Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Selling your home to pay for your care in your old age

462 replies

BlueCarnation · 04/12/2021 14:47

Please explain why this is such an issue? I’m not from the UK but have worked and lived here for about 10 years. The amount of financial help the government provides is incredible and I’m still amazed by it after being here for so long. NHS, schools, SMP, different types of benefits, child credits etc. My country provides absolute no help like that for it’s residents.

One thing I can’t get my head around is the outrage people feel regarding paying for your own care when you’re older. A few weeks ago there was a news special where people were upset that their parents had to sell their homes to go into care. Surely that’s the point of years of hard work - so that when the time comes you have sufficient money? If I recall correctly, a woman said she would no longer be able to live in her mums house and would be homeless. Her mum was already in a care home but needed extra specialised care ( I think she had dementia) which government support was not enough for. The daughter said the house would need to be sold and her mum would have been devastated if she knew her home was being used to pay for her care. Why is that wrong or unfair?

Can you explain if you cannot live safely in your house anymore why shouldn’t the proceeds from your house sale be used to care for you until death? Why are adult children so up in arms at the thought of that? I don’t understand.

OP posts:
Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 17:38

The point is why do wealthy people with assets to have great SOCIAL care get angry that a tiny tiny proportion of people who have been on benefits all their lives and have contributed not one penny of tax, get a shitty level of substandard care.
I mean as a decent human, how can you be really angry about that

And most people I know that are in long term receipt of benefits are there because they really have no other choice. But I’m sure someone will come on and tell me they know a lady on 50k year of Benefits who goes to Barbados every year!

Basically this thread has turned into another benefits bashing thread.

feellikeanalien · 04/12/2021 17:35

@Prokupatuscrakedatus

What about those people who work incredibly hard without ever being able to get a mortgage and buy a house? A lot of them providing services you - in your "I worked hard all my life -little world" - would not want to do without but are to mean to pay for properly either directly or via taxes?
This.

I find the attitude that because someone doesn't own a house they must be feckless benefit scroungers really offensive and depressing.

People who have to rent often pay much more per month than those paying mortgages and have no concrete asset at the end to show for it. I remember reading somewhere that most people are only three paychecks away from disaster. Illness, death, divorce or other unforeseen circumstances can turn you from someone leading a relatively comfortable life to someone who has to depend on benefits,

Those of you who are moaning about "scrimping and saving" to pay your mortgage have the security of living in your own home without having to worry about whether you will have to move because the landlord wants to sell or wants to push up the rent to an unaffordable level.

People often have to "scrimp and save" just to pay the rent. Even those on benefits will not always have all their rent paid.

Life isn't fair. The reality of life on benefits is grim. There will be always be some who can play the benefits system just as there are many wealthy people who play the system so as to avoid paying tax.

Whilst I do understand why some people think it is unfair I think this constant demonisation of people who are less well off is a symptom of some real nastiness in our society.

Don't forget that a relatively big proportion of people on Universal Credit are actually working.

Slightly off topic I know but some of the replies on here have been quite horrifying!

EmpressCixi · 04/12/2021 17:34

You make sacrifices to pay for your mortgage that are normally detrimental to your family. So if you didn’t need to pay a mortgage you could go on holidays, take the kids out, fill the fridge, but paying the mortgage means you sacrifice something- over years and years. To then loose your home and it not being kept in the family means those sacrifices that you and your family made were for nothing.

Mortgages are less £££ than paying rent, so no you’re not sacrificing compared to those with no home paying rent. Renters are sacrificing, not homeowners.

5128gap · 04/12/2021 17:33

@IamGusFring

Part of the problem is that people who scrounge all their lives , spend all their cash on whatever random stuff get looked after in their old age .at no cost to themselves .For those who scrimped and saved for a house it therefore seems like they are getting penalised when house is used to pay fees .
Why is it worse for people to get care with no cost to themselves than it is for someone's adult child to get a house at no cost to themselves? Why is expecting the tax payer to enable your inheritance not 'scrounging'?
BorgQueen · 04/12/2021 17:31

A house can’t be sold out from under an adult child who has lived there long term to care for a parent/parents.
They have a legal right of occupation and would have to be considered by the LA when formulating a care plan.

So the Woman mentioned upthread needs good advice.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 04/12/2021 17:30

I think if the excellent carers who work in residential care homes were paid more it would diffuse some of the resentment, but it seems to be minimum wage or close to it for a task that does deserve better remuneration. If a care home has 30 residents and two thirds are paying around 4000.00 a month, the rest funded by the LA and you try to figure out overheads versus cost, it does appear some people are profiting from providing care homes.

I personally think there should be a cap on profit, pure profit that is, from such enterprises.

Orchid876 · 04/12/2021 17:28

I do see your point, but the way we do it in the UK is quite regressive and unfair. If you have a home of average value or below, you may well need to sell your home and have nothing left when care is paid for. Someone very wealthy with a lot of assets will pay the same so will be left with a lot left over once care is paid for. Some kind of tax would be fairer imo, based on earnings/wealth. What we have is a bit like a reverse lottery, where if you're unlucky you can lose everything, and if you're lucky you lose nothing.

IamGusFring · 04/12/2021 17:26

Part of the problem is that people who scrounge all their lives , spend all their cash on whatever random stuff get looked after in their old age .at no cost to themselves .For those who scrimped and saved for a house it therefore seems like they are getting penalised when house is used to pay fees .

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 04/12/2021 17:25

@fiftiesmum

Someone upthread was concerned that their home would need to be sold if their DH went into a care home. The spouse can always stay in the family home with no financial contribution from spouses savings. Not sure about unmarried couples, siblings or adult children (unless they are fairly old themselves)
That was me. Thank you fro your answer. Obviously If I could contribute to his care I would (and I hope he'd be the same!) but downsizing isn't an option.
Turkishangora · 04/12/2021 17:25

@Maverickess

It's not just the lazy, work shy scrounging lay abouts that can't afford to buy their own home to fund their social care. I can't, and I can't because I work in social care for the pittance we're apparently worth, and I'm single so no one to share the financial burden of life with. Now before anyone pipes up with "Get a better paying job then" if all care workers do that, doesn't matter who's paying for what as there'll be no social care, we need low paid jobs like this, society relies on them, and if they're not paid enough to fund their old age then it'll need to be funded - you'll pay for it one way or the other because the stark reality is that the true cost of care (including paying those who deliver it a wage they can do more than survive on) isn't being met. The problem is that anyone who doesn't own their own home is seen as a feckless waster or a work shy scrounger and so people get up in arms about having to sell their hard work to fund their care (paying more if private because the LAs don't pay enough) and can't conceive that the person in the next bed might have been just as hardworking but not as valued financially for that hard work.

That said, the system is shit. We've got private business at the heart of it and the aim of private business is to make money, we've got LAs paying as little as possible because they don't have funds and the shortfall and profit margin has to be made up somewhere, so it's put on self funders.
If we were to fund all social care, for everyone, we'd still all be paying because taxes would be higher, but maybe the cost would be more evenly split, though those with higher income would obviously pay more. Whichever way you look at it, social care needs to be funded, through the combination we have now, or through ensuring that everyone is in a position to buy or save (so increased wages in industries like care - more tax) or funding it fully - with more tax.

Of course people like me without the means to pay for my own care could just drop dead at retirement, because we've worked a lifetime making sure other people get care for a pittance. Sure that'll appeal to some on here!

I do agree it's really bloody tough these days for hard working people to afford a house. The ones that do are either gifted deposits by their families or live at home with parents and save a huge chunk of their salary each month. This really isn't an option for many many people. I was very lucky to be able to buy a flat when 100% mortgages were a thing 20 years ago and I made quite a bit of equity on it.
5128gap · 04/12/2021 17:23

Maverickess I think your excellent post says pretty much all that needs saying on this subject.

Starcup · 04/12/2021 17:22

[quote Thursdaymiami]@Starcup
I don’t own a house. I can’t afford to.
Does that mean I am lazy ? Or that I had bad luck and you had good luck. Should I not get any care when I’m older even though I will have paid tax and NI all my life.

How many people are there out there that have been claiming from the state and contributing absolutely zero from the day they were born till the day they died.[/quote]
But your bottom paragraph is my point. It’s not people that work hard all their lives, whether that be a corporate lawyer in the city or a supermarket worker on the minimum wage, work is work regardless of how much they get paid.

It’s the people that chose not to work that get everything paid for throughout their lives, this is what makes people sick. Not people that work hard but can’t afford a ridiculously overpriced house.

We all know it’s cheaper to buy a house in the north so people in the south are always going to be disadvantaged. It’s not really about the house, it’s about the lack of work ethic of some

fiftiesmum · 04/12/2021 17:21

Someone upthread was concerned that their home would need to be sold if their DH went into a care home. The spouse can always stay in the family home with no financial contribution from spouses savings. Not sure about unmarried couples, siblings or adult children (unless they are fairly old themselves)

Turkishangora · 04/12/2021 17:21

[quote ronniz]@Turkishangora would you want to swap with your friends & be in a position to receive carers allowance or PIP? [/quote]
I fully agree that people who are entitled to benefits should receive them. I just don't think the way the system is assessed is always that fair. There's no way we could afford private school. Yet I know of at least 2 people whos kids have bursary places due to the parents being on a low income. They could work more but choose not to as it means they'll be worse off.

Maverickess · 04/12/2021 17:18

It's not just the lazy, work shy scrounging lay abouts that can't afford to buy their own home to fund their social care. I can't, and I can't because I work in social care for the pittance we're apparently worth, and I'm single so no one to share the financial burden of life with.
Now before anyone pipes up with "Get a better paying job then" if all care workers do that, doesn't matter who's paying for what as there'll be no social care, we need low paid jobs like this, society relies on them, and if they're not paid enough to fund their old age then it'll need to be funded - you'll pay for it one way or the other because the stark reality is that the true cost of care (including paying those who deliver it a wage they can do more than survive on) isn't being met.
The problem is that anyone who doesn't own their own home is seen as a feckless waster or a work shy scrounger and so people get up in arms about having to sell their hard work to fund their care (paying more if private because the LAs don't pay enough) and can't conceive that the person in the next bed might have been just as hardworking but not as valued financially for that hard work.

That said, the system is shit. We've got private business at the heart of it and the aim of private business is to make money, we've got LAs paying as little as possible because they don't have funds and the shortfall and profit margin has to be made up somewhere, so it's put on self funders.
If we were to fund all social care, for everyone, we'd still all be paying because taxes would be higher, but maybe the cost would be more evenly split, though those with higher income would obviously pay more. Whichever way you look at it, social care needs to be funded, through the combination we have now, or through ensuring that everyone is in a position to buy or save (so increased wages in industries like care - more tax) or funding it fully - with more tax.

Of course people like me without the means to pay for my own care could just drop dead at retirement, because we've worked a lifetime making sure other people get care for a pittance. Sure that'll appeal to some on here!

ronniz · 04/12/2021 17:17

It's this. Housing is often the only asset less wealthy people have to pass on, passing it on can make a huge difference to your children in terms of social mobility.

But it perpetuates the problem & makes it harder for those without this help to ever afford a house

CounsellorTroi · 04/12/2021 17:16

Old people will just splurge their savings on cruises etc

How very dare they.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/12/2021 17:14

You need to watch the Care Crises with Ed Balls. It absolutely does cost that, and most care home owners live pretty normal lives. They aren't living a live of luxury.

This is sort of not entirely true. The care sector was quite heavily targeted by private equity, which strips assets and loads up cost bases of this sort or business.

BigYellowHat · 04/12/2021 17:14

I’d be annoyed if I’d worked hard all my life to repay my mortgage and had to sell yet someone else who had never worked was getting the same care for free. That’s why people get annoyed.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/12/2021 17:13

It’s awful for social mobility. Rich people manage to hold on to their assets and pass them to their children. The entire value of poorer peoples houses goes on care.

It's this. Housing is often the only asset less wealthy people have to pass on, passing it on can make a huge difference to your children in terms of social mobility.

For richer people they have other assets and care is a smaller proportion of their incomes, meaning they continue to pass to children.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 17:12

The argument about working hard all your life for the government to take it from you is flawed. Firstly it suggests only those who have been fortunate enough to be able to buy a home and benefit from house price rises have worked hard, when it is perfectly possible to have worked equally hard but been unable to buy a house.

This prevailing attitude is so depressing.

BigWoollyJumpers · 04/12/2021 17:11

Care home costs are ridiculous and they line the pockets of care home owners. No one should make a profit from old age care- it should be provided at cost by the state so that those who use it are paying for their care not paying to fill the bank accounts of care home owners.
It does not cost £1100 a week to feed and provide a room for and a carer for an elderly person- who might spend most of their time sitting watching tv

You need to watch the Care Crises with Ed Balls. It absolutely does cost that, and most care home owners live pretty normal lives. They aren't living a live of luxury.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 17:10

This is in large part due to a misunderstanding of how taxes work.The working generation pays taxes to fund the older generation at that point in time.

yep

ronniz · 04/12/2021 17:08

@Turkishangora would you want to swap with your friends & be in a position to receive carers allowance or PIP?

MistressoftheDarkSide · 04/12/2021 17:05

The main problem is that the system is inherently unfair.

Let's say someone has rapid decline dementia. They spend 18 months living with family, and then it is unsafe to do so.

They have sold their small property, worth £100,000 which they worked hard for and wished their child to inherit.

They have pensions and attendance allowance of about 1000.00 per month.

Before they can access any assistance, every penny of their capital has to be gone to a threshold of around 23,000. At this point an assessment is done. If it is decided that any capital has been used when there was a reasonable expectation of residential care being required, it will be regarded as deliberate deprivation of assets and contrary to popular belief there is no time limit on investigation, and if POAs are involved, criminal proceedings can be instigated.

Between the threshold of 23,000 and I think 13,000 the local authority will calculate an amount to be paid on top of all pensions until the lower amount is reached. After that they just keep the pensions. I think the logic is that it's enough for death related expenses.

CHC funding is not paid even if a dementia patient is non-verbal, bed bound, at risk of weight loss and bed sores and needs to be turned every two hours. People can last years in this state due to the diligence of a good care home.

Meanwhile, 18 months of caring for a person has taken someone (often, but not always, a middle aged woman) out of their career, reduced their employment prospects and being paid around 65.00 a week for the privilege. Carers could not be paid for because someone with dementia, while they are deemed as having capacity, cannot be forced to have them, and a care home is a feared prospect, and the family carer would have to be stone hearted not to step up.

It is the people with the smallest assets that suffer most, and where a cap would help.

It should also be remembered that smaller inheritances can help boost the economy by helping people "level up" at certain points in their lives.

It's complicated, emotive and needs an overhaul top to bottom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread