Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
Her657844 · 03/12/2021 22:21

@TallulahsCurse

That’s really harsh and nasty? I personally think you have some issues if that’s how you perceive everyone’s posts “performative weeping”? Perhaps people are genuinely upset ?

tallduckandhandsome · 03/12/2021 22:20

@TallulahsCurse harsh but agreed. People are upset, yes absolutely, but those saying they have been ‘sobbing and sick’ for two days? I’m not buying it.

EberhardtSmallcock · 03/12/2021 22:19

This reply has been deleted

Post references deleted post Talk guidelines.

TallulahsCurse · 03/12/2021 22:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Innocenta · 03/12/2021 22:08

@CPL593H

People don't need to find and comfort their inner child, they need to be in touch with their actual adult self and resolve to challenge and report abuse, really resolve to do that and to campaign for the best services possible and hold them to account. It won't ever stop these tragic events completely but if enough people do it, it can rescue some. That is the best way to honour and remember little Arthur and all the children like him.
Many people do need to do this. It's totally okay if that's not for you - maybe you haven't been hurt in a way that requires this kind of healing. It's certainly not everyone's journey, and as I said in another comment, I started out incredibly scornful about inner child work myself. I understand where you're coming from, but it's also just a reality if trauma that many people are suffering in this way, and it's part (one part) of why some respond so strongly to tragic events involving children.

None of this means that we shouldn't be working towards better safeguarding in our society. But people who are in crisis often need to process and heal before it's possible to help others (again, not everyone).

Naughtynovembertree · 03/12/2021 21:59

I am not sure, I was very surprised when the living room footage was shown.
Do we need to see it? I'm not sure this creature claimed he did it to himself and a managed to attack her in the process?
I'm not sure really. It feels intrusive but at the same time it's a horrific crime that's been committed and perhaps seeing this and knowing the case might spur people to act when they see this sort of thing, I don't know.

Her657844 · 03/12/2021 21:58

No yanbu I watched the video which was on an article as it automatically played …I absolutely sobbed my heart out listening to him say them words and he was so ill he could barely stand, I really don’t think it should be publically shared. It’s disrespectful and not fair and like someone else mentioned there are monsters like his step mum that will enjoy it.

I’m so upset about it too I think it’s because I have my own little boy the thought of it all makes my stomach turn. I would of loved arthur and given him a home, food and cuddles 😢 He has been let down so badly how could social services miss this even after seeing the bruises? I wish his grandmother had just kidnapped him she must of known something wasn’t right.

HumpreyDowny · 03/12/2021 21:57

@SilverGlassHare
"Today I’m trying really hard not to obsess about it though that feels like a betrayal and a cop out, weirdly."

I felt the same when trying to block it at work...

Saraj09876 · 03/12/2021 21:55

Me neither :(

cottoncandyflossy · 03/12/2021 21:54

Wow! So surprised at some of the insensitive comments on here.

I feel absolutely heartbroken at this, can't shake it off.
I have thought about practical things I can do, but I also understand that there is nothing I can do or could have done to help Arthur but it doesn't stop the feelings.

It is human nature to sometimes feel things deeply and today I was honestly wondering what I can do to shake this off and get past the upset because it felt like it was taking me over.

That's not making it about me. It's feeling a tiny fraction of what that poor boy must felt and crying with him. For him.

So so so sad, I'm not actually sure how to deal with it. Right now doing something practical like donating to charity or volunteering doesn't seem like it will help because nothing can change what happened to that lovely boy.

It is okay to feel sad, it is okay to talk about your feelings and try to process them.

Rest in peace Arthur. I will hold this in my heart for a long, long time.

confusedmummy123 · 03/12/2021 21:52

I was so upset earlier especially having a six year old . I cuddled her like mad. Then read about his fave book was the Snail and the Whale upset me as thats my daughters favourite book and she was so happy to get it

Bluntness100 · 03/12/2021 21:50

I don’t support this, I am disturbed by what’s happened and think about it too much but crying and vomiting makes it too much about you. And not about this little boy,

CurzonDax · 03/12/2021 21:48

You are not alone in finding this all upsetting. I also cried earlier over this.

Breaks my heart - my DH and I are struggling to conceive, yet monsters like this seem to have no problems having children that they don't deserve.

Arthur was such a handsome, beautiful little boy; I would have had so much love to give him - love that his was begging for, and deserved.

royco · 03/12/2021 21:40

@HarrisMcCoo

I personally think that the video clip and audio clip should be removed from media outlets. It's very distasteful and unnecessary.
Agree
HarrisMcCoo · 03/12/2021 21:39

I personally think that the video clip and audio clip should be removed from media outlets. It's very distasteful and unnecessary.

CPL593H · 03/12/2021 21:33

People don't need to find and comfort their inner child, they need to be in touch with their actual adult self and resolve to challenge and report abuse, really resolve to do that and to campaign for the best services possible and hold them to account. It won't ever stop these tragic events completely but if enough people do it, it can rescue some. That is the best way to honour and remember little Arthur and all the children like him.

Gaagaa · 03/12/2021 21:31

To be so upset is not irrational at all

Rest in peace and sleep tight Arthur

I had a tough time as a kid, I've worked in child protection for years, I am a mum

We can all do more to take care of kids in our own families and watch out for other kids too. (I include myself in this)

Being proactive is important but so rare ime- what can we all do in our communities? Doesn't have to be complicated- checking on a neighbour with covid, reach out to your nephew that you don't know well in the nearby city, check in with your stepkid, have a chat about how they are really doing and what they like, what if they were being abused by their other parent, what would you do?

I told many people about abuse in fragmented ways. Almost everyone did (and continues to) turn a blind eye or to do nothing. Not because they are bad or nasty, it's just the path of least resistance and much easier to minimise and assume it's nothing, or that somebody else will sort it out. I was desperate for an adult to make the time to sit with me and listen to me and to say that I could talk to them about anything at all, however strange or scary it was.

The level of malicious evil intentional cruelty towards Arthur is rare ime

What is not rare is child abuse and neglect, it's everywhere and we all have a responsibility to address it. Things get kept within families because of shame, secrets, years of 'this is what's always happened in our family' and these barriers need to broken down

Sweetchocolatecandy · 03/12/2021 21:29

Sorry I have not read the full thread but YANBU to feel the way you do. It’s utterly heartbreaking what happened to that poor little boy and I have been thinking about it a lot today- feeling both upset and angry at his murderers and how he was let down by the system. Child abuse is truly the worst and the only thing that consoles me is that he’s not suffering any more at the hands of these evil ‘people’.

Fidgetty · 03/12/2021 21:25

I've only read the headlines, have had to scroll past really fast whenever I see the story come up and have skipped to the bottom of the comments on here so as not to learn any more details but just wanted to say YANBU OP. I just know if I read the details of that little boy's death I won't sleep properly for days. The little I've seen in the headlines makes me want to to weep it sounds so horrific. I've never been a sensitive person and rarely cry unless a family member dies, but since having my DDs stories about child abuse/children dying cut straight to the bone. I actually can't bear it. I cried on and off for days over two cases in particular in the past five years. It's too much for me to handle so I avoid it now. Flowers

SilverGlassHare · 03/12/2021 21:25

I haven’t listened and won’t either, though I have read various news articles. I’ve found Arthur’s case much more upsetting than any previous case, probably because I have a DS of that age. I was in tears about it (which has never happened to me before) yesterday evening and even dreamed about the case last night.

Today I’m trying really hard not to obsess about it though that feels like a betrayal and a cop out, weirdly.

Innocenta · 03/12/2021 21:22

[quote Noeuf]@Libertaire with you on that reaction. And I’ve had loads of therapy. I don’t think the inner child stuff is at the core of most approaches.[/quote]
No therapeutic approach works for everyone, and it also varies over time. The first time I was introduced to inner child work (at age 19), I was polite to the therapist, but vocally scornful at home afterwards. I know what it's like to find inner child work cringe, believe me, and I wouldn't have posted those thoughts if I was unable to tolerate some negative responses.

CBT is a very effective, evidence-based therapy, that helps many people. It didn't help me much, despite being fortunate enough to access it outside the NHS and for a long time. Eventually, via some other more or less helpful approaches, I came back round to someone who does use inner child work alongside much else. Over ten years later, I am a different person now, and now it does help me.

But sadly, there is no panacea. I wish there was. Do whatever makes you feel safest, as long as it is safe. Thanks

SammyScrounge · 03/12/2021 21:17

You should listen because every child who suffers abuse dies like that. That's something to be remembered by all of us and the authorities. You don't learn it from the written word or a summary but you learn from this.
Think about Hindley and Brady. What kept them in prison was the recordings they made. They were never made public but police and journalists still speak of them with revulsion. When there were attempts to release Hindley those people who had heard the reality of what she had done blazed it all over the media again. They literally kept her in prison on the strength of the recording. And Tustin got 29 years on the strength of her love of recording.

HumpreyDowny · 03/12/2021 21:15

I have been sick and sobbed since two days and can't concentrate on anything. You aren't alone op. I wish we could have a time machine and went and hugged that soul.. Feel so helpless...

Innocenta · 03/12/2021 21:07

@LizzieW1969 It absolutely reflects her own triggered response. I'm so sorry OP has received these replies, some of which are very unkind. I hope she can 'hear' us too.

Innocenta · 03/12/2021 21:06

@royco No counsellor should be saying the same things as an informal poster on a forum. It's totally fine that inner child work isn't for you - at least not now. I have also been in that place, and even been very scornful of it. I would not have ever guessed my mind could change so much.

Do whatever you need to feel at peace with the events and with yourself. Thanks

Swipe left for the next trending thread