Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
MiddayMass · 04/12/2021 05:10

I don’t get all those complaining about the “competitive grief”, over somebody sharing their upset at the video and seeking support over it on a parenting forum.

This little boy was beaten to death in his own home ffs. And all you can focus on is telling strangers off for expressing their upset?

Poor Arthur died in the most terrible way. How is people being upset about it causing any further harm to him, or his memory?

Let people grieve him and let people be sad over the situation. All he ever knew in his short life was hate and pain. Let him be cared about now, let people grieve the gorgeous little boy he was and let people cry over the loss of him. He deserves to mourned. For the life of god, don’t let him be forgotten.

floatinginmyhomie · 04/12/2021 01:47

YANBU. As part of my uni degree and my college course I had to learn about children who had been abused and it was awful, that was years ago and I’m so angry that the same rubbish is being spouted about leaving no stone unturned. It shouldn’t keep happening. Arthur’s story has upset me more than any other, I’m not sure why. It’s just horrific

Onthedunes · 04/12/2021 01:39

@Squizzley

Hmm, why would anyone come on these threads and dictate how others should feel. A moral superiority seeping through, a sniffy dig at others feeling over invested. It’s all a bit judgy and a bit I don’t know..class based moralising?
I agree.

How we express ourselves is due to many different factors, why would someone critisice someone for feeling empathy.

Why does it hurt some people for others to be upset.
It is not fake, it is a normal reaction to evil.

It is also very judgemental to say people should not being watching the videos of Arthur, some can, some can't, but his story should be told.

We need to know what that boy went through and remember.

Squizzley · 04/12/2021 01:00

Hmm, why would anyone come on these threads and dictate how others should feel.
A moral superiority seeping through, a sniffy dig at others feeling over invested.
It’s all a bit judgy and a bit I don’t know..class based moralising?

TurquoiseDress · 04/12/2021 00:11

@Almostmenopausal

Yes that case was absolutely awful- Alesha MacPhail

During the trial, hearing all the details- horrifying and I do sometimes wonder how her mum is doing...how do you cope & go on after something like that?

Innocenta · 04/12/2021 00:09

[quote CPL593H]@Innocenta it really isn't about devotion to a cause or about the pros and cons of inner child work. It may be working towards a better society if what is involved is picking up a phone to social services (I know, I know) or talking to the school, more than once if necessary, more than twice. Such referrals have a cumulative effect and if one person who has been upset by the terrible death of that poor little boy does so and it makes a difference (they may never know) it is worth oceans of tears. So is trying to include a marginalised child and many abused children or those suffering the after effects are excluded, at the time they need friendship and support the most.[/quote]
I don't want to derail the thread even further. I understand your point. I'm coming to this from a place of knowing many traumatised women who might indeed find those simple tasks to be things they couldn't do. I could do them, and I agree with you that everyone should - that in an ideal world, we all watch out for children (but then, in that ideal world, there would be no abuse).

I don't feel comfortable expanding further on why people couldn't do relatively 'easy' things or how it might affect them, because I think it's too off-topic and might only add to the triggering content further.

I hope everyone on the thread can get some rest tonight - whether we've agreed or not.

TurquoiseDress · 04/12/2021 00:08

YANBU

I've been reading about this during the months leading up to the trial

The more I learned about events the more upset I felt each time a new article came out

On Thursday with the convictions I watched the news and all the reports were upsetting, it's just such a horrific case

I've avoided watching the video, either on TV and news websites

It's important that Arthur's awful story is told and the world what a pair of murdering scum bags they are

I truly hope they rot in jail for the rest of their lives

RIP little Arthur

Take care OP Thanks

CPL593H · 04/12/2021 00:05

@Innocenta it really isn't about devotion to a cause or about the pros and cons of inner child work. It may be working towards a better society if what is involved is picking up a phone to social services (I know, I know) or talking to the school, more than once if necessary, more than twice. Such referrals have a cumulative effect and if one person who has been upset by the terrible death of that poor little boy does so and it makes a difference (they may never know) it is worth oceans of tears. So is trying to include a marginalised child and many abused children or those suffering the after effects are excluded, at the time they need friendship and support the most.

Almostmenopausal · 04/12/2021 00:03

I was extremely distraught over that little 6yr old girl in Scotland that was taken from her bed, raped & murdered. I stupidly read about it on the Daily Mail (it was open on my mums iPad - I don't read that rag) and they had, as per usual, not held back on the graphic, gory details with no prior warning. It absolutely destroyed me. I regularly wonder how her poor mummy is. There are 3 tracks on an album I was listening to around that time that I simply cannot listen to now as it seems to bring it back.

OP you're not odd or strange, you're just an empath with compassion and, well, normal! Unlike those monsters - which seems like a staggeringly understated word to use for them

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 04/12/2021 00:01

It’s really upset me too. I can’t bear the idea of him thinking that nobody loved him when so many people would have fallen over themselves to offer him a loving home given half the chance. I have a little boy the same age and I’ve hugged him lots today but I’ve cried lots for Arthur and have been feeling very sad about what happened to him. I can’t understand how some people are capable of being so cruel to innocent little children. I think it’s sadistic.

NotRightNowPlease · 03/12/2021 23:56

Oh OP, it is completely horrific beyond words. I think this is completely natural for some people. I was the same with Baby P (Peter Connelly), I think having a child of a similar age at the time, it really profoundly affected me. Bless his heart. It is absolutely heartbreaking but yes, I think your reaction is normal.

I haven’t read past the first 6 pages but goodness, does this have to turn into a bun fight? We all cope with things in different ways. Some will watch the CCTV and listen to the recordings. People will feel things in different ways. A little boy has died, maybe we should be channeling our energy into that and how we can change things for other children rather than picking apart peoples reactions.

RIP Arthur.

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 03/12/2021 23:54

I remember that case @ODFOgrinch
It was very sad. The parents were very young & mistakenly thought they were doing the right thing by making sure little Leroy had plenty of food to grow big & strong, unfortunately it was the wrong food. And them trying to be good parents caused the the little one to die.
It was purely a terrible but fatal mistake as little Leroy was loved by his parents.
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/1999/jul/28/familyandrelationships.features101

kathmacc · 03/12/2021 23:49

This made feel so incredibly sad 🙏🏻

Innocenta · 03/12/2021 23:44

@CPL593H I didn't say anything about your childhood. I have deliberately been cautious in my wording as it would obviously be a mistake to assume that people who are critical of inner child work are all without trauma. I do not think this.

Great suffering and unresolved trauma often impedes people's ability to work to better society. It's not something that can always be overcome by willpower or devotion to a cause - simply not how it works.

BeMoreGoldfish · 03/12/2021 23:40

And not sad

BeMoreGoldfish · 03/12/2021 23:40

@womanity you are spot on. I’ve taught children like yours sad they are poorly tolerated at school. I’m so sorry the world jis not a kinder place Flowers

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 03/12/2021 23:35

I cannot comprehend how someone especially a woman could be so cruel, callous & downright evil towards a child.
I haven't & won't listen to the recordings because I don't want to hear something so harrowing that will never be unheard.
I can't bear to hear the Little Drummer Boy carol/song for the same reasons, may you never be forgotten Lesley Ann Downey.

I hope & I pray there will never ever be another Arthur Labinjo -Hughes.........
Beautiful little boy may you never be forgotten too x

RestingStitchFace · 03/12/2021 23:31

It hit me in the solar plexus too. I just wish I could have held that poor little boy tight and promised him it would be OK.

It was haunting my dreams and I needed to do something to rest easier. Have made a donation to Barnardos because I needed to feel I was taking some form of positive action. It's a tiny thing but I couldn't think of anything else I could do in the short term.

ODFOgrinch · 03/12/2021 23:28

I can honestly say that I haven't read any details or seen the films.

I can say that when my eldest two DC were still tiny babies there was a horrific case in the press of a couple who poisoned (killed) their baby with salt because mash with gravy granules and ready break were cheaper than baby food. All these years later I remember every detail.

I'd like to say that anything I could do would make deliberately ignorant parents follow guidance. Just like I'm sure you wish that anything you could do might change the outcome for children whose carers are deliberately abusive.

All any of us can do is report concerns to any and all authorities we can. In poor Arthur's case the authorities were informed and aware but failed to act.

pumpkinpieintheski · 03/12/2021 23:26

I'm sat here with tears in my eyes.... I've only just read about the case and I can't stop crying. That poor poor little boy, it's beyond heartbreaking. I just want to jump into the screen and save him, feed him, cuddle him, love him. I can't bare it. I barely watched 2 seconds as the video came on with the news I was reading and had to turn it off.

I truly hope they get what they deserve in prison.

LifesABotch · 03/12/2021 23:25

@Simonjt

Yes and no, it is awful, however a significant amount of people seem to be making it about them by competing for the biggest show of grief, others seem to be determined to watch/listen to a child being harmed.
So true. Twitter is perhaps the worst place for this, full of people desperate to say how much they have wept etc Confused. Of course it's a horrific case, that poor wee boy 😢! And of course we are all upset when we hear or read about it, that is a normal, human reaction, but it should never have become a contest around "who is most upset/feels this most deeply." What good does that do?! It's creepy, self-absorbed and mawkish.
bellamountain · 03/12/2021 23:24

I have a 6 year old and this case has absolutely wrecked me. I've been crying on and off all day and the anxiety at night has been keeping me awake. What that beautiful little boy had to endure is horrific. He could have been safe with other family members who weren't allowed to have him.... he could have been put in another home with a loving family. Anyone but them.

NeedsCharging · 03/12/2021 23:22

The vast majority of people heartbroken over this will be back living their normal lives tomorrow without doing anything at all and will be similarly heartbroken the next time.

Won't most of us?
We all have lives that need to be gotten on with.
My sorrow and disgust at Arthur's neglect does not mean I must neglect my own responsibilities.

Will you be downing tools and staging a hunger strike until SS are better trained and better funded?
Of course you won't but for some reason you demand others should do more than you will...

Frlrlrubert · 03/12/2021 23:21

Feeling sick and being upset are perfectly normal responses to watching/listening to something like that. I haven't. I wouldn't click a video on a news site on a story like that, and I have literally turned the radio over at the 'distressing content' warning today as I had DD in the car. So you can avoid it, which is probably best if you know you are sensitive to such things.

My first safeguarding course went into detail about the DP case, DD was 11 months at the time, I'm usually hard as nails but I'll admit I found that upsetting.

I don't see how making yourself feel ill helps anyone. With all the stories over the last few years I think we all know that horrific child abuse happens, I'm not saying turn a blind eye, but you can't do anything for a child who has been murdered, listening to them be abused won't help anyone. Do something to prevent a child being abused instead, even if it's donating 50p to child line or something.

tallduckandhandsome · 03/12/2021 23:17

@MissTrip82

I find it ludicrous to equate telling everyone you’re heartbroken, feel sick or have been sobbing for days with empathy. Putting your feelings at the centre of someone else’s tragedy isn’t empathy.

The truly empathic amongst us will have taken action as a result of this. Written to an MP demanding better resources for social services, donated to a charity fighting child abuse, started the process of applying to be a foster carer etc.

The vast majority of people heartbroken over this will be back living their normal lives tomorrow without doing anything at all and will be similarly heartbroken the next time.

Indeed the next time will be happening right now, somewhere.

💯 agree
Swipe left for the next trending thread