Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is this taking it a step too far? Slimming World related.

130 replies

ThankYouStavros · 02/12/2021 20:52

I’m still a member of various SW groups though haven’t followed it in years. I just haven’t removed myself as I do use some of the recipes.

This was shared today and I was shocked. Surely if you’re sick, you shouldn’t be worried about this kind of thing? Or am I just overthinking it?

AIBU or is this taking it a step too far? Slimming World related.
OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 03/12/2021 09:21

From the SW website:

'Free Foods include lean meat, eggs, fish, pasta, potatoes, fruit and vegetables. They’re filling and low in calories for their weight'

'Healthy Extras include milk and cheese for calcium, wholemeal bread and breakfast cereals for fibre and other essential minerals, and nuts and seeds for healthy oils'

'The foods that are least filling and are higher in calories, like biscuits, sweets and alcohol, count as Syns at Slimming World. Enjoying a little of what you fancy — like a piece of chocolate or a glass of wine — means you won’t be tempted to go off track'

Ok, the Syns terminology isn't great, but that's designed to make keeping track easier. One of the benefits is that you have to do very little counting and measuring, which is tedious and time consuming unless you mainly eat food that's packaged and portion controlled, and I think we're all in agreement that's generally not the type of foods that we need to be eating for health and weight control.

Rubyupbeat · 03/12/2021 09:15

Lockets helped me through many illnesses, obviously not serious ones.
SW are crap anyway, I joined ed a few years back, and was amazed at all the bars on sale full of fake sugars and preservatives. The leader had no idea about a healthy diet.
Still they must help some, as they have been going for years.

Iamthewombat · 03/12/2021 08:58

Yes, anyone I know who has done it appears to eat a lot of sugar free jelly!

Re the original question: did anyone concerned by their calorie intake ever look at a packet of strepsils and think, yes, they will have no calories because they are medicated? Really?

In defence of Hall’s mentho lyptus and soothers, they might be full of sugar but they at least temporarily help with a sore throat.

SirChenjins · 03/12/2021 08:56

When I went, the leader spent every meeting explaining which brands/flavours of shite convenience food were better than others. Bloody Muller Lights, and supernoodles. And lots of talk of too much exercise

I don’t recognise that at all - that definitely wasn’t my experience from the group. The pack that comes with your membership explains the ‘free’ food, the limited foods and the syns really clearly, and it’s simple to build your meals around that. I suppose it’s like anything - if you want to lose weight and are prepared to put in the work you’ll do it, if you’re half hearted about it and expect a weight loss plan to work miracles as you chow down on bread and sugar then you’ll get nowhere.

Doubleraspberry · 03/12/2021 08:42

Agreed that I voted YANBU because of the Syn crap. Plain paracetamol is the best, and cheapest, remedy for a cold, and the post would do better to point that out.

Not sure I recognise this version of SW that’s all about plain, nutritious eating. When I went, the leader spent every meeting explaining which brands/flavours of shite convenience food were better than others. Bloody Muller Lights, and supernoodles. And lots of talk of too much exercise.

MaxNormal · 03/12/2021 08:39

I had colleagues that did slimming world. They never lost any weight, all their food was highly processed crap but at least they had something to talk about endlessly.

SirChenjins · 03/12/2021 08:24

I have friends who've lost weight there once, stopped doing it, regained the weight and ended up going forever and a day and still continued to stay overweight, but they like going and talking about how hard it is to lose weight

That is the shame for literally every single diet, weight loss plan or lifestyle change - if you stop doing it and revert back to your old ways then you'll put on weight. It's hardly specific to SW - and for many of us that found it works we've kept the weight off.

HireStarter · 03/12/2021 08:16

Having a cold doesnt mean people don't want to keep to plan.

YABU.

BarbaraofSeville · 03/12/2021 08:14

I have friends who've lost weight there once, stopped doing it, regained the weight and ended up going forever and a day and still continued to stay overweight, but they like going and talking about how hard it is to lose weight

But isn't that the case for any diet/weight loss/healthy eating plan? If you stop following it and go back to whatever type of overeating that made you gain weight in the first place, you'll regain. That's not unique to SW, that would also happen if you stopped low carbing or counting calories etc.

Incidentally SW also offer a maintenance plan, which is gradually increasing consumption of foods like dairy and wholemeal bread and cereal, while continuing to watch the amount of junk food you eat and you can follow that for free, for as long as you like.

Iamthewombat · 03/12/2021 08:07

Also, in terms of feeling like things are "sinned" because of the use of "Syn", slimming world try to emphasise that no food is off limits. It is about making smarter choices and being aware of where calories are coming from. It's meant to stand for synergy.

Is that what they told you? Not true, I’m afraid. My mother and several other people I know did SW in the 1990s when it was ‘sins’, not ‘syns’. See if you can get hold of some of the old literature: full of references to sins. Sins. In the biblical/Joan Collins sense.

I thought that it was barking then, and I still do. Even with the hasty revision of ‘sins’ to ‘syns’, which happened a while back, and the reworking of the backstory to pretend that ‘syns’ is a contraction of ‘synergies’.

SirChenjins · 03/12/2021 08:01

If you are not a health professional (which you are not evidently) you shouldn't be giving advice on here

Honey and lemon with some paracetamol is hardly advice that only health professionals can give. Good grief - no wonder our NHS is overwhelmed if this sort of basic, time-tested remedy needs to come from a professional.

Silveryspark · 03/12/2021 08:01

@fluffythedragonslayer

Honestly I think this is a good post! We should be annoyed at the companies selling sugar filled crap and pretending it is medicine!!

Nothing bad about opening people's eyes to the fact that something sold to you as medicine is chock full of sugar and un-necessary calories.

Seems odd that SW is getting the brunt of the outrage here not the companies selling horribly unhealthy "medicine"

Yeah, kind of agree but it's the syn nonsense that gets my dander up!
fluffythedragonslayer · 03/12/2021 07:59

Honestly I think this is a good post! We should be annoyed at the companies selling sugar filled crap and pretending it is medicine!!

Nothing bad about opening people's eyes to the fact that something sold to you as medicine is chock full of sugar and un-necessary calories.

Seems odd that SW is getting the brunt of the outrage here not the companies selling horribly unhealthy "medicine"

Silveryspark · 03/12/2021 07:52

@slashlover

I don't see a problem. I do Slimming World and if I needed them, I would have grabbed a packet of Lockets without even thinking about it, now I'd take the extra 10 seconds to look for sugar free lozenges instead.
And that's the rub isn't it? Sugar free 'food' is sky high with totally unhealthy additives, so even worse for you than sugar. Ditto for sugar free drinks. Toxic as well as revolting. People need to be encouraged to eat real food not processed crap.

In my humble opinion 😂🤭

Silveryspark · 03/12/2021 07:49

I went once as moral support for a friend. The basic premise about filling up on real food seemed OK. However it seemed to encourage ED type of thinking as people were standing up and saying what they ate that they 'got away with'. Like one woman had dampened a bread roll and sprinkled it with sugar and pretended it was a doughnut.
I have friends who've lost weight there once, stopped doing it, regained the weight and ended up going forever and a day and still continued to stay overweight, but they like going and talking about how hard it is to lose weight.

I also cunningly spotted that the group leader was not svelte herself.
It doesn't help food addiction if you're encouraged/allowed to eat small portion of chocolate say, as people lacking the off switch with sugary foods don't generally cope well with having half a bar of Cadburys lying about.
In theory, everything jn moderation is sensible, but the SW plan doesn't seem to look at empty calories either.

slashlover · 03/12/2021 07:39

I don't see a problem. I do Slimming World and if I needed them, I would have grabbed a packet of Lockets without even thinking about it, now I'd take the extra 10 seconds to look for sugar free lozenges instead.

Thehop · 03/12/2021 07:38

Slimming world is a dangerous cult who’s business success depends on members failing.

halloweenie13 · 03/12/2021 07:37

@Alwayscheerful

It is very easy to work through a whole packet of "cough" sweets while feeling poorly and sorry for ones self. How many syns is Honey, lemon & paracetamol? A sensible reminder.
If you are not a health professional (which you are not evidently) you shouldn't be giving advice on here.
halloweenie13 · 03/12/2021 07:35

@changingchanges2

I don't see a problem with this tbh? It's just trying to keep you on track I suppose.
'Keep you on track' when SW doesn't even understand basic nutrition and encourages to consume calorific items without them being 'syns' lmao. I would fully encourage anyone to join WW but avoid the toxicity of SW!
Alwayscheerful · 03/12/2021 07:32

It is very easy to work through a whole packet of "cough" sweets while feeling poorly and sorry for ones self.
How many syns is Honey, lemon & paracetamol?
A sensible reminder.

Strugglingtodomybest · 03/12/2021 07:21

I'm really surprised by so many people referring to this list as "medications". You don't need any of these if you (presumably, looking at the list) have a cold or flu. Just drink plenty of water and take some paracetamol. Cough medicine has never been proven to work.

Pinkflask · 03/12/2021 07:14

I’m fairly strict on sweets for my DC and when I bought DS a packet of Soothers for a tickly throat he thought he was in heaven and scoffed a packet in a day! It’s basically an excuse to eat sweets - great if you don’t care about the sugar and they help you, but if you’re counting calories, something else would be better.

MinnieJackson · 03/12/2021 06:56

Actually I went to slimming world once and a lady came in after that had quit smoking. As new members we had to sit at a table and the consultant told us about the plan, then told the lady it wasn't the right time for her to quit smoking if she wanted to get into a 'healthy' weight 😂

MinnieJackson · 03/12/2021 06:51

Lol, I feel poorly, I'll treat meself to 5 pellets of gum for half a syn, but I'll have to cut back on the milk in my tea.

SirChenjins · 03/12/2021 06:43

@BarbaraofSeville

Exactly. Nothing is bad for you (within reason,) as long as you have it in moderation

Which is exactly the premise of SW. Make most of your meals from fresh unprocessed food like fruit, veg, pulses, meat, fish, eggs, dairy and eat the right amount so you're not hungry and looking to snack on rubbish. Try to eat wholegrain bread and cereal not white, but if you do eat white bread, watch the amount you eat. Limit ready meals, plus obvious junk like biscuits, sweets, cakes, crisps, alcohol etc you eat so it's a small part of your diet.

How on earth anyone can interpret that as bad advice I'll never know.

Exactly. My weight had been creeping up and for the first time in my life at 51 I was becoming overweight and I found it a really easy guide to follow - I didn’t have to count the calories of everything I was eating (who can be arsed with that?), I filled up with veg, fruit, lean meat, dairy, eggs and other unprocessed stuff, I ate fewer carbs, and I could still have some cake or some chocolate or whatever I wanted each day. I’m very much more aware of what I’m eating now, have revised my approach to food and the weight has stayed off. I honestly fail to see how that approach is a bad thing.