Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

After 45/50 years old - financial security when I see other marriages failing

217 replies

JackRatt · 04/12/2021 09:58

Hello all,

I have various friends who are currently going
through terrible divorce/ break ups (in these cases male instigated -affairs etc) and at the moment finances are completely controlled by men, who seem to be holding all the cards…

I wondered what the best way to safeguard and protect your future is? Especially if you have been a SAHM for the majority of your husbands working life?

Thank you

OP posts:
Udouhun · 04/12/2021 17:49

It's important to get educated and have a proper career. That way, even if you're a sahm for a couple of years, you have something to go back to. If your only option is nmw jobs, you're bound to be in trouble. I know I'm biased as a teacher, but I would argue that your road to financial wellbeing starts in the classroom.

Redcart21 · 04/12/2021 17:07

Women need to be financially literate from a young age. It is no good sorting all this out after marriage and when DC come along. Finances need to be planned ahead. It is up to parents and families to teach their children this and prepare them accordingly

Dashel · 04/12/2021 16:55

Any couple also needs to consider the illness or death.

A high earning partner Can buy in services and may have insurance as part of their package, but if you are a struggling couple, insurance might be out of budget.

Personally I wouldn’t want to be dependent on my DH, we both have savings, cars are in our own names and although he has a better pension than I do and earns a lot more, but he is older and his last employer was extremely generous when it came to pension contributions.

He is very supportive of my increasing my pension pot and all decisions are joint, especially financial ones. I think that is really important.

vivainsomnia · 04/12/2021 16:49

But I know a lot of women who were lawyers, bankers etc but became SAHPs because they prioritised their husbands career. They now have teenage or adult children and don't work
If your husband is in a high paid job and you're a lawyer, banker or other high earning profession, then you cwrtaiy can afford private schools, a nanny, and expensive baby sitters. It is such an excuse that you have no choice but to give up a career so that your husband can have his.

Two of my friends have very good careers as do their husbands. They each have 4 children and my friends continue to work. All 4 had jobs that meant travelling at times. One had a nanny and managed to work the overnights between them. The other had alive in nanny. They are fantastic parents who manage to make it work.

It's also all good to say that as long as you get a good deal from the divorce, you'll be fine. However, spousal maintenance is now much rarer, and although you can do well with the majority of the house and a hefty child maintenance, everything changes when the kids are off to uni. Rarely the age to draw the pension, time to give ex his share of the home, and no more maintenance.

I am seeing a few mums in their 50s suddenly finding themselves with no money and little choice but to get any job. They hate it and their lifestyle is nowhere near what it used to be. No more gym membership, fancy holidays, nice new cars.

Being a sahm is a massive risk no matter what. I would never have taken the risk however appealing it's been at times.

MrsBobDylan · 04/12/2021 16:29

I am always surprised at how some women become passengers in their own lives.

I worked through the first 12 years of having kids and have been a SAHM for the last two because my middle child needs full time care.

I am married and do all the life admin. I am on our mortgage and house deeds because I oversee all of that, I have kept my pension going and am training in a career which I will build up once my son moves into supported living accommodation.

I married an honourable, decent person and he has given me no cause for concern in the 20 years we've been together. But I would be a bloody fool to rely on anyone but myself.

Cocomarine · 04/12/2021 16:02

Oddly written post, and I wasn’t surprised it was a one post wonder. Article fishing?

oneglassandpuzzled · 04/12/2021 15:58

Sorry, that should read 'couples' not 'working couples'. Man in very high-earning salary, woman doesn't work.

oneglassandpuzzled · 04/12/2021 15:50

HolidayTime2021

I know working couples where the high-earning men don't lift a finger domestically but 'pay' their wives an allowance as acknowledgement of the fact that they are enabled to work at the level they do. And that if the wife were knocked over by a bus they would have to buy in a number of services to replace what she did.

Wouldn't suit me, I've always worked, but it gives the non-working woman some financial security.Can't see why you have a problem with it.

HolidayTime2021 · 04/12/2021 15:33

@oneglassandpuzzled

If you're a SAHP tot up how much you're saving the family budget on childcare, cleaning, dog walking, taking children to doctors' appointments, dogs to vets, laundry, gardening, cooking.
other than childcare- nothing working couples do all of the rest.
StEval · 04/12/2021 15:32

daisydoh

So many people saying don't be a SAHM but then women seem to be scorned at for wanting careers like men and using childcare to bring up the kids.

I guess you can't win

Win at what?
I dont offer up my life and choices for others to comment on so their opinions are irrelevent.

oneglassandpuzzled · 04/12/2021 15:29

If you're a SAHP tot up how much you're saving the family budget on childcare, cleaning, dog walking, taking children to doctors' appointments, dogs to vets, laundry, gardening, cooking.

mostlydrinkstea · 04/12/2021 14:58

Even if you think your marriage is secure get your ducks in a row and make sure you are financially independent. I learned the hard way. My now ex husband gave no indication that he was thinking of divorce until he walked out. www.news24.com/w24/selfcare/love/relationship/runaway-husbands-when-your-loving-partner-walks-out-of-your-marriage-without-an-explanation-20210709

I had gone back to work full time having been a SAHM so it has not been as brutal financially as it would have done if I was part time or volunteering. It is still very, very tough starting again in your late 50s when you thought you had a loving stable relationship.

thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2021 14:52

@IknowwhatIneed

Absolutely *@Applesonthelawn* how often do you hear someone deciding to not return to work because it doesn’t make sense for the partner (usually the man) to reduce hours because he’s the higher earner/has better prospects. Short term gain in a reduction of childcare costs but long term pain because while his career progresses, she looses her footing in her own career. All well and good until it falls apart and he wants his strong salary for himself and she’s effectively starting her career from scratch.
Yep.

And how often on here do you here this phrase "it works for our family". Which is code for "it works for him because he can focus on his career/golfing/after hours drinks with the lads while I take care of the kids and I go along with it because he pays the bills".

Being a SAHM is very superficially attractive when you have small children, a low-paying job, childcare is expensive and you are exhausted. It must be very tempting.

Over the long term, the childcare you pay for to keep your foot in the door is probably the best investment you'll ever make.

thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2021 14:47

@ancientgran

I just think it is so hypocritical to say a lower earning woman should make sure she's married but not tell men the same because they have as much risk of losing what is their's

In theory that's true..

But in practice, in a scenario with a lower earning man and unless the lower-earning man is a SAHP, marriage just skews the financial odds further in the man's favour.

The point of marriage is to protect whichever partner is taking on the bulk of the childcare (with the assumption that its negatively impacting their lifetime's earnings, which it usually does).

In the majority of marriages where both parents work outside the home the woman is still doing the lion's share of the childcare, domestic work, mental load and all the rest of it. And therefore likely damaging her own career potential even if she is out-earning her partner.

So on the point of divorce a man who earns less than his wife but does little or nothing in terms of childcare or domestic labour can easily walk off with half of the assets most of which were generated by a woman who had to do two full jobs (a job and then all the domestic jobs).

I've seen this happen in at least half a dozen situations: a woman is run ragged trying to hold onto a high-flying job, a bloke is doing a "creative" or part time job which he enjoys but which brings in very little money, doing minimal childcare and no housework. The woman gets pissed off with the imbalance and kicks him out. They divorce and he gets half the assets.

In the vanishingly rare scenarios where a man stops work altogether to be a full time parent and is in the home its more than fair for him to take half of the assets in the case of a divorce. In the case of the vast majority of marriages where two parents are working, its a lose lose for the woman.

LuluBlakey1 · 04/12/2021 14:47

I know this is awful but I have a secret bank account. I put money into it regularly - £100 here and there. I have been doing it for 7 years and put some money from another account I had which DH knows about but never sees and the payment from an insurance policy my mum had which paid out when she died. There is £16,400 in it now. I am not planning on leaving DH- we are very happy but I just want a little bit of security. We each have an ISA and joint savings too and my money from my house when I was single, which went into our first joint house deposit, is protected in an legal agreement.
If we get to retirement age together it will be a nice treats account.

sweatervest · 04/12/2021 14:37

as others have said ... ALWAYS have your own bank account. even if you're not earning.
it's saved me tbh and was the best advice i've ever had.

lastqueenofscotland · 04/12/2021 14:35

I’m not talking about 50 years ago, I’m saying now, in 2021 if a NT woman in her 30s does not have the most basic financial literacy, take some responsibility and learn something before becoming entirely dependent on someone else. Yes lots of men are financially abusive but I do think SOME women could do an awful lot more to protect themselves.

If you WANT to become an SAHM I think you need to appreciate the risk and keep some funds and at least a toe in the door of a career, even if it’s just reading industry papers and keeping in touch with old managers

IknowwhatIneed · 04/12/2021 14:34

Absolutely @Applesonthelawn how often do you hear someone deciding to not return to work because it doesn’t make sense for the partner (usually the man) to reduce hours because he’s the higher earner/has better prospects. Short term gain in a reduction of childcare costs but long term pain because while his career progresses, she looses her footing in her own career. All well and good until it falls apart and he wants his strong salary for himself and she’s effectively starting her career from scratch.

Bubblecap · 04/12/2021 14:34

I always worked and actually had a decent quite well paid career. I even managed to stay in employment when suffering from serious MH crisis which involved me being an in patient in a psychiatric hospital on a few occasions.

I do know two long term SAHM one in mid fifties and one in her late forties. Last dc are about to finish A levels. They couldn’t cope emotionally with being away from their dc. One was the higher earner in her marriage and the other had an OK PT job. They have been SAHM for 18 and 20 years. I always thought they were mad making themselves so vulnerable and I’m the one who actually has a piece of paper that’s says I’m mental, well it has my diagnosis and care plan on.

It’s now 35 years NI contributions for a full state pension which I just made when I retired early. My own projected pension income including state pension which I do not qualify for yet is currently about 15k per year, DH is about 25k per year. He is the higher earner. My career took a big hit due to my MH issues. I turned down promotion more than once and went PT not because of childcare but to preserve the delicate balance of not ending up as an in patient again. When we met at work we earned exactly the same, it’s funny how life turns out.

Applesonthelawn · 04/12/2021 14:31

I think it's as much about the loss of career advancement than whether you can keep up with pension payments etc. I had 18 months off when DS was little (as a single parent, and I could afford it). It took me seven years of hard slog to regain the salary level I had before I left for hte 18 month break. The longer you stay out, the worse it will be.

IknowwhatIneed · 04/12/2021 14:28

I’m leaving my marriage of 30 years in a fairly secure financial position. My advice

  • if you have kids, get married
  • make sure you’ve build a solid career before having kids, to the point where you can step back if need be and return at a decent level
  • keep your contacts/some level of work if at all possible
  • have independent finances whether that be savings, investments or means to make your own money
  • don’t overstretch yourself financially on the basis of 2 incomes - can you cover all your bills on your income, or reduce outgoings to that level if need be
  • never assume he’ll look after you if you split. If he doesn’t support you to be financially independent while you’re in the relationship (eg “paying” you as a SAHM), he’s never going to support you if you split
  • have a runaway fund you can access easily if you need it
  • don’t have more kids than you can afford to support by yourself

I watched my mum stay in the most abusive if relationships because she couldn’t afford to support herself and the kids. I swore I’d never put myself in that position and that thinking is making a painful split so much easier, because I have options and know that financially we’ll be ok.

Applesonthelawn · 04/12/2021 14:27

I don't doubt that families are happier and less stressful if one parent is the SAHP. The problem comes when you separate. There can be a happily ever after, but there often isn't.

Thursdaymiami · 04/12/2021 14:25

Problem is most people become SAHM when they really can’t afford it.
I don’t mean can’t afford day to day life. I mean there isn’t enough money to pay for an extra pension, pay into savings etc which is what should be happening when you’re not working. The main earner should have enough money to be doing all the extras for the non earned

RosesAndHellebores · 04/12/2021 14:25

I've said it before and I'll say it again. So many of the dc's friends parents split when the dc became older teenagers. Husband's meeting a younger model having been married for 20 years plus to a woman whose sole topics of conversation were the children and tennis club. They hadn't worked for 20 or more years and were frankly unemployable. They became very bitter and resented their three bed terraces that were part of the settlement. So sad and yet so predictable.

SenselessUbiquity · 04/12/2021 14:24

If you want children (you will need to be thinking about this well before 40 / 50 obv) find a man who wants them as much as, or more than, you. Women can have children under any circumstances; men who want to be active fathers need to find a woman who will bear their children and then allow them to do so. This is important; it sounds counterintuitive as society is set up to make women think that men "let" them have children, but actually, men who want children, and know it, and are able to think straight, know that to be a dad they have to have a good relationship with a woman, and that allows her to set the terms - that is, to be a dad, you need to be prepared to support not just your kids but their mum, and one neat legal shortcut to all that happening is he can marry her. Don't allow yourself to be brainwashed into thinking children are a privilege men can choose to afford to women. It's the other way around.

Swipe left for the next trending thread