Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To try to protect DC from horrible things on the news

39 replies

19Bears · 03/12/2021 19:04

The 6 o clock news was about to start and I knew they would be leading with the awful story about Arthur. I went to get the remote to switch channels as the DC were sitting right in front of the TV and I really didn't want them listening to the harrowing details. But DH had already picked up the remote - to tut the volume up!! I took it off him quickly but he was moaning that he wanted to see it, that it was a terrible story, and that it was important to hear what sentence the parents had got. I'm not arguing that it's not an awful story, just that I don't want my kids hearing about this right now! It's Christmas ffs. Last Christmas he decided in his wisdom that would be a good day to watch something about authors writing about death. I just think some things they should be shielded from. Is it just me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 03/12/2021 22:38

YANBU.

My parents must have shielded me from a lot when younger. But Dunblane happened when I was 11. Old enough to not be able to be shielded, but terrifying and that still affects me now even though I lived no where near.

Itsnotdeep · 03/12/2021 20:53

I haven't let my 9 year old see any of that coverage, and in fact need to fast forward it myself as it's too upsetting.

SickAndTiredAgain · 03/12/2021 20:33

Generally, I think a problem with stopping them seeing/hearing about things is that you can’t control what they hear from other places. So if something happened, and another child at school mentioned it, your child may get a distorted story that upsets them more than if you had explained it to them.
And hearing small details about a story can also be worse. I remember being young and hearing my parents briefly discussing a new disease, I can’t even remember what it was but I’d guess SARS given my age at the time. My parents aren’t worriers, and won’t have been particularly worried about SARS but I must have overheard just the wrong sentence and honestly was convinced we were all going to die (unlike my parents, I have always been a worrier!)

Which isn’t to say just let them watch whatever, just that you giving an age appropriate explanation of something on the news, with an opportunity for them to ask questions if they have any, might protect them better.

LostForIdeas · 03/12/2021 20:05

I think it depends how it’s presented.
Very matter if fact, child has been killed, father and step mum sentenced fine.
Emotional description with harrowing details, not fine.

Just like I dint think seeing beheading would be ok either but talking about the fact they happen yes iyswim….

When I was growing up, I was watching the news too but there was never that level of emotional strings to them. Nit did you ever risk watching someone getting killed in front of your eyes.

Treats · 03/12/2021 19:56

I am unnervingly honest with my children about what’s going on in the world and answer all their questions directly. I don’t think I’ve ever stopped them watching anything or thought things unsuitable - although I will sometimes intervene to explain why I think something they’ve seen is wrong.

But I turned the radio down when the news item came on about poor Arthur this morning. I couldn’t bear for my son to hear about it and to risk it being as upsetting for him as it has been for me.

DelurkingAJ · 03/12/2021 19:55

At 9 DS1 (as I was) is reading the paper and I think that’s a good thing in moderation. A bit younger and I would agree with you and for some reason TV footage would bother me more. But an age appropriate understanding of the world is important.

SommerTen · 03/12/2021 19:54

When I was a child in the 80s my dad would watch the news after work and some of it must have really affected me - I remember I had nightmares about Argentinian soldiers out to shoot me (around the time of the Falklands War - I was 4).
Then I had nightmares about other wars; about volcanoes erupting and other disasters... this would have been before I was about 9.
I think my Dad didn't realise how much of the News I took in and yet didn't really understand, which made my fears worse.

I think that if you're going to let children watch the news you have to explain it to them and make sure they understand it.

UsernameInTheTown · 03/12/2021 19:52

And the ghouls listening to video footage of a child being tortured need help.

CSJobseeker · 03/12/2021 19:51

YANBU. The media often goes into truly horrifying (ghoulish) detail about cases like this - you can talk your children about the bad things that happen in the world without exposing them to the unfiltered news when they are very young. I understand that footage/audio of this poor child being abused has been made widely available in the media, and I don't think it would be appropriate to expose a young child to that.

I remember when Dunblane happened. I was a teen, but my brother was very small (a similar age to the victims). When my dad came home he told me not to let him watch the news.

My dad wasn't overprotective at all normally, but he (rightly imo) didn't think that was the best way for a small child to find out about the horrors in the world.

UsernameInTheTown · 03/12/2021 19:51

No. This is not appropriate for small DC to hear. Fuck me, we've had posts all week from adults who've been sobbing over this/traumatised and many kids have been left terrified by all the coverage of Covid they've been subjected to in their own homes.
Easy for me to say though, I don't have a TV, read newspapers etc, so can easily censor what DD7 hears and sees.

HaroldSteptoesHorse · 03/12/2021 19:44

It’s not Christmas. The news is harrowing. Perhaps your children could be otherwise occupied if one of the adults wants to and does watch the news.

Tomthumbsbigbum · 03/12/2021 19:40

I'm all for my DC aged 9 and 7 to have some idea of what goes on in the world, good and bad, but there's some stuff they just don't need to see or hear. I have been unable to read or listen to very much of the Arthur case myself. I turned off the radio this afternoon when the news was on and my DC were in the car. I know my older DC would find it very troubling. They don't need too much heaviness at their ages, there's plenty of it in Adulthood.

stayathomer · 03/12/2021 19:32

Yanbu, our job as parents is to act as a filter, you can mention or talk about something in passing but the news can be bleak for adults. But honestly to each their own-I remember my friend in the pandemic peak, when they were showing the lining up of ambulances with bodies in them in italy, and mass graves worldwide, and the inside of hospital covid wards, telling me her children weren't sleeping after seeing the news and when I told her they didn't watch it she very obviously thought I was babying them. So yeah, it's up to the parent really- mine knew it was serious, knew there were deaths and people could get sick but they don't have the images from this that I have in my mind.

FurrFeather · 03/12/2021 19:32

Daily Mail and Maxwell coverage that is - made me almost vomit - there was no need for that level of detail - though I notice its not there right now. Disgusting, as I said.

mewkins · 03/12/2021 19:32

I only ever have the radio on and when the news bulletin comes on I sometimes turn it off. Yesterday was a prime example. My youngest dc is 7 and he always comments that it is sad news. If it is general covid stuff I leave it on but how do I explain something so awful about a child slightly younger than him? My eldest is 11 and we would have a bit more of a discussion.

TheCanyon · 03/12/2021 19:31

@Sirzy

How old are they?

I don’t think hiding them away from the news is ever the right approach personally, much better to find an age appropriate way to discuss things.

Absolutely this. I speak to my kids about anything and everything we/they come across in the news. I read far too much true crime, i feel the need to protect and educate my kids from the potential dangers everywhere in their lives. And yes this includes child cases. They are not fearful or anxious in the slightest.
FurrFeather · 03/12/2021 19:31

I would. The media really love to go into disgusting detail. The DM and Maxwell coverage was pornographic. Atrocious.

countingto10 · 03/12/2021 19:29

I remember reading/seeing the newspaper headlines about Maria Colwell and hearing about her on the news. I was the same age as her at the time. I had nightmares about it at the time. It was local to us. Everytime something like this happens, I always remember Maria Colwell. It had a bit effect on me at that young age. So yes, it is probably right that you shield younger children from it. Although in the ‘70s, there wasn’t wall to wall news channels etc.

And nothing seems to change, there will always be Arthur’s and Maria’s. There was a public enquiry after Maria’s death (very similar situation to Arthur’s), the country was supposedly so shocked that another child should never again slip though the net like she did but here we are nearly 50 yrs later……

StillWeRise · 03/12/2021 19:29

YANBU, of all the distressing stories there are in the news, this would be the one I would try and protect my children from
And I'd be upset if my co-parent did not share my view.

saraclara · 03/12/2021 19:28

Oh yes, and climate change. Seriously, there is so much news that worries them far more than what happened to a child with parents unlike their own.

AlternativePerspective · 03/12/2021 19:27

I don’t think hiding them away from the news is ever the right approach personally, much better to find an age appropriate way to discuss things. this.

It’s unrealistic to bring children up to have a rosy view of the world because at some point they’re going to realise that the world isn’t like that, and that good and bad exists.

I was never shielded from the news at any age and I grew up with a profound interest in current affairs.

I do think that the way news is reported sometimes though is unreasonable, even for adults. That video which was released never should have been. We can know what happened to that poor child without having to watch it in detail. There was absolutely no reason other than voyeurism to release or indeed to watch that video.

saraclara · 03/12/2021 19:26

To be honest I think more children are far more anxious about Covid than this.

They live with decent parents who they know wouldn't do this to them. So they don't see this as a threat to them

I grew up with the news constantly being about the moors murders. It didn't scare me at all. It wasn't real to me. I didn't have the life experience to understand the horror of it. And I don't think children today will have the same got wrenching emotions that we have about this either.

But covid is out there, in their classrooms, affecting every area of their lives, with people like their grandparents and parents dying. That's the daily news that I wish they weren't exposed to.

Also I think rushing them or of the room makes them more anxious, not less, to be honest.

19Bears · 03/12/2021 19:25

@Luredbyapomegranate just maybe not on Christmas Day morning while the kids are opening their presents... Hmm

My youngest is 9 and I didn't want him hearing about it when we were having a fun time playing games before tea. If DH wants to see it, he can see it later. I agree they shouldn't be shielded from everything, but there are exceptions, and this is one.

OP posts:
Stormwhale · 03/12/2021 19:21

The news does not go on in front of children in our house. As a child my df watched the news morning and night and I was incredibly anxious, thinking my loved ones would all die/be murdered or there would be a natural disaster at any moment. Children can't understand that although these things are reported daily, they do not happen to everyone all the time. I dont want my children being so scared and anxious like I was. I want them to be sheltered from it all.

Hospedia · 03/12/2021 19:20

I don’t think hiding them away from the news is ever the right approach personally, much better to find an age appropriate way to discuss things.

Exactly this.

My DC are aged between 12 and 4. They're aware of today's lead story and they had some questions which I answered, we also had a talk about the importance of telling a trusted grown up if someone is hurting them or if someone they know is being hurt.