Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there needs to be a clearer diagnosis than just Autism?

344 replies

wiklowarrior · 04/12/2021 05:58

As in, 'Autism such and such'.

I'm a professional woman, had a good job (before becoming a carer), married, nice home, friends. I'm also autistic, which was once diagnosed as Asperger's (and is what I was given). That's no longer the case now. As a child, I was eccentric to other people, always played alone, unless my nightmare routine was disturbed. Spoke extensively about my favourite things in great detail. Then you'd see more obvious signs. Overall though the entire thing leaves me exhausted. It's the masking that does a lot of that.

DS was diagnosed with autism before he was 3.

He can't speak a single word, and doesn't respond to simple language communication such as 'Get shoes'. He is a complete flight risk, would run into roads in a flash. He is in nappies. Never been able to toilet train him, despite numerous efforts (of which were all very obvious weren't going to work, because he does not communicate and doesn't seem to have a desire to). He is hyperactive, climbing another danger. He runs face first into walls. Attacks me, attacks other children and just anyone really. He destroys most things I've ever owned really. But very clever at working out locks and reaching high places. I see the frustration in his face every day and it breaks my heart. My own autism is exhausting.

Can you imagine then if I couldn't speak a single word, have the ability to use sign language despite years of effort? Couldn't use picture exchange? Couldn't even POINT to what I want or need? It's obviously very much a harder deal for him. His autism is severe. And I think a label for that would be useful without having to go into detail in multiple examples of telling people about him being autistic.

He does not attend the local SEND school specifically for communication disorders because he's too disabled by his autism. He attends a very good special needs school for a variety of very complex medical and autistic needs and it's the best school for him.

Yes I know masking is hard, even for those of us appearing 'high functioning'. But at least we have the option? Surely? DS and others like him don't.

OP posts:
Coronawireless · 07/12/2021 10:50

[quote santasmuma]@lookforthespace

Why do you need another diagnosis though?

Let's take osteoarthritis as an example. It's a physical health condition that can vary in severity and symptoms can come and go. Some people will be crippled by this and in pain all the time, others will have less pain and more mobility. Each person is treated medically according to their individual needs. The person who can no longer walk due to the arthritis does not need a separate diagnosis.

[/quote]
But a person with mild osteoarthritis will see that it is mild compared to a person incapacitated with severe osteoarthritis. No one objects to the severity being defined or campaigns for equal funding across all levels of severity (although I’m sure some do!). The trouble with the very loud autism advocates - often self-diagnosed - is that they won’t accept that there is any level of autism more severe than theirs. They’re just better at coping with it apparently.

santasmuma · 07/12/2021 09:56

@Justrealised

Osteoarthritis has 4 stages depending on how much wear and tear there is to the joint and people travel along the stages. Stage 4 being the most severe. So although there isn't a separate dx it is staged in regards to severity. They aren't able to travel backwards along the stages unless they have say a hip replacement. Generally it's a condition that develops during life and can be eased with medication, possible operations etc. People generally get it in older years due to using their joints, they live their lives and can have children, carers..... Autism is life long, people who have severe autism have it their whole life. It is highly unlikely these people will have children or careers and people with autism do not get more severe as with wear and tear.

My apologies. I had absolutely no idea this was the case with osteoarthritis and I used that in my example as I genuinely thought I knew as much as I could about it. DH was diagnosed with this about 8 years ago but has never been 'staged' or anything like that. Maybe we need to be going back to the consultant then, but that's another story!

I'm not for or against separate labels within the autism diagnosis tbh, I just can't see any solid reasons as to why it would benefit any single person.

But yeah, I guess my example wasn't very helpful after all.

Justrealised · 07/12/2021 09:46

Osteoarthritis has 4 stages depending on how much wear and tear there is to the joint and people travel along the stages. Stage 4 being the most severe. So although
there isn't a separate dx it is staged in regards to severity. They aren't able to travel backwards along the stages unless they have say a hip replacement. Generally it's a condition that develops during life and can be eased with medication, possible operations etc. People generally get it in older years due to using their joints, they live their lives and can have children, carers..... Autism is life long, people who have severe autism have it their whole life. It is highly unlikely these people will have children or careers and people with autism do not get more severe as with wear and tear.

santasmuma · 07/12/2021 09:16

@lookforthespace

Why do you need another diagnosis though?

Let's take osteoarthritis as an example. It's a physical health condition that can vary in severity and symptoms can come and go. Some people will be crippled by this and in pain all the time, others will have less pain and more mobility. Each person is treated medically according to their individual needs. The person who can no longer walk due to the arthritis does not need a separate diagnosis.

lookforthespace · 07/12/2021 09:03

@santasmuma Thing is, it has become clear that more people are able to function independently or with a little support than not, and being completely disabled in every area by their autism.

My DS can't mask because he doesn't have the option or know what that is. He will never be out of nappies, can't speak, can't communicate.

I think there needs to be a separate diagnosis for that particularly type of autism that my son has - Where you are completely trapped because of the disability and unable to communicate at all, not even if it meant getting stressed and unable to cope. He literally can't do it

santasmuma · 07/12/2021 08:01

I understand your overall point but a diagnosis (or even a description of needs) is key to accessing some types of services. If we are going to ensure services meet the needs of a specific group, we need to have a some idea of what the needs are.

I think the problem here is the idea that the needs of a 'group' need to be met. That's not the case. Each individual has different and varying needs.

The level thing is not important on a professional level at all, because nobody is treated the same based on any diagnosis. That's goes for all neuro diversities; physical conditions and mental health issues. So the only reason I can see people arguing for functioning labels is to 'explain' to ignorant outsiders who don't matter anyway.

AnotherEmma · 07/12/2021 07:48

@Floundery
Thank you. He doesn't really have issues at school atm but we've raised some concerns about his behaviour at home and school has been supportive so far.
The GP did actually refer us (much to my surprise!) but the referral was rejected, we got a detailed letter explaining everything they need before they will accept a referral.
My gut feeling is that he'll be diagnosed eventually but it might not be for a while.

Barn0w1 · 07/12/2021 05:00

But Micksrooni there are so many hard to quantify autistic traits. Then you get masking which many girls and women do. One trait of autism might be mild, another severe. I don’t see how you can give an overall level.

Floundery · 06/12/2021 22:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Mickarooni · 06/12/2021 21:45

@Barn0w1

Labels aren’t going to reduce anything. Cases look at need and issues for an individual not the name of a condition. My DD’s ASC traits seem to be regraded as more than just differences.
I understand your overall point but a diagnosis (or even a description of needs) is key to accessing some types of services. If we are going to ensure services meet the needs of a specific group, we need to have a some idea of what the needs are.
Mickarooni · 06/12/2021 21:40

When people with learning disabilities are diagnosed, it’s stated if mild, moderate or severe. It does not generate the same level of debate as this topic but believe me, people who have LD have a hugely diverse range of needs.

AnotherEmma · 06/12/2021 21:19

I should point out that a major reason that I'm interested is that I suspect DC1 might have ASD/PDA. But it's too soon to tell. And I very much doubt he'll meet the threshold for an assessment on the NHS, let alone any support.

However, I'm not about to join an advocacy group and start arguing semantics and shouting down people with an actual diagnosis and significant difficulties... horrified at the thought!

Some people are just twats, it seems. I often reach this conclusion on mumsnet and in RL Grin

Floundery · 06/12/2021 20:45

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

AnotherEmma · 06/12/2021 20:28

Fascinating thread. I don't have any insight to offer but am reading others' experiences and opinions with interest. I am sorry to read about the struggles that many of you have Flowers

It seems there is no clear answer to the debate. From the little I know about autism (and I've been learning from this thread) it seems that the professionals don't even agree about how to diagnose. For example PDA is recognised as an autistic profile by some but not others.

There is a diagnostic questionnaire for depression and anxiety which gives you scores and categorises as mild/moderate/severe. I wonder if there is anything that could be developed to show an autistic person's diagnosis and support needs in a relatively simple and clear way - something more meaningful that just "mild" "severe" "classic" "low/high functioning"... all of which have been rejected anyway... but more easy to digest than a detailed essay. I'm thinking along the lines of those diagrams that show the "spiky profile" (rather than a linear scale) but personalised. So you might have, say, 5-6 key categories (the 5-6 most common difficulties) with a score for each one (0-3?) and then it could be represented by a visual chart.

In our era of appallingly limited resources for any kind of support, there do have to be thresholds for accessing it, and there has to be some way to differentiate the severity of people's difficulties and the extent of their needs.

I don't think we should sneer at self diagnosis, though. There must be so many people who know that they (or their children) most probably have autism but struggle for years to get taken seriously by HCPs. Of course it's not a proper diagnosis until you get a formal assessment. But that doesn't mean people who say they (or their child) are autistic are always just jumping on the neurodiversity bandwagon.

Skippingabeat · 06/12/2021 18:35

@Barn0w1

Labels aren’t going to reduce anything. Cases look at need and issues for an individual not the name of a condition. My DD’s ASC traits seem to be regraded as more than just differences.
Country policies are not decided on an individual level, but according to "labels". What help would it be if an individual is deemed to need residential services but these services no longer exist because "people with autism should live in the community"
Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 18:32

What is autism?

Autism is a lifelong developmental disability which affects how people communicate and interact with the world. One in 100 people are on the autism spectrum and there are around 700,000 autistic adults and children in the UK.

From the Autistic Society. Pretty clear it’s regarded as a disability.

lookforthespace · 06/12/2021 18:26

The UK will no doubt follow the US in terms of cost reduction and facilities especially as autism is being sold as ND rather than disability.

See that terrifies me. Not because I'm autistic myself. But for my son. Who can't ever graduate from using nappies, doesn't speak and doesn't meet some milestones up a 0-12 month old. Terrifies me.

Nothing 'diverse' about him. And his challenges are complete and profound disability. I have troubles of my own but they just don't compare. That's not to say what I suffer is mild. But it's not the same world as DS

Coronawireless · 06/12/2021 18:13

@Floundery

My DS has classic autism meaning he is impacted in all 3 areas that can be impacted. I had my arse handed to me on a plate when I used this term in a mum’s group to support ND children. Their reaction to me saying “classic autism” was akin to using the disgusting “N” word in a room full of POC. I was left feeling like scum when I was trying to learn and help my child. I was kicked out of the group when I tried to explain why I had used it.

I have stayed away from any debate since then, but I agree with the OP. This “no qualifiers” mandate means that “high functioning” autistic people dominate the debate (and they are typically white and MC - plenty are also “self-diagnosed”). They don’t speak for my profoundly disabled DS and are so busy congratulating themselves on how marvelous being ND is that they won’t see the challenges and shitty lives experienced by the very people for whom they claim to speak.

Ah yes the self-diagnosed who speak for everyone with autism. I do think there is a cohort who like to say they have autism just the same as any profoundly-affected person - there is NO difference between them - it’s just that there is something special about THEM that meant they got a job or got married in a way that other people with autism just couldn’t seem to make the effort to do.
Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 18:05

Labels aren’t going to reduce anything. Cases look at need and issues for an individual not the name of a condition. My DD’s ASC traits seem to be regraded as more than just differences.

Justrealised · 06/12/2021 17:54

Much much more needs to be done. The government have failed to meet their own targets.

It is cheaper for someone to be held in an ATU funded via nhs than housed in the community with proper support funded via LA's. (Many people with autism do not qualify for continuing care budgets). Autism being labelled a difference rather than disability is an avenue to reduce funding. People with autism are being held in facilities for mental health which are not fit for purpose for people with autism.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-59388886

Over a 100 people held for more than 20 years.

The UK will no doubt follow the US in terms of cost reduction and facilities especially as autism is being sold as ND rather than disability.

Barn0w1 · 06/12/2021 17:43

In the U.K. there is a lot of work to keep autistic people out of inpatient- CETR, Keyworker scheme, Dynamic Risk Register.

Skippingabeat · 06/12/2021 16:49

@Barn0w1

Why does it matter if they don’t have a different diagnosis? Your child isn’t going to be getting any difference in their care.
Of course they are!!

One huge difference in care, at least in the US where I live, is that the push for "community inclusion" has meant that there are now so few residential programs ( because residential homes, even with as few as 10 residents, are deemed as institutions), that families with teens and young adults with severe behaviors can be on wait lists for years. And they often have to send their kids to other states, and relocate with them or not.

And that also means that when the family faces an aggressive episode, they have to call the police and then you end up with young autistic people being kept in hospitals and medicated for months and sometimes years.

Floundery · 06/12/2021 15:48

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Sirzy · 06/12/2021 14:06

Sadly the lack of access to things aiming to be accessible is an issue across the board. Ds can’t go to things like the relaxed cinema trips because he can’t deal with the noise of others. Like many he is stuck in a situation where most of the world is inaccessible to his needs one way or the other.

Latenightpharma · 06/12/2021 13:58

@Floundery

Thank you *@BessieFinknottle*

I also wonder if genetics will offer more clarity. Simon Baron-Cohen (I know, the ND club hate him too!) was interviewed in the McGuinness documentary and said that over 100 genes associated with ASC have been identified. Lots more research needed, I hope it helps future DC.

Flowers for you and DC.

I'm not a fan of the neurodiversity movement, but I'm not super keen on Simon Baron Cohen either. His ideas about "extreme male brain" theory come across as sexist to me, and haven't helped with diagnosing women, regardless of how impacted they are by autism. I was surprised to see him in the McGuinnes documentary and wondered whether he diagnosed a woman on purpose to prove a point. That is probably just me being cynical though.