Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask that we stop looking for excuses for horrific child abuse and murder?!

64 replies

Dinotruxagain · 04/12/2021 07:12

Sparked by the murder of little Arthur and the threads I'm seeing trying to look for reasons that the abuse took place.

As a now adult survivor of pretty horrific child abuse , (physically ending in hospital visits) emotional and mental abuse, basically the works.
I find it so very upsetting that people are looking for the generational link, do you understand how that leaves us feeling when it comes to our own parenting?

I now have a child, DS4, but for many decades I was terrified that I would repeat the same pattern with my own child.
It took a lot of therapy to come to the realisation that I, and I alone, controlled my life and my behaviour.

We are not all destined to repeat the mistakes of our parents, yes, we've been damaged but it doesn't mean it's ' rare' to parent well in later life.

My own mother, (father wasn't around) was one of 7 siblings, all perfectly normal happy families.
She didn't have an abusive childhood, nothing different was done in her upbringing compared to her siblings.
She was the only one who turned out to be an abusive person, outward appearance of a wonderful human being, unless of course you were either my brother or I.
Yes, our abuse was reported to social services, we were not believed and returned back to her time and time again. Her job?... she was a social worker.

I'm not sure why I'm posting this, I guess that the recent threads have sparked it but I just wanted to say we're not all destined to repeat the same cycle.
We can, and are good parents despite our upbringing.
Please remember that when you are looking for links, some people are just horrible, horrible people.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dinotruxagain · 04/12/2021 14:29

I'm so sorry so many of you have been through such awful abuse but at the same time I'm incredibly happy that you have gone on to be good, decent parents.
You ( or your partners) have broken the cycle, that is to be admired.

I do believe it's a choice we make, (Thomspon was a child when he commit that horrendous
crime against Jamie, and to me that's a whole other kettle of fish!) But I do believe as adults we choose which way we go.

My brother chose a different path, violence and criminality is what he knows but at over 30 his blaming of his childhood no longer washes for me.
Shit childhoods of course impact how you see the world, the decisions you make etc but at the end of the day we are responsible for our own actions.

There are no reasons nor excuses to me that can justify , nor explain torturing and abusing a child.

Where we go from here I do not know, how do we stop things like this from happening again and again?
Or are we yet again going to be told "lessons will be learnt"?

OP posts:
Lasair · 04/12/2021 14:17

I’m so sorry for what you went through, I think for me I just can’t understand how anyone could abuse a child. So they look for some sort of reason just as it’s unfathomable to me.

You’re right though, why try and philosophise disgrace.

lochmaree · 04/12/2021 13:53

you're right. my DH was emotionally abused and is aware of how his parents behaviour impacted him and how he will not do that to DC. there is generational abuse in his family though.

EllaVaNight · 04/12/2021 13:47

I agree. I don't think abuse should be used as an excuse. My life is a prime example. I was sexually and physically abused as a child and then by an ex. I later became addicted to ketamine. The addiction is entirely on me. I could have made a choice to say no. To go down the healthy path of talking, counselling etc. However I chose drugs. I knew it was wrong and I still did it. No excuse other than my own poor choices. I now make better choices and am and always have been, if I may say so myself, a wonderful mother to my children.

AdamRyan · 04/12/2021 13:41

some don’t really think it through before making moronic statements such as being a murderer is like being disabled 🙄
Oh fgs
How would you describe a brain impairment that affects behaviour then, as setout in the article I linked? I'd describe a birth impairment as a disability. But fine, let's police language and call each other morons rather than actually consider that maybe sadistic psychopaths are born with a disorder

AndreaC67 · 04/12/2021 13:20

@Lockheart

If you don't look for the reasons why people do X then you can't prevent X happening. I think we'd all agree that prevention is better than cure.
The prevention strategies are well known, its just that as a country, we don't care. Child murders have doubled over the last 5 years, just a few days ago, a 12yo was stabbed to death in Liverpool.

26 children have been murdered in London so far this year, yet we are still closing youth centres, closing down access to sports facilities and child MH services.

We all hand wring when hi profile cases such as this horrific killing happen and then go back to our safe worlds until the next time, the harsh reality is that we'd rather have pension tax relief than fund social services.

Lockheart · 04/12/2021 13:04

If you don't look for the reasons why people do X then you can't prevent X happening. I think we'd all agree that prevention is better than cure.

RobertaFirmino · 04/12/2021 12:59

@EishetChayil

People are looking for reasons, not excuses.
It is only through looking for the reason why things happen that we can take steps to prevent them happening again.
honeylulu · 04/12/2021 12:09

Well it's a nature/nature thing isn't it?
Some people will be genetically predisposed to being a psycopath/ sociopath/ having a personality disorder. Sometimes it will be so strong the upbringing won't make it more or less likely. I'm trying to think of an example. Jeremy Bamber maybe?

Sometimes a bad nurturing experience will create an environment for the genetic predisposition to develop in a certain direction. Robert Thompson? Or a good one will result in a psychopath who isn't a murderer but, say, a successful surgeon or political leader.

And sometimes someone with little or no genetic predisposition will be so damaged by a childhood experience that a personality disorder develops.

So it's probably a very individual thing depending on the factors and circumstances. Very hard to ascertain given that psychology is such a nebulous science.

sst1234 · 04/12/2021 11:59

Agree OP. Personal responsibility is just not a thing anymore. No one can just be bad or nasty or a criminal. There has to be some mental health issue, background story. People fall over themselves to make excuses for others. Infantilising grown adults is ridiculous and not ‘progressive’.

tallduckandhandsome · 04/12/2021 11:46

The point I was making is that sometimes there is no reason for people being the way the are.
It cannot be explained.
It's understandable people are looking for reasons, I get it.

But often our childhoods are a factor in who we grow up to be. We can’t throw away decades of research because it upsets people.

No one thinks if you had abusive parents, you will grow up to be abusive.

But if you read, for example, the case of Robert Thompson and think his childhood wasn’t a factor in what he did to James Bulger then you would be misguided.

honeylulu · 04/12/2021 11:37

It troubles me too. I did not suffer the terrible abuse that some of you have posted about (I'm so sorry you went through that) but I was badly damaged by my parents emotional neglect, I think I'd call it. They didn't seem to think their children had any autonomy- we were considered possessions or extensions of them. Luckily for my sister, she was exactly what they wanted/expected. I was constantly told what a disappointment I was to them and how they suffered from that. How I felt never seemed to occur to them. As an adult I feel like I could fall off the face of the earth and they would neither notice nor care.

All this just made me so determined that my children would have a completely different experience. I do "parent" them but they can always tell us what they think and feel without judgement and they know we will always love them and be "on their team" despite any disagreement or (reasonable) discipline required.

I find it very hard to swallow that people just repeat the cycle without thinking. My own parents would say "that's what it was like when we were young and it didn't do us any harm". It's as if they totally forgot how they thought and felt as children.

kesstrel · 04/12/2021 11:33

There are acres of research linking childhood abuse with becoming an abuser.

And what is that research based on? Primarily on self-report. By abusers who not unnaturally want to make it look like it wasn't their fault.

To which we can add the large percentage of children who are absued but don't become abusers themselves. Why were they immune to this supposed link, if not because of some differences in their personalities?

And no-one is born with a personality disorder.

No, they are born with the genetic profile that significantly increases the likelihood that they will develop a personality disorder as they mature.

And large studies have shown that sociopathy is hereditary to a considerable degree. In addition, google "callous and unemotional" for the evidence that sociopathic traits can be seen in relatively young children.

FindingFlorestan · 04/12/2021 11:24

Op I agree.
I haven't time to post properly but just wanted to express solidarity.
My family history has terrible events that were not then the cause of intergenerational dysfunction. I think the focus on this is due to modern systems seeking to explain what used to be classified as "evil" but that isn't part of the modern western world viewpoint any longer.
Here's a wholly inadequate but heartfelt
Flowers.

HotPenguin · 04/12/2021 11:20

I'm sorry for what you went through. I don't think people are looking for excuses, they are looking for reasons and triggers to try and stop it happening again. For example, lockdown was clearly a factor in this case. That does not in any way excuse the vile action of the two perpetrators. But it might help schools and social services think about keeping up better contact with children who are not bn school for any reason.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 04/12/2021 11:15

@kesstrel

Of course as an adult she is responsible for her behaviour but it would be helpful to be aware of how people become so twisted so there can be appropriate interventions.

The more research that is done on personality disorders, the more evidence there is of a genetic basis. There is not any real evidence that it is negative experiences that cause people to become like this. With antisocial-sociopathic disorder, what naive people believe are "appropriate interventions" can actually make the problem worse.

What we need is more awareness among the caring professions of the nature of personality disorders, and how disordered people can often present as extremely charming and "nice". And that they are perfecty capable of lying about having experienced abuse as children in order to gain sympathy.

Sorry but that is nonsense. There are acres of research linking childhood abuse with becoming an abuser. And no-one is born with a personality disorder.
SetSail · 04/12/2021 10:01

@YourenutsmiLord

1-2 children die each week from abuse from DPs. That has remained steady for years. I would say the problem is that people including cruel parents, have human rights so it's extremely hard to remove children from bad parents.
Supposedly it’s ‘child first’ but actually, it’s adults’ human rights first, child safety be damned
Octavia174 · 04/12/2021 09:52

@Nanny0gg

I do believe some people are born evil.

She might have been a crap mother but her own children weren't treated as badly as Arthur.

Pure, unadulterated wickedness. And she knew what she was doing.

mmmm its the old nature vs nurture isn't it?

I believe that once you dehumanise someone, then that enables another human being to do what they like to them.

Look at how we view migrants and their deaths either in the channel or the Mediterranean, no one seems to be too bothered because we do not see them as humans, just like us, anymore - 3 children drowned, yet no outrage.

hangrylady · 04/12/2021 09:47

I agree OP. My parents both had very tough upbringings. Both very poor , my Dad's parents died young and he was in and out of care and my mum had an abusive alcoholic father. They are both fantastic parents and grandparents, and if anything their experiences as children have driven them throughout their lives to want better for me and my brother. I'm sorry for what you went through as a child, you're out of it now and free to enjoy your own family x

kesstrel · 04/12/2021 09:47

Of course as an adult she is responsible for her behaviour but it would be helpful to be aware of how people become so twisted so there can be appropriate interventions.

The more research that is done on personality disorders, the more evidence there is of a genetic basis. There is not any real evidence that it is negative experiences that cause people to become like this. With antisocial-sociopathic disorder, what naive people believe are "appropriate interventions" can actually make the problem worse.

What we need is more awareness among the caring professions of the nature of personality disorders, and how disordered people can often present as extremely charming and "nice". And that they are perfecty capable of lying about having experienced abuse as children in order to gain sympathy.

Confusedteacher · 04/12/2021 09:38

@ronniz “I think people look for excuses as a reassurance that they will be shielded from bad things.”

This, exactly! People see something horrific in the news and want to reassure themselves it would never happen to them/their children. So they blame the upbringing, or they blame single mothers, just so they can feel reassured that “this could never happen to me or anyone I know, I’m not like them”.

Mumoblue · 04/12/2021 09:38

I understand the motivation behind wanting to know why these terrible things happen, but it can sound a bit like minimising the perpetrators actions.

I suffered neglect as a child, and while I don’t blame my mother (because she was seriously mentally ill at the time)- I remember hearing people say that children who were badly treated will grow up to treat their kids badly and it scared me. It made it sound like an inevitability, which of course it’s not.

WhoWants2Know · 04/12/2021 09:34

@HoseMeDownWithHolyWater

Some people are just cunts. No excuses needed.
This is kind of my view. Of course in a lot of cases, an abuser will have a history of being abused. But more people who suffer abuse don't go on to abuse others.

I don't like allowing headspace for the reasons why someone like her does what she does. I'd never get my head around it.

But it is important to understand that there are people out there like her and learn to recognise the signs so we can help vulnerable people escape.

SnarkyBag · 04/12/2021 09:27

@AdamRyan

Arthur's stepmother was at one point an innocent newborn baby. I hate to think what happened to her as she was raised because her behaviour is so extreme and sadistic Some people are sadistic psychopaths. I believe they are wired like that, it's not upbringing, its more a disability. I don't think there is evidence they "become" like that because of something that happened to them.

There is evidence there's a genetic basis for psychopathy and some suggestions it is a result of a damaged brain

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-15386740

I don't know what the answer is. It must be almost impossible to be a social worker, dealing with families where they don't have the skills to be effective parents for whatever reason, whilst simultaneously needing to diffetentiate that from those who are sadistic child abusers.

Great now child murderers are being bunched in with people with disabilities.

I think people are trying to make sense of it which is fine but some don’t really think it through before making moronic statements such as being a murderer is like being disabled 🙄

Bubblecap · 04/12/2021 09:24

People are attempting to understand and there is nothing wrong with that.

I am someone who survived a very sexually violent and abusive childhood with regular beatings, starvation and to the point my stepfather tried to strangle me.

How am I as a parent? Well I have never done any of those things but I know I have times when I have struggled to connect to any humans due to my mental health. It’s taken years of therapy and along the way I have met many seriously mentally ill people, mainly women as much of the time has been in a Mother and Baby unit or on a women’s ward.

What happens to children is so terrible it’s good that people are discussing it. It’s an issue that needs as much airing as possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread