Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
Wooky073 · 07/12/2021 22:09

@NanaRant

I completely agree *@Wooky073* about intervention with Arthur. I am the person who intervenes in the street when I see people smacking children (smacking, thankfully, is now illegal in Scotland). My background is child protection - I am not backwards at coming forwards and I am a real ambassador for the rights of the child. I would not hesitate to take a child to hospital, for example and have taken similar actions in the past. This particular case I refer to is extremely complicated and caring family can't get near the child. The referral went to the police as well as social work services. I can't say much more as it is outing and I need to respect the confidentiality of those concerned, but I am not going to rest and will reignite my concerns. I am beyond frustrated. As far as I am concerned, the protection of children where there is deliberate harm is not complicated. There is very clear and robust legislation in place alongside stringent regulations in accordance with the law. Individuals are tasked (and paid a salary) to be public servants on behalf of the government to exercise their duties in accordance with their job descriptions. I have seen some very poor practice in my career and some exemplary practice. Time and time again the Serious Case Reviews say the same thing and have being saying so for decades. One of the top failures is always professionals taking the word of adults and not making it a priority to get a child to a safe place and to speak with them. It is so disheartening to hear that this has taken place again in the case of Arthur. No one took the time to speak with him and the professionals seemed so easily able to take the parents word. This is something that can be changed overnight. That is not a resource issue. I appreciate your advice and concern. Thank you.
@NanaRant I hear and share your frustration. It is so good to hear that you are doing what you are doing in the background to help and suppot them.

I agree that a common feature in these horrific abuse cases is professionals not seeking out and listening to the childs voice and believing manipulative parents who lie and cover up the truth.
However I disagree that resources are not an issue - government have spent a decade stripping bare childrens services, and removing protective factors and support systems, there is a national shortage of social workers, which means case loads are high, they get burnout and experienced workers leave the profession meaning that inexperienced professionals are dealing with complex cases and things gets missed. Demand is increasing and funding decreasing. Such an important role need proper resourcing to be done effectively.
All the best with the case you mention. I hope it has a good outcome

NanaRant · 07/12/2021 21:32

I completely agree @Wooky073 about intervention with Arthur. I am the person who intervenes in the street when I see people smacking children (smacking, thankfully, is now illegal in Scotland). My background is child protection - I am not backwards at coming forwards and I am a real ambassador for the rights of the child. I would not hesitate to take a child to hospital, for example and have taken similar actions in the past.
This particular case I refer to is extremely complicated and caring family can't get near the child. The referral went to the police as well as social work services. I can't say much more as it is outing and I need to respect the confidentiality of those concerned, but I am not going to rest and will reignite my concerns.
I am beyond frustrated. As far as I am concerned, the protection of children where there is deliberate harm is not complicated. There is very clear and robust legislation in place alongside stringent regulations in accordance with the law. Individuals are tasked (and paid a salary) to be public servants on behalf of the government to exercise their duties in accordance with their job descriptions. I have seen some very poor practice in my career and some exemplary practice. Time and time again the Serious Case Reviews say the same thing and have being saying so for decades. One of the top failures is always professionals taking the word of adults and not making it a priority to get a child to a safe place and to speak with them. It is so disheartening to hear that this has taken place again in the case of Arthur. No one took the time to speak with him and the professionals seemed so easily able to take the parents word. This is something that can be changed overnight. That is not a resource issue.
I appreciate your advice and concern. Thank you.

Wooky073 · 07/12/2021 19:53

@NanaRant

I had a sleepless night as this, again, triggered me. I cannot bear the statistic that 1 to 2 children die at the hands of their parents or carers in the UK every week. Time after time, we hear the same mantra.

Social Work Services are the very worst professionals to respond to this type of thing. Time and time again they ignore the signs, listen too intently to parents, never take the child aside - the list goes on. Case reviews say the same thing, and God knows I have written enough myself (child protection background).

I can't decide if it is plain incompetence, overwhelm, over-work, or just laziness.

I had the misfortune to make a child protection referral myself recently. it takes a lot of courage. I evidenced and substantiated everything. It could have been cut & pasted and used for the application for a court intervention. Yep, no further actioned. Not even investigated. 7 pages. This, on the back of at least 2 previous referrals of concerns.....school says no issues. Case closed, no further action.

Very similar circumstances. Entire family cut off and denied contact. Child is being deliberately harmed every day - by Dad and step Mum. It is harrowing. All she knows is punishments, withdrawal of food, not allowed drinks. Family can't get near and all Social Work say is apply to the courts for a contact order. Sickening.

@NanaRant you describe a terrible and potentially really serious child abuse case. Dont just rely on social services. They are under-resourced for the work they have.

You can report child abuse concerns to the NSPCC. www.nspcc.org.uk/keeping-children-safe/reporting-abuse/report/

I have also heard to take a child who looks in physically poor condition to hospital for medical attention which would evidence the physical abuse and get the child care and also trigger police and SS involvement. However that would be tricky in many cases.
I have thought that if I were the hairdresser or her partner and a child in that poor physical and mental condition such as Arthur was in the house I would make an excuse to pop to the shops or something and take him with me and drive him to a hospital or just call an ambulance.

Innocenta · 07/12/2021 16:47

@phishy

What seems to have been a factor in the murders of Victoria Climbie, Baby P, Daniel Pelka and now Arthur is a point at which that the caregivers stopped seeing the child as human, let alone their loved one. The child becomes a thing and receptacle for all their anger and hatred.

The child is isolated and othered, whilst sometimes other children (e.g. Daniel's siblings and Arthur's step-siblings) had a normal upbringing in the same house.

Does anyone know why this is? What causes adults to demonise a child / one particular child?

This seems to have been happening for a long time, but probably (?) just went relatively unnoticed in less 'recorded' times. The infamous Sylvia Likens case from the 1960s is a relatively modern example, but still not well-understood. (I strongly advise not looking this up if easily triggered.)
Borderterrierpuppy · 07/12/2021 16:42

I had to totally avoid the story after accidentally overhearing a tiny clip of audio.
Yanbu it’s horrific.

missfliss · 07/12/2021 16:36

Sorry I meant feel the same @Lilou21 - sorry for typo

missfliss · 07/12/2021 16:16

Totally get it @PleasantBirthday - feel the same very much

phishy · 07/12/2021 15:14

@PleasantBirthday

I think there is a phenomenon of the golden child and the scapegoat in families.

thenarcissisticlife.com/why-do-narcissists-have-a-golden-child-and-scapegoat-child/

Obviously I can't diagnose anyone I only know from the papers as a narcissist but...

That's interesting, Pleasant, and yes, it could be an extreme version of this.

What was really upsetting to me was that the hairdresser suggested to Emma Tustin that she send Arthur to his nan, and Tustin refused, saying that means he would have won.

She didn't want to just not have Arthur around, she wanted him around to cause him pain.

phishy · 07/12/2021 15:11

@BalladOfBarryAndFreda

phishy, I think that’s an important area for research. It’s a known phenomenon but I don’t think enough is known about why or what triggers it.

Agreed Ballad. There's not much info online. Maybe this should be considered as part of the new inquiry.

Lilou21 · 07/12/2021 14:51

@missfliss and @JLee123 same here, it’s not something I want to do and I know it doesn’t help anyone but it keeps happening. I’ve tried to do some positive things to help other children, as others have suggested but it’s like I can’t accept that I can’t help this one even though I know that’s the case.

PleasantBirthday · 07/12/2021 11:29

I think there is a phenomenon of the golden child and the scapegoat in families.

thenarcissisticlife.com/why-do-narcissists-have-a-golden-child-and-scapegoat-child/

Obviously I can't diagnose anyone I only know from the papers as a narcissist but...

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 07/12/2021 11:22

@Doriscox

I don't think it's irrational at all, he was such a handsome little boy and his life had barely begun, my grief is palpable. I personally like to think that God saw how how much he was suffering and decided to end it and have him with him, he's at peace now, no one can ever hurt him again
Wow. Child was tortured to death but hey-ho, it was God’s will.

phishy, I think that’s an important area for research. It’s a known phenomenon but I don’t think enough is known about why or what triggers it.

As for ‘what happened to society’ in the OP. Not a lot. Society has never been ‘safe’ for children.

phishy · 07/12/2021 11:16

What seems to have been a factor in the murders of Victoria Climbie, Baby P, Daniel Pelka and now Arthur is a point at which that the caregivers stopped seeing the child as human, let alone their loved one. The child becomes a thing and receptacle for all their anger and hatred.

The child is isolated and othered, whilst sometimes other children (e.g. Daniel's siblings and Arthur's step-siblings) had a normal upbringing in the same house.

Does anyone know why this is? What causes adults to demonise a child / one particular child?

Doriscox · 07/12/2021 10:52

I don't think it's irrational at all, he was such a handsome little boy and his life had barely begun, my grief is palpable. I personally like to think that God saw how how much he was suffering and decided to end it and have him with him, he's at peace now, no one can ever hurt him again

oakleaffy · 07/12/2021 00:06

@PoleFairy
Re Jyoti's case, I just googled, and four of the perpetrators who were involved have been hanged, after various appeals.

This is from BBC News site "
''Minutes after the convicts were hanged on Friday morning, the victim's mother said, "I hugged my daughter's photograph and told her we finally got justice."'

oakleaffy · 07/12/2021 00:03

@PoleFairy

I think sometimes, for whatever reason, there are news stories that haunt you. For me it was the Delhi bus gang rape. I remember feeling sick and horrified for weeks, had to keep turning off the news. Kept thinking of that poor woman and all she endured and her fiance being almost beaten to death. Just horrendous. There was no reason for me to be particularly afflicted by that story, I just was. I think occasionally it happens. It strikes a nerve and haunts you. I did eventually get over it
Oh yes, that was horrendous. Jyoti Singh, aged 22. Many women all over the World where the case was reported were appalled that that and there were protests all over India, and rightfully so. It was sickening and resonated with many people. It was about this time of year, too, if I remember?
Rhannion · 06/12/2021 23:07

@Drumshambo

What purpose do you think all this crying and grieving is going to serve? Does it he!p Arthur? Does it help other children who are / will no doubt come after him? There are lots of arthur's. They're in every city village and town all over the country!

Your performative grieving is just that. It helps nothing or no one!
This awful.episode will be forgotten in a few months.,- until t happens again. and the grief vampires appear again on forums like this and Facebook to repeat the same meaningless drival. For God sake have some decency. and afford the poor soul some dignity in death. and stop with these threads.

Do you really think that people aren’t allowed to vent their feelings on here just because you don’t agree with them? Women post on mumsnet for many reasons and to vent our feelings about this utter tragedy isn’t a competition, it’s a human reaction to an inhuman tragedy.
sst1234 · 06/12/2021 23:04

The videos being out there a are a good thing. Hopefully Emma and Thomas’ new friends in prison have seen them too.

sst1234 · 06/12/2021 22:46

@Mufasa1118

It's awful and wrong on every level and I have felt so sad for him.

This is just my own opinion - dont flame me. I also have sympathy for her. She probably had an awful life, had a cruel life, had her kids taken off her and She was mentally ill.
Prison is the right place for her

Best not to flame you. You simply don’t understand what you are saying. If you did, you wouldn’t come out with this nonsense.
Buddhabowl · 06/12/2021 22:31

I am haunted most by those cries, and the fact he was constantly wearing those pyjamas. I think what makes it harder for me to deal with is that he had a good life with his grandparents previously, you can see he was well looked after. It must have been brutally hard for him to endure that knowing his loving family were so near but he couldn't get to them.That poor poor boy.

Piglet89 · 06/12/2021 22:27

It is awful, awful, awful OP and I also can’t stop thinking about him and wishing something could have been done to save him.

I also didn’t know that about poor baby Peter. I will say, though, I personally am much more affected and upset by these stories since I had my own son. I don’t know how anyone could do it to a defenceless child. I know from the news that domestic violence soared during the lockdowns (which is heinous) but I can’t get my head around it.

sqirrelfriends · 06/12/2021 22:05

@Bluntness100 I didn't know that about baby P, that really is just so awful.

It resonated with me when you said be that certain things haunt you, I feel like some things are so horrific that it's incomprehensible that they were caused by another human. Humans are meant to feel compassion, to nurture young people, not break them.

What haunts me is Arthur's voice saying no one loved him, no one is going to feed him. No child should ever feel like that.

Bluntness100 · 06/12/2021 21:48

@PoleFairy

I think sometimes, for whatever reason, there are news stories that haunt you. For me it was the Delhi bus gang rape. I remember feeling sick and horrified for weeks, had to keep turning off the news. Kept thinking of that poor woman and all she endured and her fiance being almost beaten to death. Just horrendous. There was no reason for me to be particularly afflicted by that story, I just was. I think occasionally it happens. It strikes a nerve and haunts you. I did eventually get over it
For me, it was baby p and the fact they broke his spine and paralysed him. And then sat him in a buggy so the social workers wouldn’t know.

For some reason it haunted me, it still haunts me. I didn’t cry or start telling millions of people I was crying, but in amongst the avalanche of cruelty that child endured, much of it just as bad or worse, for some reason paralysing him just absolutely haunted and still haunts me.

I think for many of us there is one thing that strikes such a chord of absolute horror in us, that we struggle to get past it.

Handholdtoday · 06/12/2021 20:58

I think the issue with those on here that think it's 'performance grief' don't understand it because they don't feel the same strength/depth of feeling. But that doesn't mean it doesn't exist or is an act just because YOU (the ones harangueing) have different feelings/perspective. It's like accusing people in lots of situations in life that their experience or perspective is attention seeking or an act just because it's an experience you've never had! Ridiculous!

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 06/12/2021 20:50

@Drumshambo

What purpose do you think all this crying and grieving is going to serve? Does it he!p Arthur? Does it help other children who are / will no doubt come after him? There are lots of arthur's. They're in every city village and town all over the country!

Your performative grieving is just that. It helps nothing or no one!
This awful.episode will be forgotten in a few months.,- until t happens again. and the grief vampires appear again on forums like this and Facebook to repeat the same meaningless drival. For God sake have some decency. and afford the poor soul some dignity in death. and stop with these threads.

How can it be performance grief when people are posting on an anonymous forum? I’ve posted on threads like this because I feel so heartbroken over what’s happened to the little boy. You can’t avoid these stories in the news. I keep seeing the look on his face in that room at 1am in the morning all alone and I can’t forget it.

There needs to be outcry over things like this because maybe then there will be more pressure on the powers that be to do something about it. That little boy bravely spoke out at what was going on at home. He spoke out and the people in authority didn’t listen to him. I’m upset, partly because I have a boy the same age as Arthur and if I want to speak to others who feel the same way then I will.

Swipe left for the next trending thread