Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lancaster or brighton?

135 replies

BrightonOrLancaster · 03/12/2021 16:06

For a woman in her 30s moving alone with her cat!
Brighton: very good friends, warmer sea, more fun, livelier, but all family in north and expensive, closer to London and handy for getting away
Lancaster: very close family, much cheaper, less bullshitty, but no friends to start with, more isolated

No need to talk to me about schools etc as irrelevant to me! I work freelance in something creative. I'm really torn!

Vote:
YABU: Brighton
YANBU: Lancaster

OP posts:
earsup · 06/12/2021 17:07

I dont like either place really...lancaster is too small for me..used to visit friends there....used to want to live in brighton but its lost the appeal....teens stumbling all over clutching cheap bottles of wine...vomitting everywhere....awful traffic and parking....nearly bought there over 30 years ago when super cheap but dont regret not going ahead etc

BrightonOrLancaster · 06/12/2021 17:06

I'm really quite torn. The fact that the split is so even is comforting though, it feels like I cant really make a "wrong" decision. Brighton is quite a heavily charged place for me as I have great memories there, it was a very...colourful period in my life. I would slip right back into a community. But theres something about Lancaster that really appeals. However, I googled writing groups in Lancaster and couldn't find a single one :( Brighton is awash with that sort of thing.

I do know what PP mean about this weird liberal vibe you can get down there though. Lots of people "working" on themselves, lots of forced soul searching but then simultaneously not living with enough quietness or non-distraction to actually get anywhere. When I was in brighton it felt like a lot of people I met were on this intense quest for meaning but almost as if that could be bought. I include myself in there by the way. It feels like Lancaster could be more grounding. On the other hand less stimulating maybe?

Also as a single woman am I going to meet many eligible men there? Or will all the eligible men have fucked off to Liverpool or Manchester? 🤔

OP posts:
earsup · 06/12/2021 17:04

@Iamnotminterested

WTF is bungaroush?
its a mix of crap....old stones...bits of old brick, anything really...once it starts to crumble the whole house can collapse...!!...its a victorian super bodge building material.
Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/12/2021 17:03

The Boot and Shoe Grin

hilsea · 06/12/2021 17:01

(And it has a Waitrose!)

hilsea · 06/12/2021 17:01

Throwing another town into the mix in the South - how about Southsea? Its part of Portsmouth and has a bohemian, Brighton-ish vibe but is smaller and cheaper - you could easily live a 5 minute walk from sea in good accommodation, it has lots of bars, theatres and stuff and is only an hour on the train from Brighton or less time from Chichester, Southampton, Guildford and other places, plus London is 1 hour 30 away.

BrightonOrLancaster · 06/12/2021 16:59

I was at the Booths (dont know if theres a bigger one? The one I was at was quite small, near a pub with something to do with shoes or boots in the name) and it was indeed nice.

But brighton has a WAITROSE!!!

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 06/12/2021 16:43

@KaycePollard

Also, where the North has this Booths, the South has Wholefoods surely?

You've clearly not lived near a Booths. I used to shop at Wholefoods (Wholepaycheck) in its original Austin TX (USA) location, and subsequently in its big shops in the USA. It's OK, but not a patch on Booths for a proper day to day excellent supermarket.

UK Wholefoods are rubbish compared to the big USA ones. Even the Kensington 'flagship' is a poor effort. I do love a 'proper' USA Wholefoods though.

So Booths wins hands down.

ToughTittyWhompus · 06/12/2021 16:39

A close friend of mine lives in Brighton and I wouldn’t hesitate to move there if I could!

MrsHamlet · 06/12/2021 16:37

It's currently dark but I can vouch for the scenery on the train to grange. We had some lovely sunrises last week.

Nanoo1234 · 06/12/2021 15:18

Lancaster is very friendly. If you regularly go to say the gregson community.and arts centre and the dukes cafe bar theatre.. you naturally make friends. Its arty and academic and quite politically liberal.
The train lines are exellent.
If we didnt live were we live now , we wd only ever live there.
Amazing countryside amd easy access to places.

KaycePollard · 06/12/2021 12:14

Also, where the North has this Booths, the South has Wholefoods surely?

You've clearly not lived near a Booths. I used to shop at Wholefoods (Wholepaycheck) in its original Austin TX (USA) location, and subsequently in its big shops in the USA. It's OK, but not a patch on Booths for a proper day to day excellent supermarket.

Pinkdelight3 · 06/12/2021 09:47

I love them both, but Lancaster is bloody freezing. And I'm from the north west and can handle the cold, but given the choice, screw that. I remember going to up Lancaster to visit mates there and always had to put extra woolly layers on then sit right up to the fire. Which is cosy now and again, but everyday... Nah. Brighton is just as nice, warmer - and much buzzier and better connected for career and dating options.

JustDanceAddict · 06/12/2021 08:47

Brighton, or nearby. I love it!
Only been to Lancaster once on a uni open day but looked a bit boring!!

Ihopeyourcakeisshit · 06/12/2021 08:38

Don't get the love for Lancaster, it's grey, wet and miserable.
Town is run down and rough, it's completely student dominated, stinks of weed. House prices have shot up for anywhere half decent. I could go on.

pilar3 · 06/12/2021 08:34

Also, where the North has this Booths, the South has Wholefoods surely?

pilar3 · 06/12/2021 08:27

Do NOT move to Lancaster. Grey, grey, grey and more grey. Day in day out. Grey houses and grey skies and grey sea. A LOT more rain in the NW than somewhere like Brighton. This really affects your mood, energy and general mental health.

If places are cheaper there’s generally a whole set reasons for this!

RedRobin100 · 06/12/2021 07:28

I’ve never been to either place, but for where you are in life and what you want right now - I’m voting Brighton

(or close to Brighton that is cheaper to live in but close enough to let you enjoy it)

tenredthings · 06/12/2021 07:22

Lancaster weather is shite. It rains and rains. The town center is small and run down. The traffic is awful and if you want to go anywhere South you have to deal with the M6.

TheRigatonini · 05/12/2021 23:12

@Goldenbear

TheRigatonini, yes, definitely there are very left wing areas of the North but I don't really mean just politics. People are left wing here although lots of Green party supporters. It is hard to express really but people's concerns go beyond politics, I'm in some groups (due to friends suggestions) where the emphasis is on emotional well being and concerning yourself with carving out time for yourself if you are a woman. Paying lots of money on life affirming training. I can't even give the title somebody gave to that 'me time' running one of those sessions as it is too outing. To be fair, my references are the Midlands in contrast where I think most of this would be considered BS. I don't know, it is hard to explain.
I think I get what you’re getting at.

I think there’s a suburban mundanity to much of the Midlands. And a lot of conformism. (This is a sweeping generalisation tho obvs.)

I would not live there again, and have lived mostly abroad and in the north of England since leaving home a few decades ago. Also lived in London for a bit years back and love Brighton (would also consider a move there).

I’d say the Midlands is quite different to the North though. I’d imagine too there is more in common between say South Manchester and Brighton than Brighton and Bury St Edmonds or Hebden Bridge and Hull.

Goldenbear · 05/12/2021 22:44

TheRigatonini, yes, definitely there are very left wing areas of the North but I don't really mean just politics. People are left wing here although lots of Green party supporters. It is hard to express really but people's concerns go beyond politics, I'm in some groups (due to friends suggestions) where the emphasis is on emotional well being and concerning yourself with carving out time for yourself if you are a woman. Paying lots of money on life affirming training. I can't even give the title somebody gave to that 'me time' running one of those sessions as it is too outing. To be fair, my references are the Midlands in contrast where I think most of this would be considered BS. I don't know, it is hard to explain.

KaycePollard · 05/12/2021 22:19

Lancaster has Booths. Brighton does not. Decision made surely?!

Sadly much of the UK is Booths-deprived, poor things. They have to make do with Waitrose.

TheRigatonini · 05/12/2021 22:16

Hang on, you just mean something else by ‘Southern values’ @Goldenbear – I’ve just read back and feel silly stating that there are left-wing labour voters in the north as well as the south Grin

HundredMilesAnHour · 05/12/2021 22:13

Lancaster has Booths. Brighton does not. Decision made surely?!

TheRigatonini · 05/12/2021 22:09

@Goldenbear

I would say the Brighton is very 'southern' in it's outlook, vibe, politics. I am originally from London but my Mum moved to the Midlands in my late teens and when I visit her the contrast in outlook is refreshing sometimes as people are friendly in a day to day way but conservative with a small C in another way so there is a real culture shift for me personally. Lancaster I only know slightly due to one of my friends going to uni there but it was ages ago but I felt it was similar so more conservative with a small C. There are lots of people I know that live up to the Brighton stereotypes so it is not just made up but yes, lots of kissing on cheeks at the school gates, marketing, PR jobs or people working in those areas so maybe more convenient if that's what you work in.
I’m from the midlands and agree with this in relation to the places I know (just one small corner).

However lots of northern cities are pretty left-wing / labour-voting - Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds, etc. Not sure about Lancaster but I suspect it’s more a city vs town/village thing than North vs South!