Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
NeedsCharging · 03/12/2021 23:16

.I agreed with whatTallulahCursesaid, and I didn't see it as a personal attack. I saw it more as frustration at the grief vampires.

Why call people names?
Why be that personal and use a name which personifies the undead/unfeeling?
Can you not accept that some people choose to reach out, seek comfort and reassurance that most of humanity are not murdering abusive cunts?
Why does that make them vampires?

tallduckandhandsome · 03/12/2021 23:16

@HumpreyDowny I didn’t mean you in particular, I meant the various posters who have said they’ve been physically sick for days etc.

Look, I hope I’m wrong and, but I do agree with @womanity , there are much better ways to channel that ‘grief’ than sobbing for days.

womanity · 03/12/2021 23:14

@zlister
I'm sorry your kids were treated like that, that's not acceptable. However why makes you think those kind of people would be the ones upset on this thread?

I’m not talking about OP particularly. I think a lot of people who’ve been there are empathetic. Other people, not so much.

I think @CPL593H sums it up quite nicely.

zlister · 03/12/2021 23:12

@MissTrip82

I find it ludicrous to equate telling everyone you’re heartbroken, feel sick or have been sobbing for days with empathy. Putting your feelings at the centre of someone else’s tragedy isn’t empathy.

The truly empathic amongst us will have taken action as a result of this. Written to an MP demanding better resources for social services, donated to a charity fighting child abuse, started the process of applying to be a foster carer etc.

The vast majority of people heartbroken over this will be back living their normal lives tomorrow without doing anything at all and will be similarly heartbroken the next time.

Indeed the next time will be happening right now, somewhere.

I don't think op put their feelings at the front of anything, she hasn't even been on the thread since about 200+ posts

The people dragging out this thread and being pissed that others are sad, are equally centring their feelings in that case.

NeedsCharging · 03/12/2021 23:12

Putting your feelings at the centre of someone else’s tragedy isn’t empathy

The OP is reaching out. She feels pain/confusion/anger and is looking to others to try and make sense of it. That's not a bad thing.
That does show compassion.
It shows humanity.
Something the 2 people Arthur relied on lacked in spades.

EberhardtSmallcock · 03/12/2021 23:08

@NeedsCharging

EberhardtSmallcock

I dont belive MN censored TallulahsCurse post because they expressed their feelings but because they posted a personal attack.
Many posters have said public grief is wrong and their posts still stand.

Yes, possibly so. I suppose I've noticed a recentish tendency on the part of MNHQ to censor posts (not just about this - anything anti-lockdown was also censored last year) which would not have been censored in the Good Old Days. I agreed with what TallulahCurse said, and I didn't see it as a personal attack. I saw it more as frustration at the grief vampires. I am just very uncomfortable about censorship unless it's someone who's clearly either being a troll or a complete and utter shit.
MissTrip82 · 03/12/2021 23:06

I find it ludicrous to equate telling everyone you’re heartbroken, feel sick or have been sobbing for days with empathy. Putting your feelings at the centre of someone else’s tragedy isn’t empathy.

The truly empathic amongst us will have taken action as a result of this. Written to an MP demanding better resources for social services, donated to a charity fighting child abuse, started the process of applying to be a foster carer etc.

The vast majority of people heartbroken over this will be back living their normal lives tomorrow without doing anything at all and will be similarly heartbroken the next time.

Indeed the next time will be happening right now, somewhere.

CPL593H · 03/12/2021 23:05

@Innocenta You know nothing about my childhood, of course you don't.

The appalling mixture of hyperbolic expression of ever more inventive ways of torturing the perpetrators and competitive expressions of second hand grief achieve absolutely nothing in protecting children from harm. Yes, what happened to him is more than sad, it's a bloody appalling tragedy and there is nothing amiss in feeling bad about it and I'm not surprised people do. I do.

All I am asking is that people use the agency and power of being adults to always act upon their feelings of unease about a child in danger. You don't need cuddly jumpers or "sweeties" to do that, you don't need to heal yourself, you just have to do it, whatever the circumstances.

zlister · 03/12/2021 23:03

@womanity

I’m raising two DC who were removed from their birth family.

I wonder how many of the ‘sobbing for days’ posters are the ones who most harshly judge my DC because they’re weird/late/aggressive/loud/unpredictable as a result of their experiences and who spent years not inviting my DC to their DCs’ birthday parties and who ask for my DCs not to sit next to their DC in school and who give me the side eye in the playground.

The world is not kind to DC who have survived these early experiences.

I'm sorry your kids were treated like that, that's not acceptable. However why makes you think those kind of people would be the ones upset on this thread?

I would think people who are very sensitive or abused themselves would probably be the more empathetic type.

eastegg · 03/12/2021 23:02

Must have been very difficult for the police, lawyers, jury, judge and everyone else involved who didn’t have the luxury of switching off or turning away.

Obviously my first thoughts are for that poor boy (I have deliberately avoided the details on the news as I don’t think I can take it, despite having a background as a criminal barrister myself), but I also think we should spare a thought for the people who work in an under-the-cosh system which generally just receives either criticism or indifference. Many professionals will have had sleepless nights to ensure these two were brought to justice.

NeedsCharging · 03/12/2021 23:01

EberhardtSmallcock

I dont belive MN censored TallulahsCurse post because they expressed their feelings but because they posted a personal attack.
Many posters have said public grief is wrong and their posts still stand.

SeaWitchly · 03/12/2021 23:01

I am in Australia and have also been deeply affected by this little boy's tragic story. The only thing I feel we can hold on to is that we must all be that bit more vigilant as a society when we feel children are at risk of harm and report any concerns to the authorities. Of course, this is no guarantee that the child will be saved from the harm inflicted by abusive parents.

Jane335 · 03/12/2021 22:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

womanity · 03/12/2021 22:50

I’m raising two DC who were removed from their birth family.

I wonder how many of the ‘sobbing for days’ posters are the ones who most harshly judge my DC because they’re weird/late/aggressive/loud/unpredictable as a result of their experiences and who spent years not inviting my DC to their DCs’ birthday parties and who ask for my DCs not to sit next to their DC in school and who give me the side eye in the playground.

The world is not kind to DC who have survived these early experiences.

EberhardtSmallcock · 03/12/2021 22:46

@NeedsCharging

TallulahsCurse

You are entitled to feel and express how YOU feel as is the OP.
The fact that people are physically upset by this is a good thing. Grief no matter where it comes from should be expressed.
A little boy died in a disgusting and avoidable way. The more people that show grief/compassion/sympathy and empathy the better.
Why hide from it ir pretend it is not happening? Will that help future Arthur's?

@TallulahsCurse evidently isn't entitled to express it, as MN has censored her post.
HumpreyDowny · 03/12/2021 22:44

Tallulahscurse and tallduckhandsome,

Do you think I care if you may buy it or not? I don't understand why you are being toxic about grieving and shocked people. How dare you? Why would someone write to an anonymous forum as a contest? People have been so deeply affected by this and have nothing to prove to you. People who are writing here are trying to find solice, and others to talk about it, it's a completely human thing to do. The least you can do is not belittle people's feelings, why can't you just scroll away. And yes I too did cry and threw up. People process horror differently and apparently that's my way.

People deeply genuinely caring and being affected makes me feel a tiny bit more optimistic about society. If I hadn't seen these posts I'd have thought evil has normalised in our society and would depress me even more...

Mama234567 · 03/12/2021 22:44

I have a 5 Yr old son and I have wept and wept for Arthur. I haven't watched any videos but the details are enough.

Its not a competition or ghoulish to talk about it. Its unbearable knowing what he went through and if people need to talk about him and how sad it is thats just proof of empathy.

TheUsualChaos · 03/12/2021 22:43

No I don't think it's strange to be so upset. It's a truly horrific case. The thought of such a young child having such a sad and lonely life at the end is very distressing. I have actively avoided reading too much detail or seeing any recordings as quite honestly I don't want it allow it to overwhelm me with sadness. That sounds quite selfish and yes it is, self preservation I suppose.

I feel so utterly disillusioned with the the system that there can be so many warning signs and even his close family asking for help and this little boy still ends up dying at the hands of these abusers. How often do people not bother to report child abuse because they hear of cases like this and think what's the point, no action will be taken.

I hope those evil specimens rot in prison. They should never ever be released.

iwanttobeonleave · 03/12/2021 22:39

@PooWillyNameChange

I think YAB a bit U to listen to the recordings. I'm not sure why people do, so gory. I don't know all the details, I can't even bear to read the articles.
I agree. There's no way I can listen to those. It would haunt me terribly.
Gaagaa · 03/12/2021 22:38

Of course this is about Arthur. But we have all been children and feeling upset about his life is no bad thing and surely if anything his experiences should make us all think about compassion for other people's pain? It's when people shut down to others pain that it all starts to go horribly wrong.

Anyone minimising the experiences of other people being very upset, crying, vomiting etc is showing no awareness of the impact of trauma

Especially for people who have experienced abuse themselves (as the OP mentions) trauma is experienced in physical ways in the body and there needs to be acceptance of this to heal.

Read van der kolk, the body keeps the score he says-

Trauma victims cannot recover until they become familiar with and befriend the sensations in their bodies. Being frightened means that you live in a body that is always on guard. Angry people live in angry bodies. The bodies of child-abuse victims are tense and defensive until they find a way to relax and feel safe. In order to change, people need to become aware of their sensations and the way that their bodies interact with the world around them. Physical self-awareness is the first step in releasing the tyranny of the past.

Upyouranty · 03/12/2021 22:35

@HarrisMcCoo

I personally think that the video clip and audio clip should be removed from media outlets. It's very distasteful and unnecessary.
I agree.

I watched it accidentally and haven’t been able to wipe it from my mind and have cried about it several times.
I work in cp and deal with upsetting situations regularly but that impacted me in a way I don’t feel is healthy for anyone.

Arthur’s horror shouldn’t be something that’s viewed by anyone.

abcdeg · 03/12/2021 22:31

@TallulahsCurse

Well that was a bonkers reply. You're making it about yourself and your own incense. And you're pretending that somehow you're own reply is thinking of Arthur, a post slamming those affected by his death? Nice

longtompot · 03/12/2021 22:30

I've not listened to any of the recordings, the photo of him sat in the room alone was enough for me. Reading the whole case has been incredibly heartbreaking. How someone could treat another human being in that way, let alone a child is beyond me. Pure evil.
That woman should have been made to leave her cell and be in court for sentencing. A Coward through and through.
RIP Arthur Flowers

NeedsCharging · 03/12/2021 22:28

TallulahsCurse

You are entitled to feel and express how YOU feel as is the OP.
The fact that people are physically upset by this is a good thing. Grief no matter where it comes from should be expressed.
A little boy died in a disgusting and avoidable way. The more people that show grief/compassion/sympathy and empathy the better.
Why hide from it ir pretend it is not happening? Will that help future Arthur's?

L0stinCyberspace · 03/12/2021 22:26

OP I think the level of distress, the intensity, that you are experiencing (weeping / vomiting) is excessive and unhealthy, but it probably relates to your past. I think you should seek counselling or support.