Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask that we stop looking for excuses for horrific child abuse and murder?!

64 replies

Dinotruxagain · 04/12/2021 07:12

Sparked by the murder of little Arthur and the threads I'm seeing trying to look for reasons that the abuse took place.

As a now adult survivor of pretty horrific child abuse , (physically ending in hospital visits) emotional and mental abuse, basically the works.
I find it so very upsetting that people are looking for the generational link, do you understand how that leaves us feeling when it comes to our own parenting?

I now have a child, DS4, but for many decades I was terrified that I would repeat the same pattern with my own child.
It took a lot of therapy to come to the realisation that I, and I alone, controlled my life and my behaviour.

We are not all destined to repeat the mistakes of our parents, yes, we've been damaged but it doesn't mean it's ' rare' to parent well in later life.

My own mother, (father wasn't around) was one of 7 siblings, all perfectly normal happy families.
She didn't have an abusive childhood, nothing different was done in her upbringing compared to her siblings.
She was the only one who turned out to be an abusive person, outward appearance of a wonderful human being, unless of course you were either my brother or I.
Yes, our abuse was reported to social services, we were not believed and returned back to her time and time again. Her job?... she was a social worker.

I'm not sure why I'm posting this, I guess that the recent threads have sparked it but I just wanted to say we're not all destined to repeat the same cycle.
We can, and are good parents despite our upbringing.
Please remember that when you are looking for links, some people are just horrible, horrible people.

OP posts:
Iggly · 04/12/2021 09:19

The point I was making is that sometimes there is no reason for people being the way the are. It cannot be explained

I just find that so defeatist.

I’ve asked questions about why my mum is how she is and I think it’s a combination of her mental state (she had undiagnosed bipolar), her upbringing (she had no parents after the age of 4) and lack of support around her. Some of it is circumstances which made her who she is.

I don’t understand it all, but I don’t think it was inevitable.

I’m just sad she didn’t get the support she needed when she needed it. Not everyone needs that support but those that do, should be able to obtain it.

Iggly · 04/12/2021 09:17

@Nanny0gg

I do believe some people are born evil.

She might have been a crap mother but her own children weren't treated as badly as Arthur.

Pure, unadulterated wickedness. And she knew what she was doing.

I don’t because that absolves them to some degree, creates a dangerous logic and is a bit defeatist. If you write them all off as evil then nothing could have been done right?
Dinotruxagain · 04/12/2021 09:14

@Courtier

OP, it's natural for humans to look for reasoning in these situations. This isn't your mum. It's not the same. Stop taking another child's abuse personally.
That's harsh! I'm not taking what happened to little Arthur personally. It's absolutely horrific what has happened to him by those vile excuses for human beings.

The point I was making is that sometimes there is no reason for people being the way the are.
It cannot be explained.
It's understandable people are looking for reasons, I get it.
I spent 20 years looking for them, there were none and this constant " well she/he was possibly abused themselves" thought process doesn't actually help anyone. It just leaves us who have worked through it wondering if we are destined to repeat the same mistakes. (We are not!)

It would do more good if people reported abuse when seen, not thinking its not my business etc.
That we actually funded social services properly, and we ALL took safeguarding seriously.

I wasn't being specific about Arthur , although the current case brought it to my mind.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 04/12/2021 09:01

Arthur's stepmother was at one point an innocent newborn baby. I hate to think what happened to her as she was raised because her behaviour is so extreme and sadistic
Some people are sadistic psychopaths. I believe they are wired like that, it's not upbringing, its more a disability. I don't think there is evidence they "become" like that because of something that happened to them.

There is evidence there's a genetic basis for psychopathy and some suggestions it is a result of a damaged brain

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-15386740

I don't know what the answer is. It must be almost impossible to be a social worker, dealing with families where they don't have the skills to be effective parents for whatever reason, whilst simultaneously needing to diffetentiate that from those who are sadistic child abusers.

Fernando072020 · 04/12/2021 09:01

I know it must come across as awful when people look for reasons, but I genuinely think it's because most of us can't fathom abuse like that taking place just because someone is evil. It's a scary thought for a lot of people. Like if there's a reason, then there's an explanation.

Sometimes there just isn't a reason. Sometimes people are just downright evil. And I believe that is a terrifying fact to grasp, so making up a reason (although not justifying it), allows people to go "ah yeah but she was abused as a child so that's why".

I'm NOT justifying abuse. There are people who were abused / had awful things happen and who would never do that. I'm only attempting to answer your question.

Nanny0gg · 04/12/2021 09:00

I do believe some people are born evil.

She might have been a crap mother but her own children weren't treated as badly as Arthur.

Pure, unadulterated wickedness. And she knew what she was doing.

SoSoTiredToday · 04/12/2021 08:54

I'm sorry all that happened to you OP, and yes, I agree, we do not all end up.repeating the mistakes of our parents (my parents were abusive and I'm trying hard too, to be a good mum for my children).

However, I do not (and will never) believe any child is born evil/bad. I 100% believe our experiences in life mould and shape us into the person we become.

lotsofdogshere · 04/12/2021 08:51

Many parents who suffered abusive childhoods are determined not to repeat the pattern. Some parents/people never take responsibility for their behaviour. They blame their parents, their partner, children, stress etc for their bad decisions or behaviour.

I know many people who didn’t repeat abuse patterns and others who had much easier loving, stable childhoods who were abusive, neglectful parents

Absolutely45 · 04/12/2021 08:50

Normal people can do extremely evil things, i remember the Yugoslavian war, a much loved and respected head teacher became a leader of a Serbian murder squad.
That country was a very popular destination for tourists from all over the world, yet within a few short months ordinary people did terrible to things to each other.

People are not a product of their up bringing nor are born evil, we all have free will.

Iggly · 04/12/2021 08:40

I had a horrific childhood in some ways. And so did my mother.

And I’m terrified of even passing on a drop of that to my dcs.

So I think it is important to understand reasons because then it could be prevented. I would rather time and money was spent on prevention instead of time on punishment - because by then it’s too fucking late and a child has died or suffered terribly.

It’s easy to call people evil monsters when the reality is, they are human beings with some similarities to most of us. Something turns them down a terrible path and I’d rather that did not happen. Ultimately it’s about saving children from a terrible fate.

ElfontheShelfisLookingatYou · 04/12/2021 08:37

I completely agree op but not everyone is on the same page and I think it's really important to talk about and explore what lead to this point. If we don't as a society understand it how can we watch out for it?
I think sometimes it is as simple as a perp knowing no better.
But as you say that's not an excuse and in no way is in inevitable.

kavalkada · 04/12/2021 08:23

I agree, OP.

Like you, I was afraid I will repeat mistakes of my parents with my children.

It took me a lot to realize that I'm not my mother, that I'm not my father and I have a choice what kind of a parent I want to be.

I do the same as you because I don't want my children to go through hell I've been through when I was a child.

No spanking or any kind of physical violence in this house, no shouting, screaming, and I always apologize to my child when I do something wrong. Always.

I'm the happiest when my little boy who is 7 tells me that one day when he grows up he wants to have a family that is just like ours.

OP, I'm really sorry for everything you've been through and your little boy is happy to have you as a mum.

Suspiciousmind20 · 04/12/2021 08:19

So sorry you had to endure that as a child. You are, of course, right. There is NO excuse for child abuse. EVER. If you bring a child into the world you are fully responsible and accountable for how you treat them. No question. You deserved better and should have been protected. And, of course, you are not your past. You can chose a different path. I’m so glad you have changed the trajectory.

I do think, though, that asking ‘how on earth did a human being come to a point where they could treat a child so heinously?’ is important. Not to get them off the hook. Not even to empathise with them. Certainly not as an excuse. But to see how it could be prevented.

Most of the parents I’ve worked with (never abusive to the extent of recent events, but doing some emotional harm nevertheless) didn’t set out to be like that, have histories themselves of difficult childhoods and are doing their best. It’s not good enough - their best - but through intervention they heal their own past hurts and go on to be the parents they truly want to be. Relationships with children are healed and resilience built. I wish my family had had access to the same when I was a child.

We couldn’t do that work if we didn’t at least try to understand how a parent can get to the point of being abusive. We can do that and still believe fully that children come first, and that parents should be held fully responsible and accountable. We can do that and still feel rage about the experience for the child. Shock and horror at recent events. We can do that and still hold enormous empathy for the child’s experience and put their well-being first. It honestly, isn’t excuse making for parents when I try to understand how they got to the place they are in. It’s an absolute desire to make things better for the child.

Surviving childhood abuse and going on to build a good life and be a good parent is an amazing feat. Awe inspiring.

Courtier · 04/12/2021 08:18

OP, it's natural for humans to look for reasoning in these situations. This isn't your mum. It's not the same. Stop taking another child's abuse personally.

EishetChayil · 04/12/2021 08:17

People are looking for reasons, not excuses.

YourenutsmiLord · 04/12/2021 08:16

1-2 children die each week from abuse from DPs.
That has remained steady for years.
I would say the problem is that people including cruel parents, have human rights so it's extremely hard to remove children from bad parents.

Bagelsandbrie · 04/12/2021 08:14

I think child abuse is sadly much, much more common than people think. And therefore if you consider how many people have been abused (and many never reveal that they have been) then the vast majority of abused people don’t go on to become abusers. The only place I ever reveal my own abusive childhood is here - and with my dh. No one else has a clue.

FOJN · 04/12/2021 08:11

I'm sorry your mother was so abusive. I don't believe that children who were abused are destined to become abusive parents and never have. My own mother had the most horrifically abusive childhood and a lifetime of severe mental health problems as a consequence, her parenting was not perfect but it was not abusive and I knew I was loved.

I wonder if we've been lead up the garden path by research into what makes adults abuse children. I was listening to something a few days ago about research interviews with people who commit CSA, in interview over 60% claimed they had been abused in their own childhoods but polygraph results (not always reliable) showed that figure to be closer to 30%. There was a thread recently where a number of people posted links to evidence that the theory of the abused become the abuser was not true to the extent we had previously thought. I doubt anyone will be surprised to find abusers lie for sympathy.

I agree some people are just horrible people. Whatever someone's history our priority should be protecting children not making excuses for adults.

Bagelsandbrie · 04/12/2021 08:06

I was abused as a child by my schizophrenic alcoholic mother in the 80s. I completely agree with you. I’m fed up with people making assumptions about people like me.

CaputApriDefero · 04/12/2021 08:03

My dad was physically, mentally and emotionally abusive. We all have lasting emotional damage, even though he worked on himself when we were all adults and addressed what made him so. Some of it was generational, some of it was unmet ND needs. Regardless, we suffered. Not one of us have ever raised a hand to our children. My children are not afraid of me. At all. They don't want to disappoint me because I'm a loving parent that shows them a great deal of respect, but they're not afraid I'll hurt them. Sometimes, the generational legacy is to repeat the pattern. More often it's to be a totally different kind of parent because of the negative experiences you felt growing up

Tomatobear · 04/12/2021 08:00

I'm so sorry OP. I think people are so far detached from the horrors of the world that they can't imagine evil like that just exists.

ElectraBlue · 04/12/2021 07:52

Agreed.

We all make a choice.

I had toxic, abusive parents and I would NEVER hurt a child physically or mentally.

It makes my blood boil when I read stories about bad parents with things like 'they did the best they could' or 'all parents want the best for the children'. Absolute nonsense.

There is never an excuse/justification for hurting a child. If you have issues it is your responsibility to address them, not to take them out on your kids...

HoseMeDownWithHolyWater · 04/12/2021 07:49

Some people are just cunts. No excuses needed.

Hollyhead · 04/12/2021 07:47

I have put YABU but not because your points are invalid, they’re not, you’re totally right that having a horrendous abusive childhood does not equal automatically being an awful parent yourself. I’m so sorry for what you went through.

However I don’t think people are looking for an excuse, I think they are looking for explanations as to how people can do such evil, and it is the case that in the vast majority of cases perpetuators of horror like this were indeed abused themselves. I see it as just another reason why as a society we should never take our eye off the ball with safeguarding. Primarily to protect the children right now, but secondarily because in a small number of cases, the abuse will cause harm that will result in further harm to others. You only have to read accounts of foster parents etc to see how utterly damaged children as young as 3/4 can be.

starrynight21 · 04/12/2021 07:45

I agree. I was abused as a child, physical, sexual, verbal. And I'm the best damned mother that my children could have ! We don't all end up repeating history , we know how horrible it is so we resolve to do better.