Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
cutietooties · 04/12/2021 21:15

@Bluntness100 I just done it and shared it, hopefully it makes a difference

cutietooties · 04/12/2021 20:55

Genuine question.. what can I do to help, is it donating to the nspcc, did they have any input in this case or anything similar who can I donate my time or money to in order to help vulnerable children

Fizgig · 04/12/2021 20:45

This isn’t about me or my feelings, it is about the horror Arthur went through. I don’t need any support, Arthur did. It’s that, as a social worker, I struggle with this. I just wish someone had saved him. I know how pressured social workers are and we can all discuss lessons learned. If individuals are set on a path to manipulate, deceive and harm it is sometimes impossible to protect. It is all just heart breaking, thank you for responding , I appreciate you offering supportive advice.

Innocenta · 04/12/2021 20:32

@Yearn , you said Victims deserve to be remembered at their best, not by their abuse

What about surviving family members who disagree with you? The most famous being, perhaps, Mamie Till:

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mamie_Till

(Trigger warning: murder of a child, hate crime)

Innocenta · 04/12/2021 20:29

@Fizgig

I am a social worker and run a parent assessment centre. I support a lot of parents who genuinely wish to care for their child but have experienced poor childhood experiences, mental health, trauma etc. None of the families I work with have ever wanted to intentionally hurt their child. I feel traumatised by Arthur’s horrific experience. It literally hurts my heart and I can’t stop thinking about him. I’m devastated that he was let down by services who should have supported him. Ultimately his carers murdered him. I think it is vital to share Arthur’s experience however I do wonder if showing the CCTV is ok? It really is traumatic and is impacting my mental health daily. Bless his little heart. Such a beautiful boy, it’s just unbearable to think how he must of felt .
I'm really sorry to hear that you're having such a hard time with this case. Do you currently have someone who gives you clinical supervision? I know it is not about your work, but given how much it's affecting you, I think it could be worth raising - you may also be suffering additional trauma from your experiences through work, perhaps having built up over time. It can be so easy to put oneself down and just add to the pressure to 'cope'. But it's okay to tell someone and ask for help.
Stiffcondomhat · 04/12/2021 18:50

I remember years ago that snuff movies were an urban myth. Now there's one in the public domain that anyone can watch. In an epidemic of anxiety that's not going to do any good at all.

Fizgig · 04/12/2021 18:39

I am a social worker and run a parent assessment centre. I support a lot of parents who genuinely wish to care for their child but have experienced poor childhood experiences, mental health, trauma etc. None of the families I work with have ever wanted to intentionally hurt their child. I feel traumatised by Arthur’s horrific experience. It literally hurts my heart and I can’t stop thinking about him. I’m devastated that he was let down by services who should have supported him. Ultimately his carers murdered him. I think it is vital to share Arthur’s experience however I do wonder if showing the CCTV is ok? It really is traumatic and is impacting my mental health daily. Bless his little heart. Such a beautiful boy, it’s just unbearable to think how he must of felt .

Yearn · 04/12/2021 18:10

I was talking about the service in general with that comment, not this particular case. Obviously there were severe and horrific failings at the most basic level here but once again I believe that proper funding leads to better training, better support, better communication, better management etc. which means those failings become fewer and and less serious.

tiktokniknok · 04/12/2021 18:08

I hope the jury have been offered support and counselling. Just being excused from
future service won't help them
with the trauma ....

Bluntness100 · 04/12/2021 18:03

@Yearn

Overworked, underfunded people, who often don't have the support they need to actually do their jobs properly. Poor management to the highest level. Afraid to enter homes with aggressive and angry parents, no help dealing with the trauma they themselves will experience when dealing with horrific cases so they get burned out/compassion fatigue, etc. No support or poor communication from other agencies. The list goes on but it all boils down to money in the end. If there was money and it was spent appropriately, services would be properly staffed, communication could be properly monitored and maintained and so on leading to few vulnerable people being let down.
No it doesn’t come down to money. Any human being seeing Arthur hours before he died should have known something was wrong. No matter how overworked or under paid, it’s impossible to understand how those two women claiming to be social workers, didn’t see it.

Christ we are lay people and we can see from the videos well before this , the terrible physical condition of that little boy.

That’s not about money, walking away was a level of cruelty seldom seen.

Yearn · 04/12/2021 18:03

@Bluntness100

Can you please explain why you believe this? It seems like a monstrous view in my opinion

To turn away from a child suffering for me, is what is monstrous.to not want to look, becayse your feelings come first. A dead child doesn’t want privacy, their abuse should not be hushed up and hidden, to pander to others sensitivities. So they can carry on without being a little too upset about it. Telling people to remove it, so people don’t have to see it. That’s what’s monstrous.

That's such bullshit in my opinion. Viewing it will not force people to care. It turns it in to entertainment for the sickos out there, it becomes a way for grief vampires and the facebook wailers to make it all about them (even more than they do now), sharing even more harrowing screenshots of a child's torture to prove how much they "care" without actually doing anything at all.

Putting every single detail out there doesn't change a thing. It runs the risk of desensitising people in my opinion.

Victims deserve to be remembered at their best, not by their abuse.

Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 18:00

@Yearn

Overworked, underfunded people, who often don't have the support they need to actually do their jobs properly. Poor management to the highest level. Afraid to enter homes with aggressive and angry parents, no help dealing with the trauma they themselves will experience when dealing with horrific cases so they get burned out/compassion fatigue, etc. No support or poor communication from other agencies. The list goes on but it all boils down to money in the end. If there was money and it was spent appropriately, services would be properly staffed, communication could be properly monitored and maintained and so on leading to few vulnerable people being let down.
These child murders and neglect were happening under labour governments. It's not just a case if throwing more bodies into the mix. The whole system needs overhauling. Too much administration like every public sector job - I work in one said emergency service. Too many chiefs and not enough Indians. The job on the ground has been forgotten about in a quest to have smart administration systems. They don't work.

Looking back through my care notes in the 80s. My social worker was stretched. Yes funding is an issue but in some cases and it appears on this case its pure incompetence. It will be interesting what comes out in the review.

OP posts:
Yearn · 04/12/2021 17:54

Overworked, underfunded people, who often don't have the support they need to actually do their jobs properly. Poor management to the highest level. Afraid to enter homes with aggressive and angry parents, no help dealing with the trauma they themselves will experience when dealing with horrific cases so they get burned out/compassion fatigue, etc. No support or poor communication from other agencies. The list goes on but it all boils down to money in the end. If there was money and it was spent appropriately, services would be properly staffed, communication could be properly monitored and maintained and so on leading to few vulnerable people being let down.

Bluntness100 · 04/12/2021 17:53

Can you please explain why you believe this? It seems like a monstrous view in my opinion

To turn away from a child suffering for me, is what is monstrous.to not want to look, becayse your feelings come first. A dead child doesn’t want privacy, their abuse should not be hushed up and hidden, to pander to others sensitivities. So they can carry on without being a little too upset about it. Telling people to remove it, so people don’t have to see it. That’s what’s monstrous.

Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 17:42

@sqirrelfriends

I agree with *@Yearn*, watching a child's pain doesn't help them. If my DS was in a tragic accident, would I want footage of that shared? No I wouldn't.

Arthur is already gone, what we can do for him is respect his privacy and vote in governments that aim to fund social care appropriately. It costs an absolute fortune to remove children, if social services had more money, they might have taken the reports about Arthur being abused more seriously.

It's not just a money issue. It's a collective mess of paperwork and administration and it's failing every year. Rightly so there has to be stringent measures but equally its missing these poor children. Arthur wasn't failed by money he was failed by people
OP posts:
sqirrelfriends · 04/12/2021 17:35

I agree with @Yearn, watching a child's pain doesn't help them. If my DS was in a tragic accident, would I want footage of that shared? No I wouldn't.

Arthur is already gone, what we can do for him is respect his privacy and vote in governments that aim to fund social care appropriately. It costs an absolute fortune to remove children, if social services had more money, they might have taken the reports about Arthur being abused more seriously.

Yearn · 04/12/2021 17:26

@Bluntness100

I personally believe we owe it to children to watch the videos and see the images, we should not turn our heads away from it. Unless there is something very triggering due to mental illness or past experiences then we owe it to the children to not turn away and refuse to watch.
Can you please explain why you believe this? It seems like a monstrous view in my opinion.

I don't believe the details of an innocent child's suffering should be for the general public's consumption. I don't see how it will help anybody, least of all the victims. There is a reason the jury in this case have been excused from serving again in the future.

Onthedowns · 04/12/2021 17:25

No one is engaging in anything competitive just airing and sharing their upset and disgust.

Just like I have heard many do in real life is that sick? People discussing in a coffee shop?

People leaving flowers as a gesture is that sick? I would say your over invested in what people are thinking and feeling. There is no right or wrong

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 04/12/2021 17:20

@ronniz

I hope everybody who has seen the footage will remember it and campaign when Huges and Tustin come up for parole.

Whilst I agree with harsh sentences how does the above stop it happening to other children?

She appears quite manipulative and could most likely inviegle her way into another family...esp as she ages and can seem a sweet older lady...

He may well be out in 14 years... Will be only in his mid 40s.
He will have many potential years of fathering more children or being step father.

These thoughts make my blood run cold.

ronniz · 04/12/2021 14:12

@Porcupineintherough and I hope those measures are taken. That's my point.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 04/12/2021 13:59

@PleasantBirthday

I think I struggle with the mawkishness of Facebook posts and we love yous and I would have taken him in etc. You wouldn't have taken him in. He went through a hellish experience and would have been a difficult child with very difficult to meet needs as a result of his horrific experiences. Maltreated, abused, neglected, victim and witness to shocking violence, he would not have been the smiling grateful recipient of anyones munificence.

If you really feel affected and you must do something, hold down your dinner, dry your eyes and be kinder to the child you think is feral and a bad influence on yours. Report every legitimate concern you have. Ask questions. Actually consider the nuisance child that irritates you as possibly the child whose situation is deteriorating and do what you wish you had done for this child.

This is a really good post
Porcupineintherough · 04/12/2021 13:58

@ronniz absolutely nothing. Confused To do that other measures must be taken but I, for one, do not want Hughes back on the streets in 10 years.

Neoncoral · 04/12/2021 13:57

@Porcupineintherough

Arthur has no need of privacy any more and he needed it even less in spring 2020. He needed a bloody great spotlight shone at his life.

I hope everybody who has seen the footage will remember it and campaign when Huges and Tustin come up for parole.

So true.
shinynewapple21 · 04/12/2021 13:55

@discombob

Me too, I cried a bit earlier. It's a normal reaction to a sweet boy being treated so horribly. Bless him, it's the "nobody loved me" that gets me every time.

Yes hearing that was heart breaking .

I understand OP. In my work I come across cases of child neglect but this is something different . I really couldn't bring myself to read much of it , so upsetting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread