Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many are jealous of social media influencers

257 replies

pebimo6 · 03/12/2021 12:06

There's a couple I follow on Instagram and it's obvious some of the things they show are ads and that's fine. When I watch itv it's free because there are ads, that's the world. You either pay for a service or it finds another way to make you pay.

But has anyone else notice how instamums attract so much negativity? It seems to be nothing more than jealously! They're not harming anyone and no one is forced to follow

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kanaloa · 06/12/2021 20:04

[quote onlychildhamster]@Mercurial123 she can be both. she writes articles about lifestyle too, doesn't she. I also don't believe claudia winkleman uses head and shoulders either! But she is a host for a telly show more than she is an influencer! She is a celeb paid to advertise a shampoo. the thing is if celebs can do it, why can't ordinary girls from essex and milton keynes?

I think the issue is a lot of people do seem to 'trust' influencers more, i don't know why, but maybe cos they live in ordinary houses and have lives that resemble ours much than claudia who is neighbours with tony and cherie blair...[/quote]
Influencers set themselves up for being trusted specifically. From the language they use to the videos they make etc.

When I see Demi Lovato or somebody advertising trainers I am very aware that this is a poster made by the brand with celebrity endorsement on the side of the Skechers shop to sell trainers.

When Mrs Hinch comes up in someone’s feed, alongside pictures they will see from people they follow because they know, with a colloquial and friendly comment written in the same language you would use when recommending a product to a friend - well it isn’t rocket science. They make themselves seem like a friend.

RobinPenguins · 06/12/2021 17:14

Yeah Sali Hughes wasn’t always great about disclosing her use of Botox (which I felt was important when she’s reviewing e.g. anti ageing products and foundations) or disclosing paid promotions. AFAIK she’s compliant with the requirements now but I stopped reading as I’d lost trust - if I just wanted to read a paid-for advert I’d pick up a magazine.

Mercurial123 · 06/12/2021 16:27

Fair enough. I wouldn't class her as a journalist but that's just my opinion.

I don't trust celebrities or influencers.

onlychildhamster · 06/12/2021 16:13

@Mercurial123 she can be both. she writes articles about lifestyle too, doesn't she. I also don't believe claudia winkleman uses head and shoulders either! But she is a host for a telly show more than she is an influencer! She is a celeb paid to advertise a shampoo. the thing is if celebs can do it, why can't ordinary girls from essex and milton keynes?

I think the issue is a lot of people do seem to 'trust' influencers more, i don't know why, but maybe cos they live in ordinary houses and have lives that resemble ours much than claudia who is neighbours with tony and cherie blair...

Mercurial123 · 06/12/2021 14:19

Sali Hughes claims to be a journalist and not Influencer. She's definitely the latter. I don't believe for a second she uses Head & Shoulders.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 06/12/2021 13:50

Depends on the influencer though, surely?

I can't stand Mrs Hinch and her ilk, but I do like ThingsIBoughtAndLiked and Mary Orton. I've bought several things they've suggested and not regretted it.

I also like Jamie Beck and bought a few of her prints for my house.

Similarly, I follow Sally Hughes and Sasha Wilkins and always like a look at their recommendations - they're pretty scrupulous about saying when it's an ad and when it'a not.

I tend to just...not follow people I don't like.

Snuggledupforwinter · 06/12/2021 09:28

They're vapid sales/marketing people. Only the gullible believe everything they see on IG or social media.
The idea of children being videoed or photographed by a parent and uploaded to the internet to make money is vile.

potoforchids · 05/12/2021 21:28

@CourtRand she meant that her friend thought Mrs Hinch was still a hairdresser and that Instagram was just a hobby and she recommended things to people to be nice, not that influencing was her full time job earning her a ton. It shows that some people aren't aware that they are seeing constant ads.

Lemonlady22 · 05/12/2021 20:53

Why would you want/need influencing by someone who has probably never done a proper day's work in their life...the concept amazes me.....I have my own brain that's quiet intelligent and i don't need to be 'influenced' by some dunce on 'their channel' thanks very much!

InPatagonia · 05/12/2021 20:18

I love how so few people can conceive of reasons more complex than ‘jealousy’ when others dislike something. I don’t have social media, whenever I’ve had a cursory glance at any ‘influencers’ (god imagine being influenced by some of these people!) I’ve thought they seem shallow and vapid. Who can be arsed with the minutiae of others lives to such an extent that they’d have an influence on how you live yours? It’s insane. It’s definitely not anything to do with envy on my part! Such an easy way to dismiss the ‘haters’. Meh

allfurcoatnoknickers · 05/12/2021 20:03

My friend is an influencer - she has an Instagram famous dog with 250k followers. They make about 3k-5k a month from the dog Shock. I'd do that if I could!

LalalalalalaLand123 · 05/12/2021 19:46

Believe me, no one is jealous of them

Bellyups · 05/12/2021 19:44

I’m not jealous. I just find them fake, egotistical and embarrassing.
I consider all ‘influencers’ to be freebie grabbers anyway

CourtRand · 05/12/2021 19:43

@ChristmasKrackers

For instance my best friends sister thought Mrs Hinch was a hairdresser at the beginning. Says it all doesn’t it.
She was a hairdresser...
gogohm · 05/12/2021 19:43

Because a lot of its staged, fake - sponsored items, fake smiles and kids can't consent to the publicity. Reality shows similar.

GingerFoxInAT0phat · 05/12/2021 19:21

10 pages here of posts in a similar vein, influencers are vacuous, monetising children is hideous etc. So who are the people who are commenting blowing smoke up their arses? ‘Aw baby Raffy is to bloody gawjuss 😍😍’

I’ve never heard anyone say they like influencers in real life, I wonder where the engagement is coming from?

Toadsinholes · 05/12/2021 10:07

It’s the rampant narcissism that gets me the most. I can’t believe anyone thinks their life is so interesting that they need to share it with everyone else? It’s so weird. I know someone from the gym who does it & has about 100k followers - she makes out she lives in London but actually she’s still at home living with mum & dad in our crappy commuter town, & works in Sainsbury’s part time. That but never goes on the ‘gram. It makes me laugh.

The children bit is the worst though. My kids are embarrassed that I have ANY videos of them at all, even just saved on my phone. They won’t even let ME watch them. I can’t imagine how they would feel if literally 10000s of people had all seen them. It’s dreadful.

mnp321 · 05/12/2021 09:08

I don't have an issue with people making money, including influencers. I'm not jealous of them, partly because we're well off but also because I'd hate to share my family life in that way. It's hard enough for kids to grow up with social media and I strongly believe that sharing little Johnnie in the bath, on the loo and having a meltdown to millions of strangers is not being a good parent and protecting your kids.

I agree that they're sales people, just using a different format. Thats fine. But there's something that makes me uncomfortable about it. I'm not sure everyone can understand that they're not your "friend", you don't know them and what you see is a carefully manicured image. Plus the use of filters and staging making everything look unattainably perfect. It makes me worry that people on low incomes get sucked into consumerism they can't afford.

Chakraleaf · 05/12/2021 09:01

No one should be using their children for engagement.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 05/12/2021 08:55

Blimey OP,

Why not spend your time dealing with real issues the world faces like hunger, disease and people being killed in Afghanistan? It's just the suffering of people selling makeup and Hoover's on social media that you find beyond the pale in life?!?

Honestly where is your compassion OP.

Grin See how silly your argument about diseases and Afghanistan was?

HighlandPony · 05/12/2021 01:41

But are they really not doing anyone any harm? I’m not jealous of influencers at all but they do irritate me. The vast majority of them are promoting ‘stuff’ to look a certain way and apart from the negative body image message and the message it sends that you’re only as good as you look, all this ‘stuff’ is just more tat destined for landfill. I live less than a mile from a landfill and I wish they would stop promoting fads that basically end up as pollution

Cocogreen · 05/12/2021 01:30

OP, search the term " parasocial relationships" about the one-sided relationships between social media influencers and viewers.
There is no jealousy from me.
Most of them are very pretty young women who are using their youth and beauty and cute children to make money which is not something I would do because of the lack of privacy. I hope they realise as soon as their kids age into surly pre-teens and they hit their mid 30s they're out of a job. We've seen it with all the bloggers who were a big thing circa 2010 or earlier who've now faded into obscurity. They have a short shelf life and there is always a prettier younger woman coming up to replace them.

onlychildhamster · 05/12/2021 00:40

The difference between influencers and traditional advertising/Kardashians is that an influencer is attempting to established a relationship with her followers and build trust. I have never watched the kardashians but they are firmly in the 'celebrity' bracket, same with people like paris hilton- they obviously have extravagant lifestyles and it is much more 'detached' like watching a tv programme with rich people in it.

However, a lot of influencers cultivate 'a girl next door' image and they go above and beyond to show us how they are just ordinary people. Have you ever had a kardashian respond to your comment on instagram? plenty of influencers painstakingly respond to all their comments and form friendships with their followers. Some of their followers trust their opinion the same way they would trust a friend, its because they are 'relatable. You can see why this is dangerous when you are an ordinary average woman and your 'friend' is asking you to buy all this stuff cos she 'used it' and 'its great'.

I was in the caroline hirons skincare freaks group and left because I was weary of all the incessants hashtags #carolinemademedoit, stories of women hiding their purchases from their husbands, spending over £200 on the latest kit (i think she has one every few months I swear), buying every single thing she recommended (very few things below £50-75 for a serum or face oil). I had a peek at many of their facebook profiles and no, they weren't all upper middle class women on 6 figure salaries. Quite the opposite actually.

Knickynackynoo · 05/12/2021 00:04

Oh OP you are so very stupid. I've just read through all your posts, have a day off 'hun' yeah.

Knickynackynoo · 04/12/2021 23:22

.....said the insta mum

Swipe left for the next trending thread