Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there needs to be a clearer diagnosis than just Autism?

344 replies

wiklowarrior · 04/12/2021 05:58

As in, 'Autism such and such'.

I'm a professional woman, had a good job (before becoming a carer), married, nice home, friends. I'm also autistic, which was once diagnosed as Asperger's (and is what I was given). That's no longer the case now. As a child, I was eccentric to other people, always played alone, unless my nightmare routine was disturbed. Spoke extensively about my favourite things in great detail. Then you'd see more obvious signs. Overall though the entire thing leaves me exhausted. It's the masking that does a lot of that.

DS was diagnosed with autism before he was 3.

He can't speak a single word, and doesn't respond to simple language communication such as 'Get shoes'. He is a complete flight risk, would run into roads in a flash. He is in nappies. Never been able to toilet train him, despite numerous efforts (of which were all very obvious weren't going to work, because he does not communicate and doesn't seem to have a desire to). He is hyperactive, climbing another danger. He runs face first into walls. Attacks me, attacks other children and just anyone really. He destroys most things I've ever owned really. But very clever at working out locks and reaching high places. I see the frustration in his face every day and it breaks my heart. My own autism is exhausting.

Can you imagine then if I couldn't speak a single word, have the ability to use sign language despite years of effort? Couldn't use picture exchange? Couldn't even POINT to what I want or need? It's obviously very much a harder deal for him. His autism is severe. And I think a label for that would be useful without having to go into detail in multiple examples of telling people about him being autistic.

He does not attend the local SEND school specifically for communication disorders because he's too disabled by his autism. He attends a very good special needs school for a variety of very complex medical and autistic needs and it's the best school for him.

Yes I know masking is hard, even for those of us appearing 'high functioning'. But at least we have the option? Surely? DS and others like him don't.

OP posts:
Floundery · 06/12/2021 13:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

BessieFinknottle · 06/12/2021 13:23

I'm so sorry to hear of you and your child's cinema experience Justrealised. That was awful.

I'm very sorry to hear of your experience too, Floundery. I'm not at all a fan of 'autism is awesome'. It was probably started with the best of intentions, but it's a milllion miles away from my DC's experience too (even though he's verbal with no ID, his condition is very debilitating).

I don't know what the solution is really. I agree the term autism has become so broad as to be almost meaningless unless further explanation is added. But people vary so much that the three categories mentioned as examples upthread wouldn't come close to covering it either.

In future, it's possible that the condition will be subdivided on the basis of the genetics causing the autism? Something like the way autism secondary to Fragile X is a distinct grouping today. Even then, there will be a lot of variability within groups I would think. So I'm not sure it would help.

Floundery · 06/12/2021 13:09

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Latenightpharma · 06/12/2021 12:59

@Floundery

My DS has classic autism meaning he is impacted in all 3 areas that can be impacted. I had my arse handed to me on a plate when I used this term in a mum’s group to support ND children. Their reaction to me saying “classic autism” was akin to using the disgusting “N” word in a room full of POC. I was left feeling like scum when I was trying to learn and help my child. I was kicked out of the group when I tried to explain why I had used it.

I have stayed away from any debate since then, but I agree with the OP. This “no qualifiers” mandate means that “high functioning” autistic people dominate the debate (and they are typically white and MC - plenty are also “self-diagnosed”). They don’t speak for my profoundly disabled DS and are so busy congratulating themselves on how marvelous being ND is that they won’t see the challenges and shitty lives experienced by the very people for whom they claim to speak.

I was with you until you started with the belittling stereotypes about 'high-functioning' autistic people.

I hope you find a support group that is useful to you.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 12:56

You can’t really attribute that to being services watered down. Whose to say the complaint wasn’t from another children in your group 3. Symptoms will vary. It could also have been staff ignorance. There are zero services to support my DD’s autism

SmellyOldOwls · 06/12/2021 12:55

'My child has been denied access to autism specific groups as he is too autistic, we were asked to leave a relaxed cinema screening as his vocalisations (happy) were too much for another child with autism and it was distracting them from the film (this was a few years ago), he cannot go to the local autism specific school as he is too autistic....'

I can't believe this. I'm so sad to hear he was asked to leave the cinema Sad

Spikeyball · 06/12/2021 12:47

These days I say my son is severely disabled and then say what adjustments he needs or what he cannot do. I don't think saying he has ASC says enough.

I also have the experience of no activities or social provision for my child. It is more expensive and complicated to provide it for him compared to others so it isn't provided.

He has direct payments that we cannot use because no one will work with him because they can earn the same taking an easier to manage child bowling or swimming.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 06/12/2021 11:38

My child has been denied access to autism specific groups as he is too autistic, we were asked to leave a relaxed cinema screening as his vocalisations (happy) were too much for another child with autism and it was distracting themfrom the film

Oh, that has really broken my heart. That's not fair at all. Did you complain?

Floundery · 06/12/2021 11:14

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 11:13

@Barn0w1

Why does it matter if they don’t have a different diagnosis? Your child isn’t going to be getting any difference in their care.
My child has been denied access to autism specific groups as he is too autistic, we were asked to leave a relaxed cinema screening as his vocalisations (happy) were too much for another child with autism and it was distracting them from the film (this was a few years ago), he cannot go to the local autism specific school as he is too autistic....

So yes some facilities and services are being watered down.

If out and we need to apologise or calm a situation saying I'm sorry and examining he has autism doesn't cut it any more as the general public perceive autism as something different which isn't reflective of him.

I want him to have a dx which reflects him.

Yes it does matter, the dx conveys a message about him and it's an important message. It should be accurate and specific.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 11:03

@Elephantsparade I agree that in giving so much detail it takes time which is why I've been advocating for a separate dx for those most impacted.

I find I have to give a list of details to convey my sons needs also.

I don't think there is an easy answer, if/when there is a change, whatever it is will not suit everyone.

Personally I think the group I'm talking about should be diagnosed showing a distinction. As you said it's an easy group to classify and would be a start.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 10:52

@Percie they were just made up examples designed to demonstrate the difference in how people with the same diagnosis can present and how their needs are different.

elliejjtiny · 06/12/2021 10:33

YANBU

I have 3 dc who have autism without learning difficulties. All with very different needs. I don't think lumping all autistic people into one category does anyone any favours tbh.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 10:25

Why does it matter if they don’t have a different diagnosis? Your child isn’t going to be getting any difference in their care.

Elephantsparade · 06/12/2021 10:21

My sons diagnosis is simple ASD but the document that came with it does break it down into the three areas and does say the level of support he might need in each area but its not quick to read through.

On documents and emails i say 'verbal autism, with low personal care need but high level of risky behaviours and limited understanding' its not very snappy.

Percie · 06/12/2021 10:07

Person 1: autism dx (aspergers given as a child) married, has children, has a career, has a mortgage

The thing is, all of the bits you're using to describe person 1 are outward appearances that NT people expect. What it does is ignore the impacts of the Asperger's.

In my case a marriage that's in pieces because I can't cope or mask since having DC. A job that's my sanctuary because it is routine and gives me something to cling onto. A persistent sense of failure that I'm not a good enough parent to DC and that I'm to blame for DCs ASD despite loving them more than anything ever.

The person 1 description doesn't include the meltdowns (usually internalised) when something changes, e.g., the shopping delivery doesn't turn up and I don't know what to do. It doesn't tell you that my career involves not remaining with the same team for more than 2 years because it just gets too hard. It doesn't tell you that I've had to take unpaid breaks from work when I can't cope any more. It doesn't tell you about my MH. It doesn't tell you about the times I'm selectively mute because the words won't move from my brain to my mouth so I sit there feeling like a desperate fool. It doesn't tell you about my sensory issues with clothes and heat, how I dread each summer. The need for extreme repetition when stressed and to just be able to sit alone without those around me feeling rejected. It doesn't tell you how miserable my life is a lot of the time despite appearing to tick all the boxes because I just don't fit.

Marriage, kids, career and mortgage is not a yardstick of impact, it's a yardstick of how well you can hide in public.

That said, I do see the benefit of having some sort of nuance of diagnosis although I've no idea what it could be.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 10:03

@Elephantsparade u see your point but for it to be known that they are severe in 2/3 and moderate in 1/3 they would have been assessed as such.

Maybe you're on to something and the dx should be broken down into the three areas and the three areas defined by themselves? That would give more info about the persons needs.

I agree about using the word profound and do use it. I do also use severe depending on who I'm talking to.

santasmuma · 06/12/2021 09:51

Is this in regards to you, me of the person I care for? Or are you trying to evoke a response that you're not getting in other ways?

I meant the person you were talking to and it was not an unreasonable question.

If it's me, not that I know of, suspect of or have been suspected of. University educated.

If you have ld, that's your business.

I don't.

The person I'm thinking of, no not as such just autism (unless you class autism as a ld?) and the impact that has as a difficulty in their ability to learn. No learning disability either, just autism.

No I don't decide to class autism as a LD. I was simply asking if the person you were talking about had LD. again; not an unreasonable question.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 09:41

@santasmuma is "
However, have we an element of co morbid learning disabilities at play here?"

Is this in regards to you, me of the person I care for? Or are you trying to evoke a response that you're not getting in other ways?

If it's me, not that I know of, suspect of or have been suspected of. University educated.

If you have ld, that's your business.

The person I'm thinking of, no not as such just autism (unless you class autism as a ld?) and the impact that has as a difficulty in their ability to learn. No learning disability either, just autism.

You may want to read some of the earlier posts regarding comorbid conditions, I take it you agree autism is separate to other dx inc learning difficulties?

You may also want to look at the post I made with NCSA links.

Elephantsparade · 06/12/2021 09:40

[quote Justrealised]@Elephantsparade I completely understand your fear and yes I can see that happening too being honest. I don't agree with it.

But including a group of people who are incredibly different in presentation just to aid support for others and not for that groups benefit isn't right either. They shouldn't be used in that way or have their individualism sacrificed.[/quote]
I certainly dont want to use the most vulnerable people with the most significant care needs as an aid for support and i can see your point.

But i suppose thats the crux of it - i dont feel the severe autism group are incredibly different in presentation to all other people with autism who are not severely affected in all areas all the time. I can just see they are easy to categorise.

The gulf between a person severe in all areas and someone severely affected in two areas but moderatley affected in one area doesnt feel so significant they no longer need the same core diagnosis to me.

I dont know the answer. I always quite like the idea of profound autistim as a term over severe autism.

winchfem · 06/12/2021 09:36

From what I read when I first got diagnosed several years back, the reason why Asperger's as a separate diagnosis was phased out is because there's no clear line between 'Asperger's' and 'classic autism'- the distinction depended on the professional's opinion rather than a set of specific symptoms. I was diagnosed simply with autism though it was said a few years earlier it would have been Asperger's- which fits me far better than Asperger's ever would have as I am unlikely to ever live independently and suffer with periods of being nonverbal and regular meltdowns. There was no leeway for the way people's functioning levels changed in different situations or the way some people experienced totally different symptoms to others without either necessarily being 'better' or 'worse'. I think the latest trend of specifying by support needs- high support needs, medium support needs and low support needs- better describes the differences as while all autistic people express the condition in a wide variety of ways, it is one single condition.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 09:26

@Barn0w1

Yes it would. In the past her needs wouldn't have been recognised.How is her having the diagnosis she deserves impacting your child? They have different needs and will be accessing different services.
So why does it matter if they have a different dx?
Justrealised · 06/12/2021 09:24

@Sirzybecause AFRID as a dx communicates quite well what it means to other people and it can be quite easily worked out that some may be peg fed and some may live on breadsticks and McD's nuggets.

That is also your choice and you do quantify by saying he is an extreme case. I'm also not taking anything away, I haven't said autism should be removed as a dx I've said some of the group should be dx with a separate dx that conveys easily the impact their dx has.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 09:19

[quote Latenightpharma]@Justrealised because the way this is argued, including by you earlier in the thread, almost always ends up with saying that we have to show that certain people are 'severe'. I have no issue with the fact there are people whose autism affects them more profoundly than it does me, but others do. You tag someone severe, and others immediately become 'mild'. And the way that is always interpreted is 'doesn't need help'. It ends up with the functioning of one autistic person being compared with that of another autistic person, instead of being compared with the functioning level of neurotypicals, which is a big issue for accessing support.

You did this yourself by presenting those three boxes earlier. Being married doesn't mean you need little support. My aunt and uncle are married and they need daily care and supported living. Yes, they are more independent than someone who is in a wheelchair and will hurt themselves if they try and leave the building on their own, but they are miles away from neurotypical married people who live their independent lives. They are not your box 1. Yet they have aspergers.[/quote]
I gave three possible examples not categories or boxes in order to demonstrate differences in presentation of the same dx. You are misrepresenting what i said.

I think for the group of people I'm talking about the social model which I think you're alluding to isn't practical or relevant.

I have said I don't agree with the use of mild for those with a dx a couple of times.

The truth is though there are people who are more profoundly/ severely impacted by autism. This shouldn't be overlooked or hidden or not acknowledged because others feel it under represents them or lessens their dx. If they are able to articule this, they are impacted to a lesser extent. Why does their needs and their best interests have to be prioritised over the other group with their needs secondary?

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 08:54

One of DS comorbid conditions is ARFID, for him he is in the small group where it means he is primarily tube fed. But I wouldn’t try to take away from the needs of others with the same diagnosis who can still eat enough orally to survive or say that DS needs a different diagnosis. It’s the same condition just different presentations.

The most I may say when talking to someone is he is an extreme case simply to stop others worrying that it’s what to happen to their child.