Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

After 45/50 years old - financial security when I see other marriages failing

217 replies

JackRatt · 04/12/2021 09:58

Hello all,

I have various friends who are currently going
through terrible divorce/ break ups (in these cases male instigated -affairs etc) and at the moment finances are completely controlled by men, who seem to be holding all the cards…

I wondered what the best way to safeguard and protect your future is? Especially if you have been a SAHM for the majority of your husbands working life?

Thank you

OP posts:
hardtobelieve · 05/12/2021 11:40

Amazingly if you are a married SAHP, there are tax advantages to having savings solely in the SAHP's name, if the working person is a higher rate tax payer.
Internet banking makes it harder to have joint savings products I have found, so share them out.
ISAs can only be in sole names.
My mother gave me excellent advice and said part of agreeing to be SAHP was being the one to control the finances, you have more time after all.
Being married before kids is the best protection though as others have said.

RedskyThisNight · 05/12/2021 11:34

Having the ability to be financially independent is probably the best advice you can give your children. Note I say "having the ability". By all means be a SAHP if that works for your family, but think through the what-if scenarios and plan for them. It's not just worrying about what happens in the case of divorce. My friend was a SAHP for 12 years when her husband developed a degenerative disease. Suddenly relying on his salary, whilst letting her own career go didn't look like such a good plan.

thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2021 11:23

@caringcarer

The most important advise is to marry. At least then you would be entitled to a share of assets and pensions. If not married carry on working and if have a child insists childcare costs, and drop offs and pick up are all shared. Also while on may leave continue to pay into pension or else it will be light.
As has been said before, marrying is a safety net if you don't work or don't earn much. It gives you a degree of financial protection if you split. But a) marriage is a bad idea for a higher-earning woman and b) its really no substitute for having your own money in the first place. So I would disagree that its the "most important advice".

Far far better advice would be for women to focus on maximising their financial independence in the first place, putting pensions etc in place, so marriage doesn't really come a need (financially speaking).

RosesAndHellebores · 05/12/2021 10:53

The best advice for women is to invest the max into pensions before dc. Whether they work again or not, there will still be a cushion later.

LemonTT · 05/12/2021 10:43

@caringcarer

The most important advise is to marry. At least then you would be entitled to a share of assets and pensions. If not married carry on working and if have a child insists childcare costs, and drop offs and pick up are all shared. Also while on may leave continue to pay into pension or else it will be light.
I don’t think that’s the best advice. It’s basic advice that needs a lot of qualification.

Marriage won’t give you access to someone else’s income unless they want to give you access to it. Divorce is legal process to give you access to someone’s wealth and income.

A single income generally won’t provide enough wealth to be split between two adults with responsibilities for their children. It might for a few but not for most women. Divorce will impact on your lifestyle, man or woman. You need to be able to earn and parent in your own right if divorce happens.

Legal judgements are changing with progress in working lives. It’s getting harder to argue that you sacrificed to stay at home to look after healthy teenagers. That’s now seen as a privileged choice that might get you a bigger share of assets but not spousal maintenance.

StEval · 05/12/2021 09:46

@sst1234
Yes
Its an internalised form of misogyny, put your child before yourself, financial security and rely solely on a man.
This paves the way for control and abuse.

sst1234 · 05/12/2021 09:28

@notacooldad

*So many people saying don't be a SAHM but then women seem to be scorned at for wanting careers like men and using childcare to bring up the kids I'm not sure who is scorning. I've never heard anyone criticising either a working mother or a SAH mum in all the years I've been working and been a mother. If anyone is criticising they have been below my radar and clearly dont matter.
True. This so-called scorn seems to be a proxy for SAHM prioritizing looking after children over building financial security for themselves. So many threads on here where women give up years of hard work building a career after having a child. Leaving yourself at the mercy of man to support you is the biggest gamble a woman will make with her life.
caringcarer · 05/12/2021 00:47

The most important advise is to marry. At least then you would be entitled to a share of assets and pensions. If not married carry on working and if have a child insists childcare costs, and drop offs and pick up are all shared. Also while on may leave continue to pay into pension or else it will be light.

LemonTT · 05/12/2021 00:38

@RosesAndHellebores

I had a pre-nup to protect my assets Engaged, married, children in that order Have some financial independence and own bank account Do not give up work forever.
I think we need pre and post nups. Better to thrash these things out when you like each other than when you want to divorce and hate each other.

I would rather a couple considered the implications of a career sacrifice and accepted what it would mean if they split. That the high earner, usually a husband, knows and accepts what they need to pay to make good any loss due to career sacrifice. That the SAHP accepts they are taking a risk.

Divorce and separations have been prevalent in our society for decades now. They are a freedom and right we need. Women need to be realistic and practical about what this means. Because funnily enough a lot of men are already.

notacooldad · 05/12/2021 00:15

*So many people saying don't be a SAHM but then women seem to be scorned at for wanting careers like men and using childcare to bring up the kids
I'm not sure who is scorning.
I've never heard anyone criticising either a working mother or a SAH mum in all the years I've been working and been a mother.
If anyone is criticising they have been below my radar and clearly dont matter.

Lockdowninfinity · 04/12/2021 23:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Udouhun · 04/12/2021 23:51

Shmithecat well yes... everyone in the UK is entitled to a comprehensive education. I taught there for ten years and I can assuredly say that most teachers in comprehensive schools absolutely break themselves to give students the best opportunities possible. And no, I'm not ignorant.

Mary46 · 04/12/2021 23:25

Great advice. Im looking for work at moment but pay has be worth my while too. But I agree you do leave yourself vulnerable. I have been sahm and worked outside home too.

LuluBlakey1 · 04/12/2021 23:16

@JudgeJ I don't know 'cos it would be a secret. Perhaps he has- I doubt it knowing DH. He never worries about money. Grin

sassbott · 04/12/2021 21:00

Interesting thread. Earlier this morning I skimmed one about a SAHM complaining about her mother constantly asking her when she was returning to some form of work. When she herself was very content to be a SAHM and ‘it works for her’. From the little I skimmed, she was met with resounding support.

I personally find threads like that astounding.

How and why women, time and again, hand their financial security across to men is beyond me. Keep some form of employment/ training. As a PP said, if your financial bucket is not sufficient enough to split 50/50 and sustain your lifestyle? Then being a SAHP is not even remotely an option. But if that is what you have done?

Keep a separate bank account (you will however have to legally disclose it in the event of a divorce)
Know the finances - what is where etc
Have your own pension/ ISA’s
Ensure you are on the deeds/ equal on bank accounts/ property
Do whatever you can to get back into work/ get some form of paid work. Judges will expect you to get back out and work. Regardless of how long you have been a SAHP.

JudgeJ · 04/12/2021 20:39

@LuluBlakey1

I know this is awful but I have a secret bank account. I put money into it regularly - £100 here and there. I have been doing it for 7 years and put some money from another account I had which DH knows about but never sees and the payment from an insurance policy my mum had which paid out when she died. There is £16,400 in it now. I am not planning on leaving DH- we are very happy but I just want a little bit of security. We each have an ISA and joint savings too and my money from my house when I was single, which went into our first joint house deposit, is protected in an legal agreement. If we get to retirement age together it will be a nice treats account.
I do hope he has a secret bank account too, with more than £16K in it!
JudgeJ · 04/12/2021 20:37

@nocnoc

Make sure you are married. Make sure you have your own bank account with enough in it to pay for legal advice if shit hits the fan. Start thinking about getting paid work. Retrain.
Hopefully the husbands of such women also have their own bank account in case things go wrong! Or would that be deemed 'family money'? This sort of topic always produces the most hypocritical responses!
JudgeJ · 04/12/2021 20:34

@Ozanj

Keep working and offer to be the ‘saver’ while your OH pays the bills - this means you have all the control over finances in case there is a break up. Top tip 1 from my gran who was abused all her married life.
If someone were to suggest that the man had 'all the control over finances' the outrage here would be massive.
SofiaMichelle · 04/12/2021 19:47

@THisbackwithavengeance

I think a lot of SAHMs expect to get divorced and yet keep the house, lifestyle and income and not have to work.

And then come crying on MN about how unfair it all is and how they don't see why they should have to get a job.

Getting 50-50 is not being shafted.

This. In buckets full.

And also, what on earth do you mean by "especially if you have been a SAHM for the majority of your husband's working life"?

Most people's working life is ~40 years.

No one is a SAHM for anywhere near 40 years. You'd have to be popping kids out for 25+ years!

CorvusPurpureus · 04/12/2021 19:35

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@ancientgran

I just think it is so hypocritical to say a lower earning woman should make sure she's married but not tell men the same because they have as much risk of losing what is their's

In theory that's true..

But in practice, in a scenario with a lower earning man and unless the lower-earning man is a SAHP, marriage just skews the financial odds further in the man's favour.

The point of marriage is to protect whichever partner is taking on the bulk of the childcare (with the assumption that its negatively impacting their lifetime's earnings, which it usually does).

In the majority of marriages where both parents work outside the home the woman is still doing the lion's share of the childcare, domestic work, mental load and all the rest of it. And therefore likely damaging her own career potential even if she is out-earning her partner.

So on the point of divorce a man who earns less than his wife but does little or nothing in terms of childcare or domestic labour can easily walk off with half of the assets most of which were generated by a woman who had to do two full jobs (a job and then all the domestic jobs).

I've seen this happen in at least half a dozen situations: a woman is run ragged trying to hold onto a high-flying job, a bloke is doing a "creative" or part time job which he enjoys but which brings in very little money, doing minimal childcare and no housework. The woman gets pissed off with the imbalance and kicks him out. They divorce and he gets half the assets.

In the vanishingly rare scenarios where a man stops work altogether to be a full time parent and is in the home its more than fair for him to take half of the assets in the case of a divorce. In the case of the vast majority of marriages where two parents are working, its a lose lose for the woman.[/quote]
Ah. It would appear you know my 'creative' ex husband.

There seems to be a lot of him about! Grin.

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/12/2021 18:40

Women need to be financially literate from a young age. It is no good sorting all this out after marriage and when DC come along. Finances need to be planned ahead. It is up to parents and families to teach their children this and prepare them accordingly

I’ve been astonished in the past at the lack of basic financial literacy displayed on this site. There was a thread a few months back started by a mum who had just returned to work full time from her first maternity leave but was expecting her second child in less than 3 months. The number of posters who laid into her about going back full time (‘why did you even bother having kids’ etc) was extraordinary. She kept trying to point out that going part time for less than three months would put her in a much more precarious position during her upcoming maternity leave, particularly as her employer offered a reasonably decent maternity package based on salary - going part time would have cost her twice as much again during her second mat leave, she’d essentially be giving up free money. The number of posters who didn’t seem to understand her position was really astounding.

4amstarts · 04/12/2021 18:28

Nothing wrong with being a STAHM of course but it's a choice - one that women knowingly take but then like to use the old excuse "well I furthered his career" when it comes to splitting assets in a divorce forgetting it suited them at the time that they didn't need to work and were home all day with the kids (or not even that when they went to school)

You should always hope for the best plan for the worst. either go back to work when the kids are in school or accept that the price you pay for not working and expecting/allowing your partner to bear the financial responsibility of carrying the entire family is that you are then in a vulnerable position if the relationship breaks down and need to have a back up plan in place

Shmithecat2 · 04/12/2021 18:24

@Udouhun

It's important to get educated and have a proper career. That way, even if you're a sahm for a couple of years, you have something to go back to. If your only option is nmw jobs, you're bound to be in trouble. I know I'm biased as a teacher, but I would argue that your road to financial wellbeing starts in the classroom.
Because everyone is afforded the privilege of a sound education Confused. Blimey, how ignorant can you get?
thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2021 18:21

@Udouhun

I agree. Too important to leave this to whims of parents.

fournonblondes · 04/12/2021 18:21

Circumstances vary from each family. Sahm sometimes comes out of lack of family or close red of help. Even if childcare can be paid it may not be adequate. I went through so many nannies, au pairs and after school help. However, regardless of circumstances always keep your state pension payments by national insurance voluntary contributions, private pension if possible , do not stop saving, keep a separate account and an eye in how to make money and come back to work ASAP if you can. Even if you are married.

Swipe left for the next trending thread