Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lancaster or brighton?

135 replies

BrightonOrLancaster · 03/12/2021 16:06

For a woman in her 30s moving alone with her cat!
Brighton: very good friends, warmer sea, more fun, livelier, but all family in north and expensive, closer to London and handy for getting away
Lancaster: very close family, much cheaper, less bullshitty, but no friends to start with, more isolated

No need to talk to me about schools etc as irrelevant to me! I work freelance in something creative. I'm really torn!

Vote:
YABU: Brighton
YANBU: Lancaster

OP posts:
Lunificent · 03/12/2021 17:49

Brighton on balance.
If you’re going Lancaster way, how about somewhere near to the the Forest of Bowland/Ribble Valley e.g. Clitheroe.

samesign · 03/12/2021 17:38

Having lived in Brighton previously, I wouldn't want to again, very expensive to live, it's mostly a dirty dump tbh, druggy beggars shout and Harass you dare you say no to giving them money. Summer time , the streets are crammed full of students, very busy, driving is nightmare, high rates of crime. Depending on your age , if you're young the nightlife is great and I do miss the palace pier.

Don't know about Lancaster but I'd rather move there by the sound of it.

MerryMarigold · 03/12/2021 17:37

I voted Lancaster because Brighton just irritates me a bit (a lot) even though I'm a Southerner. I think putting some money into the North is a good thing even if it's only one person! It makes a difference. And I think being close to family could be amazing and I'm sure you could make be friends or reconnect with old ones. If you're moving back from abroad, now is the time for a new start!

If it doesn't work out, you will have more reason to swallow the costs of Brighton. But if you don't try it, you could just be opting for an expensive option which is equal to, or even worse than, the cheaper option!

Joban · 03/12/2021 17:31

I kind of agree with PP about Liverpool, I’d be inclined to live there or Manchester. Then you have the creative scene and accessibility, with cheaper property prices and mega achievable to drive to Lancaster every weekend if you so wished.
It depends on what lifestyle you’re looking for I think, and I would say it’s way easier to make friends as an adult in more of an urban location.

Justleaveitblankthen · 03/12/2021 17:28

As a proud Lancastrian ( a person from Lancashire, not necessarily Lancaster 🤓 )
I would say 'oop north every time.
You're on the edge of the forest of Bowland/ Lake District/Pendle and East Lancashire/penines. You get much more for your money and there is so much more space..

Mind you, I haven't actually ever been to Brighton 🤔

changedforschoolpost · 03/12/2021 17:27

I live in Lancaster, moved here from Bath several years ago. I love it but it is very different to Brighton ( although in my mind, the beach with amazing views over the bay at nearby Morecambe is far more pleasant than the nasty rocks at Brighton) Lancaster is a lovely place with brilliant transport links- Edinburgh and Glasgow under two hours, no changes and stunning scenery but you have the Lake District far closer and the joys of Arnside and Ulverston close by and Manchester under an hour away by train. Beautiful countryside nearby, Williamson Park in Lancaster is my favourite park ever, wonderful for kids to go and look at butterflies and meerkats. Some lovely cafes, pubs and restaurants to be found- I am veggie and spoilt for choice but it is not as 'fancy' as Brighton and not really comparing like against like. I am happy here in my house which is so much cheaper though :-)

DeepaBeesKit · 03/12/2021 17:26

If you are a Brighton sort of person you will probably love brighton. The fact that you are considering it and have good friends there mean you probably will.

I personally never quite get the appeal of brighton.

housemaus · 03/12/2021 17:25

I love Lancaster so much - I went to uni there, and grew up not too far away. There's a growing scene of creatives, some great places to work in the day and good coworking rental spaces available - so meeting people I think wouldn't be too hard (I'm only down the road and a creative too, give me a DM if you move haha!). Some gorgeous food and drink options, it's BEAUTIFUL (you'll never get bored of walking round the castle, I lived looking onto it for a year and was always excited by the view), excellent views across the Lakes and the bay from Williamson Park. It's friendly, it's tiny so mega walkable, house prices and rent are reasonable, some good green space, you're near the sea, you're near the Lakes and not too far from e.g. Manchester on the train for a day out. In fact, well connected by trains either way because it's on the west coast line, so direct train to London is about 2.5h so Brighton wouldn't be too inaccessible for visits at all. Great walks along the canal (and some excellent pubs on the way), and it's getting more 'cool' every year. I'd go back in a heartbeat :)

For the sake of fairness though, the cons: it's fucking freezing about half the year haha, traffic can be awful at rush hours because of the one way system, it's very small so if you want buzzy and nightlifey rather than nice little pubs/bars/restaurants you'll be out of luck, obviously there are a lot of students (although nobody I know who lives there now says it's much of a problem unless you live in very specific areas), and... I cannot even imagine how cold the sea in Morecambe Bay would be!

I'm biased, I know. Brighton is great (although whenever I've been it looks really run down!? But I've not seen much of it), but Lancaster is so lovely - it always feels old and witchy and a bit mystical (not that I'm remotely into that kind of thing, but it feels a bit magic and atmospheric because of the old buildings and the witch trial connection). In autumn it was the prettiest place to live, too. But it's a very, very different place to Brighton.

HunterGatherer · 03/12/2021 17:21

Bugaroush Confused

I'd move to Brighton. Lancaster can be dreary.

JennieLee · 03/12/2021 17:17

Brighton's just London by the sea isn't it?

I'd go North for the space and the scenery.

Otherpeoplesteens · 03/12/2021 17:17

I've actually lived temporarily in both, and although my views may be distorted by the reasons I was in each place I'd chose Lancaster every time.

Admittedly it was twenty years ago, but Brighton for me was near-London prices without London incomes, some very pretentious people, a lot of bullshit as you point out, big enough to be impersonal but too small to have the big-city distractions. And when I was there the city centre had a monumental garbage problem because the refuse collection consisted of putting black bags out on the pavement, which the seagulls attacked. I rented in Preston Park and commuted into the centre, but I found living there a grind.

It's also fine if you want to fly from Gatwick, but less so for other south eastern airports.

Lancaster has the look and feel of a large provincial town and is under no illusions about what it is. Lots of independent shops, great food scene, and I found the people simply much more genuine and friendly. It's also under an hour from not one, but two national parks. If you're set on beach access that's in Morecambe, which is not the nicest place on Earth or even in the North West. The town centre has been prone to flooding, so have a think about this when choosing where to live or buy, and it also has a hideous one way system which backs up badly at rush hour.

Lancaster is counterintuitively warmer in winter because it's wet and doesn't get affected by continental weather systems like Brighton does. It's also much less windy. Summers are hit and miss, usually miss.

The only other thing I'd point out is that whilst it is feasible to live in Lancaster without a car, going out of town without one is not for the faint hearted and you will want to get out for a variety of reasons (not least because the Lune valley has some incredible pubs!). For non-drivers Brighton is probably the more sensible.

You'll know what's best for your career, but I was in Brighton to work in marketing and found it has a couple of good creative agencies and something of a 'scene' for it. Never had to look in Lancaster, but I'm not really aware of anything similar up there.

MsAnnFrope · 03/12/2021 17:15

@FateHasRedesignedMost has a point. I have lived in various bits of Northern England and Scotland and Lancaster wins the "rain most likely to soak through even full goretex gear" award.

It still has a special place in my heart but I can;t deny the traffic and weather are dire!

Iamnotminterested · 03/12/2021 17:15

WTF is bungaroush?

amsadandconfused · 03/12/2021 17:14

Brighton is more buzzy and probably easier to get to know people but very expensive!
Lancaster is lovely with the Lake District on your doorstep and cheaper. Found it very friendly when my son at Uni there but not sure how easy it would be to get to know people unless you are a student.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 03/12/2021 17:12

Lancaster is one of the coldest, wettest cities imaginable. Dreary all year round. I went to uni there. Still get the shivers going back to visit friends.

I’ve never experienced driving rain quite like it.

pigsDOfly · 03/12/2021 17:09

@HairyFeline

There’s not an awful lot to Lancaster to be honest. It’s getting very awful in the city centre with drunks/stoneheads lying and shouting everywhere. It’s not a particularly nice place and soooo noisy with sirens constantly heard due to it being so small. Awful one way system constantly closing due to accidents which clogs up the whole place. It’s got a decent student feel but with that there’s not much to actually do unless you like a million coffee shops. It’s a bit “meh” on a good day and “argggh” on a bad day. Brighton on the other hand is warmer!
Most of what you've written in the above post HairyFeline describes Brighton exactly.

Yes, it is warmer but it's also incredibly overpriced.

CruCru · 03/12/2021 17:04

I grew up in Brighton. It’s a lovely place but it is expensive. Lots of the houses are made of bungaroush.

HairyFeline · 03/12/2021 17:01

There’s not an awful lot to Lancaster to be honest. It’s getting very awful in the city centre with drunks/stoneheads lying and shouting everywhere. It’s not a particularly nice place and soooo noisy with sirens constantly heard due to it being so small. Awful one way system constantly closing due to accidents which clogs up the whole place. It’s got a decent student feel but with that there’s not much to actually do unless you like a million coffee shops. It’s a bit “meh” on a good day and “argggh” on a bad day.
Brighton on the other hand is warmer!

DDivaStar · 03/12/2021 16:56

If you're creative brighyon without a doubt. Do make sure you've done your sums tho as it is ridiculously expensive.

VickyEadieofThigh · 03/12/2021 16:37

Lancaster. More affordable, close to the coast if you want the sea, very close to the glorious Lakes, Yorkshire, best parts of Lancashire, near enough to Scotland to make trips there quite easy (Dumfries and Galloway is just fabulous).

Did my first degree at Lancaster and am still very fond of the city and all areas named above.

justaddcandlelight · 03/12/2021 16:36

Brighton

BrightonOrLancaster · 03/12/2021 16:36

@LadyWithLapdog
The vote is very evenly split! But so far the Lancaster crew have stayed quiet 🤔

OP posts:
MsAnnFrope · 03/12/2021 16:35

Oooh yes Liverpool is a good suggestion!
A good friend has moved from Lancaster tor Brighton recently. The only thing she is not keen on is house prices.
I think Lancaster can feel a bit isolated and also how buzzy it feels can fluctuate according to when students are there or not. And I say that as someone who loved living there and goes back quite a bit to visit friends.

BrightonOrLancaster · 03/12/2021 16:35

@Toddlerteaplease
I don't know why but I'm scared Liverpool would be too dressy and out on the towny! I would be open to Liverpool later but I'm actually moving back to the UK after time abroad so I want a "soft" landing where I know people to ease myself back in for a year or two and then will think about moving elsewhere possibly

OP posts:
LadyWithLapdog · 03/12/2021 16:32

The vote currently stands at 52% to 48%. Where have I seen those % before? 🤣