Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 06/12/2021 14:09

@CHIRIBAYA

I agree. I wany my children to inherit because that is the only way they will ever be able to afford a home and pay off astronomical student debt. People should not be made to feel ashamed for wanting to support their children; I certainly don't and if others want to abandon theirs to fate, then I wish them all the luck in the world as according to this thread, that is what gets you a home and assets.
To be fair, you are advocating that your children should get the ability to buy a house based entirely on luck - the luck of being born to parents who own property.
AndreaC67 · 06/12/2021 14:01

Should read - have never understood this argument...sorry

AndreaC67 · 06/12/2021 14:00

That comes from the tax payer, and if we funded everyone's care from it then we'd be needing to raise taxes quite a bit I would think in order to cover that - increasing the tax burden on the generation that's working when we're at an age we may need social care. It's got to be paid for one way or another

Have understood this argument.
We are spending 100s of billions on railways, track and trace, nuclear weapons and billions more on higher rate pension tax relief.

Yet cannot afford to pay carers a decent wage and expect people who have done the right thing and saved for a house to sell it to pay for their last year or two of care.

Increased carers wages also benefits their communities as they spend it in their locality, pensions are invested worldwide.

BigWoollyJumpers · 06/12/2021 13:44

The issue with death taxes is that most peoples estates are very small, the majority leaving little or nothing. Other inheritances are between husband and wife, you can't tax that. So, you are once again relying on a small proportion of the population to pick up the bill for everyone else. It's all very well to say the rich should always pay, but there is never enough of them to pick up the bill for the rest, the majority, of the population.

itisthecause · 06/12/2021 10:40

@Kennykenkencat

Figmentofmyimagination

What I don’t understand is why, if you can raise ‘enough’ with a capped contribution of £80k from those unfortunate enough to fall ill or become too infirm to remain in their own home, you can’t raise the same amount as a much smaller ‘death tax’ on everyone, levied as a proportion of their estate

Because where there is a tax there is a tax loop hole and you would find that those who are supposed to be paying it are not and it is left to those who don’t have tax accountants at their disposal to not only to pay the original taxation but also the shortfall.

This kind of taxation would be a fairer option to aim for but would need to able to resist accountants finding loopholes.
Kennykenkencat · 06/12/2021 09:31

Figmentofmyimagination

What I don’t understand is why, if you can raise ‘enough’ with a capped contribution of £80k from those unfortunate enough to fall ill or become too infirm to remain in their own home, you can’t raise the same amount as a much smaller ‘death tax’ on everyone, levied as a proportion of their estate

Because where there is a tax there is a tax loop hole and you would find that those who are supposed to be paying it are not and it is left to those who don’t have tax accountants at their disposal to not only to pay the original taxation but also the shortfall.

Figmentofmyimagination · 06/12/2021 08:33

What I don’t understand is why, if you can raise ‘enough’ with a capped contribution of £80k from those unfortunate enough to fall ill or become too infirm to remain in their own home, you can’t raise the same amount as a much smaller ‘death tax’ on everyone, levied as a proportion of their estate.

Nat6999 · 06/12/2021 04:23

There should be a ban on care companies making a profit from care, both home care & care homes. Too many care companies are making a mint out of elderly & disabled people who are vulnerable, provide sub standard care & pay their staff minimum wage. My ex husband has carers as he is badly disabled by MS, if he has a fall they aren't trained to get him up even though he has an electric hoist, they just ring ds as first contact & expect him to do it, ds is 17 & isn't trained either but that doesn't matter as if anything goes wrong he can't be sued. He has sometimes been on the floor for up to 19 hours.

Maverickess · 06/12/2021 00:16

[quote Narutocrazyfox]@maverickess where does the money for care come from for those with no assets currently? That's where I expect it to come from.

I'm not being flippant here - I genuinely believe it's criminal to strip an elderly person of their home to fund their care. If you have savings/additional assets, then I agree you should be helping to fund your care, but your home should always be protected.[/quote]
That comes from the tax payer, and if we funded everyone's care from it then we'd be needing to raise taxes quite a bit I would think in order to cover that - increasing the tax burden on the generation that's working when we're at an age we may need social care. It's got to be paid for one way or another.
I agree that the system currently is rubbish, part funded by government, part funded by the 'customer', mostly run by private firms with profit at the heart of it, but really the provision, on the floor, that determines the level of care isn't good enough imo, whether that be because the money going in isn't enough or the money isn't getting where it's needed most is hotly debated, but the reality is social care needs to be paid for, and ideally paid more for in total so that standards improve and workers in the social care system don't end up in the position of caring for others for a pittance and then being maligned for not being able to afford to fund it themselves.

Narutocrazyfox · 05/12/2021 23:41

@maverickess where does the money for care come from for those with no assets currently? That's where I expect it to come from.

I'm not being flippant here - I genuinely believe it's criminal to strip an elderly person of their home to fund their care. If you have savings/additional assets, then I agree you should be helping to fund your care, but your home should always be protected.

itisthecause · 05/12/2021 23:31

Should inheritance tax not be increased anyway to help even things out a bit?

And why is it such a black or white issue for people ? Is there not a middle ground?

stairway · 05/12/2021 23:23

Narutocrazyfox everyone pays into the system but it isn’t enough. Hopefully you won’t need care but I don’t think there is any guarantees of inheritance for your children. If enough wealthy homeowners try and dodge the system loopholes will be closed or the government will just massively increase inheritance tax.

Maverickess · 05/12/2021 23:21

[quote Narutocrazyfox]@emmagrundyforpm I feel for anyone who wants to get onto the property ladder but can't. But what's your point?

The op was talking specifically about selling your home to pay for care. Something I'm (along with many others) am not prepared to do.[/quote]
This isn't a snarky question, I genuinely want to know, where do you forsee the money coming from to fund your care and everyone else's who want to leave their homes to their children instead of paying for care?
And it's not really the government that gets it, people like me get some for delivering the care (should we expect people to deliver care for free and if so, what do they live on?) The rest goes to a private company that arranges delivery of the care, (though they do pay tax so the government gets some of it) and the costs associated with that - and of course, profit.

Narutocrazyfox · 05/12/2021 23:18

@stairway By the time I retire, I will have paid into the system for around 50 years - my care will certainly not be free!

You've highlighted a very important point - many young people will not be able to afford their own home. Precisely why my home will go to my children.

stairway · 05/12/2021 23:10

Narutocrazyfox I think the point is someone has to pay for it, if those that can afford to don’t then it falls on younger tax payers to pay for it, many of whom will never be able to buy their own home.

Narutocrazyfox · 05/12/2021 22:59

@emmagrundyforpm I feel for anyone who wants to get onto the property ladder but can't. But what's your point?

The op was talking specifically about selling your home to pay for care. Something I'm (along with many others) am not prepared to do.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 05/12/2021 22:54

@Narutocrazyfox. and many other people work really hard,pay their taxes and never manage to get on the property ladder.

Narutocrazyfox · 05/12/2021 22:50

I've worked my whole adult life to buy a home for my children - and I've paid tax on every single penny I've earned and spent.

Damned if the government are getting my house to pay for my care (if needed). My house is going to my children. I will be signing it over to them when they are slightly older. If you have a clever accountant you can avoid as all this nonsense.

Maverickess · 05/12/2021 22:42

I think there needs to be thought into where the money is going and not just where it's coming from.
Care home fees cover the basic costs of living - a roof over your head, food, gas, electric, cleaning, maintenance, bedding, towel, TV licence, gardening, security and then for care and maintenance of things that are needed to care - staff (and the costs they incur like DBS, tax and NI, training, uniforms, PPE as well as wages*) equipment like hoists, stand aids, slide sheets and profiling beds and the extra electricity to run the ones that rely on it, maintenance of them, replacement, replacing items broken and ruined by residents due to their needs or behaviour like chairs, tables etc.

*I'll just say that not all but many companies expect staff to buy their own DBS, uniform and don't pay for training, some I have heard charge staff for training (though that's never happened anywhere I've worked).

In theory, the more you pay, the better care you should get because there should be more staff, better trained and paid, more equipment that's better, better food etc. But every home has to meet the needs of their residents, maybe room 3 doesn't need a hoist now, so why are they paying towards it? But what if they fall and need it for a few weeks - should they then pay more? Or should the home use the hoist they already have anyway and should they have these things regardless because a high proportion of residents will need one at some point?

What I'm saying is that does all the money that's being paid by self funders and LAs go towards care and there's a shortfall so the costs aren't being met? Or are we funding bargain style care to maintain company profits?
I know one thing, the workers delivering the care aren't getting a very good deal either, especially when they're paying for the essentials to do the job themselves out of minimum wage and the residents aren't getting much of a good deal if they're paying more than the LA will but recieving the same care.

Ultimately though, funding everyone for free social is going to cost a lot more in the way of tax than we pay now, which will be ok for the higher earners, not so great for people like me who can barely survive on what I earn now never mind with more taken off.
I don't know what the fairest answer is, but I don't think any model of funding will ever be truly fair for everyone.

Figmentofmyimagination · 05/12/2021 22:22

hellodulling but why, in that case, don’t people get charged for their food, cleaning, bed etc when in an NHS hospital? There’s no difference in principle. It’s just down to location.

itisthecause · 05/12/2021 21:33

Is the issue not more nuanced than to pay yes or no?
Is £5000 a month my Dad pays per month for just care alone in his own home a reasonable amount? - this is a minimal amount of care required for his needs.
All other bills, cleaning, shopping, maintenance, gardening etc are covered separately or done by family.
He is currently on the last amount of 'home' money which will ran out soon having spent £25000 in 5 years.
As a comparison his care is less hours than a daily child care setting.

Ozanj · 05/12/2021 21:10

It’s because this doesn’t impact the rich as their wealth is more likely to be tied up in investments / trusts that don’t count as their wealth in this instance; or they have such big houses that they can make any improvements & buy in (cheaper) home care services; or can negotiate much better private rates at far superior care homes. Only the middle classes really pay hundreds of thousands for absolutely shit care

HelloDulling · 05/12/2021 20:52

Why should care in old age be treated (funded) any differently than say cancer treatment in a much younger person?

Care isn’t just medical treatment though. The costs of being in a care home include rent for your room, someone to do your food shopping/cooking/serving, cleaning, laundry, personal care. Any medical treatment is on top of that. When my friend had her chemo, she was still paying her mortgage, cleaner, food bills etc herself.

astrowars · 05/12/2021 20:38

@BeautifulBirds

Because people who chose not to work, that get handouts all their life, thanks to my hard work and my relatives hard work. Then at the end of life get the same level of care that costs my family £1k a week, for free! That's why I get cross.
And to make it worse, this money will subsidise the care of those who cannot afford to pay for their own, then when your money runs out, you'll be threatened with being moved to a home with lesser care, because there aren't enough self funders to subsidise you, now your assets have all been used up.
astrowars · 05/12/2021 20:31

@ItsDinah

The problem is that if you don't own your own home or other assets, your care will be paid for by the government. If someone is very wealthy this won't bother them. If someone has scrimped and worked hard to acquire savings/house, they will feel hard done by if they have to pay while someone who had similar earnings but did not save does not. This is particularly so as in many parts of the UK, private payers have to pay as much as double what the local authority pays for exactly the same care and accommodation in the same care home. They are in effect subsidising the publicly funded.
This