Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there needs to be a clearer diagnosis than just Autism?

344 replies

wiklowarrior · 04/12/2021 05:58

As in, 'Autism such and such'.

I'm a professional woman, had a good job (before becoming a carer), married, nice home, friends. I'm also autistic, which was once diagnosed as Asperger's (and is what I was given). That's no longer the case now. As a child, I was eccentric to other people, always played alone, unless my nightmare routine was disturbed. Spoke extensively about my favourite things in great detail. Then you'd see more obvious signs. Overall though the entire thing leaves me exhausted. It's the masking that does a lot of that.

DS was diagnosed with autism before he was 3.

He can't speak a single word, and doesn't respond to simple language communication such as 'Get shoes'. He is a complete flight risk, would run into roads in a flash. He is in nappies. Never been able to toilet train him, despite numerous efforts (of which were all very obvious weren't going to work, because he does not communicate and doesn't seem to have a desire to). He is hyperactive, climbing another danger. He runs face first into walls. Attacks me, attacks other children and just anyone really. He destroys most things I've ever owned really. But very clever at working out locks and reaching high places. I see the frustration in his face every day and it breaks my heart. My own autism is exhausting.

Can you imagine then if I couldn't speak a single word, have the ability to use sign language despite years of effort? Couldn't use picture exchange? Couldn't even POINT to what I want or need? It's obviously very much a harder deal for him. His autism is severe. And I think a label for that would be useful without having to go into detail in multiple examples of telling people about him being autistic.

He does not attend the local SEND school specifically for communication disorders because he's too disabled by his autism. He attends a very good special needs school for a variety of very complex medical and autistic needs and it's the best school for him.

Yes I know masking is hard, even for those of us appearing 'high functioning'. But at least we have the option? Surely? DS and others like him don't.

OP posts:
Coronawireless · 06/12/2021 08:44

@Justrealised

Personally I would class severe autism as those who are severely impacted all the time by their autism. Social interaction, communication and repetitive behaviours. If your ds is severely impacted by her mental health I would say she has autism and severe mental health needs. Eg autism and severe anxiety, autism and an eating disorder,

The distinction is important, it's different, it's a different diagnosis and a different meaning conveyed with it. It doesn't mean I don't think your ds should get support or funding etc. Having a way to easily communicate to others that someone has autism which equates to "low functioning" or "severe" or "profound" is needed whether it's those terms or some other wording. There needs to be a distinction in the diagnosis as, as others have said the dx is now all but meaningless.

So articulately stated.
Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 08:36

Yes it would. In the past her needs wouldn't have been recognised.How is her having the diagnosis she deserves impacting your child? They have different needs and will be accessing different services.

Latenightpharma · 06/12/2021 08:35

@Justrealised because the way this is argued, including by you earlier in the thread, almost always ends up with saying that we have to show that certain people are 'severe'. I have no issue with the fact there are people whose autism affects them more profoundly than it does me, but others do. You tag someone severe, and others immediately become 'mild'. And the way that is always interpreted is 'doesn't need help'. It ends up with the functioning of one autistic person being compared with that of another autistic person, instead of being compared with the functioning level of neurotypicals, which is a big issue for accessing support.

You did this yourself by presenting those three boxes earlier. Being married doesn't mean you need little support. My aunt and uncle are married and they need daily care and supported living. Yes, they are more independent than someone who is in a wheelchair and will hurt themselves if they try and leave the building on their own, but they are miles away from neurotypical married people who live their independent lives. They are not your box 1. Yet they have aspergers.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:33

@Barn0w1

Abd I want my dd to have better understanding about her condition which she’s finally getting with her diagnosis. Shes being kept out of inpatient l, he’d treatment is being adjusted and improved.
Great, I mean truly. having a separate dx for someone who is different to someone vastly different to her won't remove that, why would it? It would help those families though.
santasmuma · 06/12/2021 08:32

[quote Justrealised]@santasmuma I am talking about people who live their whole lives without effective communication or understanding of communication as the majority of people do, people who will never type on mumsnet etc, people who live their whole life with the severe elements, all the time, every day.[/quote]

And I'm talking about me, who many years ago, may have fitted that box. Please don't be dismissive of my past because I can post on mumsnet. I was completely non verbal for many years. It's not uncommon for people to change.

However, have we an element of co morbid learning disabilities at play here?

WaitingForSanity · 06/12/2021 08:31

@SwanShaped
I haven't seen that paddy programme yet but usually people don't receive a diagnosis from a simple questionnaire. I had an assessment which lasted 4 hours. Of asking me questions, filling out some questionnaires. Asking me about specific childhood experiences, work experiences, relationships, communication, doing different kinds of tests, mental tests, visualisations activities. They also spoke to my wife and asked many questions.
It was incredibly thorough before I received a diagnosis.

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 08:31

You can advocate without taking away from the needs of others though. It’s not a race to the bottom

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:29

@santasmuma I am talking about people who live their whole lives without effective communication or understanding of communication as the majority of people do, people who will never type on mumsnet etc, people who live their whole life with the severe elements, all the time, every day.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 08:27

Abd I want my dd to have better understanding about her condition which she’s finally getting with her diagnosis. Shes being kept out of inpatient l, he’d treatment is being adjusted and improved.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 08:26

Amy teacher or SENCO would need to read reports and info. They’d never go oh autism and treat all children the same. How could they?Autism has hoards of traits. No 2 people will be the same.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:21

@Sirzy no what I'm doing is advocating for someone I care about, who deserves to have better understanding about their condition.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:18

[quote Latenightpharma]@Justrealised so why take it away from me, as it is what I have.[/quote]
What am I taking away from you by saying that a group should have a different dx? How does that take your dx away?

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:17

@Elephantsparade I completely understand your fear and yes I can see that happening too being honest. I don't agree with it.

But including a group of people who are incredibly different in presentation just to aid support for others and not for that groups benefit isn't right either. They shouldn't be used in that way or have their individualism sacrificed.

Latenightpharma · 06/12/2021 08:15

@Justrealised so why take it away from me, as it is what I have.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:11

As a general reply, it seems like what is being said is that these people are needed in this dx so that others have their needs met? Why should these people lose agency and a clear descriptor for others benefit and yes their and their carers detriment as it does make life harder.

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 08:10

[quote Justrealised]@santasmuma you are communicating on mumsnet, the people I'm talking about will never do this. You are also understanding this thread and able to articulate a response.[/quote]
But my DS wouldn’t be able to do either of those things but he wouldn’t fit into your severe box!

Your trying to restrict things and it’s exceptionally naieve to think doing that won’t create issues for those who need support.

santasmuma · 06/12/2021 08:09

[quote Justrealised]@santasmuma you are communicating on mumsnet, the people I'm talking about will never do this. You are also understanding this thread and able to articulate a response.[/quote]

Indeed. However previously I would not have been able to do that, and despite being able to post on mumsnet I also have quite severe non verbal episodes. I suppose I should have said I have been elements of all 3. That said your example of person 1 is unrealistic, very few people with autism for a box where they have no struggles; the defecits have to be present for diagnosis. So person 1 maybe has elements of person 2?

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:08

[quote Latenightpharma]@Justrealised that sounds a bit like 'what happens to autistic people who aren't non-verbal is none of my concern'. The way it was previously was detrimental for me and my family. You are saying that now your (child's) needs aren't being met, which is obviously an issue, but your solution is for us to go back to a situation where my family's needs aren't acknowledged, and you don't care about that being the case. How is that progress?

In that case, how about removing the word autism from the severe group and giving them a completely new name? If the majority of autistic people are not 'severe', wouldn't that be easier than taking away autism from the majority and adding seven or so boxes to suit a minority? Why is that never offered as an option?[/quote]
I did offer that as an option.. I said Fred. But why should they lose the autism dx, that's what they have?

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:06

@santasmuma you are communicating on mumsnet, the people I'm talking about will never do this. You are also understanding this thread and able to articulate a response.

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 08:06

But by having an umbrella term it means those who work with the person need to get to know that individual which is much better than making assumptions based on which box they have been squished into.

Latenightpharma · 06/12/2021 08:05

@Justrealised that sounds a bit like 'what happens to autistic people who aren't non-verbal is none of my concern'. The way it was previously was detrimental for me and my family. You are saying that now your (child's) needs aren't being met, which is obviously an issue, but your solution is for us to go back to a situation where my family's needs aren't acknowledged, and you don't care about that being the case. How is that progress?

In that case, how about removing the word autism from the severe group and giving them a completely new name? If the majority of autistic people are not 'severe', wouldn't that be easier than taking away autism from the majority and adding seven or so boxes to suit a minority? Why is that never offered as an option?

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 08:04

@Barn0w1

So under the term autism your child gets their needs met and so does mine. Each will be assessed . There is a big push on keeping autistic people out of inpatient now which my dd is at risk from and I suspect yours is too.

A range of autistic people finally getting their needs recognised and understood is progress. It doesn’t take away anything from your child. I suspect your child wouldn’t need half of what my child gets and vice versa.

You seem to think my child getting the diagnosis she needs and deserves is taking something from yours.

Why do you need who was previously described as severe to be in that umbrella for your childs needs to be met? Do you believe that having a separate dx for those who are severely impacted by autism and not mh would reduce your childs support? What difference does their separate dx make? I'm not saying your child shouldn't have a dx, I'm saying their should be a separate dx for severe autism. It could be called red autism or puppy autism or chip autism or Fred but a name that conveys the presentation of this group and their needs.

Why do you feel this removes something from your child?

I think everyone should have their needs met. I think part of that is being able to give a dx or describe briefly what someones condition is and have people understand roughly what that is. This used to happen with autism as people (mistakenly) thought of rainman. Now if you say x person has autism, it could mean anything. That isn't helpful to support workers, teachers, ta's, service providers or Joe Bloggs in street infront of you in a queue. I think this understanding has been removed now and it isn't helpful to anyone.

santasmuma · 06/12/2021 07:59

@Justrealised

Ok, so this is general reply and not aimed at one person, as to why i think people with "severe", "low functioning", "classic", Kanner's....autism should be given. Please note I have said I don't agree with the term mild being used where a formal dx has been given.

So 3 people, not based on anyone in particular:-

Person 1: autism dx (aspergers given as a child) married, has children, has a career, has a mortgage.

Person 2: autism dx, verbal and articulate in surroundings that don't cause anxiety, severe anxiety leading to suicidal thoughts, able to engage with psychologists and understand their explanations and help, academic and able to learn (possibly really bright in some areas), didnt get GCSE's as couldn't cope with school, no career as can't cope in the workplace, able to have conversations, lives with parents who help manage mental health aspects. Enjoys xbox gaming. No friends due to social anxiety but has acquaintance and online friends, able to engage in chat rooms and forums/ online gaming.

Person 3, autism dx. Non verbal however verbalises with grunts, whizzing, humming, other noises, few personal hygiene/ self care skills, rocks and stims alot, no qualifications but went to special school until 19, learning age in most areas of year 1, requires at least 2:1 care at all times, has no understanding of safety, lives in shared facility with good PA's via budget (have to dream), enjoys being around animals and mickey mouse.

How can the one dx adequately describe all three people?

I have been all of those 3 people throughout my life. Which box do I go in?

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 07:56

And those most likely to not get the support they need are those who would fall just out of the tick boxes for “severe” but who are still severely impacted.

Elephantsparade · 06/12/2021 07:47

@Justrealised - i want everyone to get the support they need and if the most vulnerable need that new diagnosis then i support it as its not all about me.

But put simply, the thing I fear is that my child is only able to access particular services because as much as things are supposed to be needs lead, much of what we needed only became available on disgnosis. Will these services become reserved for severe autism only in a post brexit, post covid, austerity britain? Services like cut-offs as a form of rationing but people dont fit cut-offs so neatly. I also think the people who assess PIP are cruel and if if you put all people who can talk in one category away from the severe category then it runs the risk that only the severe diagnosis will be considered for benefits or sheltered housing etc.

So thats my fear and I think its a rational response to my experience of services so far. That my son whose repetitive behaviours are extensive and dangerous will find he is in the university lecturer category due to his speech and toileting skills, and the expectation for this group will be much higher because all the people with severe autism have been seperated out.

i want enough services for everyone that needs them basically and you do to but we feel a bit different about how to achieve that.