Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Abusive dh wants kids 50/50

169 replies

Secretdancers · 02/12/2021 22:21

I'm posting here for traffic. Really need some help.
I have finally managed to tell my emotionally and financially abusive dh that I want a divorce. I can see him for who he really is, and want out.

The problem is that he is so so clever with appearances, and everyone thinks he's a really good husband and a nice guy. He is absolutely great with everyone else, just not me. I'm the one who gets all the bad stuff. His manipulation is so clever, you can't put a finger on it. I have no evidence.

I'm the event of divorce, he wants the kids with him 50/50. They are 6 and 8. I'm worried he will take all his darkness on them when I'm not around to protect them and I'm not there to take the shit instead. He is not violent, but invalidates them, is very authoritative, doesn't allow them to express emotions, makes unfavourable comparisons about them etc. I'm very close to my children, and handing them over every other week scares me so much that I've promised him I'd go to councelling with him to attempt to save our marriage.

I don't think the councelling will magically give him morals or empathy or cure him of his deeply dishonest and abusive ways. I really just want this to be over. But what do I do?

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/12/2021 14:03

@Skeumorph

Yes perhaps time for a carefully worded reply. Not in writing!

'Well 50-50 would obviously be good in many ways as it would give us both a chance to have real free time to move on with new lives and ultimately new relationships. However I don't believe, given your behaviour, that it would be in the best interests of the children while they are still so small. I don't want to have to make public the reasons why we split, I am sure our family and friends wouldn't like to hear about the prostitutes and the threats but if it comes to me having to state my reasons why I think they should mainly be with me then I will have to.'

So - allude to the fact that 50-50 means you've more free time to meet a new man, which he won't want. He won't have thought of that yet. Then, the veiled threat.

I would really advise against doing this especially in writing as it's tantamount to blackmail, giving a vengeful ex the perfect new stick to beat OP with - threatening legal action against her for blackmail which is a crime.
Fizzbangwallop · 03/12/2021 13:24

Quietly tell all your family and friends about him using prostitutes. Explain that he has threatened you and is emotionally abusive, but you wanted to tell them the real reason you are divorcing him. Ask them not to discuss it with him or his family and friends. I guarantee that many people will have already seen through his nice guy and great dad act.

Agree to 50-50 parenting and don’t support him for ANY childcare arrangements. Tell him he has to do half of everything. Let him fail to collect the DCs a few times (and be sure to tell the school in advance which days to phone him as you will not be available).

coodawoodashooda · 03/12/2021 13:20

@PigeonLittle

He loves control. Children, especially of a split marriage are not easy.

When you arent there to shush them, maintain their behaviour etc and fulfil their basic care needs he will not cope

He will do better going along the line of "that bitch wont let me see my kids" than "look at the brilliant single dad I am"

It will suit his single lifestyle much more. I agree tell him you will be grateful of the time off parenting and you will be able to socialise again. And also tell your friends and family.

Mumsnetters hate the constant recommendations that everyone is a narcissist - but this discrepancy of feeling like no one will believe you, and there is nothing to say he did wrong, you just know he's manipulative. I think researching ex narcissistic partners will help you understand the abuse and gaslighting you may have fallen foul of.

I agree.
PigeonLittle · 03/12/2021 12:44

He loves control. Children, especially of a split marriage are not easy.

When you arent there to shush them, maintain their behaviour etc and fulfil their basic care needs he will not cope

He will do better going along the line of "that bitch wont let me see my kids" than "look at the brilliant single dad I am"

It will suit his single lifestyle much more. I agree tell him you will be grateful of the time off parenting and you will be able to socialise again. And also tell your friends and family.

Mumsnetters hate the constant recommendations that everyone is a narcissist - but this discrepancy of feeling like no one will believe you, and there is nothing to say he did wrong, you just know he's manipulative. I think researching ex narcissistic partners will help you understand the abuse and gaslighting you may have fallen foul of.

Theunamedcat · 03/12/2021 12:39

@Secretdancers

The things he doesn't concern himself with are childcare arrangements, remembering pick up times, doctors appointments, hobby schedules.. Nothing. I have to text him on the day from work to tell him where to go and what time or he just doesn't do it. Sometimes I text several times. And sometimes he still doesn't do it. Causes me so much stress.
Stop doing this let him publicly fail tell the school to call HIM not you
Saucy99 · 03/12/2021 12:38

I think you need to separate your feelings towards him and his parenting skills. Just because you don't like him, that doesn't mean he isn't a good Dad.

Skeumorph · 03/12/2021 12:37

@Secretdancers

The things he doesn't concern himself with are childcare arrangements, remembering pick up times, doctors appointments, hobby schedules.. Nothing. I have to text him on the day from work to tell him where to go and what time or he just doesn't do it. Sometimes I text several times. And sometimes he still doesn't do it. Causes me so much stress.
Then you can allude to this too. There will be no more texts and no more free secretary...
Skeumorph · 03/12/2021 12:37

Yes perhaps time for a carefully worded reply. Not in writing!

'Well 50-50 would obviously be good in many ways as it would give us both a chance to have real free time to move on with new lives and ultimately new relationships. However I don't believe, given your behaviour, that it would be in the best interests of the children while they are still so small. I don't want to have to make public the reasons why we split, I am sure our family and friends wouldn't like to hear about the prostitutes and the threats but if it comes to me having to state my reasons why I think they should mainly be with me then I will have to.'

So - allude to the fact that 50-50 means you've more free time to meet a new man, which he won't want. He won't have thought of that yet. Then, the veiled threat.

Secretdancers · 03/12/2021 12:37

The things he doesn't concern himself with are childcare arrangements, remembering pick up times, doctors appointments, hobby schedules.. Nothing. I have to text him on the day from work to tell him where to go and what time or he just doesn't do it. Sometimes I text several times. And sometimes he still doesn't do it. Causes me so much stress.

OP posts:
Secretdancers · 03/12/2021 12:32

@kelseypops he looks after them OK. Dc are quite capable of sorting themselves out with snacks, getting dressed etc, so parenting is mostly just time, screentime and argument management which he does. He also cooks, brushes teeth, bedtime stories etc. A perfect dad 🙄

OP posts:
kelseypops · 03/12/2021 12:25

I have just left my H for similar reasons and have the same worries as you. I haven't read the full thread but how is he actually at child care? Does he do his bit?

My H could quite easily threaten me with court but the reality is he cannot look after his dc and deep down has no interest in doing so. Anything to do with custody or court is just to get at me.

Obviously this is just my case but I feel it's common in most abusive cases

youvegottenminuteslynn · 03/12/2021 09:32

They can be in a toxic environment where they are unhappy 100% of the time, or 50% of the time. I appreciate the latter is awful but it's still better than the alternative. And it's amazing how many fathers claim to want 50:50 then don't follow long term in reality. Or even medium term.

Secretdancers · 03/12/2021 09:17

Thank you for the suggestions and experiences everyone.
Sadly I think he is definitely asking for 50/50 and since he looks after the kids quite a lot (I work shifts) he would get it also. I have no doubt.
The councelling was already pre- planned before I started talking about divorce. Our child is going through assessments for neurological /psychological issues, and as a part of that I asked for family therapy. I knew something is wrong in our family, just couldn't put my finger on it. So maybe that's a way forward. Talk about splitting when we get to the therapy.

OP posts:
Skysblue · 03/12/2021 08:51

I’m so sorry OP.

The law is inadequate in this area and doesn’t protect women and children from abusive men, who are expert at manipulating the system.

All I can suggeat is that you (without telling him) get advice from a good divorce lawyer about ways in which you could fight his request for 50:50.

Any threats of violence he makes, report to the police or at least make a note of what happened and when, somewhere private (a draft email perhaps). This might help with the divorce ruling re child custody. perhaps also talk to Womens Aid.

Babyiskickingmyribs · 03/12/2021 08:34

What would happen OP if you go to counseling and when the counselor asks why you’re there you say ‘H used prostitutes on X number of occasions in X time frame and I am not prepared to put up with such disrespect in a marriage so I a going to petition for divorce for unreasonable behavior. I would like to use this counseling time to calmly discuss how we can coparent together as divorced parents.’ ?

Hankunamatata · 03/12/2021 08:20

OP he wont stick yo 50:50. He will want a wee young thing who soothes his ego and not want kids around - it's a scare tactic

Bingbangbongbash · 03/12/2021 08:16

If he’s so concerned about appearances, how would he feel if you petitioned for divorce on the basis of his use of prostitutes / the stds? I know very little about family law, but would that information become matters of public record? In which case perhaps you could compromise on a lesser split if you weren’t as specific in your reasons for leaving him.

KeyboardWorriers · 03/12/2021 07:56

I feel your pain. It is very hard knowing that in order to escape abuse you will have to leave your children with your abuser for long chunks of time.

On the other hand, they will have one happy home that is free of abuse, and that means so much.

Rushing, or I would say more Flowers

coodawoodashooda · 03/12/2021 07:49

@GoodnightGrandma

Is he actually going to want them 50% of the time in reality ? He’s probably threatening this to stop him having to pay maintenance.
I disagree. I didn't think we'd see my xh again. He was barely involved in any aspect of family life. Then of course he discovered his, 'rights'. They think of us as their possessions and i wouldn't suggest for one minute that he wont follow through. Op it's not easy. You could pursue a ton of hobbies but youllbe too tired to. But, don't estimate the joy of actual sleep, a tidy home and the satisfaction of your kids finding out what you already know for themselves..
jackiebenimble · 03/12/2021 07:16

I totally agree that his demands for 50/50 are because he knows it will scare you. Its worked as you have now agreed to counselling. It will also be because in 50/50 you get no maintenance so he can financially control you then.

I can see it's terrifying. But does he understand what 50/50 means. That you share both the fun times and the boring mid week daily grind. So as well as working he does all his own drop offs and pick ups and makes packed lunches and does all the school admin and work, birthday parties, clubs. From what you describe he would tire of this quickly as its a lot of grunt work and v little glory or ego massage.

With the concerns you have there is no way i'd agree to one week on one week off schedule. Its too long for the kids. You need to do something with shorter
Stints. Its then also easier for you to keep an eye on whats going on.

Duckschmuck · 03/12/2021 07:16

My ex was and is like that. He has dragged me and more importantly my children through the mire.

I fought tooth and nail to get a CAO, fortunately for me the court seemed to understand it needed to be very prescriptive. He still pushes everything to the limit. Even now, years later,anyway he can hurt me he will and he has no compunction about using the children to do this.

But, I have learnt to have super strict boundaries with him, I now compartmentalise my stress about dealing with him. The children have suffered but they have a loving home with me and have grown to be surprising astute and lovely people.

At your point I thought the same, should I stay, but I couldn't any more. Over the years I have questioned whether it would have been better if I had stayed, but now I'm glad I didn't. The children gravitated to me anyway and have become resilient, empathetic individuals. They have the values I demonstrated and have grown (as I have) and I'm glad that is what they have seen, not someone who tolerated them being treated badly and did little, but someone who did their best to provide a decent life for them.

Honestly, it probably won't be easier in the short term but now I really respect myself and I'm a much stronger person and my children are too.

Santaischeckinglists · 03/12/2021 07:15

Personally I would be investing in some tech.
Hidden camera in a dc's toy maybe? Or a button one in a coat.
Given current dc related court cases I wouldn't be chancing anything.. My ex was similar. When dc were 12 and 14 they went nc with df and told me about the abuse and neglect they suffered while with him..

Secretdancers · 03/12/2021 07:01

@IAAP that's so sad. I'm sorry you're also both stuck in this situation. I'm wondering if I can hold on til the dc are a bit older and can decide where to stay 😭

OP posts:
IAAP · 03/12/2021 06:57

[quote Secretdancers]@coodawoodashooda thanks for replying 🙏 but what do you mean? How can I hand my kids over to this man every other week knowing he will gaslight and manipulate them like he does with me?
And I don't think he will just go away. He likes to make me pay if I managed to gave a nice life without him. He is definitely the revenging type, and might take it out on the dc. For example right now he's super good with them, because he knows I want to divorce, and by being nice to dc I could see what a good husband /dad he is. I see through it now..[/quote]
You have no evidence so it is likely he will get 50/50.

My son sees his emotionally abusive father several times a year and plays video games all day - hardly parenting - he is just a toy at the moment he is 7 I can not see him wanting to go at 14

Theunamedcat · 03/12/2021 06:56

You need evidence of how he really is sadly

Swipe left for the next trending thread