Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so upset about Arthur is it normal

741 replies

Onthedowns · 03/12/2021 16:37

I just cannot stop crying. I know it's another thread but listening to those recordings of that poor boy i have been physically sick and so upset. I have cuddled my children so hard. I came from an abusive background but nothing like him.

I feel completely irrational

Coupled with covid what has happened to society 😔

OP posts:
Stiffcondomhat · 05/12/2021 09:31

What's an 'empath'?

Emotionally incontinent.

Bagelsandbrie · 05/12/2021 09:30

I’m glad to read the comments here. People need to be talking about this and to be angry about this. As others have said the last thing child abuse needs is privacy.

Those who are negative and spouting off about competitive grief need to go and have a word with themselves. There is absolutely nothing wrong with people wanting to share their sadness and shock and horror over this case. Nothing.

pangolina · 05/12/2021 09:30

I actually think it should be mandatory to report suspicions of child abuse. I know it would be almost impossible to enforce and could be used maliciously, but I think it needs to be harder for people to turn a blind eye

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 05/12/2021 09:28

@LampLighter414

As an empath I have really struggled since first hearing about this case. It's just so awful.
What's an 'empath'?

Everyone is upset by this case.

LampLighter414 · 05/12/2021 09:27

As an empath I have really struggled since first hearing about this case. It's just so awful.

Bagelsandbrie · 05/12/2021 09:26

@Darbs76

Re the hairdresser (not sure if this has been said already not read all the comments) her dad came into a FB group and said she didn’t get involved as she’s been in court before and was treated badly. I’m sorry but how can anyone see a child in the state he was in (and we see that from the video, and from her and her husbands comments in the trial) and do nothing. If they had phoned the police Arthur would be alive. Just no excuse
I agree.

We make too many excuses for people. This is a child’s life we’re talking about! There should be no excuses.

Darbs76 · 05/12/2021 09:25

I am also terrified they will release the CCTV they have of Star Hobson, as the description of it is horrific

HumpreyDowny · 05/12/2021 09:23

@missfliss hear hear... Absolutely disgraceful that people are belittling others strong emotions. I really needed a place to read that there are other people who have been just as deeply affected and that there's hope in our society.

Darbs76 · 05/12/2021 09:21

Re the hairdresser (not sure if this has been said already not read all the comments) her dad came into a FB group and said she didn’t get involved as she’s been in court before and was treated badly. I’m sorry but how can anyone see a child in the state he was in (and we see that from the video, and from her and her husbands comments in the trial) and do nothing. If they had phoned the police Arthur would be alive. Just no excuse

Darbs76 · 05/12/2021 09:19

I have followed the trial every day - well every hour , and Arthur has been on my mind for weeks. Also been following poor Star Hobson’s trial, jury will retire tomorrow or Tuesday. Both those kids are on my mind multiple times a day. My heart goes out to all those children suffering abuse, life is not fair

Onthedowns · 05/12/2021 09:10

@ElfontheShelfisLookingatYou

I was already aghast that the hair dessser did nt do anything but seeing the living roll footage and see just how weak he must have been... Wow. They really turned a blind eye to that? Really? I actually think they should be tried for some sort of complicity. His legs were obviously so incredibly weak! His "throwing himself" was obviously falling with sheer exhaustion. No one should be allowed to stay silent when they see a child in that state.
I was thinking exactly the same thing another complicit party
OP posts:
ElfontheShelfisLookingatYou · 05/12/2021 08:51

Well I think we need urgent law change that you can't expect to witness such abuse and get away with it.

ElfontheShelfisLookingatYou · 05/12/2021 08:49

I was already aghast that the hair dessser did nt do anything but seeing the living roll footage and see just how weak he must have been... Wow. They really turned a blind eye to that? Really?
I actually think they should be tried for some sort of complicity. His legs were obviously so incredibly weak! His "throwing himself" was obviously falling with sheer exhaustion. No one should be allowed to stay silent when they see a child in that state.

missfliss · 05/12/2021 06:46

Some excellent points here.

This thread is not aimed at sharing details or fantasizing about ways to punish the perps unlike the many others.

People that accuse others of taking voyeuristic pleasure in being upset about this have something very very wrong with them. We have been called disgusting by them for caring about it and wanting to talk about it - well I'm actually disgusted by YOUR cowardice and your warped minds in trying to suppress those conversations and opportunities to learn about abuse.

Someone said it - the last thing needed now is privacy. Privacy us what allowed this case to fester. Arthur is dead - how is privacy going to help him now exactly. Does privacy matter more than excluding more possibilities for us to face up to what happens behind closed doors? That's a weird point of view.
Your attitudes of closing off conversations and dismissing the varied emotions it surfaces are a big part of the problem we have with this society and maybe Arthur's truth should be told.

Maybe someone else might be helped by adults not putting our own feelings / sensibilities first and actually facing up to the horribly reality of what happened. Maybe it will effect some change somewhere and maybe more cases will be spotted before a preventable murder.

Gem176 · 05/12/2021 01:16

It's not unreasonable at all, I have two DDs (one is 8, the other 14 weeks) and this has affected me profoundly.

Upset isn't quite a strong enough word for what I felt reading what happened to little Arthur. I've cried so many times since yesterday and not just when reading news articles but at random times. Making dinner, doing homework, tucking in at bedtime. Things that are such simple daily things for me to do and that in my sheltered little world believed were things all parents did for their children. I get very emotional realising no one did these things for Arthur, but more than that, the people that were meant to do these things instead actively deprived him of the absolute basics and inflicted unimaginable cruelty upon him.

I've been scared by the vitriolic hatred I feel towards Tustin and Hughes. I generally think of myself as very liberal and do not believe in violence but would genuinely be unable to contain myself if I found myself in the company of either.

I'm also incredibly angry at those who had the opportunity to save this little boy but didn't. From the social workers to the police to the hairdresser and her partner to the extended family. I cannot comprehend how and why they didn't do something. I know the grandmother and uncle reported them to SS but when nothing came of it why didn't they take more drastic action? When you believe a child's life is in danger surely the threat of arrest pales in comparison to what could happen if you don't act.

I really hope Arthur's legacy is that we as a collective do more to ensure children's safety. That we should shout louder when we believe a child is being abused or neglected. We don't just accept a brief pre arranged visit from a social worker to be sufficient proof that all is well. That we are willing to be a nuisance until something is done because there is no point crying in court when you are a witness at a murder trial. By then it's far too late.

Wooky073 · 05/12/2021 00:11

I am in 2 minds. I think that the video was released as Arthur was expressing his emotions and deserves to have his voice heard and not to be silenced any more. I cannot think of a murdered child ever when we got to understand their suffering from their perspective as by the time the horrific abuse is known about its too late. So I think this is why they released the videos. To allow arthurs voice to be heard. However, it was so distressing - I saw it on the news so was difficult to avoid. I wasnt prepared for what I saw and heard even despite the 'distressing content' warning. I kind of agree that it doesnt seem right to show it. However given that the child went in that poor physical state to the step mums friends for her hair to be done and 2 other adults saw him and how he was being treated (the day before he died) and yet did not act .... then I kind of feel that everyone should see the video and know the story of what happened to poor Arthur to raise awareness of what an abused child looks like and what can happen if you do nothing. If seeing the video can save another child by raising awareness then is it not worth the distress of watching it. I actually think there should be public service adverts and posters in every pulic place about what abuse looks like and how to report it or what to do for both adults and children. We cannot rely on the public services.

Lottie2shoes · 05/12/2021 00:07

Not read the full thread but wow some harsh comments on here! Personally I have not seen any competitive grief on the pages I did read. No " I feel worse than you" stuff.
To the OP, everyone deals with grief in different ways. It's ok to feel " physically sick" . Some people do that.
As for the posters who said why watch the vid. Some people watch the video and understand the story/ pain a bit better. I personally watched it after hearing about it, it did not change much how I felt as I was already upset, but it made me feel even more empathy actually hearing the pain and upset in his voice.
I wish to God they are never ever released from prison.
How anyone, let alone his own parent can do that to a young kid.
Unfortunately it's very common these days. Still the pain is felt each and every time I come across this type of case.

Italyanyday · 04/12/2021 23:26

I have learnt a hard lesson that by reading the details of horrendous cases like this, it will haunt me for the rest of my life. Probably OTT but that's the truth. I'm still haunted to this day by the Jamie Bulger case - particularly at the moment as I have a 2 year old. The idea of actually listening to these recordings makes me shudder. No way I'd do it, particularly as I have a 5 year old.

DrSbaitso · 04/12/2021 22:52

Does the criminal justice system work that way?

Drumshambo · 04/12/2021 22:10

@PleasantBirthday

I don't think sentencing and parole are decided by petition yet.
Thankfully not!
PleasantBirthday · 04/12/2021 21:52

I don't think sentencing and parole are decided by petition yet.

Rabs6 · 04/12/2021 21:39

I think anyone not effected by this situation is more of a worry. I have children similar ages to him so have avoided it as much as I can, but I still can't stop thinking about him.
If hearing those recordings makes people angered and appalled, then thats' a good thing.
Maybe we should channel our anger at the government who cut funding and reduce the effectiveness of social services and police?

Catatemyhomework · 04/12/2021 21:26

This case is so upsetting. I haven't listened to the recordings. I just couldn't. I can't even read it in the papers. It's heart breaking. I can't stop thinking about it, about him. That poor little defenseless boy. I hope they get killed in prison. Vile dispicable thugs. I too have Covid and this has depressed and upset me so much 😢😢

Aphrodite31 · 04/12/2021 21:22

OP it is horrific and graphic and we all just want to run in there and save him 😞

Bluntness100 · 04/12/2021 21:19

I just notified it’s not done on the gov website, I think it needs to be to be debated in Parliament, I’m not sure.