/2021 06:54

@Nat6999
The fund should go to fund those without a fund. With tax some pay in more than they take out , we have taxes to help support those that need it. I pay tax if I decide to eg send children to private school/use private healthcare should I demand my tax back!

Isabellabasil · 05/12/2021 06:46

@ronniz

Because people who chose not to work, that get handouts all their life, thanks to my hard work and my relatives hard work.

You can't generalise like that. I have a home, have I worked harder than those that haven't? No I just was helped on to the ladder by parents & prices weren't so crazy then.

A million times this.
Gooseysgirl · 05/12/2021 06:44

The 'deprivation of assets' is interesting and I wonder if some people still manage to avoid paying for their own care having knowingly done this. My MIL was widowed 40 years ago while DH and his siblings were little. She has lived very frugally ever since (often mentions being 'hard-up' in the early years of being widowed) but has savings and owns her house that's currently worth about £600k. Her view is that if her DH had lived, the kids would have had a better childhood financially and she wants to protect their inheritance... she worked full-time but had to sell his business when he died to make ends meet. She worked full time for over 50 years (ironically for the NHS!) until she retired in her early 70s. She is adamant that if she needs residential care that they won't have to lose the money they stand to inherit. So she signed 3/4 of the house over to them about five years ago. She's now in her early 80s, and other than some mobility issues is thankfully in good health. I sympathise with her view, but all her DC are currently plodding along financially, work full time in good jobs, definitely not wealthy but on property ladder, can afford annual holiday etc. I think there are grounds here for deprivation of assets if she eventually needs care 🤷🏻‍♀️ but she is adamant about protecting their inheritance!

MsJinks · 05/12/2021 06:43

It’s not as simple as they can pay for nice care, as I said upthread - my mum is currently paying for care in the home, but her savings will run out and then she will get less care in the home which isn’t nice for her. Equally if she goes into a home, when her house cash runs out she will be moved to a cheaper one. This must apply to many, many elderly who have some savings, and a 1-2 hundred k home. Also, as someone pointed out we get the social worker regularly around checking and assessing. A separate point is the carers not having time to do a decent job and some breaking stuff lately when she pays 425 a week so generally you’d expect a reasonable service for those costs. It varies from council to council but my mother pays £25 per hour per carer though it is then capped at 425. One council in London charges nothing - that’s right, 0 pounds, but others also charge more. One of my daughters is a carer and gets less than NMW overnight as it’s called a sleep in, even when it isn’t. Money is made by private firms and cost is not really equitable.
There is so much wrong and/or broken with the system that needs fixing and whilst glad at least this is recognised now just haphazardly throwing cash at it via NI or as much from those average savers/owners who can pay as possible is not resolving these issues, seems unfair to the squeezed average elderly homeowner, and so is continuing to cause resentment.
Current elderly probably never expected to pay, so they are bound to be a bit upset or puzzled by it. Not many would rather get an inheritance than see their relatives cared for, but this has turned into yet another us/them argument like we see with benefits/migrants etc etc when really we need to be on the same side and seeking fairness for all.

110APiccadilly · 05/12/2021 06:36

I agree with you, OP. I think the argument is that it's not fair that some people have to sell their houses and some don't and can leave them to their children, but isn't it also unfair that some people don't have houses to leave in the first place?! Inheritance (which I'm not against per se) is unfair.

Nat6999 · 05/12/2021 06:22

ronniz add say 5% on to workplace pension contributions, give tax relief like pension payments, the Health & social care levy can go towards basic care & the personal contributions go towards anything else, make it compulsory, if someone pays from age 20 to retirement age then it will amount to a good size pot to cover care & care home fees, make a base rate for lower earners up to £75k & a higher rate for higher earners.

itisthecause · 05/12/2021 06:21

My father has had Parkinson's for 18 years, for the last 5 years he has been unable to stand or walk and is effectively bed/chair bound.

We have done everything to try to keep Dad at home as that's what he wants and he is 'happy' to pay. That now amounts to over £5000 a month in carers costs not including normal bills. Our carers are amazing and have become part of the family as we spend many hours there a week too doing his shopping/cleaning/gardening/ maintenance of his home.

It can be exhausting and depressing and there have been many moments of drama, need for ambulances, emergency repairs, let alone the endless issues with medical support access, it all has had a massive impact on us all.

Whilst my Dad is 'happy' to pay and has equity released to do so - it's shocking to pay any sort of bill each month that's £5000 as when else do we ever spend that sum of money on anything? He is philosophical and jokes he no longer owns the upstairs of his property.

He is only 74 and has been widowed for nearly 18 years, Parkinson's has destroyed physically who he was and what he enjoyed doing but he jokes sometimes it would be nice to spend the care costs on something a bit more fun for a change.

I think families dealing with any sort of long term care whether a child or an adult know how hard the financial and emotional impact are.

Its natural parents want to financially help their children/grandchildren and I think it must be quite hard to see all your assets and savings go completely as my Dads probably will. We try to reassure him that's not important.

ronniz · 05/12/2021 05:30

If the fund is never used it could be paid to the person's family after their death. Anyone who hasn't a fund just gets very basic care & care home provided by the state.

And if you don't use it & it goes to the family instead what funds those without a fund?

ronniz · 05/12/2021 05:29

@Nat6999 there is a new health & social care tax, I don't think people are going to be able to give up anymore of their income.

Nat6999 · 05/12/2021 05:25

It would be better if everyone from when they started work paid a deduction like you do for workplace pensions towards care when you eventually need it, either to the state or to an insurance company, it could be tax deductible like pension contributions & you could pay extra payments if you wanted to so you would have enough in your account for better care or a better care home. If the fund is never used it could be paid to the person's family after their death. Anyone who hasn't a fund just gets very basic care & care home provided by the state.

Nat6999 · 05/12/2021 05:11

My parents were lucky enough to buy the house they rented as sitting tenants when the landlady died, they got it for £2k when it was worth probably 3 or 4 times that. My grandparents paid for it so that they wouldn't have to have a mortgage, my parents ploughed all their time & money renovating the house turning it in to a wonderful home. That house is now worth £250k, my parents always worked & never claimed a penny in benefits, my dad passed away 3 years ago & my mum continues to live there as they future proofed the house putting in a walk in shower, stairlift, grab rails etc. When anything happens to my mum the house will be sold & the proceeds split between me & my brother, there will be enough for me to either buy my council home or buy a bigger ex council house which will mean I will no longer have to claim housing benefit as I am unable to work due to disability. My housing benefit now is £5k a year, imagine if I live for another 30 years that is £150k that I will save the state at today's prices. Why should someone have to sell their home to fund what is in the most crap care in rubbish care homes when someone who owns a £500k home will have to pay less than 20% of the value of their home?

gofg · 05/12/2021 04:31

If my mother hadn't spent her last few years in care I would probably have been left enough money to buy a house of my own.

However, I couldn't care less that I inherited much less because she had to pay for her care. I would far rather she have been well cared for in the last few years of her life than inherit her money. I cannot believe the greed and entitlement of those who think they have a right to their parents' money, and it should not be used for their care in old age. If you want money, earn your own!

ShineySparkleyChrissmassy · 05/12/2021 04:27

@H0tJarSpicy

I haven't read all the thread

Some people also have an emotional attachment to property, its contents & memories. Especially, if the property was a forever home.

You could have someone who had lived somewhere for 70, 80 years.

There is a difference between selling a property before someone has passed & after they have passed.

That's unfortunate but nothing to do with funding. If someone was struggling excessively and couldn't get over this emotional impact then medical care kicks in and they become eligible for antidepressants or counselling. It's not a reason why people should keep their houses and not pay for care.

and what of those who do do the daily care of their parents, all of it, and still end up homeless, never mind any inheritance.

The state has provision in place for homeless people too. I know it's imperfect and provision depends on area/number of homeless etc but there is a system.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 05/12/2021 04:19

The argument about working hard all my life to afford my house is too simplistic. Many, many people work hard all their lives but are not in a position to buy a house because they are priced out of the market.

DH and I own our house, and it's worth double what we paid for it 20 years ago. We haven't paid any tax on the increase in value. We now have a spare bedroom as DS2 has moved out, and will have another one when DS1 eventually moves out. Someone who has worked just as hard as us but in a lower paid job and who is in a council house would be forced to move or pay a bedroom tax due to having an unused bedroom. If they were in private rented accommodation then have no real security, can't make changes they might want to their home, might not even be allowed to paint the walls their preferred colour.

DH and I bought a house not to give an inheritance to our children but so that we had somewhere secure to live. Buying our own home has given us choices.

HighlandPony · 05/12/2021 04:11

I think the real question is how many of these people would choose that existence? It’s big business. Mother nature decided it was your time but modern medicine developed a pill to keep you in existence just long enough to fleece you of all you have. Care home operators are cashing in while staff have low wages and horrible working conditions. I don’t want to sell my house so some rich board members can get richer while some single mum on minimum wage wipes my backside. Phone dignitas. Or the local farm vet. I don’t care I’d rather check out on my own terms.

StopGo · 05/12/2021 03:54

@Thursdaymiami

But why shouldn’t the LA get a bulk discount That’s capitalism

You can’t have capitalism for the good bits where you win. And socialism for the bits you don’t want to pay for.
That’s not how it works.

That in a nutshell is my point. The care industry is a lucrative industry for some people.
StopGo · 05/12/2021 03:52

[quote Cameleongirl]@StopGo. So they told you what your DF would have to pay as a self funder and what SS would pay if he wasn’t self-funding?[/quote]
Yes. They gave me a 'budget' for the emergency provision, then when we were considering our options they openly explained the charge differences.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2021 03:02

But what about those of us with disabled dc who wont be able to manage independently?

My home is my gift to them to ensure they are safe when I'm gone. I have saved the government hundreds of thousands by giving up my career to become their carer and sacrificed my ability to save or have a decent pension.

Hell will freeze over before I let the government take the house off them to pay for my care.