Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 12:01

It obviously suits you to pick apart people's comments instead of just taking what is written. I have written exactly how i feel no airs or graces. There seems to be a small portion of posters who cannot wait to try and take the moral high ground.

On this subject matter i don't think there is one?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 04/12/2021 12:01

Why do those who haven't seen or heard feel the need to take a superior stance? Like they are a morally better human being.

I don't know. Why do those who have watched the recordings feel the same way?

Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 11:59

Not really. I posted later in the afternoon after hearing late yesterday afternoon.

My DH is a completely different kettle of fish and we have had a disagreement regarding this issue we have had different viewpoints . He comes from a normal family not blighted by any issues

OP posts:
Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 11:57

@tallduckandhandsome

If some people choose to ignore what goes on outside their front door or because they can sleep easier that's great.

Can you give examples of anyone who has said or implied this?

There are plenty of examples of comments ' I don't need to read' I don't need to see' why don't you need? Just as you are stating people don't need to see.

Just as those are validating their reasons it might appear to some it's easier to ignore and carry on.

As previously posted i didn't actually seek out the videos they were heard on the radio when i was another room and the news flashed up.

It's equally not a competition about who and who hasn't seen or heard.

Why do those who haven't seen or heard feel the need to take a superior stance? Like they are a morally better human being.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 04/12/2021 11:56

@tallduckandhandsome

If some people choose to ignore what goes on outside their front door or because they can sleep easier that's great.

Can you give examples of anyone who has said or implied this?

From the same post: "I didn't watch anymore or listen since yesterday lunchtime. My DH cannot and won't listen or read as he can't cope my two young children are not appropriate to discuss with."

I don't blame OP or anyone else for not subjecting themselves to more than they need to know how harrowing this case is. But there's something contradictory in the latest post.

tallduckandhandsome · 04/12/2021 11:51

If some people choose to ignore what goes on outside their front door or because they can sleep easier that's great.

Can you give examples of anyone who has said or implied this?

Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 11:45

I haven't posted as i thought i had requested this be deleted however I am a new poster although have been a member for many years.

I didn't watch anymore or listen since yesterday lunchtime. My DH cannot and won't listen or read as he can't cope my two young children are not appropriate to discuss with.

I grew up in Foster care from age 9. Having been in social services radar from birth. I was subject to sexual abuse, violence neglect and witnessed domestic violence from birth parents. My DM left me when i was 5 and haven't seen her since, she died earlier this year. My DF died when i was 12.

I consider myself extremely hard and so do those around me. This broke me i haven't slept maybe as my DS is 5.

To the sanctimonious posters who suggested donating money. I do that already and i volunteer until lockdown as volunteer for children in care. Neither of these appear to stop child abuse.

The system is also broken through bureaucracy not just funfing. To weighed down in paperwork and administration, passing the responsibility ftom one service to another - WHICH wastes crucial time.

I have never voted conservative in my life.

I didn't post for competition but in the hope of finding like minded people. If some people choose to ignore what goes on outside their front door or because they can sleep easier that's great. There are plenty of children who are dysfunctional in both my children's classes it doesn't convert into abusive backgrounds - another ignorant comment

No he is not my son and his mother must feel wretched however she is also a catalyst for this boy.

Some of the comments have been pure vile and show exactly what society is dealing with. Even a thread like this descends into a bin fest of attacks.

The media have always shown distressing images, articles. If this was stopped for all i think it sends a dangerous precedent.

I hope that Arthur will now find some peace as he certainly didn't have any in life.

OP posts:
bandek · 04/12/2021 11:12

@Drumshambo

These threads are in really poor taste! The rehashing of what this poor child went through is not entertainment, or a platform for posters to virtue signall about how upset they are. The competitive grief is really awful.. There will be many more cases like this sadly. While there are evil people about., and social services continue to escape any consequences for these appalling failings.

The fact you can't understand why others are upset doesn't mean it's competitive grief.

Drumshambo · 04/12/2021 11:02

These threads are in really poor taste! The rehashing of what this poor child went through is not entertainment, or a platform for posters to virtue signall about how upset they are. The competitive grief is really awful..
There will be many more cases like this sadly. While there are evil people about., and social services continue to escape any consequences for these appalling failings.

TuesdayRuby · 04/12/2021 10:52

I agree with you @Squizzley. There is a horrible trend on Mumsnet that whenever people come on here and express that they’re feeling sad, or upset about something in the news, a “high-and-mighty” clique appears to tell these people that they’re “grief groupies” or having some sort of compassion competition. I remember similar comments on a thread about Azaylia Cain, where it originated as a thread for people who felt affected by her plight and then turned into some sort of battle about what we could and couldn’t say.
It’s such a shame people can’t just accept that some people feel more outwardly emotional than others. I’ve cried for Arthur these past few weeks. I’m not in competition with anyone. That’s how I’m feeling. It’s a shame people feel like they can’t talk about that on here in a safe space without being criticised.

zlister · 04/12/2021 09:41

@TonkinLenkicks

A social work page put a picture on their Instagram that’s said ‘social workers don’t kill children, parents kill children. Remember that’

I was appalled. Too fucking soon. And I say that as a social worker

Agreed. It's like people who went on about blue lives matter- after people right called out disgraceful police conduct.

Now it's not all social workers- in a case where we know there were shortcomings, negligence even.

Not the time to be getting defensive and those who had any humanity would actually want to fix the problem🤷🏽‍♀️

TeloMere · 04/12/2021 09:05

Sorry its on the BBC news page and it's been played on the radio I haven't sought out anything

It's still easy to avoid hearing the upsetting details and seeing the video. I managed to look at the BBC News page and listen to radio news without listening/watching the video.

missfliss · 04/12/2021 08:46

Can't be bothered to be honest to argue with people who are dismissive of others experiences- you are entitled to your opinions. I disagree that this is a thread on competitive grieving.

To the many people who are just really feeling upset - massive empathy and some kindness in a world that has shown real ugliness in this case.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 04/12/2021 08:39

@TheCatWearsPrada

Threads like this are all the same it's competitive grieving and it's sick.
Agreed
queenofarles · 04/12/2021 08:32

I can’t stop replaying those words in my mind , young children are often not very vocal in expressing their emotions ,for him to feel how unloved he is, is beyond heartbreaking.

royco · 04/12/2021 08:23

@Squizzley

Hmm, why would anyone come on these threads and dictate how others should feel. A moral superiority seeping through, a sniffy dig at others feeling over invested. It’s all a bit judgy and a bit I don’t know..class based moralising?
And who's class are you assuming? Interested to know
royco · 04/12/2021 08:18

@womanity

I’m raising two DC who were removed from their birth family.

I wonder how many of the ‘sobbing for days’ posters are the ones who most harshly judge my DC because they’re weird/late/aggressive/loud/unpredictable as a result of their experiences and who spent years not inviting my DC to their DCs’ birthday parties and who ask for my DCs not to sit next to their DC in school and who give me the side eye in the playground.

The world is not kind to DC who have survived these early experiences.

Hear hear
porridgecake · 04/12/2021 08:06

Yes, the video came on the news with barely any warning. I have pretty bad mobility issues and couldn't get out of my chair and grab the remote before hearing and seeing it. I wonder if the family asked the BBC to show it? Very, very distressing.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 04/12/2021 07:52

I only know the minimal information about this case as there is no way I could cope with all of the details.
I suggest OP, you turn the news off and focus on something positive. Maybe make a donation to a children’s charity, take some unwanted things to a charity shop, volunteer?

Stories such as this hit the news every so often and each one show us that some innocent child has suffered at the hands of those supposed to love and care for them. This is shocking and upsetting to most people but we can’t do anything for that child now. What we can do is be vigilant to these events possibly happening near us and try to put a bit of goodness back where we can.

This is such an awful story and I think many of us have shed tears for this little boy.

AlwaysLatte · 04/12/2021 07:32

So many people saying op went looking for this video. It really SHOULD have been an article that had a warning so you could choose whether to open it but the papers and tv are just flashing it up with no warning, even the video (which I think should never have been shown to the public). So op was just watching the news, like the rest of us.
I do think it's human nature to feel things as awful as this and to react - especially as a parent. As a society it's in our DNA to look out for other people's children. That's why you would react the same way if someone else's child went to run in front of a car as you would your own.

TonkinLenkicks · 04/12/2021 07:04

A social work page put a picture on their Instagram that’s said ‘social workers don’t kill children, parents kill children. Remember that’

I was appalled. Too fucking soon. And I say that as a social worker

MiddayMass · 04/12/2021 07:01

I was deeply affected by the Becky Watts case, for a month I honestly wasn’t myself. She looked so much like my daughter.

It wasn’t a feeling I could help, and it certainly wasn’t ‘competitive sadness’.

bluebellYellow · 04/12/2021 06:54

No one should be made to feel like they shouldn't be sad over this. It's horrendously upsetting.

We are not competing as someone suggested.

Since the original thread on here got deleted, I have spoken to no one about this case. I have cried only whilst on my own. No one truly knows how this has affected me.

This should be a place where people can come and share their feelings anonymously. Many of us do not have people in real life who we can talk to.

missfliss · 04/12/2021 06:34

Agree with the posts below ( I've posted twice already on this thread).

My grief and sadness and depression doesn't help Arthur and it is the most useless feeling.

My mind can't stop going over how much he will have suffered and been so lonely.

I've been awake in the night again with my brain just fixating now.

It doesn't help anyone I know and this is not competitive- I'm not relishing any part of it - I've really never been so affected by a case.

This thread helps me feel less alone with it - not revelling in some competitive grief as posters suggest. More reassurance that other people are also so affected by Arthur.

I work at home all day alone and have had to push back the tears and get in with it. My little boy obviously cannot hear or talk about it beyond the basics that another little boy has died.

My husband is lovely but spends all his day working with vulnerable kids in a special school and can listen but is wrung out a bit by that.

So for me this is one place where I know that others are sharing.

It's not like the other threads which are focused on the perpetrators and revenge/ it is mostly full of people who are just saddened and not sure what to do with their own very strong emotions on the topic.

Don't get the moral superiority of those on here suggesting grief tourism etc. really bizarre.

MiddayMass · 04/12/2021 05:16

It’s beyond me that people are telling those who have been upset at the news about Arthur that they shouldn’t cry or be sad over what happened to him.

His family didn’t give a shit about him and actively harmed and killed him. He’s an innocent child and deserves to be cared about and grieved, and if that has to come from the general public rather than the people it should have come from then let it be. Let people care about him and show emotion for him, please. Care was something he was so sorely deprived of.

You aren’t big or clever guilt tripping people for being upset.