Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by piano teacher comments

413 replies

FlibberdyGibbett · 02/12/2021 15:14

My 10 year old son ‘Josh’ has been having piano lessons for six weeks and I have received this text from his teacher.

“Josh seems to be struggling in his lessons. He complains his fingers are tired even after we have just started the lesson. This morning he told me he has been doing too much writing in class beforehand. He seems to talk a lot and doesn’t seem particularly interested. He tells me he practises on his iPad?? I’m not sure the piano is right for Josh, maybe consider a different instrument next term.”

AIBU to feel upset and my son is being unsupported?

OP posts:
CMeredithC · 02/12/2021 19:29

BTW I correct myself as I mistakenly said LRSM is a Level 4 and equivalent of the Year 1 at conservatoire.

LRSM is a Level 5 and equivalent of a Year 2 of a BMus.

You’re judged on performing and stage and written presentation skills, so nothing to do with teaching.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 02/12/2021 19:27

The violin is harder to learn and they sound dreadful when they're new to the instrument ... strongly suggest you be out of the house when he's practicing for a while. Grin

CaribouCarafe · 02/12/2021 19:25

Also just to add to the above. LRSM is the second grade of performance diploma (I.e. above grade 8 standard). It doesn't necessarily mean the teacher is not qualified, only means she hasn't sat the exam. That can be all sorts of factors including opportunity and price.

Also I'd like to add that being a good performer doesn't necessarily translate translate being a good teacher. Especially when it comes to beginners. To find out if she is well qualified to teach, the "proof" would be in her students and their achievements and feedback from their parents.

Case in point, I didn't go to music conservatoire and "only" have DipABRSM (first level) diploma but I have a 100% merit/distinction rate in my students up to grade 8 level and am still receiving referrals.

monkeysox · 02/12/2021 19:24

She's telling you not to waste your money

Summerfun54321 · 02/12/2021 19:22

The guitar might be better for him. Don’t even go there with trying to get a reluctant 10 year old learn the violin! Could you encourage him to join a choir or percussion group as well or instead?

CaribouCarafe · 02/12/2021 19:21

I used to teach piano and violin whilst at uni. I had really good results and got most my students through referrals.

At one point I was oversubscribed and was teaching a kid who was completely unmotivated, didn't practice, was more interested in showing me that she could do handstands rather than play the piano.

When I nicely told her parents that in my final year I was decreasing my workload so that I could focus on my studies and just keeping on the students who were most passionate about piano they then turned rude and said BUT YOU'RE A TEACHER SO YOU SHOULD TEACH, REGARDLESS OF STUDENT. Then threatened to tell everyone they knew that I was a terrible teacher. I just laughed and walked away. It didn't affect my business.

Point is, for every unmotivated student there will be a motivated one who is an actual joy to teach and doesn't make you question what the hell you're doing with your life.

Maybe you should find out what your son is actually interested in doing rather than shoehorning him into the instruments that you feel are most convenient/easily available. Otherwise it really is an almighty waste of time, money and energy for all parties involved

SlavineRichter · 02/12/2021 19:18

@CMeredithC

I’m a professional musician OP, currently working with one of the top 5 orchestras in the world.

I’ve gone from being a 5 year old learning the recorder, through all the learning stages, music degree, performing, competing at international level, teaching kids and adults and everything in between. So this is all coming from my personal experience and professional opinion after years of learning, teaching and doing music.

To answer your most recent question, there is no such thing as a ‘qualified’ music teacher, unless you’re looking for a specific qualification yourself. A performance diploma sits right above Grade 8, and it’s (meant to be an) equivalent to the 1st year at conservatoire, so Level 4.

There are great and awful teachers with diplomas and degrees. There are great and awful teachers without them. There are people who just teach from what they can play, others have gone to conservatoire / done music at uni and are much more qualified on paper, which sometimes translates into practical teaching skills, and sometimes it doesn’t. They do normally have an incredibly higher standard of playing, and many will have taken pedagogy courses during their studies.

Now to the crux of the matter. Does your son know how to read music? Just basic stuff?

10 is not old to start learning an instrument. One of my best friends who is a principal player with the BBC Symphony Orchestra started at 12 and had graduated with honours from Juilliard 10 years later.

You can start music at any age, BUT you don’t teach a four year old the same way you teach a ten year old. The expectations and methods used will be different. At the age of 10 I would expect a student to very quickly learn some music theory because it will be very difficult to explain the technicalities of the instrument and pieces/exercises he’s trying to learn, if he doesn’t know the theory.

If your son can’t read music and hasn’t started doing theory, 90% of what the teacher says will sound like Japanese to him. Music is a foreign language. If I want to write poetry or read novels in Japanese, I first need to learn the characters and how to form words with them.

So it is not surprising that he isn’t very interested, it’s very possible he simply doesn’t understand what she’s asking of him. Of course, a good teacher would tell you this in advance, or would make sure s/he introduces theory concepts in the piano lesson itself. Regularly.

He needs a proper instrument to practise on. And he needs to practise it regularly. If he’s not keen on regular practice, that’s usually a clear sign that maybe formal music learning isn’t for him. This doesn’t mean ruling music out of his life by the way.

The violin is NOT easier than the piano. They are both complex instruments but an extra level of detail, precision and ‘natural ear’ is required for the violin. Because you need to learn how to actually make a note sound. On the piano you just press a key and there it is, perfectly in tune and everything.

Take the violin and bow to the teacher. Let her assess if they’re adequate or not. If she says they’re not good, trust her.

The amount of parents that used to send me links from this manufacturer in Tajikistan with cheap instruments, or photos of their grandma’s old instrument in the attic… If you want your child to learn an instrument, they need to practise on a proper one regularly. The instrument I play has a start value - for a beginner - of £10k. We couldn’t afford one for years so I would practise every lunchtime at school. When I got a bit older I’d also stay for another hour after school.

He might like the violin more than the piano, but if he still doesn’t know where an F# is on the stave, what 6/8 means or what the little numbers on top of the notes are, it will still sound like Japanese.

At 10 I would also expect focus and concentration, unless there are special needs. I had an 11 year old once who was more interested in chatting to me about her upcoming school trip than getting some playing done in the lesson. I gave her mother a similar message as the one you received (albeit in person). Don’t get me wrong, I chat to my students all the time about their schools and friends, but it’s 2-3 mins tops. A lesson is not for chatting.

I am personally not a fan of group lessons either, unless they’re very young. They don’t learn the same way, it goes much slower when there is another child there, because they will have different needs and abilities. Does she offer individual lessons? At least 30 mins a week is what I would recommend. Look into young musicians from a local music college if there is one nearby, as they’re often much more enthusiastic and flexible in teaching methods and techniques.

In short, music is a wonderful hobby and something all kids should be exposed to. But taking regular lessons in one requires dedication, patience, and lots and lots of work. Both on the instrument and off it. There should be respect and enthusiasm towards the teacher, and honesty from both sides if things aren’t quite working out. Your son’s teacher seems honest and caring, so that’s a good start.

This is a fantastic post by someone who really, really knows what she's talking about.
Howshouldibehave · 02/12/2021 19:15

We’ve decided the piano is not for him, so he is switching to violin which should be a bit easier to learn

Riiiight Grin

HubbaBubbaIsMyFavourite · 02/12/2021 19:14

I have three kids, all play two instruments and get classes in those. Things I have learned over the past 6 years:

  • talk to your child; what is bothering them, why is the class not working out. And listen to them. All of my kids started with “classical instruments” mainly because I thought it was the “right thing to do”, but for some kids, it’s not. Now, we have a mix of classical and more “modern” instruments (electrical bass guitar etc)
  • teachers and personalities are really important; they can make or break a good tutoring relationship. Don’t be afraid to cancel and try someone else.
  • I always let them chose, whether to continue or not and they have tried several instruments over the years (we have given up on violin and cello), but they were always clear: once I paid for a period, they were going to do the classes and try their hardest. Gave them responsibility and consideration.

Talk to him; work it out together.

We now play: bass guitar, electric guitar, drums, piano and saxophone

Good luck!

Rinoachicken · 02/12/2021 19:14

Excuse the typos - that would be my tough cello fingers!

XelaM · 02/12/2021 19:14

badly played*

XelaM · 02/12/2021 19:14

Have you never heard the sound of a bafly played violin?! 🙉 omg don't do it

Rinoachicken · 02/12/2021 19:14

If he wasn’t interested enough to practice and build his finger strength for piano, I seriously doubt he will have the willpower and commitment to practice and build calluses on his fingers for playing a strong instrument.

I play the cello. Strings HURT when you first start. You get blisters and sore spots and then after a while your fo gets toughen up snd you’re fine. But there’s a period of pain you have to go through first! That’s on top of aches as you build muscle strength in your arms, shoulders hands and fingers.

Strong instruments are NOT easier to learn.

CoachBeardless · 02/12/2021 19:11

Violin is so much harder than piano!

fumfspos · 02/12/2021 19:09

We’ve decided the piano is not for him, so he is switching to violin which should be a bit easier to learn

Haha... good luck there....
The violin is very difficult at the start. Coordination and fine motor control is essential. You have to have an ear for music as you have to find the positions of the fingers on the strings yourself.
The piano is easier in the initial stages as it's "just" pressing keys. However, it does become difficult quickly once both hands are involved and many people struggle with reading two staves and the coordination of the two hands.

The teacher was honest with you. I think she should have phoned instead of texted but otherwise it's good to be honest and open.

I hope you did not push her too much into giving the money back for the missed lessons due to COVID. That was unfair of you if you did. Read the terms and conditions. I am a music teacher and I have strict terms and conditions - no money back for missed lessons ever. Replacement lessons offered at my discretion and if room on the timetable to allow it.
I can't simply say oh if you're ill etc you get your money back, people just lie. When I first started I did that but found out that kids who were supposedly ill were actually at birthday parties or the swimming pool.
I reserve my time for a pupil each week - they are paying for a time slot. If they do not turn up I can't sell that time to anyone else and would have lost money for every no-show for whatever spurious reason people have.
I simply cannot afford to let people off with refunds every single time they are off. And if you have a policy where they get money back the absence rate tends to be even higher.

Try your child on the violin if you really must but at least pay the woman even if he does have to miss lessons.

Viviennemary · 02/12/2021 19:08

She is telling you he isnt interested, doesn't want to do it and you are wasting your money.

Violinist64 · 02/12/2021 19:06

Their lessons…. Predictive text!

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 02/12/2021 19:06

The violin is much much harder to learn than the piano.

Coreblimy · 02/12/2021 19:05

The LRSM is a level 5, equivalent to the work required for the final year of a BSc. She will presumably already have the Level 4 or equivalent experience. Not that how she plays is necessarily the next indication of whether or not she's a good teacher, and she sounds like she is a good teacher to give you this feedback rather than just pocketing the money for months or years.

The violin is one of, if not the hardest, instrument to learn, definitely harder than the piano.

Violinist64 · 02/12/2021 19:02

@Georgie8, I am glad you have a musical family and all enjoy it but music is about far, far more than graded exams. Those children who you disdainfully say should give up their instruments because they never get further than around grade 3 obviously get something from them lessons. Music should be for everyone. For those of you who are saying that ten is too old to start learning certain instruments l say rubbish. It is never, ever too late. I teach people of all ages and abilities. At one end of the scale l occasionally have children who l think could make a career out of music and at the other l teach people with special needs who gain a great deal of satisfaction from playing simple pieces well. I teach adults too; many of whom have always wanted to play an instrument but never had the opportunity or who are picking up the instrument that they first learned in childhood and want to have another go at. Most people have no aspirations to a musical career but want a satisfying lifelong hobby. For my violin pupils this often means that they enjoy making music with others in amateur orchestras. Music is for everyone.

rosesinmygarden · 02/12/2021 19:00

You sound like a nightmare parent. I can't believe you've expected the teacher to go without pay!

The teacher sounds very honest and incredibly supportive.

Let's hope YOU can support your son with the next instrument.

CMeredithC · 02/12/2021 18:54

I’m a professional musician OP, currently working with one of the top 5 orchestras in the world.

I’ve gone from being a 5 year old learning the recorder, through all the learning stages, music degree, performing, competing at international level, teaching kids and adults and everything in between. So this is all coming from my personal experience and professional opinion after years of learning, teaching and doing music.

To answer your most recent question, there is no such thing as a ‘qualified’ music teacher, unless you’re looking for a specific qualification yourself. A performance diploma sits right above Grade 8, and it’s (meant to be an) equivalent to the 1st year at conservatoire, so Level 4.

There are great and awful teachers with diplomas and degrees. There are great and awful teachers without them. There are people who just teach from what they can play, others have gone to conservatoire / done music at uni and are much more qualified on paper, which sometimes translates into practical teaching skills, and sometimes it doesn’t. They do normally have an incredibly higher standard of playing, and many will have taken pedagogy courses during their studies.

Now to the crux of the matter. Does your son know how to read music? Just basic stuff?

10 is not old to start learning an instrument. One of my best friends who is a principal player with the BBC Symphony Orchestra started at 12 and had graduated with honours from Juilliard 10 years later.

You can start music at any age, BUT you don’t teach a four year old the same way you teach a ten year old. The expectations and methods used will be different. At the age of 10 I would expect a student to very quickly learn some music theory because it will be very difficult to explain the technicalities of the instrument and pieces/exercises he’s trying to learn, if he doesn’t know the theory.

If your son can’t read music and hasn’t started doing theory, 90% of what the teacher says will sound like Japanese to him. Music is a foreign language. If I want to write poetry or read novels in Japanese, I first need to learn the characters and how to form words with them.

So it is not surprising that he isn’t very interested, it’s very possible he simply doesn’t understand what she’s asking of him. Of course, a good teacher would tell you this in advance, or would make sure s/he introduces theory concepts in the piano lesson itself. Regularly.

He needs a proper instrument to practise on. And he needs to practise it regularly. If he’s not keen on regular practice, that’s usually a clear sign that maybe formal music learning isn’t for him. This doesn’t mean ruling music out of his life by the way.

The violin is NOT easier than the piano. They are both complex instruments but an extra level of detail, precision and ‘natural ear’ is required for the violin. Because you need to learn how to actually make a note sound. On the piano you just press a key and there it is, perfectly in tune and everything.

Take the violin and bow to the teacher. Let her assess if they’re adequate or not. If she says they’re not good, trust her.

The amount of parents that used to send me links from this manufacturer in Tajikistan with cheap instruments, or photos of their grandma’s old instrument in the attic… If you want your child to learn an instrument, they need to practise on a proper one regularly. The instrument I play has a start value - for a beginner - of £10k. We couldn’t afford one for years so I would practise every lunchtime at school. When I got a bit older I’d also stay for another hour after school.

He might like the violin more than the piano, but if he still doesn’t know where an F# is on the stave, what 6/8 means or what the little numbers on top of the notes are, it will still sound like Japanese.

At 10 I would also expect focus and concentration, unless there are special needs. I had an 11 year old once who was more interested in chatting to me about her upcoming school trip than getting some playing done in the lesson. I gave her mother a similar message as the one you received (albeit in person). Don’t get me wrong, I chat to my students all the time about their schools and friends, but it’s 2-3 mins tops. A lesson is not for chatting.

I am personally not a fan of group lessons either, unless they’re very young. They don’t learn the same way, it goes much slower when there is another child there, because they will have different needs and abilities. Does she offer individual lessons? At least 30 mins a week is what I would recommend. Look into young musicians from a local music college if there is one nearby, as they’re often much more enthusiastic and flexible in teaching methods and techniques.

In short, music is a wonderful hobby and something all kids should be exposed to. But taking regular lessons in one requires dedication, patience, and lots and lots of work. Both on the instrument and off it. There should be respect and enthusiasm towards the teacher, and honesty from both sides if things aren’t quite working out. Your son’s teacher seems honest and caring, so that’s a good start.

pigsDOfly · 02/12/2021 18:53

If his fingers got tired in piano lessons I can't imagine how tired they'd get trying to wrap themselves around violin strings.

Definitely not easier than piano and takes a lot of dedication to achieve results.

What about singing?

Although if he can't sing that would be a non starter but if he can hold a tune at all he might find it more rewarding than slogging away at an instrument.

MeltedButter · 02/12/2021 18:53

Also she’s just billed me to pay for December lessons, but he missed 2 earlier in the month due to having Covid and she’s basically said she doesn’t carry missed lessons over?!

Sounds reasonable

Yellownotblue · 02/12/2021 18:52

Six weeks is very little time to be drawing a line under an instrument. I would have thought a much longer commitment (at least a year or more) was needed before deciding DS is not interested. The basics are hard to learn - I speak with experience, I’m currently doing Grade 8 and my children are Grade 6 and Grade 4. I think the fun bit really only starts around Grade 5. So learning must absolutely be seen as a very long term commitment. He will reap the benefits later, but it will be years from now. It’s totally worth it though.

However, be warned that the violin is immeasurably more difficult. The piano is a breeze by comparison. I would really try hard and stick with the piano if I were you. If DS later wants to learn the violin, it will be much easier for him as he’ll know how to read music so can concentrate on the technique. It’s very hard to draw a beautiful sound out of a violin.

We’ve had many teachers over the years, and getting the right teacher makes an enormous difference. It may be that you should look for a different teacher, it doesn’t sound like your current one wants to work with complete beginners. It takes a lot of patience.