Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by piano teacher comments

413 replies

FlibberdyGibbett · 02/12/2021 15:14

My 10 year old son ‘Josh’ has been having piano lessons for six weeks and I have received this text from his teacher.

“Josh seems to be struggling in his lessons. He complains his fingers are tired even after we have just started the lesson. This morning he told me he has been doing too much writing in class beforehand. He seems to talk a lot and doesn’t seem particularly interested. He tells me he practises on his iPad?? I’m not sure the piano is right for Josh, maybe consider a different instrument next term.”

AIBU to feel upset and my son is being unsupported?

OP posts:
alsonotmyname · 02/12/2021 18:52

The performance diploma is just that, how she performs not how she teaches - you can take it at any stage in your career even if you already have a music degree for example, it may be that she's doing it just for pleasure or maybe her first instrument is Violin and now she wants to take it in Piano too.

GrumpyTerrier · 02/12/2021 18:52

Maybe he just doesn't like her. I liked my first piano teacher. When she retired I tried 3 more and didn't like them so ended up not continuing. Kids can be funny about who they like and don't like.

Her message sounded ok and will save you money if he doesn't like the lessons/teacher/instrument.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 18:51

Violin and piano are hard in different ways - piano is easier upfront - but putting together 2 hands and sight-reading 2 clefs at once - is more challenging.

Smartiepants79 · 02/12/2021 18:49

I do have to say I disagree with all the people saying don’t even bother. You’re pushing him…etc..
Both mine have piano lessons. They’re not musical prodigy’s but they’re doing ok for their age.
The youngest in particular wouldn’t have even tried it if I left it up to her. I insisted that she give it a good go for a year. She LOVES it.
I do think 6 weeks is not long enough to know if you want to do it or not. It does sound like this particular lesson set up is not right for your son.

Brigittebidet · 02/12/2021 18:49

Oh and by the way, violin is a bloody AWFUL noise when it's being learnt. I suggest the cello which is much more forgiving on the ears. Or, better still any brass, which is really quite easy comparatively to strings - he will make much more progress much more quickly with brass than with piano or strings. Also, once you've learnt one brass instrument (e.g. cornet) you can play them all other than trombone or horn.

WonderfulYou · 02/12/2021 18:49

A lot of children are like him. They desperately want to learn something but then once they start it’s not as fun as they thought it would be.

I’d give him a break from it and see if he wants to start again or try something else.

I think it was nice that she was honest about it instead of encouraging you to keep paying for lessons.

Violinist64 · 02/12/2021 18:48

I play and teach both piano and violin and can tell you unequivocally that the violin is MUCH harder than the piano. Depending on the person it can take quite a while to get a recognisable tune. You really have to be dedicated to it if you are going to be any good. If he is keen to learn an instrument but not sure which one to try, my suggestion would be to look at brass instruments, in particular the cornet or trumpet. Once you can blow a note, progress can be rapid and ten is the ideal age to start these instruments. If there are brass bands in your area he can gain a lot of experience and often tuition through these.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 18:47

@FlibberdyGibbett

Not sure why so many people are assuming I’m pushing my child into learning a musical (piano or violin)? We talked earlier and it’s what HE wants!! Why shouldn’t he have an opportunity?

OP, in the nicest possible way get a grip.

He’s 10, which is quite late to start, those are difficult instruments - he needs something easier - flute, saxophone, guitar, guitar, drums.. etc

Georgie8 · 02/12/2021 18:47

🤣🤣🤣 sorry OP, but are we to assume you’re not musical?

You have to have an instrument to practise on -so for many people piano isn’t the best starter instrument -a keyboard isn’t a suitable substitute beyond the very early grades. Piano also require you to learn treble and bass clef -that’s like learning two languages. Let’s not even start about the feet becoming involved!

However, I always think it’s best to start on a portable instrument which you can play in groups -and that’s not the piano.

My children are very musical (play 3 instruments each and have done grade 8 in their favourites and are grade 7 in the others) and we’ve noticed their friends remaining on grade 3-ish for several years and thought, “why don’t you stop?”

As a family we (minus husband) play, ‘cello, viola, violin, clarinet, flute, oboe, and all play piano. But nothing is easy if you’re not interested.

Lessons are really hard for music teachers when they can see their pupils aren’t there through choice.

Don’t abandon music (great skill for maths and languages IMO) but find something portable that gives instant satisfaction. I’d go with the ukulele 🙂

Emails/text can seem a bit rude, but I think you’re lucky to have such an honest piano teacher.

Brigittebidet · 02/12/2021 18:46

DH is a piano and strings teacher. DS (12) could be very musically talented but will.not.learn.an.instrument. We've tried him on piano and brass. He just doesn't enjoy it. He's found something else that he loves and does three times a week and is quite happy doing that. It's sad, but it is what it is. It is something he came upon himself and I'm sure that's the reason he loves it so much. However much DH and I would like him to play something, it's not his thing.

DD is marginally more interested and is learning piano and violin with DH but practice is still a bit of a thing!

Let him find his own way. It's sad but true!

Notmenotme · 02/12/2021 18:45

Good lord please tell me you haven’t signed him up for violin!!!!

I’m a music teacher and first instrument is piano… I’ve been doing violin for about 5 years, had two years of lessons before covid. I’m very musical and talented - and I sound god awful on the violin. I’ve practiced hours - and I am only just after 5 years able to stay mildly in tune!!

Your piano teacher was much kinder than I’ve been in the past!!!

Cindercat · 02/12/2021 18:43

Grin Violin will be way harder than piano, OP. Tbh, you are v much coming across as that parent. He might very well like the thought of playing an instrument but the actual path to getting to even a basic level of proficiency is pretty repetitive and arduous. He'll have to really be interested in learning to play and not just in playing. If he didn't practice the piano enough and wasn't interested during the lessons, what makes you think violin will be different? I'd certainly not be forking out for a better violin until he's proved he's committed to it.

JinglingHellsBells · 02/12/2021 18:40

@FlibberdyGibbett

Not sure why so many people are assuming I’m pushing my child into learning a musical (piano or violin)? We talked earlier and it’s what HE wants!! Why shouldn’t he have an opportunity?
You need to buy a piano or a keyboard.

My DC got one at 5 and started proper lessons at 7.
During their time learning they practised for 20 mins every single day.

If he won't practise piano, how do you think he will practise the violin?

You need to talk to him and explain that the lessons are the tip of the iceberg. Learning to play is really 90% practise at home. If he can't see this or manage it, then he's too immature still or has an airy fairy idea of what is involved.

At 10 he ought to understand this.

toomuchlaundry · 02/12/2021 18:40

Good luck with listening to him learn the violin!

Smartiepants79 · 02/12/2021 18:39

I’m not sure that violin is a good idea. It is not easier to learn and takes a lot longer to see any real results that would a make a child feel good about their playing.
A child new to the violin sounds like a dying cat.
The piano/keyboard is a much more sensible choice for a first instrument. It makes a good sound with little skill.
I would suggest that maybe group lessons are not the right thing for your child.
1-1 would likely be more successful as it sounds like focus is what he struggles with.
How does he normally manage in school!?

EllieSattler · 02/12/2021 18:38

@Ceci03

If you want advice, honestly the violin is very hard and to start at aged 10 he most likely won't catch up with his age for a good few years.

A better option would be recorder, which could lead to clarinet or flute...? A recorder is very cheap, he will learn all the fingerings, and how to read music, and then he can transfer to another wind instrument.

Or guitar would be a better option than violin which is very hard to pick up and play.

Agreed. My 7yo is learning recorder. It's easy enough to get the sounds from it and the instrument cost about a tenner. She can learn something else in a year or two if she shows interest and commitment (and to be fair she willingly picks it up every day for 10/15 minutes - the other bonus of the recorder is that we can leave it sitting on the kitchen table ready to be picked up when she has 5 spare minutes).
JinglingHellsBells · 02/12/2021 18:38

@FlibberdyGibbett

I’ve got an old violin he can use. I just phoned the teacher, she was really nice. She told me the violin is a bit harder though, but we’ll give it a go. She also said she would let me off the two lessons in December as a gesture of goodwill, so that’s very kind of her. She mentioned she was currently studying herself something called the LRSM performance Diploma - does this mean she’s not qualified? I thought I’d ask as a couple of music have posted and therefore might know what this means?
Why not google LRSM and find out for yourself?

Are you saying now that you think she's not qualified therefore she has misjudged your child?

Are these lessons in school or at her home? If they are in school I am sure she has 'passed' the requirements for teaching.

Honestly, @FlibberdyGibbett, as a parent of a child who achieved a high grade in piano, I can assure you that if your son does not practise and you have no piano, he will not progress. It's a sheer waste of time and your money.

Are you forcing him to learn an instrument? Have you actually asked him how he feels?

There is nothing worse than a pushy parent making a child learn something out of their own thwarted ambitions or whatever.

I don't have the feeling your son is being asked what he wants to do.

FlibberdyGibbett · 02/12/2021 18:35

Not sure why so many people are assuming I’m pushing my child into learning a musical (piano or violin)? We talked earlier and it’s what HE wants!! Why shouldn’t he have an opportunity?

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 02/12/2021 18:34

Violin is harder definitely. if you want an easier one try something like the flute.
What size is your old violin? Because if it's too big (and for most 10yos a full size one will be) it can be very frustrating. I speak from experience there.

With your remarks about her "not being qualified" it doesn't sound like you trust her much, so I'm not convinced that learning with the same teacher is a good idea.
She may not be qualified to top level, but she may be excellent with beginners. Dh plays the piano really well. he started with someone who wasn't qualified, but knew when to say he had reached the top of her ability to teach, and then he moved to a more advanced teacher. She was quite eccentric by his description, and partially deaf, but taught brilliantly, but wouldn't have worked with a beginner.

LalalalalalaLand123 · 02/12/2021 18:34

I meant to also say - unless you have an agreement that states otherwise, missed lessons are not refundable or transferrable

Eddielzzard · 02/12/2021 18:32

Unless your Josh actually says to you 'please please mummy I really want to learn the xxx I promise I'll practice each and every day' he probably doesn't want to learn an instrument.

Honestly, without regular practice, he won't progress and won't enjoy it. Violin IS harder than piano.

The best thing you can do is find out how he really feels about all this, and then go with what he says. If he doesn't want to learn, pushing him into it will be a total waste of money.

hulahoopqueen · 02/12/2021 18:28

violin is definitely harder.
have you actually asked your son what he wants to play? or whether he wants to play at all?
unless he has the desire to learn, you're throwing good money down the drain.

Ceci03 · 02/12/2021 18:25

If you want advice, honestly the violin is very hard and to start at aged 10 he most likely won't catch up with his age for a good few years.

A better option would be recorder, which could lead to clarinet or flute...? A recorder is very cheap, he will learn all the fingerings, and how to read music, and then he can transfer to another wind instrument.

Or guitar would be a better option than violin which is very hard to pick up and play.

Staryflight445 · 02/12/2021 18:24

Why are you switching to violin? Why is it so important he does these lessons?

Has he even ever held a violin?

HideousKinky · 02/12/2021 18:23

You don't need a performance diploma to teach but good teachers often have them