Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
ohdear10 · 06/12/2021 20:22

@Drumshambo

What purpose do you think all this crying and grieving is going to serve? Does it he!p Arthur? Does it help other children who are / will no doubt come after him? There are lots of arthur's. They're in every city village and town all over the country!

Your performative grieving is just that. It helps nothing or no one!
This awful.episode will be forgotten in a few months.,- until t happens again. and the grief vampires appear again on forums like this and Facebook to repeat the same meaningless drival. For God sake have some decency. and afford the poor soul some dignity in death. and stop with these threads.

Get lost. Why do you care that others are grieving, would you rather their forgotten? Bizarre take from you.

You say op isn't helping children- what have you done, other than upset others?

somewhereoverthechipshop · 06/12/2021 18:26

You are not alone OP. I try and avoid tragedies in the news, but Arthur and the Star Hobson case have utterly depressed me. I feel like my outlook, views of humans and the world have changed. I can't help it, along with covid it feels like the end of days. Dark I know, but there's something about these cases that has hurt my soul. Sorry if that sounds dramatic but there it is.

Buddhabowl · 06/12/2021 18:08

I think it's right that the video is out there for people to see. We shouldn't be able to shy away from the reality of his tragic life. To those saying to respect his privacy... Do you think he wanted or needed privacy?? He needed that shouting from the rooftops, he was crying out for help.
Shocking videos and media awareness is what drives change. Look at the George Floyd case, the video was so impactful it created a slogan that went worldwide 'I can't breathe' and caused widespread protests.
'we love you Arthur' has come from that video, yes it's fucking awful, but it has made people pay attention to the cruel reality of what went on. His face is being displayed at football matches, he is being talked about all over social media and the news, people are aware! It has shocked me to the very core and I have been able to think of little else over the last week. But no amount of my suffering or 'performative grief' comes close to what that poor boy endured. The more awareness there is the more likely people are to spot signs of abuse, the more closely a school night monitor that worrying pupil, the less likely a social worker will be to trust a manipulative parent, the list goes on.

oakleaffy · 06/12/2021 16:59

@Drumshambo

What purpose do you think all this crying and grieving is going to serve? Does it he!p Arthur? Does it help other children who are / will no doubt come after him? There are lots of arthur's. They're in every city village and town all over the country!

Your performative grieving is just that. It helps nothing or no one!
This awful.episode will be forgotten in a few months.,- until t happens again. and the grief vampires appear again on forums like this and Facebook to repeat the same meaningless drival. For God sake have some decency. and afford the poor soul some dignity in death. and stop with these threads.

But YOU are on Arthur's thread!

Can you not see the irony there, putting yourself 'Above' those who are struggling to understand how on earth it had happened?
How do you know what others are feeling?

Why attempt to belittle their upset?

Annabellerina · 06/12/2021 16:45

I haven't read anything about Arthur beyond the original story but I do think having it in the news, quite graphically and in a way that we cannot ignore, is helpful to remind us ALL of our duty towards children. Eg if one of us found ourselves in that hairdresser's situation we would now know what action to take.

Buddhabowl · 06/12/2021 16:39

Or even performative sneering!

Buddhabowl · 06/12/2021 16:38

Lots of competitive sneering on this thread.

PoleFairy · 06/12/2021 16:01

I think sometimes, for whatever reason, there are news stories that haunt you. For me it was the Delhi bus gang rape. I remember feeling sick and horrified for weeks, had to keep turning off the news. Kept thinking of that poor woman and all she endured and her fiance being almost beaten to death. Just horrendous. There was no reason for me to be particularly afflicted by that story, I just was. I think occasionally it happens. It strikes a nerve and haunts you. I did eventually get over it

TooManyGiraffes · 06/12/2021 15:58

@GetTheFlockOutOfHere

You do sound a BIT over invested though *@Onthedowns*
"Overinvested" in being upset by and wanting to stop child abuse?? How could that be possible?
TooManyGiraffes · 06/12/2021 15:58

@FourTeaFallOut

I don't think reading it is enough

Is enough to achieve what? What does it serve?

Perhaps to realise the full impact of child abuse. Unfortunately making a child feel like not a single person in the world loves them is not that unusual. Even the police stated that usually they can have some emotional distance from how horrific it is for a child to be abused but the recordings in this case made that impossible, they saw and had to comprehend the full horror that Arthur did, how it actually felt, how much pain he was in, physical and emotional, not just deal dispassionately with facts about what happened as they usually do.

I think that is why the case has had such a strong reaction. And that would be the biggest way to honour Arthur and his suffering and bravery: if the general public became so outraged that this is allowed to happen that this abuse is stamped out. That we all demand that child services are funded properly and the thresholds for intervention changed to ensure that this doesn't keep happening, over and over.

That is why it is in the public interest to make the videos public: in the hope it may force changes to ensure that no more children have to suffer what he did, with nobody helping them despite repeatedly telling adults that he was in danger.

missfliss · 06/12/2021 15:57

Is performative haranguing a thing?

ToykotoLosAngeles · 06/12/2021 15:53

You're right. Best nobody mentions it and pretends it never happened, because god forbid someone creates a thread that gets on your nerves @Drumshambo.

missfliss · 06/12/2021 15:50

Slow hand clap for you.

Drumshambo · 06/12/2021 15:47

What purpose do you think all this crying and grieving is going to serve? Does it he!p Arthur? Does it help other children who are / will no doubt come after him? There are lots of arthur's. They're in every city village and town all over the country!

Your performative grieving is just that. It helps nothing or no one!
This awful.episode will be forgotten in a few months.,- until t happens again. and the grief vampires appear again on forums like this and Facebook to repeat the same meaningless drival. For God sake have some decency. and afford the poor soul some dignity in death. and stop with these threads.

user1471538283 · 06/12/2021 15:24

I feel the same. It was psychological torture and they did it to get off on it. I just can't get past how hopeless he felt. If I were that hairdresser he would not have left with them. They've proven (especially her) what cowards they are so they wouldn't have called the Police.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 06/12/2021 15:02

Rabbit hole is it exactly. It's like my brain seizes hold of it again and wills the outcome to be different. As the mum of a little blonde 3-year-old boy it's like it's tapped into some intrusive primal desire to protect a child for whom it's too late.

ilovebrie8 · 06/12/2021 14:59

@JLee123 I agree with your post...it catches me and I get so upset have to try to not go over it...it’s got to one of worst cases ever...let’s just pray his killers never see the light of day again ...

missfliss · 06/12/2021 14:46

and @JLee123 - the Rabbit Hole is a great term. I keep being caught unwares and its a really difficult thing to get out of.

missfliss · 06/12/2021 14:45

@HumpreyDowny totally agree. I am very upset for Arthur, and I've donated to the NSPCC, and I have a child with SEN who often is excluded and judged by others. Guess what - I am still upset and am allowed to say so.

Also hate the term 'brigade' smacks of utter DM reader stupidity to me...

HumpreyDowny · 06/12/2021 14:22

" I hope the sobbing for days brigade also manage to do something positive in Arthur’s memory"

I fail to understand why people are so hostile to people having emotions and assuming that they aren't actually already donating to charity, keeping their eyes open, embracing the difficult child in the classroom. These a tions are not mutually exclusive. I am from the "sobbing brigade" as you so kindly put it, and I do these things and try my best. May I still be allowed to cry over Arthur please? I come back to mn not because I'm in some "grief fest" (lovely poetic name calling people who are trying to deal with emotions), but to read about others who are feeling like this. So I'm not alone, and it is good for Arthur that so many have been moved and cared for what happened to him. His memory must live and serve some purpose. If it's a neighbour calling the police, someone hugging their child once more, someone questioning behaviour of a new partner, an abuser thinking twice...anything that his memory helps is beneficial to society.

Jlee123, the rabbit hole is real for me too...

dottiedodah · 06/12/2021 14:20

This was a terribly upsetting case.This morning his GDF was on BBC Breakfast saying how he ,a family friend and some of the NDN had reported Parents to SS.They had not come out due to Covid Restrictions apparently! WTF is going on with them.I try not to read about it really .Sounds awful ,but only way I can cope with it .Seems no lessons learned after poor Baby P ,Victoria Climbie and others .I had a loving childhood ,with my parents and GDP taking care of me as well .Still cant believe that anyone could be so utterly cruel .They are due to be re sentenced today ,as original sentence too short .TBH though they could get 100 years each and nothing will bring back poor Arthur .I like you find this sort of thing heartbreaking .Take care of yourself ,you sound a wonderful mum xx

JLee123 · 06/12/2021 13:29

I'm sorry to hear lots of people on here have been suffering since learning about this case. I too feel like I have sank to the depths of hell in my head quite a few times since seeing it on the news, and also questioning my own sanity, waking in the night to talk to him, placing a chocolate on my Christmas tree for him, trying so very very hard not to think about it but returning to it almost immediately. That clip should never have been released! Although awareness is key to change and so this public trauma could be channelled into something positive. When I find myself going down that rabbit-hole thinking trying to imagine how he must have felt, I now stop and imagine his cheeky beautiful little smile on that photo in his football shirt and remind myself of the work people are doing to get his face on the football flags and get one of the stands named after him. It also helps to realise how many hundreds of children are saved every year by the authorities. Work needs to be done to ensure that ALL children are saved. Children slipping through the net is completely unacceptable

FlyingPandas · 06/12/2021 08:59

@Bllueblazerblack

I've seen reports but purposely avoided seeing the other videos. I feel that the videos were part of his abuse and by watching them, I'd some how be contributing. He deserved dignity in both life and death and I'll ensure that by not watching.
I must admit I agree with this. It would feel voyeuristic to look at footage, and I have purposely avoided doing so-the written reports are traumatic enough to read.

I think to feel devastated, tearful and traumatised is totally normal but I also think some posters can be guilty of turning these awful child abuse/murder cases into something of a competitive online grief fest, which feels incredibly distasteful. I hope the sobbing for days brigade also manage to do something positive in Arthur’s memory, as well as posting about their emotions online. Donate to a charity, volunteer for an organisation supporting vulnerable children, do some research into safeguarding and the role that we can all play as members of society. And especially, be kind and supportive of people in your community who are adoptive or foster parents - chances are that these DC could have ended up like Arthur, but their behaviour as a result of neglect and abuse will almost certainly leave a lot to be desired. As a PP has commented, so many of us are horribly intolerant and judgemental of the behaviour of adopted or fostered children who are inevitably so scarred by their treatment prior to removal by social services. I wonder how many of the online grief festers are also the first to complain to schools about the ‘awful child’ disrupting their DC’s class.

SusanHalf · 06/12/2021 08:52

@Onthedowns feels like I’m right back there again. I haven’t watched any of the videos etc, I saw a still of a video with a headline. That’s all it’s taken for me to sink. I’ve had counselling but I’m so tired of constantly going round in circles. Thank you for listening.

Takingastand1 · 06/12/2021 08:43

I am a social worker who has witnessed the most horrific things in my seven years in the field and I can assure you, you are not alone in how you feel. What happened to Arthur was horrific and tragic. Since learning about this poor little boys life I have not slept well. Like many I have questions about what agencies did to try and prevent this. I will not be making any judgements in this regard until I have seen the serious case review and have seen the facts. These are dark days.