Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there needs to be a clearer diagnosis than just Autism?

344 replies

wiklowarrior · 04/12/2021 05:58

As in, 'Autism such and such'.

I'm a professional woman, had a good job (before becoming a carer), married, nice home, friends. I'm also autistic, which was once diagnosed as Asperger's (and is what I was given). That's no longer the case now. As a child, I was eccentric to other people, always played alone, unless my nightmare routine was disturbed. Spoke extensively about my favourite things in great detail. Then you'd see more obvious signs. Overall though the entire thing leaves me exhausted. It's the masking that does a lot of that.

DS was diagnosed with autism before he was 3.

He can't speak a single word, and doesn't respond to simple language communication such as 'Get shoes'. He is a complete flight risk, would run into roads in a flash. He is in nappies. Never been able to toilet train him, despite numerous efforts (of which were all very obvious weren't going to work, because he does not communicate and doesn't seem to have a desire to). He is hyperactive, climbing another danger. He runs face first into walls. Attacks me, attacks other children and just anyone really. He destroys most things I've ever owned really. But very clever at working out locks and reaching high places. I see the frustration in his face every day and it breaks my heart. My own autism is exhausting.

Can you imagine then if I couldn't speak a single word, have the ability to use sign language despite years of effort? Couldn't use picture exchange? Couldn't even POINT to what I want or need? It's obviously very much a harder deal for him. His autism is severe. And I think a label for that would be useful without having to go into detail in multiple examples of telling people about him being autistic.

He does not attend the local SEND school specifically for communication disorders because he's too disabled by his autism. He attends a very good special needs school for a variety of very complex medical and autistic needs and it's the best school for him.

Yes I know masking is hard, even for those of us appearing 'high functioning'. But at least we have the option? Surely? DS and others like him don't.

OP posts:
Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 07:44

So under the term autism your child gets their needs met and so does mine. Each will be assessed . There is a big push on keeping autistic people out of inpatient now which my dd is at risk from and I suspect yours is too.

A range of autistic people finally getting their needs recognised and understood is progress. It doesn’t take away anything from your child. I suspect your child wouldn’t need half of what my child gets and vice versa.

You seem to think my child getting the diagnosis she needs and deserves is taking something from yours.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 07:31

NCSA stance rather

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 07:14

@Sirzy

Nobody should slip through the net though. You seem to be suggesting that those who are in your category 3 are more worthy or something.

Small boxes don’t work.

I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying that they have vastly different needs and presentation and that the umbrella diagnosis due to the vast array of presentations it covers doesn't adequately describe them and isn't helpful to them or their carers/ support. How does separting that group remove anything from anyone else in that umbrella. I haven't said what I think should happen to the remaining, infact I've said I stand by the NCAA stance that it isn't my concern.
Sirzy · 06/12/2021 07:06

Nobody should slip through the net though. You seem to be suggesting that those who are in your category 3 are more worthy or something.

Small boxes don’t work.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 07:04

@Sirzy

That’s a very good point barn0w1, we all know that too many girls and women slip through the net as it is because the diagnosis models are too often focused on the typical male presentation of autism we don’t want to do anything that could make that even harder.
The person in my 3rd example isn't able to slip through the net, they can't mask or struggle to get by due to their needs. This is my point a person who can mask still has needs but their needs are a million miles away from someone with severe autism who would never get missed in dx terms.
Justrealised · 06/12/2021 07:01

I'm not advocating for 3 categories my example was to show the difference in how people present, I could give more and more examples.

I'm advocating for a separate dx for those with what was described previously as classic autism/ severe etc to have a separate dx as the way they present and their needs are clearly vastly different.

Why are you so against this group of people having a separate dx? What do you fear it'll remove or change fod your loved ones?

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 06:51

That’s a very good point barn0w1, we all know that too many girls and women slip through the net as it is because the diagnosis models are too often focused on the typical male presentation of autism we don’t want to do anything that could make that even harder.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 06:49

And squashing women and girls who mask into a type 1 kind of box, dismissing their struggles is why we have seen an epidemic of mental health struggles which often explode in the teen years when they can’t contain themselves in that box anymore.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 06:46

And how can you put people into boxes?My dd doesn’t fit into any of your categories. Has traits from 2 and 3, one would hope 1 too eventuallyCrucially struggles to understand her own feelings and emotions so struggles to understand, communicate and engage with psychs and psychologists.

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 06:43

But how do you separate? It doesn’t work and trying to separate just creates more issues.

Autism is the overall umbrella term. It doesn’t fit simply into 3 (or more) categories like your trying, the vast majority of people with autism will have such spiky profiles they simply won’t fit into a neat smaller box like your trying.

To try to restrict the criteria into tighter categories will lead to too many falling through the net because they don’t fit into a box

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 06:38

Ok, so this is general reply and not aimed at one person, as to why i think people with "severe", "low functioning", "classic", Kanner's....autism should be given. Please note I have said I don't agree with the term mild being used where a formal dx has been given.

So 3 people, not based on anyone in particular:-

Person 1: autism dx (aspergers given as a child) married, has children, has a career, has a mortgage.

Person 2: autism dx, verbal and articulate in surroundings that don't cause anxiety, severe anxiety leading to suicidal thoughts, able to engage with psychologists and understand their explanations and help, academic and able to learn (possibly really bright in some areas), didnt get GCSE's as couldn't cope with school, no career as can't cope in the workplace, able to have conversations, lives with parents who help manage mental health aspects. Enjoys xbox gaming. No friends due to social anxiety but has acquaintance and online friends, able to engage in chat rooms and forums/ online gaming.

Person 3, autism dx. Non verbal however verbalises with grunts, whizzing, humming, other noises, few personal hygiene/ self care skills, rocks and stims alot, no qualifications but went to special school until 19, learning age in most areas of year 1, requires at least 2:1 care at all times, has no understanding of safety, lives in shared facility with good PA's via budget (have to dream), enjoys being around animals and mickey mouse.

How can the one dx adequately describe all three people?

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 06:28

Ds has a list of Comorbids as long as your arm. There is no way you could ever begin to try to separate things out because they all overlap and influence each other too much.

Just the same as his physical health issues where things often go hand in hand and one impacts the other. The lines get blurred between them

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 05:08

Bessie my DD’s psych seems to be going with that too. More of a focus on the traits than the label. If she was written of as mild autism I’m not sure the severity of some of her traits would be dealt with as seriously

I think if anybody is unable to communicate how they’re feeling to the extent they self harm, restrict food or become suicidal and continuously mask during treatment it’s not a mild condition.

BessieFinknottle · 06/12/2021 04:31

Believe me, I do not trivialise any of the conditions I mentioned, BlankTimes. If you prefer to
say comorbid diagnoses that's fine too. I think we pay too much attention to the names/labelling of conditions, and create division somewhat arbitrarily. Each new revision of the DSM brings change.

My point was that so many people have these mutiple diagnoses - one study in 2010 found 95% of people with ASD have 3 comorbidities, and 75% have at least 5. The same types of comorbidities too. Yet pp have said, for example, that MH issues, or intellectual disability are entirely separate to autism. I disagree. If these conditions are occurring at such high frequencies in the autistic population, then I don't think they can be considered entirely separarely. They're linked, though not in everyone of course. It can be hard to say where one diagnosis ends and the other begins - my DC's MH problems stem directly from the 'black and white' restricted thinking typical of ASD, and cannot be treated without acknowledging this.

I don't think having an alphabet soup of diagnoses is helpful either. My DS was truly upset by the number of conditions he was diagnosed with, he found it dehumanising to have so many issues, and it greatly affected his self esteem. His psychiatrists helped a lot when they explained they were just tools used to describe various facets of his condition. It's of note that two (highly qualified) psychiatrists, working completely independently of each other, told him this. Both were adamant that 'it didn't really matter what you called them' (them being the diagnoses), that he didn't really have so many conditions, that they were just different ways of describing aspects of him. It's addressing the problems a person faces that's important, not separating those problems into boxes. A unified approach, in other words.

lborgia · 06/12/2021 03:51

@BlankTimes - perfectly said.

BlankTimes · 06/12/2021 01:13

Labels are found on suitcases and jars of jam.

Medical diagnoses, sometimes given after several appointments in different settings, often by a team of highly qualified professionals, do not deserve such a derogatory term.

It minimises and trivialises conditions which are debilitating, disabling and lifelong.

BessieFinknottle · 06/12/2021 00:07

I don't really agree with the notion that you can separate a person into all their separate diagnoses as @Justrealised, for example, has suggested. So far my DC has asd, adhd, dyspraxia, dyslexia, hypermobility, ocd, generalised anxiety. The camhs psychiatrist told us the collection of labels is basically meaningless, they're all more than likely just describing different aspects of a single condition (probably genetic) that affects my child. Where do you draw the lines between the different labels? They overlap and layer upon each other. Putting the traits of a person into neat little boxes isn't possible or even desirable in my opinion.

Inquisitivearchitect · 05/12/2021 23:27

I totally agree @wiklowarrior

I have autism & ADHD and every single professional I’ve dealt with regarding both have been totally against “labels”

Barn0w1 · 05/12/2021 23:10

Nope not really as impact can be catastrophic in other ways even leading to death.

The description will surely hinge on the report and professionals who gave it. Even non verbal autistic people will vary and a one size fits all label within that category.

My DD’s diagnosis hasn’t been meaningless at all. It’s been hugely beneficial as her treatment abd handling is tailored towards it.

RavingAnnie · 05/12/2021 23:09

[quote Justrealised]Ncsa statement of changing the dsm and why it is required. Counter points to the comorbid learning disability argument.

www.ncsautism.org/dsm?fbclid=IwAR15MRfsTXr_wkQMWkSTEkMzeZxQswx5vE5p_1IK4tvtDcI-s0L85hvN6Dw

YouTube webinar on changing the dsm (which will lead to changes in the UK). The video outlines some vital points

lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fyoutu.be%2FGVxE5RH0ycg%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR3ve_0sSy2_ZZbgSdF1kZzAr7htpXiHlibKnJ8Otw5Esb3h_9mbOfdhtK4&h=AT1BK6q2XqbBgQ3E3pj7ifN-t02j81XHcU1Mkc8gIQfVX_G2c3v4OEyAYQiNOAwx_IsQ3MVb98nZ3ljEgXXlQL9UEyRzmUTeVjWYwKZA-2fPJi6zYfLJhikQbHVtWMQiKWQs--Mt56CPULi6L-2L9p_s0UlUVF3TUTs[/quote]
I completely agree with this and am glad to hear their us lobbying afoot to make this type of change.

Elephantsparade · 05/12/2021 23:09

@Justrealised - thank you for elaborating.

It does feel a very broad diagnosis and sometime i think it is hard to see a core that makes all autistic people autistic and not just a random bunch of people with different difficulties and abilities.

Its a shame support is so difficult to access. I dont think people would give much time for this debate if services and support were adequete.

I already feel anxious about whether there is enough supported living available for him as an adult.

Justrealised · 05/12/2021 22:49

@Barn0w1

Ok so my dd is severely impacted by her autism but is academically able and verbal so unless you’re going to elaborate on your levels you can’t really come out with such a sweeping inflammatory statement. It’s meaningless without some detail.
Can you really not see how someone verbal and academically able is less impacted than someone with extremely limited communication with a education age years below their chronological age?

The dx is meaningless as it's meaning is so different for each person it doesn't convey an adequate description.

UselessASD · 05/12/2021 22:44

Trigger MH
I don’t know the answer. Levels might help with the general public. I think a lot is about recognition and all needing to fight hard to get support that we need for ourselves or loved ones.

I have adult 40 autism diagnosis, missed at 16 . No follow up and no social skills training. As you can see from just this post I can understand that I have autism and a level of ability. It does seem strange that I have the same condition/disability as someone that cannot speak and 24 hours supervision to be safe.

However appearances can also be deceptive. I am aggressive with my parents. I have melt downs. I have no friends, can manage acquaintances but not get beyond that. If something happens in my flat I ask my parents. I honestly don’t know whether if something really serious happens that just affects me I would be able to get help from anyone except a professional or my parents. So if there was a fire I would get help from neighbours because it could affect them. If I broke my ankle parents or wait many hours for ambulance rather than be able to contact anyone - it only affects me. I hate myself and autism.

My mother once asked me how I will cope when they can jo longer help or die. I didn’t say but we both know that I could be a danger to myself and would wish for death. (Underlying MH but not sure how or whether I will be able to ask for help due to autism)

I don’t care if I was diagnosed with Asperger’s, ASD, autism or level brought in. There needs to be tailored support available across the country through health and social care and education but of course that costs money. Though it is very hard if we can all advocate including for those with completely different experiences that might help. That means I need to push for support for OP and son, and if possible though it may not be due to the sheer effort of care, others need to advocate for people like me.

Justrealised · 05/12/2021 22:41

@Elephantsparade I personally wouldn't use the word mild. I agree that mild isn't a good descriptor for something that you need a dx for in the first place.

How the other groupings/ naming or even if the rest should be grouped isn't my concern nor would I want it to be.

The NCSA are lobbying for the dsm to be changed to reflect severe but haven't concerned themselves with other groups. For me this is my train of thought too not because I'm not interested but because It isn't my priority.

Barn0w1 · 05/12/2021 22:28

Ok so my dd is severely impacted by her autism but is academically able and verbal so unless you’re going to elaborate on your levels you can’t really come out with such a sweeping inflammatory statement. It’s meaningless without some detail.