Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there needs to be a clearer diagnosis than just Autism?

344 replies

wiklowarrior · 04/12/2021 05:58

As in, 'Autism such and such'.

I'm a professional woman, had a good job (before becoming a carer), married, nice home, friends. I'm also autistic, which was once diagnosed as Asperger's (and is what I was given). That's no longer the case now. As a child, I was eccentric to other people, always played alone, unless my nightmare routine was disturbed. Spoke extensively about my favourite things in great detail. Then you'd see more obvious signs. Overall though the entire thing leaves me exhausted. It's the masking that does a lot of that.

DS was diagnosed with autism before he was 3.

He can't speak a single word, and doesn't respond to simple language communication such as 'Get shoes'. He is a complete flight risk, would run into roads in a flash. He is in nappies. Never been able to toilet train him, despite numerous efforts (of which were all very obvious weren't going to work, because he does not communicate and doesn't seem to have a desire to). He is hyperactive, climbing another danger. He runs face first into walls. Attacks me, attacks other children and just anyone really. He destroys most things I've ever owned really. But very clever at working out locks and reaching high places. I see the frustration in his face every day and it breaks my heart. My own autism is exhausting.

Can you imagine then if I couldn't speak a single word, have the ability to use sign language despite years of effort? Couldn't use picture exchange? Couldn't even POINT to what I want or need? It's obviously very much a harder deal for him. His autism is severe. And I think a label for that would be useful without having to go into detail in multiple examples of telling people about him being autistic.

He does not attend the local SEND school specifically for communication disorders because he's too disabled by his autism. He attends a very good special needs school for a variety of very complex medical and autistic needs and it's the best school for him.

Yes I know masking is hard, even for those of us appearing 'high functioning'. But at least we have the option? Surely? DS and others like him don't.

OP posts:
CrumbsThatsQuick · 04/12/2021 16:21
  • learning disability
CrumbsThatsQuick · 04/12/2021 16:20

I truly believe these "low functioning: children have a learning difficulty BECAUSE of their very severe ASD, not in addition to it. Like the OPs son is actually quite decent escape artist involving cognitive ability. They can't learn as others do because they are so significantly impacted by their communication impairment. But they have the same diagnosis as the savants and the slightly quirky maskers (who are all significantly impacted by their ASD in their own individual way). It seems crazy that there isn't a separated diagnosis.

bhooks · 04/12/2021 16:14

Very quickly
Learning difficulty = dyslexia, dyscalculia, etc (and includes ADHD)

Learning Disability = "reduced intellectual ability"

MENCAP has a good explanation
www.mencap.org.uk/learning-disability-explained/learning-difficulties

peboh · 04/12/2021 16:04

Personally no. My dd presents differently on different days. Some days her support needs are much higher, others they are not. She in herself has a spectrum with asd. How would you manage a case like that? Would you base it on what professionals see, or what parents and family see, or school etc.
There was a reason functioning labels were done away with, and because you cannot apply the same label to the same individual consistently. To then say we need to start adding more labels, we're then taking away the validity of those who don't seemingly to the outside world struggle. That's not right.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 04/12/2021 16:02

Ds was diagnosed just after he turned 2. They told me he doesn't seem to have any additional learning disabilities. I remember going home and thinking but what does that mean? At the time he couldn't communicate at all , was violent and a danger to himself.

Now at 8 he masks so well people don't realise he has autism at all but when he was very young in some situations I'd just say he has a learning disability so , as a pp says I didn't have to listen to oh my neighbours son has that but is at Cambridge now or like rain man? Is he really good with numbers?

My dsis is a learning disability nurse and she definitely isn't out their in the community supporting people with dyslexia so .

It's rare that I have to say anything in public these days but I'll never forget the disapproving looks we used to get.

Barn0w1 · 04/12/2021 15:57

No I’m not. Re the one case speaking for all I mean cases who perceive their autism to be the real deal and somehow more worthy of the diagnosis than others.

Autism varies and the struggles can be huge for those without learning difficulties. Separate labels just belittle that.

shouldistop · 04/12/2021 15:49

[quote wiklowarrior]@VividGemini Sorry to jump on your response but what would you say to someone you're apologising to in public?

I often say 'So sorry, he's autistic'. And sometimes people are very nice and say 'oh such and such is autistic and they've just got into uni'. Or 'oh my granddaughter is autistic and she works at such and such'.

I just don't think saying autism is enough, especially when there are so so many of us who are fully functioning, even if it's masked [/quote]
I'd just say 'disabled' rather than autistic so you don't have to listen to how their neighbours son is the next Nobel prize winner.

PriamFarrl · 04/12/2021 15:49

@Barn0w1

YABU and I’m sick of threads like this. Autism has hoards of different traits so no one case speaks for all. All individuals will vary. I have it and so do my 3 children. We vary hugely. I also work with children who have SENs. You don’t just stick them under an SEN label but look as them and their need as individuals. Autism should be no different.

Some people have learning difficulties with their autism some don’t, some have mental health difficulties, others don’t. My dc has been hospitalised several times due to her autism. Like many autistic girls she has Anorexia and other mental health problems.She has other learning difficulties too but attends a grammar. Not sure why her autism doesn’t count because her difficulties don’t warrant a 121. If you are autistic you are neurodiverse and will be facing challenges. The generic label says that.

Also many women and girls mask and hide their autism. Not validating their autism because they don’t display it the right way is hugely damaging and I suspect why so many struggle. We are finally starting to validate how autism presents differently in girls, gate keeping isn’t helpful.

You seem to be agreeing with the OP.
Barn0w1 · 04/12/2021 15:46

YABU and I’m sick of threads like this. Autism has hoards of different traits so no one case speaks for all. All individuals will vary. I have it and so do my 3 children. We vary hugely. I also work with children who have SENs. You don’t just stick them under an SEN label but look as them and their need as individuals. Autism should be no different.

Some people have learning difficulties with their autism some don’t, some have mental health difficulties, others don’t. My dc has been hospitalised several times due to her autism. Like many autistic girls she has Anorexia and other mental health problems.She has other learning difficulties too but attends a grammar. Not sure why her autism doesn’t count because her difficulties don’t warrant a 121. If you are autistic you are neurodiverse and will be facing challenges. The generic label says that.

Also many women and girls mask and hide their autism. Not validating their autism because they don’t display it the right way is hugely damaging and I suspect why so many struggle. We are finally starting to validate how autism presents differently in girls, gate keeping isn’t helpful.

Grimbelina · 04/12/2021 15:26

Having said that I heard a podcast the other day arguing for naming the level of support. So your ds would be asd with high support needs. It was from Life Kit: Parenting. We're not broken.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale I am really interested in this way of describing autism as it focuses on the person with ASD and need rather than the perception of others/the neurotypical. Off to listen to the podcast.

I also know people who were diagnosed with Aspergers years ago and refuse an ASD label and will stick to Aspergers.

Heartofglass12345 · 04/12/2021 15:19

I think they got rid of functioning labels as they weren't helpful in the way that people with 'high functioning' or Asperger's diagnoses weren't getting the correct support as they were expected to be like NT people just a bit quirkier. I think they've discovered now that a lot of them were struggling a lot and were masking and actually needed more help than it seemed like on the surface if that makes sense?

My son is autistic and completely different to yours so I understand your frustration though.

It does sound to me as if your son has a learning disability as well though. Have you had a look on the mencap website? There might be useful information on there.

Even if he does have a learning disability diagnosis as well, it wouldn't change how he is, it sounds like he needs input from professionals such as occupational therapy and you need support on how to meet his sensory needs which may help with things like smearing. They may also be able to help with communication aides too. (Sorry if you have already gone down that route and I'm sounding bossy)

I found it weird when my son was diagnosed though, they sent us a letter saying he was autistic, he did a few OT sessions to help him learn some skills then we were just discharged from everything Confused

steppemum · 04/12/2021 15:03

what an interesting discussion.

We think my dd aged 14 is on the spectrum and are pursuing a diagnosis. She is not 'bad enough' to get an NHS diagnosis, so we are paying to go private.

She needs support as she has high anxiety and it costs her so much effort to mask that she struggles.

But she does not need the sort of support that OP is talking about.
It is almost like we need two completely different type of services for autism. One for kids like OP herself and my dd, and one for kids like the OPs son.

liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 14:47

I agree, I work in a school and when we are told a joining pupil is autistic it doesn't tell us much without further detail. We have 2 diagnosed autistic children in our class. One doesn't need any extra support at all, he's in the top reading and maths groups and is good at sports is happy pretty much all of the time as long as you spend some time each day talking about hoovers with him. He has good friendships. I imagine him in future in a very successful career and a fully active, self sufficient member of the community.

The other child, who I work 1:1 with is verbal in that he can say certain simple words to try and communicate when motivated and regulated, other times he has no idea to explain what he needs. He does not have the ability to have a 2 way conversation, will throw himself to the ground, cry and scream if things aren't exactly as he wants them. Doesn't engage with the other dc in the class at all, it's almost like
they don't exist unless one of them has something he wants. He isn't able to throw or catch a ball, hold a pencil in the pincer grip etc He will never be able to live alone or even go out alone as I can't see the sense of danger eg roads changing. It's basically like having a really large toddler in many ways.

The spectrum is just so broad that Autism alone doesn't tell you much

PriamFarrl · 04/12/2021 14:46

I completely agree. I teach and we have 4 children in this cohort with an ASD diagnosis.
All 4 children are completely different and require totally different support.
At one end of the scale one child needs nothing more than instructions clarifying and checking on every so often. At the other end is another child who has their own separate work space and a 1:1.

Just a label of autism doesn’t really help.

UserOfManyNames · 04/12/2021 14:38

I totally agree. The blanket diagnosis of ‘Autistic Spectrum Disorder’ doesn’t help anyone in understanding the diagnosee’s needs. Where are they are on the Spectrum exactly? Level 3, Level 1?

My DS has a diagnosis of ASD and an intellectual disability. I struggle to understand it as I don’t know if the ASD is the reason he’s not interested in learning at all and has totally shutdown due to very bad experiences at school from when he started, or if he really can’t learn due to his intellectual disability. If it is a topic he’s interested in, he has reams of knowledge about it and speaks very eloquently about it and you’d would be shocked he apparently had an IQ of 68 but he’s also very like an 8-10 year old (at 19) in terms of behaviour with associated SEMH issues.

It is extremely frustrating.

Figgit · 04/12/2021 14:29

Eh? But a parent won’t be telling you that as a supply teacher!
No two people with ASD are exactly the same. What’s the solution - give all of us a unique diagnosis?

salviapages · 04/12/2021 14:08

@Figgit yes if I was taking over as their teacher I would have access to these, but supply teachers arrive in the morning and if we're lucky a TA will be there to briefly tell us of any children with SEND. I'm saying this kind of brief overall diagnosis doesn't account for the huge range of differences, so I can imagine as a parent telling someone your children has autism isn't very useful

Figgit · 04/12/2021 14:02

@salviapages that’s not a diagnosis issue, that’s a school issue. Surely the children have IEPs so you can see or be briefed as to their particular needs.

salviapages · 04/12/2021 13:50

I was talking about this just the other day. As a supply teacher I'll go into a class and be told 'x child is autistic' as if that's enough information to go on, it isn't.

The other day I had 2 autistic boys in the class. One can't do eye contact or be touched, obsessed with rules, get frustrated very easily. Other one loves eye contact and wanted to cuddle me all day, loves breaking rules to make others laugh. They are completely different to each other and have different needs, just saying 'they are both autistic' helps no one including them.

Gottahavehighhopes · 04/12/2021 13:49

@Latenightpharma @ozanj

I agree that down syndrome often comes with a similar spectrum. A close relative has downs syndrome and has very low communication, won't be able to live independently etc. The discourse about down syndrome is often of smiling happy people. Often discussions talk of those people who work in shops, can live independently and if you don't fit the cutesy image then support is very limited and your excluded from the discussion

Sockwomble · 04/12/2021 13:41

"How do we differentiate between what's the Autism and the intellectual disability?"

I think the two are so intermingled in people who have both that you cannot separate them out. It isn't the case of having the difficulties of one and the difficulties of the other. However for ds you cannot support his learning disability without making sure his needs associated more with autism ( eg sensory difficulties, right environment) are met first.

Figgit · 04/12/2021 13:34

@eloquent you could have described my son.

But what this discussion shows to be is that it is incredibly difficult to sub-categorise ASD as it is so very complex.

I think I said it above, but will say it again. It’s not a competition. Our experience of ASD doesn’t invalidate someone else’s, just as theirs doesn’t invalidate ours. Personally I find the idea that somehow x’s situation is worse than y’s upsetting, distasteful and doesn’t help anyone.

Doubleraspberry · 04/12/2021 13:33

This is why the term Asperger is no longer used by the medical profession:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-43820794

x2boys · 04/12/2021 13:27

@Justrealised

I understand that there are varying degrees of impact on different days/ times whoch is hard and difficult but and here's the thing, there are some people who are impacted all the time. These people are losing out on funding, specialism, research and understanding. The dx has changed so much over the years and has almost become a fad.

Diagnosis shouldn't be self made, it takes a team of people to dx autism and for good reason too. Autism is a serious and debilitating disability which seems to have become trendy.

There needs to be separate dx.

Agree ,my son is severley impacted in every area, his level of needs does not fluctuate ,he needs 24 HR care seven days a week.
Hankunamatata · 04/12/2021 13:24

I think your right op - sub sections are useful, though some people would disagree. I use term high functioning with learning diffs for my wee asd dude. It's a minefield though as some people pref different usage of asd to describe themself. One friend says she is autistic and another says she has autism as in a medical condition. Iv come to learn it's a personal thing how to describe yourself.

I think it's also hard now if you dont have an asd diagnosis, just learning difficulties or processing issues. It's almost like being left out of a club as so much support is geared towards asd

Swipe left for the next trending thread