Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
Onthedowns · 06/12/2021 08:25

[quote SusanHalf]@Onthedowns thank you I’ll try, I’ve spoken to my husband but he doesn’t know the full extent of what I went through. He wants me to tell him but I’ve told him please don’t make me. I’ve spoken with my sister but she went through the same as me so is hard for us both. I’m going to speak to a mental health charity today because I just can’t pull myself out of how I’m feeling.[/quote]
That sounds like a good idea. It's very difficult my DH had a polar opposite upbringing and struggles with my background. Take care it's hit lots of people extremely hard which as stated above is normal too

OP posts:
SusanHalf · 06/12/2021 07:58

@Onthedowns thank you I’ll try, I’ve spoken to my husband but he doesn’t know the full extent of what I went through. He wants me to tell him but I’ve told him please don’t make me. I’ve spoken with my sister but she went through the same as me so is hard for us both. I’m going to speak to a mental health charity today because I just can’t pull myself out of how I’m feeling.

LittleNinaNanar · 06/12/2021 07:38

OP I read a couple of lines on a news feed and balled my eyes out, big reaction and have been upset about it since. Have a child of similar age and relate it to that. Everybody mostly is really upset about this and some of us react by crying. It's normal and just so fucking sad. Xxxxx

Annoymouser2 · 06/12/2021 07:27

I cant bring myself to watch the video the online news has. Its a sad reflection of society and theres so many little arthurs out there

Onthedowns · 06/12/2021 07:13

@SusanHalf

I’m also struggling, I come from an abused childhood and memories have come back upon hearing about poor Arthur. I just want to cry all the time, I’ve removed all news sites from my phone but I don’t know what to do tbh.
It's very hard and in part opened a can of worms. It will pass please take care of yourself

I had a long chat with a friend and it helped a little

OP posts:
Onthedowns · 06/12/2021 07:10

@Swizzel

Thank you for posting this *@Onthedowns*. Knowing that I am not alone in my feelings about Arthur is hugely reassuring. I have cried many times whilst thinking about what he went through, including waking in the night and sobbing for him.

Atrocities happen daily in the world, and I think over time we become immune to a lot of what we see and hear on the news, but what happened to Arthur has knocked me so far sideways that I've honestly been questioning my own sanity. Reading that a lot of people are also feeling the same way is, selfishly, somewhat of a relief.

As @TobKat said: Reading about what this poor child endured has left me feeling traumatised, haunted, angry, ashamed, tearful & very depressed. But what can we all learn from this horror? Surely it's obvious that safeguarding children & child protection is the responsibility of us ALL. We shouldn't ever turn away or tell ourselves it's not our business when we see a sign that something's not right.

I think you are right, to me it appears basic human instinct to want to protect and love. Something his carers lacked.
OP posts:
Swizzel · 05/12/2021 23:57

Thank you for posting this @Onthedowns. Knowing that I am not alone in my feelings about Arthur is hugely reassuring. I have cried many times whilst thinking about what he went through, including waking in the night and sobbing for him.

Atrocities happen daily in the world, and I think over time we become immune to a lot of what we see and hear on the news, but what happened to Arthur has knocked me so far sideways that I've honestly been questioning my own sanity. Reading that a lot of people are also feeling the same way is, selfishly, somewhat of a relief.

As @TobKat said: Reading about what this poor child endured has left me feeling traumatised, haunted, angry, ashamed, tearful & very depressed. But what can we all learn from this horror? Surely it's obvious that safeguarding children & child protection is the responsibility of us ALL. We shouldn't ever turn away or tell ourselves it's not our business when we see a sign that something's not right.

Chiscuits71 · 05/12/2021 23:22

I've been welling up every time I think of the sweet little boy and his smiley face. It's just so heartbreaking to read about what he went through and the thought he left this world thinking no-one loved him. I've not watched the video of his final hours.

I have seen the video, though, the family have released of Arthur happily talking of which teams he was going to play football for when he was older. This is how the family would like him to be remembered.

HunterGatherer · 05/12/2021 23:21

His poor grandmother, she tried. No one listened to her.

SusanHalf · 05/12/2021 22:59

I’m also struggling, I come from an abused childhood and memories have come back upon hearing about poor Arthur. I just want to cry all the time, I’ve removed all news sites from my phone but I don’t know what to do tbh.

Bllueblazerblack · 05/12/2021 22:32

I've seen reports but purposely avoided seeing the other videos. I feel that the videos were part of his abuse and by watching them, I'd some how be contributing. He deserved dignity in both life and death and I'll ensure that by not watching.

aquashiv · 05/12/2021 22:00

I couldn't watch the video seeing his frail little body was enough to have me crying my eyes out.

Onthedowns · 05/12/2021 21:59

@Emmajgreen89

Ahh I just can’t get his sweet little face out my head. I have a little boy who is 2 in Jan and I too cannot stop crying when I think about what he went through. To die thinking no one loved him just breaks my heart and yes it has made me so upset I’m crying every time I see his face or read the news 😭💔
I think this is the worst part. He died thinking and feeling no one cared about him this is what upsets me the most, no child should ever think or feel that. As well as being in unimaginable agony most of the time.
OP posts:
bandek · 05/12/2021 21:24

With abused women, you also very often find that if you step in, they will turn against you and defend their abuser.

I also think women being abused is different to children. Children are completely at the mercy of their caregivers. They have little knowledge of the outside world beyond what their parents tell them. They have no idea what SS is, that there are adults who want to protect them. They have zero choice to leave, especially in Arthur's case in lockdown, or a very young child. Can't even run away.

With an adult woman in an abusive situation, intervening might not change things because the woman may be with the man out of compulsion (e.g. finances, family unit, risk of homelessness, social isolation). So even if she appreciates your kindness, she may drop charges, or go back because she feels there's no other choice.

I'm not sure if I even explained this coherently. It's scary to think anyone can just have a kid. They obviously get no say in being brought into any situation.

Emmajgreen89 · 05/12/2021 21:16

Ahh I just can’t get his sweet little face out my head. I have a little boy who is 2 in Jan and I too cannot stop crying when I think about what he went through. To die thinking no one loved him just breaks my heart and yes it has made me so upset I’m crying every time I see his face or read the news 😭💔

TobKat · 05/12/2021 20:26

Thank you so much for posting this. I'm so glad that there are others out there who feel the same way as me! Reading about what this poor child endured has left me feeling traumatised, haunted, angry, ashamed, tearful & very depressed. But what can we all learn from this horror? Surely it's obvious that safeguarding children & child protection is the responsibility of us ALL. We shouldn't ever turn away or tell ourselves it's not our business when we see a sign that something's not right.

HumpreyDowny · 05/12/2021 20:18

Minitree, those two things were unrelated.

DrSbaitso · 05/12/2021 18:28

[quote Porcupineintherough]@tallduckandhandsome there are quite a few people on here that will say intervening if you see a woman abused on the street is the worst thing you can do, as it will only lead to her getting more abuse when she gets home. Maybe they are even right? I'm guessing that if you think this way for women, then you probably act in the same way for children.[/quote]
With abused women, you also very often find that if you step in, they will turn against you and defend their abuser. I guess it's safer for them to do that, although it's alarming how often their loyalty really truly is to this shit and they're not just saying anything to avoid a beating. How often on here does a woman tell us all about her POS of a partner and, on being told he's a POS, starts defending him, saying he's lovely really, she's presented him unfairly and everyone else just doesn't know him?

It's similar to children in some ways and different in others.

Mufasa1118 · 05/12/2021 18:12

@PleasantBirthday I don't think what you said is right? I dont think the threshold for removing children is far higher than bruises.

I've definitely read about cases where the children were removed from their parents after SS noticed huge bruising on the child

There is a difference in bruises too.
There are normal bruises that a child gets from playing/ bumping into things.

Then there are bruises on a child that you can tell are from Some one hitting them and are not from an accident.

Arthur's bruise was huge and it was on the back of his left shoulder. It would be very hard for a child to to bump into something with the back of his left shoulder. It was obvious that bruise came from someone hitting him.

PleasantBirthday · 05/12/2021 17:15

I think the threshold for removing kids is far higher than bruises.

Mufasa1118 · 05/12/2021 17:11

@ToykotoLosAngeles yes I agree.

I am sure there are some good stepmums out there. I hope so anyway.

Really Social services were at fault here too. If a child has massive bruises, why leave him there for God sake.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 05/12/2021 17:08

You can't police that though. I'm willing to bet there are hundreds of thousands of stepmums who are decent at the very least.

The onus here was on Thomas Fuckwit Hughes not to move in with her in the first place but god forbid he not get a shag over lockdown. The problem we have is parents who prioritise their own love life over their children - I'm not talking about a bit of moaning about a step-parent here but when there is mental and physical harm being inflicted.

Mufasa1118 · 05/12/2021 17:01

I also think there should be more rules in place about what people are allowed into children's lives.

I think sadly, that there is often a primal thing in women - where they do not love children that are not theirs, and they in fact hate children that their partner has from another woman, as it reminds them of his previous girlfriend.

My dad's girlfriend was the same as Emma Tustin, bar any physical violence. She absolutely hated me because I was not her child.

Should women that are not related to the child be allowed in children's lives?

Toddlerteaplease · 05/12/2021 16:58

I also agree with the OP's saying that the videos shouldn't be published.

Mufasa1118 · 05/12/2021 16:58

When I heard about Arthur, my first thought was

"I am ashamed of humanity"