Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
LindyLou2020 · 03/12/2021 19:13

@NanaRant

I had a sleepless night as this, again, triggered me. I cannot bear the statistic that 1 to 2 children die at the hands of their parents or carers in the UK every week. Time after time, we hear the same mantra.

Social Work Services are the very worst professionals to respond to this type of thing. Time and time again they ignore the signs, listen too intently to parents, never take the child aside - the list goes on. Case reviews say the same thing, and God knows I have written enough myself (child protection background).

I can't decide if it is plain incompetence, overwhelm, over-work, or just laziness.

I had the misfortune to make a child protection referral myself recently. it takes a lot of courage. I evidenced and substantiated everything. It could have been cut & pasted and used for the application for a court intervention. Yep, no further actioned. Not even investigated. 7 pages. This, on the back of at least 2 previous referrals of concerns.....school says no issues. Case closed, no further action.

Very similar circumstances. Entire family cut off and denied contact. Child is being deliberately harmed every day - by Dad and step Mum. It is harrowing. All she knows is punishments, withdrawal of food, not allowed drinks. Family can't get near and all Social Work say is apply to the courts for a contact order. Sickening.

@NanaRant......I'm appalled and truly shocked to read what you've written. I can honestly say that that is not the response you would have got from me, or my colleagues, when I was a practising social worker in my last local authority. But as I said, I am out of touch and possibly naive regarding how things are today. What you're describing is disgraceful and in my view, negligent on the part of Social Services, and I cannot understand how they can refuse to act. Is there no way you can take this further? (Granted, I don't know what your position is in this matter).
BFCfairy · 03/12/2021 19:12

Yanbu I have cried felt sick and decided not to listen as would have been physically sick.

ElftonWednesday · 03/12/2021 19:11

Also, given that his natural mother is in prison for murdering her partner, how the hell was he not on the radar of social services, even before his grandmother drew attention to his injuries?

peaceanddove · 03/12/2021 19:10

Why anyone would actively choose to listen to the recordings FFS? It's downright macabre. It's akin to the people who buy those dreadful, dreadful child abuse 'autobiographies' FFS. Why would you want to read pages and pages of child abuse and torture? What is wrong with you?

I hate the shallow, mawkish goulish frothing that is splashed across Facebook. It's insincere and puddle deep.

LakieLady · 03/12/2021 19:10

On the basis that I am a hard-faced old bat and it's even got to me, I'd say YANBU.

The video of the poor soul trying to pick up the duvet is just heartbreaking.

harveythehorse · 03/12/2021 19:08

I think everyone feels absolutely devastated by this case. Yet again social services turned a blind eye to abuse and yet AGAIN a defenceless child has died. How many people need to raise concerns (with photographic evidence) before they are taken seriously??? It certainly made me hug my children even tightly than normal.

DrSbaitso · 03/12/2021 19:08

@Applesonthelawn

Or alternately Carrotsticks, it could be genuine feelings that have no other place to find expression. This is not something we can discuss with our partners, our children. I'm for one doing my best to keep it to myself in real life because I don't want to burden them when there is nothing they can do. It has helped me to know that I am not the only one who has found it so upsetting. This is nothing to do with competitive grieving. I am the last person who would virtue signal.
Why can't you talk to your partner about it?

And did you truly think you were the only one to find it so upsetting?

ElftonWednesday · 03/12/2021 19:07

I found the reporting pretty gratutitous, there was a warning before it was shown, but as there is a warning before everything these days, most things which are very minor indeed, I had seen and heard everything before I realised. Children would have heard it too, it was on at 8am on BBC Breakfast.

ladygindiva · 03/12/2021 19:07

@PleasantBirthday

I think I struggle with the mawkishness of Facebook posts and we love yous and I would have taken him in etc. You wouldn't have taken him in. He went through a hellish experience and would have been a difficult child with very difficult to meet needs as a result of his horrific experiences. Maltreated, abused, neglected, victim and witness to shocking violence, he would not have been the smiling grateful recipient of anyones munificence.

If you really feel affected and you must do something, hold down your dinner, dry your eyes and be kinder to the child you think is feral and a bad influence on yours. Report every legitimate concern you have. Ask questions. Actually consider the nuisance child that irritates you as possibly the child whose situation is deteriorating and do what you wish you had done for this child.

This is a great post.
FurrFeather · 03/12/2021 19:07

I understand to some extent OP. It was disgusting. I couldn't actually read about it Sad it was so desperate and shocking. Fuckers, throw away the keys.

neveradullmoment99 · 03/12/2021 19:06

@royco

In fact, I disagree with those recordings being in the public domain.

Can someone explain why they are? Surely Arthur's privacy should be respected?

It's like a gore-fest to some.

I agree. Why are these even published? I am so shocked they are.
PleasantBirthday · 03/12/2021 19:05

I think I struggle with the mawkishness of Facebook posts and we love yous and I would have taken him in etc. You wouldn't have taken him in. He went through a hellish experience and would have been a difficult child with very difficult to meet needs as a result of his horrific experiences. Maltreated, abused, neglected, victim and witness to shocking violence, he would not have been the smiling grateful recipient of anyones munificence.

If you really feel affected and you must do something, hold down your dinner, dry your eyes and be kinder to the child you think is feral and a bad influence on yours. Report every legitimate concern you have. Ask questions. Actually consider the nuisance child that irritates you as possibly the child whose situation is deteriorating and do what you wish you had done for this child.

flymetotheloon · 03/12/2021 19:04

@WeirdArchitecture

Just to add, i dont have any 'fantasies' - it is a knee jerk, temporary emotion. To suppress honest emotions might not be so good an idea, or tell others how to deal with theirs. I wouldnt actually enjoy seeing anyone tortured, of course. So long as the feelings pass and do not stick, we are all entitled to that liberty. Self awareness is the thing.
You said this: "I want to see those bastards tortured like they tortured him" that's you sharing your torture fantasies with others on the internet. It's not a 'feeling' a feeling is an emotion. You've shared a graphic fantasy.
gallbladderpains · 03/12/2021 19:04

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@Kippersfortea

The fact that both grandmothers wanted to help, reported concerns snd would have housed him/loved him but didn’t get the chance is just fucking awful and people need to lose their jobs as a bare minimum but won’t[/quote]
If it's true as reported that the police threatened the Uncle with being arrested for breaking lockdown rules when he said he wanted to go and check on the child, someone needs to be sanctioned....at all times the welfare of a vulnerable person was an exception during lockdown. If I know that, so should the police.

WeirdArchitecture · 03/12/2021 19:02

havent seen vid, that is a step too far.

WeirdArchitecture · 03/12/2021 19:02

Just to add, i dont have any 'fantasies' - it is a knee jerk, temporary emotion. To suppress honest emotions might not be so good an idea, or tell others how to deal with theirs. I wouldnt actually enjoy seeing anyone tortured, of course.
So long as the feelings pass and do not stick, we are all entitled to that liberty. Self awareness is the thing.

gallbladderpains · 03/12/2021 19:01

@royco

I don't know why anyone would listen to, or watch the video.

Just reading about it is horrifying enough.

This
Applesonthelawn · 03/12/2021 19:01

Or alternately Carrotsticks, it could be genuine feelings that have no other place to find expression. This is not something we can discuss with our partners, our children. I'm for one doing my best to keep it to myself in real life because I don't want to burden them when there is nothing they can do. It has helped me to know that I am not the only one who has found it so upsetting. This is nothing to do with competitive grieving. I am the last person who would virtue signal.

flymetotheloon · 03/12/2021 19:00

@Katyppp

I will remember this thread every time I read a poster gleefully proclaiming 'Grandparents have NO rights' in response to some minor tiff, usually with the MIL. Maybe if the grandparents did have rights, their concerns might have been taken more seriously.
With all due respect child safeguarding is a state responsibility it has nothing whatsoever to do with grandparents and I'm glad my parents have not rights over my children because they abused me and the law as it stands helps me to prevent the cycle repeating.
WeirdArchitecture · 03/12/2021 18:59

This type of thing brings out my inner thug. Despite how tolerant or open minded we might consider ourselves, this shit creates powerful, primal emotions.
I want to see those bastards tortured like they tortured him. It makes me furious that scum like that can breed. And yet i know nothing is this simple, and my thoughts are perhaps understandably, temporarily .....disturbed. Im not so sure i ought to be ashamed of those feelings - i think it is a healthy reaction, so long as it passes by and doesn't stew. The story made me want to cry, but the anger shifted in too quickly. Real, real fucking anger. And the only sickness i feel is disgust.

21 years inside, pathetic.

Libertaire · 03/12/2021 18:59

@FourTeaFallOut

I've actively avoided any of the recordings from the case. I don't see any merit in having my nose up to his suffering. I think it's voyeuristic and unethical of the media to publish.
The media may be cynical, but they aren’t stupid. They understand what their readers want, and they know the grief tourists will lap up every gory titillating detail before making a public show of their self-indulgent vicarious anguish. They do protest too much, methinks….
flymetotheloon · 03/12/2021 18:59

@CarrotSticks19

Obviously what happened to Arthur was truelly horrific. And I feel very angry towards his father and step mum

However I find threads like this really distasteful. For me I have read enough to know what happened and I don't need to keep rehashing it. It feels very disrespectful to keep replaying his abuse and I often feel these threads use a young boys distress to demonstrate how empathetic some people are. It's competitive grief, and it's morbid and self serving.

Those videos and recordings are of a real boy, and I think we should give him some dignity. Would anyone want to be remembered by their last moments of distress when they are most vulnerable? Genuinely how would you feel if that video was of you, and a lot of strangers on the Internet started threads about how they kept being physically sick because of something that happened to you. Or if it was your grandchild, or nephew.

By all means feel angry, by all means find what happened to Arthur upsetting. But to start threads detailing exactly how upset you are by it, to me just seems very disrespectful and quite distasteful. It is grief tourism

Completely agree, and all the 'string them up' and 'let them drop' fantasies on the other thread were bordering into sick fantasy, too.

Some real narcissism shining through when picking over this horrific case.

Katyppp · 03/12/2021 18:59

I will remember this thread every time I read a poster gleefully proclaiming 'Grandparents have NO rights' in response to some minor tiff, usually with the MIL. Maybe if the grandparents did have rights, their concerns might have been taken more seriously.

Onionbhajisandwich · 03/12/2021 18:58

I couldn’t listen to it. I cried at the pictures though. Poor little thing. 😔

Arsewangry · 03/12/2021 18:57

I listened to the recordings. The poor kid wanted his voice to be heard, nobody listened to him at the time, the least I can do for him now is to hear him.

I was sickened by a headline I read yesterday about his mum because she was in prison he was "left in the grips of his father and step father" it wasn't his mums fault he died. Yes she killed her partner but I happen to know for a fact through work that that murder case was not as simple as her just being a murderer.

I hope that soon little Arthur can be properly laid to rest.