Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have accepted this offer, or did we embarrass her?

81 replies

WestendVBroadway · 03/12/2021 18:23

I was in a discount store earlier. There was a lady being served, 1 lady behind her in queue, then me. None of us knew each other. First lady was buying an item that cost less that £1.00. She offered a £10 note. The cashier asked if customer had anything smaller as there was not sufficient change in the till. The customer said she had nothing smaller, and apparently either had no card to use, or choose not to for such a small amount. I said that she could just put it with my stuff and I would happily pay for it. The lady in front of me also offered to pay for it to help her out. The customer said she couldn't accept the kind offer. I suggested she just pay it forward, and other customer said to think of it as a Christmas gift. The original customer quickly disappeared before myself of other lady could pay for it. So , AIBU to think it was just a goodwill thing to do? Would you have accepted it, or was it embarrassing? Just to add there were no other customers around, so we didn't make her look like a charity case.

OP posts:
CharityDingle · 03/12/2021 21:11

@tillytoodles1

I was in the card shop the day before Mother's Day and a young lad about 14 had bought a card, a Teddy and a mug. He was about 50p short and was going to put something back, but he looked so embarrassed that I told the check out girl I'd pay the difference. I know it was only 50p, but he had a handful of coins and had obviously been saving up.
I did the same one day in a supermarket. Young guy, twelve or thirteen, was short some very small amount for a bottle of water. He had coins, and obviously thought he had enough. He was turning away, deflated, from the till. Aww. And he turned straight around to try to give me back whatever small bit of change he ended up with.
Notthissticky · 03/12/2021 21:09

I'd have both offered and accepted, and have indeed done both in the past. A lady paid my bus fare when my phone wouldn't work, even after the driver had said he'd let me on for free. I still feel guilty about it as in the area I live in the bus is mainly used by those who have free travel and people who can't afford to run a car. I felt like she could afford it much less than me, but it was so kind and I have thanked her again when we been on the same bus again. I paid £0.40 for a teen who was caught short at the local garage. She then walked off without even looking at me, never mind thanking me. I don't expect excessive gratitude but that was just plain rudeness.

blameless · 03/12/2021 21:08

@Chikapu

The sentiment was to help someone having a bad day.
The gesture ended up being rather grander than I first assumed, but the money was paid forward. It felt good to be able to do a kindness.
Russell Brand tells a story about giving a beggar a twenty pound note. His friend berated him as the beggar was only going to spend it on drink and drugs. "Well, what was I going to spend it on?" was the reply.

HunterGatherer · 03/12/2021 21:06

I would have offerred and I'd have accepted.
I would also have played it forward.
Your offer was kind.

Peppaismyrolemodel · 03/12/2021 21:05

I’d always offer- someone once paid for my shopping when my mums card was declined (teen), and I was so grateful and also SO embarrassed I couldn’t look at the woman! I think sometimes the more you need the offer of help, the more awkward it feels-

Bluntness100 · 03/12/2021 21:05

Id have declined politely and also disappeared assuming I didn’t really need what it was.

I think it’s lovely to offer but leave it there. No means no.

WhenSepEnds · 03/12/2021 21:01

I think that's kind, I would have accepted and not been embarrassed. I think it was a nice thing to do

santasmuma · 03/12/2021 21:01

I'm autistic and I wouldn't have processed the shop not being able to give change by the time 2 people started offering to pay so I would decline because it would cause too much confusion in my head. I would then leave the shop and later think 'what a tit I should have just let them do it'

TatianaBis · 03/12/2021 21:00

I’d have offered, in fact I have done in the past; but I wouldn’t have accepted it.

EmeraldShamrock · 03/12/2021 20:58

I'd think it was a good gesture.

Chikapu · 03/12/2021 20:58

@blameless

In the midst of the first lockdown, I was struggling with guilty feelings about personally doing well while so many people were suffering horribly. Giving to charity, made me feel less bad and I found myself in the supermarket behind a woman who had half a dozen items on the conveyor but had no purse and couldn't get her phone to make the payment. I told the cashier to add the charge to my bill and declined the woman's offer to repay me. She left the supermarket happily - then I found out that the small packages were upmarket pet food, £23 pounds worth. As they say, no good turn goes unpunished - though it helped my mental health and I consider it money well-spent.
How do you consider it money well spent when you obviously resent what her purchases were?
TurnUpTurnip · 03/12/2021 20:55

She accepted £5 but tbh I wouldn’t accept £1 or £5 and people on here have paid for strangers shopping for £20 for some cat food, cheeky to accept that kind of money off people.

ShirleyPhallus · 03/12/2021 20:54

@TurnUpTurnip

Yes that’s the one, doesn’t matter the amount either way I wouldn’t have accepted any amount off a stranger
Right. But £20 is very different from £3.
TurnUpTurnip · 03/12/2021 20:53

Yes that’s the one, doesn’t matter the amount either way I wouldn’t have accepted any amount off a stranger

ShirleyPhallus · 03/12/2021 20:51

@TurnUpTurnip

Erm yes it is true, it’s a different thread to the one you mentioned 🙄 I didn’t even see that one
You commented on this one?

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4370743-There-are-kind-people-in-the-world

TurnUpTurnip · 03/12/2021 20:49

Erm yes it is true, it’s a different thread to the one you mentioned 🙄 I didn’t even see that one

ShirleyPhallus · 03/12/2021 20:48

@TurnUpTurnip

I wouldn’t have accepted, there was a recent thread like this where someone let a stranger pay for her shopping (£20) and I got jumped on for saying I would have declined 😐
That’s not true. That thread said that someone had given her a fiver because her shopping was £3 more than she had on her.
HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 03/12/2021 20:48

I'd have offered and accepted.

I've previously offered similar, if someone offered to help me in my time of need I would happily accept.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/12/2021 20:46

It's less than a quid.

Hardly a Christmas miracle for the lucky recipient of your largesse .

Personally I'd be embarrassed to tell her "pay it forward" like you've given her a kidney.

Q123R · 03/12/2021 20:42

(Whoops!) In Poundland when the woman in front was in the exact same predicament as yours. I added her shopping to mine and paid for it all. I also lent £20 to an old colleague of DP's who we bumped into in the supermarket. I knew I'd get that back, but tbh I was so relieved to see he was still alive I wouldn't have been bothered if he hadn't.

On the other hand I fell in the street last year and was picked up by a stranger. I was in a hurry to meet a friend so refused to go to the pharmacy for plasters so she did just that and brought supplies to the cafe I'd gone to. Wouldn't take money. I was, and am still, beyond grateful.

Q123R · 03/12/2021 20:37

I've been on both sides and yes, felt warm and fuzzy each time. I was

godmum56 · 03/12/2021 20:33

I would have both offered and accepted.

blameless · 03/12/2021 20:23

In the midst of the first lockdown, I was struggling with guilty feelings about personally doing well while so many people were suffering horribly.
Giving to charity, made me feel less bad and I found myself in the supermarket behind a woman who had half a dozen items on the conveyor but had no purse and couldn't get her phone to make the payment. I told the cashier to add the charge to my bill and declined the woman's offer to repay me.
She left the supermarket happily - then I found out that the small packages were upmarket pet food, £23 pounds worth.
As they say, no good turn goes unpunished - though it helped my mental health and I consider it money well-spent.

mam0918 · 03/12/2021 19:44

I agree she might have been getting change, most times I use cash its because I need change for something that doesn't accept cards. I usually get £10 from a cash point and then buy a 50p item to get the change for the bus etc...

The only time I would accept it is if I was genuinely stuck.

I remember being 14 and me and my friend (who were out for the first time in town an hour away from home) were £1 short of the bus fair home, the last bus of the night and the driver wouldn't let us on when a random man lent over put £1 down and just said 'get on the bus girls' and that meant a lot because we were panicking but in general for a £1 non urgent item when I have a £10 on me I wouldn't accept it.

ChampagneLassie · 03/12/2021 19:42

I was behind a lady with a newborn in coop buying a, handful of things cost about £9 who then realised she didn't have her purse and burst into tears. I immediately offered to pay and she was so grateful. And I assumed we both felt warm and fuzzy. I dont know why anyone would feel embarrassed by kindness? Equally I've offered to pay for lunch and dinner for someone I thought it was clear I was entertaining (for work purposes) and had them insist on paying and that's felt awkward/werid. But there are potentially more levels to that (people not wanting to feel "bought")

Swipe left for the next trending thread