Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
rwalker · 04/12/2021 16:02

My mum and dads have friends he's been a self employed builder all his working life put the bare minimum through his books and she's was a mobile hairdresser again not paying tax.
They earned more than my mum and dad spent every penny they got done various equity realise on there house . Holidays cars caravans cruises and now have nothing . The state pick up the bill
My mum and dad worked hard paid every tax going no lavish life style or holidays ploughed everything into there home the state would not pick up the bill even though they have contribute more but because they haven't pissed there money up against the wall they get no help .

So basically contribute fuck all and piss your money away state pay
Be sensible contribute loads and in return state give you fuck all

LittlePearl · 04/12/2021 16:02

I believe people with the means to do so should pay for their care, but there are several injustices in the system.

Some care residents are paying inflated rates that effectively cover those that are state funded.

And dementia is a disease. As is Parkinson's, and many other illnesses that do not qualify for NHS funding.

I understand why some people feel aggrieved and think there are ways to make the system more equitable.

Flipflopblowout · 04/12/2021 16:02

When the NHS was set up it was advertised as care from the cradle to the grave. All very ambitious and forward looking after the misery of WW2. However, I do not believe that they could envisage a time when specialist treatments would cost over a million pounds and a course of specialist injections costing over £10,000.00 for each injection. In 1947 many of the operations that are now common place were not even thought viable. The NHS has turned into a dark money pit and recent events have highlighted that the system repeatedly needs to be shored up. I hope that I can leave something for my children and my grand children but dementia appears to be a misery lottery with no winners just all losers in one way or another.

cptartapp · 04/12/2021 16:01

If someone has MS and can't manage at home, or a massive heart attack and needs a care home, or Parkinson's, or osteoporosis of course they will pay. It's not just those with dementia who do.
Imagine allowing your adult child in the prime of their life to actually give up work to become your carer indefinitely. No days out or holidays. The physical and mental drain. You becoming their priority. I would never ever let my Dc do that. Dreadful.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 04/12/2021 16:00

People make choices in life - you either save or spend - it’s your choice. You know the score, so you make a decision.

The thing is I don't think people do know the score. A lot of people assume that with no money, councils will just pick up the bill and I don't think that is true. Councils will fund the bare minimum to keep you safe. Your quality of life is irrelevant to them. We all hear about the council funded carers who spend literally 15 mins getting someone out of bed but have no time to stop and chat. Paying for that yourself gets you someone who will stay for as long as you pay them for.

JassyRadlett · 04/12/2021 16:00

Old people will just splurge their savings on cruises etc too make the most of their savings as there is little incentive to save to pass on to future generations.

Is this really true, though?

First, the incentive is still there. According to Dilnot (2010, so allow for inflation ), 50% of people will spend up to £20k, 10% will spend over £100k. So there’s still a good chance of handing on your wealth.

Second, you’re ignoring another incentive - that of choice. I know that for people of my parents’ generation, being able to pay for and choose a nice care home if they needed, rather than whatever they are allocated by the state, is a strong motivation for protecting some of their assets.

At any rate, it doesn’t sit right with me that I should be able to protect my (partly unearned) asset values at the cost of a younger taxpayer who didn’t have the benefit of being able to get into the housing market when it was easier, or benefiting hugely from house price rises.

Starcup · 04/12/2021 15:59

@Comedycook

most people would like to leave money for their children if possible

Of course but we could apply this attitude to anything. Should the elderly be entitled to free food and utilities so that they don't spend their own money and can leave it to their kids?

Of course not, but if there is no incentive to save, then people will find ways to spend their money or ‘gift it’, so they’ll probably need financial assistance from the government anyway.

I don’t think people shouldn’t pay for their care, but it is frustrating to think that those that make life choices to not work (much) get everything paid and those that try to make provisions and save are told to sell up.

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 15:57

The NHS do pay for care if its a clinical need. I thought everyone knew that. It’s called the NHS continuing care fund and it has nothing to do with social care.
If you need social care then yes of course you should pay it yourself.

The problem is, the government have decided that many ailments don’t come under clinical care, what can you do about it? I guess take the NHS to court, that’s how the continuing care fund came about, from legal action

waitingpatientlyforspring · 04/12/2021 15:57

@ItsDinah

The problem is that if you don't own your own home or other assets, your care will be paid for by the government. If someone is very wealthy this won't bother them. If someone has scrimped and worked hard to acquire savings/house, they will feel hard done by if they have to pay while someone who had similar earnings but did not save does not. This is particularly so as in many parts of the UK, private payers have to pay as much as double what the local authority pays for exactly the same care and accommodation in the same care home. They are in effect subsidising the publicly funded.
This is what many peoples complaints are about.

Owning a house is not unearned income. We pay thousands above loan cost in interest by the time you pay your mortgage off. We work hard to EARN that money to pay our mortgages. So calling a house unearned income is grossly unfair.

User2638483 · 04/12/2021 15:57

The biggest thing that would make a difference is they could find a cure/better treatment for dementia.
If you don’t have a cognitive impairment you’re far more likely to be able to stay in your own home and be safe in between carer visits. If you have dementia then at some point that often becomes untenable because of wandering, mobilising alone when it’s not safe to do so, and other risky behaviour.

If dementia didn’t exist or was less prevalent, less people would need less care home places and for generally much shorter times.

MrsLarry · 04/12/2021 15:56

@Comedycook

Cannot bear the "I've worked hard all my life and paid my taxes" brigade. You worked because you needed money...it's not a huge moral sacrifice. You paid taxes because it's illegal not to and in most cases, it's deducted before we even get our wages. That's life...
I'm out.

There's just no dealing with the stupid people...

Bagamoyo1 · 04/12/2021 15:53

People make choices in life - you either save or spend - it’s your choice. You know the score, so you make a decision.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 04/12/2021 15:53

Old people will just splurge their savings on cruises etc too make the most of their savings as there is little incentive to save to pass on to future generations.

Then they're idiots. Having money made life so much easier for my PILs. They could afford to pay for carers to come in to cook, do stuff round the house, take MIL out on shopping trips etc. And when my FIL died it meant that my DH could bypass SS and just find her a lovely care home that she helped to choose. She is taken out on day trips and the activities co-ordinator runs all sorts of events. I cannot imagine that this happens in homes where councils are paying about £400 a week.

Eustaciavile · 04/12/2021 15:53

@alexdgr8

dementia is a progressive terminal disease. we have a nhs. why are people suffering cancer or heart disease or MS etc not forced to sell their homes to pay for care. that resident daughter may have spent years caring for her mother in her home, getting less than £10 a day in carer's allowance, if she is lucky. there is very little support for family carers. they save the govt millions. then they are pitched out. homeless. probably had to give up work to care for relative, day and night, now too old to get a job, or a mortgage. no priority for social housing. i think people who have not had experience of this have no idea what it is like. imagine having a large heavy toddler, who has to be constantly supervised, fed and washed, inco pads changed in the bed, turned to avoid pressure sores, who may be violent at times, and who regresses, able to do/understand less and less. forgets who you are. whom you love. and doing that all alone usually, day and night. and constant battles with HCPs, to maintain best medical condition. continence care, skin care, all monitoring, soft food, spoon feeding. cannot just pop out, never go on holiday. then if social services intervene and say this relative must go into a nursing home, house sold, family carer tipped out on to street. no one cares for the carer. and the relative while they can still speak, saying thinking at least devoted daughter will be safely housed, even if poor, a roof over their head. that they can, will, want to, leave house to daughter. but they can't. i know whereof i speak. it is a national disgrace. the whole system.
This. 100%
icedcoffees · 04/12/2021 15:53

@Bagamoyo1

I think a lot of people confuse care costs when medical costs. Medical treatment remains free regardless of age or diagnosis. Care homes provide the care you would previously have done yourself, or you family would have done - like washing, dressing, feeding, going to the toilet, getting into bed etc. And plenty of people with cancer and MS end up in care homes, it’s not just the very elderly, so there’s no discrimination . They’re basically for people who can’t manage in a home environment.
Typically people who can't manage in a home environment are that way because of their medical needs, though - be they cognitive decline, dementia, Parkinsons, cancer, ME or any other number of illnesses and disabilities.
zafferana · 04/12/2021 15:52
  1. Because many people scrimp and save to buy a house, going without many things in life to afford one. But someone who didn't do that, who spent their money on other things, get social care on the government with no financial penalty.

  2. Because if that person was ill with a terminal illness, they wouldn't have to pay for their care - it would via the NHS, which is taxpayer funded. So many say why should social care and the kind of care that people need when they've got a condition like dementia be self-funded when treatment and care for those with cancer, heart disease, etc is funded by the government?

What it means is that you're penalised if you're financially prudent and unlucky enough to need social care in your old age.

Comedycook · 04/12/2021 15:50

most people would like to leave money for their children if possible

Of course but we could apply this attitude to anything. Should the elderly be entitled to free food and utilities so that they don't spend their own money and can leave it to their kids?

Bagamoyo1 · 04/12/2021 15:50

I think a lot of people confuse care costs when medical costs. Medical treatment remains free regardless of age or diagnosis. Care homes provide the care you would previously have done yourself, or you family would have done - like washing, dressing, feeding, going to the toilet, getting into bed etc.
And plenty of people with cancer and MS end up in care homes, it’s not just the very elderly, so there’s no discrimination . They’re basically for people who can’t manage in a home environment.

Starcup · 04/12/2021 15:50

@NeedAHoliday2021

Old people will just splurge their savings on cruises etc too make the most of their savings as there is little incentive to save to pass on to future generations.
Exactly.
JassyRadlett · 04/12/2021 15:48

Owning my own home - and having profited from unearned property wealth due to house price inflation - gives me choices others don’t have, if misfortune strikes.

If I lose my job and go through a long period of unemployment, it gives me a cushion - I can downsize and live off the equity for a while; I don’t expect the state to subsidise it beyond baseline benefits when I have a valuable asset.

If my husband dies and my household income dips significantly, I have options that cushion the blow that non-home owners may not have.

If I become incapacitated and can no longer work, we can again downsize and the equity would give us a cushion, I would not expect the state to protect the equity in my home for my kids in that case.

And similarly, if in my old age I need expensive and complex care, I know that the current system and the demographics of our population make it nearly impossible to fund everyone’s care. I know that my assets and in particular the unearned wealth I’ve had as a homeowner in the UK gives me greater choice, and I do not expect the full value of my valuable asset should be preserved for my children, while other people’s children who may not have been so fortunate as I was in terms of employment or home ownership have to pay higher taxes to fully fund my care.

Starcup · 04/12/2021 15:48

@Comedycook

Have you got kids?

Yes and if I can leave them my house, then great. I don't think I should live in my old age entirely subsidised by the tax payer to protect my asset

I don’t think anyone is suggesting no one should have to pay for their care on old age, but most people would like to leave money for their children if possible.
icedcoffees · 04/12/2021 15:47

@Ifailed

It goes against the fundamental idea of what the NHS stands for, which is that care is free for everyone at the point of service.

No it doesn't. The NHS was never meant to provide 'care', it was set up to provide a health service based on clinical need, not ability to pay.

Having a hotel-type stay is not clinic need, if we wish to provide a National Care Service then that is a separate requirement that should be funded accordingly. No government is going to introduce a solely tax-payer funded care system, it would kill them in an election if everyone's income tax raised by, say, 15%.

Many people who have dementia (or other age-related conditions) cannot safely live alone, so for them, 24/7 care IS a clinical night.

What else do you think it is?

Disfordarkchocolate · 04/12/2021 15:46

I agree with you.

Ask yourself who should pay for your care? Surely it yourself and not people who are currently working and paying taxes?

Starcup · 04/12/2021 15:45

@bordermidgebite

If the purpose of a house is to save money for your children, no wonder house prices are so screwed

I have children, I don't feel the need to scrounge off the state so I can give then lots of inheritance

No, the ideal of buying a house is the security and knowing that when the term ends, you don’t have to keep making payments.

If you always rent, you’ll always have to pay rent. How does an 80 year old pay rent? If they haven’t got savings? They’ll get government help, whereas a homeowner wouldn’t need the financial assistance.

If you rent, you’ll never have anything to leave your children (other than capital) at least if you buy a house, the hope is you don’t need to go in to a care home!

NeedAHoliday2021 · 04/12/2021 15:45

Old people will just splurge their savings on cruises etc too make the most of their savings as there is little incentive to save to pass on to future generations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread