Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

After 45/50 years old - financial security when I see other marriages failing

217 replies

JackRatt · 04/12/2021 09:58

Hello all,

I have various friends who are currently going
through terrible divorce/ break ups (in these cases male instigated -affairs etc) and at the moment finances are completely controlled by men, who seem to be holding all the cards…

I wondered what the best way to safeguard and protect your future is? Especially if you have been a SAHM for the majority of your husbands working life?

Thank you

OP posts:
RedskyThisNight · 04/12/2021 13:16

Men can aggressively say no. You're a bit stuck then.

or you could just not buy a house with someone who's not prepared to treat you as an equal?
Better still, not stay with them at all.

PegasusReturns · 04/12/2021 13:14

Being married is all well and good but does it help a lot in the end? Men still hide their money and refuse to pay child support. You'll still be homeless

It helps in the vast majority of cases where there are assets. Men might hide assets but that takes the money and effort that generally only the wealthy have. And the wealthy also have many visible assets: cars, houses, jewellery, pensions. That will all be split.

Bob who works as a sales manager on £100k is going to find it much harder to stash any meaningful sum of cash. Provided you are married, if there are assets you’ll get half.

Where being married is no help is where you are the higher earner or there are no assets to speak of.

Viviennemary · 04/12/2021 13:14

Even if your DH earns a good salary and you earn very little or even nothing don't sit back and think it's all family money. When push comes to shove it absolutely isn't.

GoodnightGrandma · 04/12/2021 13:14

Have a will in place.
Make sure you are Tenants in Common so you individually own 50% of your house. That way your half won’t be taken into account if your DH needs care.
Think about leaving everything to your children, but giving your DH a lifetime interest in your half of the house, unless he co-habitates or remarries.
The will is REALLY important.

FrancescaContini · 04/12/2021 13:11

@Ellen888

I have told all the girls in my/my extended family not to even consider having a child with a man unless they were prepared to financially, emotionally, physically and psychologically support that child alone.

You cannot guarantee that your partner will always be there for you, and you will still be alone even if he did not choose to leave you.

Great advice. Totally agree.

Make sure you can afford mortgage on just one income.

GoodnightGrandma · 04/12/2021 13:09

Make sure your car is in your name, not his.

lastqueenofscotland · 04/12/2021 13:08

I think a lot of relationships have a partner that does the finances because they are better at it, which is an absolute cop out. Like the poster that mentioned not realising they weren’t on the deeds, take some responsibility!
A NT adult should have basic financial literacy rather than just “oh that’s so and so job” it’s both pathetic and hugely risky.

GoodnightGrandma · 04/12/2021 13:08

Check that you’ve paid enough NI for a full old age pension.

mayblossominapril · 04/12/2021 13:08

@WaterBottle123

Previous posters are incorrect. ONLY marry if you are the LOWER earner and have no assets.

Under no circumstances give up your job or go part time whike he remains full time

This Don’t marry if you have more assets and equal or greater earning power.

I took my full mat leave but have gone back to full self employment. It’s barely manageable at the moment be will get easier in another year.

Remember to look at ways you can increase your earning potential whilst not increasing the hours you work. So reducing the commute, more wfh, changing what you do etc.

Ellen888 · 04/12/2021 13:04

I have told all the girls in my/my extended family not to even consider having a child with a man unless they were prepared to financially, emotionally, physically and psychologically support that child alone.

You cannot guarantee that your partner will always be there for you, and you will still be alone even if he did not choose to leave you.

saleorbouy · 04/12/2021 13:03

Like any part of life and marriage each partner should take an interest all areas, finance, maintaining the home, caring for the children, this way no part of life is completely alien to the other and if one of you dies or leaves the relationship then the others can pick up the pieces more easily.
Its natural that partners have more interest or time to spend in certain areas of home life but to bury your head in the sand an ignore important areas is disastrous.
You should have an understanding of the household finances, savings and pension provisions, and life cover as a basic minimum.

Ana27 · 04/12/2021 13:02

@RealBecca

Pay into/top up NI contributions from joint finances and look at whether you can start a private pension fund (i honestly dont know if you can if you arent working?) If you can it will require large contributions to equal your husbands
Yes you can pay in £2880 into a pension if you are not working and it is topped up to £3600 through tax relief even though you are not paying income tax. Not a huge amount but would add up if you started it as soon as you became a SAHM.
CaliforniaDrumming · 04/12/2021 13:00

Yes, men can aggressively say no to having property and assets in your name as well. This is a warning sign to get back to work if you can. It means he will leave you high and dry.

RealBecca · 04/12/2021 13:00

Pay into/top up NI contributions from joint finances and look at whether you can start a private pension fund (i honestly dont know if you can if you arent working?) If you can it will require large contributions to equal your husbands

Vintagevixen · 04/12/2021 12:58

@BridStar

Being married is all well and good but does it help a lot in the end? Men still hide their money and refuse to pay child support. You'll still be homeless.

Obviously being a non married partner is worse, but court fees and hidden, squirreled money are still factors for the married ones.

See it would have given me access to his pension, after years of me having no pension because I couldn't afford the monthly payments due to childcare and low earnings etc. So marriage would have benefitted me yes.

Also my ex has tried to hide his earnings and CMS have been able to refute this and I now get a reasonable monthly amount. possibly he could have been more devious and tried harder to hide then I suppose.

BridStar · 04/12/2021 12:55

@CaliforniaDrumming

Do you all not sign property deeds when you buy a house? When we did I made sure my name was on it and I had copies. Ditto all assets like shares, bonds and so on.
Men can aggressively say no. You're a bit stuck then.
FrancescaContini · 04/12/2021 12:55

@Vintagevixen

This stuff needs to be taught in school.
Yep
BridStar · 04/12/2021 12:54

Being married is all well and good but does it help a lot in the end? Men still hide their money and refuse to pay child support. You'll still be homeless.

Obviously being a non married partner is worse, but court fees and hidden, squirreled money are still factors for the married ones.

ancientgran · 04/12/2021 12:54

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@ancientgran

Marriage is an insurance policy to protect the lower earning person in the partnership (usually the woman). It only makes sense to get married for the lower earning partner.

Historically in the vast majority of cases it benefited women more than men to get married. In practice these days more men may benefit from it because a higher proportion of women are financially autonomous.

But strip out the religious and romantic window-dressing and the purpose of it really is to protect women while they are unable to work. Generally speaking, the same does not apply to men. I would be very suspicious of a lower-earning man who doesn't look after children wanting to get married as it has no benefit for the woman whatsoever.

TBH if more women became financially independent the need for marriage would diminish significantly. Which wouldn't be a bad thing in my opinion as it would encourage more women to look after their own economic interests.[/quote]
If I look at my DD and her friends they are almost all the higher earners not by massive amounts but still the higher earners. They all seem more ambitious then their husbands. One of the husbands is the SAHP.

I've always been independent financially, married for 36 years and don't have joint accounts and neither of us know exactly what income the other has, never been an issue, we both pay our way and then do what we want with what's left. I just think it is so hypocritical to say a lower earning woman should make sure she's married but not tell men the same because they have as much risk of losing what is their's. I worked with someone who was not a high earner but he was asset rich as his parents died young. He got married, she'd just graduated and never had a job, they got pregnant almost immediately so she said it wasn't worth working, as soon as baby was born she told him she wanted a divorce. She also wanted the house that had been bought with the money his parents left him, half the money, maintenance oh and by the way she didn't want him to see the baby. It was a long messy affair and it nearly broke him, financially and mentally.

FrancescaContini · 04/12/2021 12:54

Don’t be a SAHM for years on end
Have an education, training, professional experience
Have your own money
NEVER rely on a man financially

Redcart21 · 04/12/2021 12:52

Imagine if most men took that train of thought and only wanted to marry if they were the lower earners Hmm

Just don’t be a SAHP. And regardless of work status, get yourself as financially independent as possible. Even if that means you learn to invest on the side or day trade and keep your profits in your own separate account.

Vintagevixen · 04/12/2021 12:51

This stuff needs to be taught in school.

Vintagevixen · 04/12/2021 12:51
  1. Don't repeat my mistake and GET MARRIED particularly if you have children.I wasn't and thus had no rights to any of my Ex partners pension despite sacrificing my career and working part time to do childcare, allowing him to build up his career nicely and so his pension.

  2. Don't believe in common law wife - total myth.

3)Always, ALWAYS always have your name on property deeds - this saved me and allowed me to be able to purchase a property with the equity - still with a lot of sacrifices, had to move area, had to move DD to another school, we still really miss and mourn for our old area and friends. But at least we have a roof over out heads.

  1. Always keep up some form of income - I worked part time as a nurse when I could and kept up my registration, skills etc. This has allowed me to now work full time, earn money and get back into the NHS pension scheme. Even if you are a SAHM have property assets or investments or SOMETHING.

  2. Do believe that it does happen that someones DH/DP can be hiding secrets or undergo a complete personality change - I've seen it in action. Equally this applies if DH/DP undergoes another life change - eg serious accident, disability, mental health etc. You need to be able to cope in these circumstances even if you are a SAHM.

  3. Always have a run away fund - save an amount each month. I did and it helped pay for my movers/solicitors and enabled me to get our house sold and the situation resolved.

Sowhatifiam · 04/12/2021 12:46

My ex walked out aged 38, cleared the bank accounts as he left and never looked back. I had 2 toddlers and was pregnant. I had a dreadful few years just getting the divorce sorted but I did do well financially out of it with the sale of the family home. I lost everything else. Luckily, As I was educated and had plenty of work experience, re-training was relatively simple and I have since earned enough to support my children without their father’s help. But none of it has been easy and would have been a million times harder on minimum wage with no recent work experience to speak of.

I would never marry again, precisely because I don’t want what I have gained independently to be taken from my children in the event of another marriage breakdown.

ancientgran · 04/12/2021 12:45

@RandomLondoner

at the moment finances are completely controlled by men, who seem to be holding all the cards…

If the men control the finances, it's probably because they earned the money, and it's in their own account. They will regard it as their own. Divorce may change that. So I take the opposite view, it's the women who hold the cards, and the men who should be shivering in fear at the prospect of divorce, because divorce is the trigger for a transfer of wealth from them to to their soon-to-be-ex-wives.

This is true, I know a very unhappy couple. She stays because she likes the lifestyle, he stays because he doesn't want to give her half of the money he has made, truly a self made man from a very poor background. They split up briefly 35 years ago and have lived unhappily at war ever since.

I can't see their life of unhappiness was worth the money involved but I guess we all have different priorities.

Swipe left for the next trending thread