Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by piano teacher comments

413 replies

FlibberdyGibbett · 02/12/2021 15:14

My 10 year old son ‘Josh’ has been having piano lessons for six weeks and I have received this text from his teacher.

“Josh seems to be struggling in his lessons. He complains his fingers are tired even after we have just started the lesson. This morning he told me he has been doing too much writing in class beforehand. He seems to talk a lot and doesn’t seem particularly interested. He tells me he practises on his iPad?? I’m not sure the piano is right for Josh, maybe consider a different instrument next term.”

AIBU to feel upset and my son is being unsupported?

OP posts:
CaribouCarafe · 02/12/2021 20:26

@TatianaBis dyspraxia isn't necessarily a barrier either - I'm dyspraxic and also know some professional musicians with a dyspraxia diagnosis too.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 20:22

Where are you in the country @Arren12?

I could recommend some teachers depending where you are.

Asd is definitely not a bar as long as she is not dyspraxic too, which, if she’s coordinated enough to be good at art, may not be an issue.

Luredbyapomegranate · 02/12/2021 20:18

@MysteriousMonkey

I think she's trying to be kind and I say that as a mum who has spent thousands on piano lessons for my kids over the last few years. One of them I wish their piano teacher had said this, it's so expensive and if they don't want to practise it's such a waste of money!
This. Talk to him - what does he say. You could ask the teacher to try another 6 weeks if she’s willing, or try a different teacher. But some kids just aren’t up for it - in which case you’re better finding something else.
hedgehogger1 · 02/12/2021 20:17

@Winter2020 what sort of level does simply piano go up to? My DD is about grade 2/3 level but doesn't have lessons any more - went with a different instrument- but still likes to play

GnomeDePlume · 02/12/2021 20:16

[quote Violinist64]@Georgie8, I am glad you have a musical family and all enjoy it but music is about far, far more than graded exams. Those children who you disdainfully say should give up their instruments because they never get further than around grade 3 obviously get something from them lessons. Music should be for everyone. For those of you who are saying that ten is too old to start learning certain instruments l say rubbish. It is never, ever too late. I teach people of all ages and abilities. At one end of the scale l occasionally have children who l think could make a career out of music and at the other l teach people with special needs who gain a great deal of satisfaction from playing simple pieces well. I teach adults too; many of whom have always wanted to play an instrument but never had the opportunity or who are picking up the instrument that they first learned in childhood and want to have another go at. Most people have no aspirations to a musical career but want a satisfying lifelong hobby. For my violin pupils this often means that they enjoy making music with others in amateur orchestras. Music is for everyone.[/quote]
This, with bells on.

Best piece of advice from DBiL was to have musical instruments around which DCs could pick up and play as they wanted.

Also our county music service runs Saturday music schools. Students from early years to 18 participate in various sessions from music theory to instrument lessons. Some may also be having private lessons others are just enjoying making music in a group. There are also choirs of all ages and orchestras.

Both my DDs attended the Saturday morning sessions for a number of years. DS wasnt interested in anything formal but loves picking up a guitar. We often hear bits of Pink Floyd coming from his room when he is practicing.

Dindundundundeeer · 02/12/2021 20:15

@Meadowbreeze

Is your violin even the right size for him?
My DD13 is 5’5 and has recently started to play her Great Grandads violin. It’s full size and on the basis that she is still growing has only recently moved up a size. I wouldn’t expect a 10 year old to fit a full size instrument.
MushMonster · 02/12/2021 20:14

It does not seem to be interesting him at present. That may change.
Have a chat with him, and gather info about whether he still wants to learn, or he is not bothered.
Lessons will not be of much use at all untill he can practice. And a keyboard is not equal to a piano,but close enough.
His fingers will struggle till they get strong enough, so he has to be ready to put up with it.

Notanotheruser111 · 02/12/2021 20:09

Bloody hell. I have 3 children who have learnt the piano (and practice on a keyboard). They are not ever going to be amazing pianists, But they get joy out of their lessons. When they started they often complained of sore fingers. Sometimes they are completely uninterested sometimes they love it. They have learnt so much about the importance of practice, resilience when practicing a harder piece. Their teacher was very unsure when my first started but he became one of her favourite students (not her best) and I think she learnt some lessons about not making assumptions.

Arren12 · 02/12/2021 20:07

Thank you to whose who have answered my questions. I'd tag you but it seems my phone is doing its own thing this evening.

Pascal80 · 02/12/2021 20:03

Speaking as a piano teacher of adults and infant children - your son is neither interested nor has the aptitude to ''wing it'' at lesson. He may have liked the idea of learning to play an instrument, but not the reality, like most people.

Meadowbreeze · 02/12/2021 20:02

Is your violin even the right size for him?

HubbaBubbaIsMyFavourite · 02/12/2021 20:01

@Arren12
My eldest is autistic (piano and electric guitar), my youngest dyslexic (drums)

I found my eldest is technical extremely focussed, and although I thought it unlikely when he started he thrives.
My youngest, although dyslexic reads music really easily, do again proved me wrong.
I think for children with challenges, music brings so many benefits (partially shunt gave mine free reign) as it develops parts of the brain that otherwise might be overlooked. Would TOTALLY recommend….

Dindundundundeeer · 02/12/2021 20:00

We’ve decided the piano is not for him, so he is switching to violin which should be a bit easier to learn

I have to say I did laugh at that. Clearly you’re not a violin player Grin

Violinist64 · 02/12/2021 19:50

@Arren12

Sorry to hijack your thread op.

Can I ask teachers or anyone who might know. My dd has shown an interest in piano for most of her life. She is 8 now. She begged for a keyboard but we only got her a toy one. She messes about with it a few times a week. She has taught herself to read a couple of notes.
There was an electrical piano at a playgroup we recently attended. All the kids were making a din pressing the keys and dd went over and played a pretty decent tune out of nowhere. All the parents were a bit taken aback. I have no enquired about lessons. Not heard back from the company yet.

Thing is we don't have a piano. I had one in my home as a child but my mum gave it away. I'm willing to get one but reluctant before she has had actual lessons because she has form for giving things up. She has tried a few activities and has not enjoyed them as much as she expected. Usually after we have shelled out gor the equipment.

She has stuck at art which she is quite talented at and attends an art school.
She loves singing and has stuck at choir.
Il add she is autistic so won't always understand when I explain. She says it will be fun and she says she knows she will be good at it.
Also to add her writing is poor (although she has worked extremely hard to improve this to an ok level) will this mean she will struggle.
I'm totally non musical, I was forced to play the clarinet as a child and was crap at it. I can't read music. I don't want to waste our money we are not well off.

As l said earlier, music can be for everyone. There are many free or low priced pianos around and piano lessons can be especially good for someone with special needs. I would make enquiries about piano teachers who are good with and understand special needs. Word of mouth is best but local music shops are very useful too. Progress might well be very slow but if your daughter enjoys it then that is all that matters. It will be her thing. If she is autistic, it’s a good idea to tell her that the rule is that she has to practice every day. Parental involvement is even more important in these circumstances. At present l teach an eighteen year old young man who is autistic and went to a special school. He is a joy. He has been learning for around five years and the pleasure he gets from playing simple Christmas carols, for example, is infectious. It has helped him in so many other areas of his life too.
Georgie8 · 02/12/2021 19:48

@Violinist64

You’re absolutely right in what you say. Music should be pursued for enjoyment and grades aren’t necessary. My children didn’t “go through” the grades and only took them when they wanted to.

However, I didn’t “disdainfully” say people should give up if they couldn’t progress beyond grade 3, I was pointing out that usually children don’t progress because they’re not interested anymore, or don’t have the innate talent to take it further despite practising.

Why flog a dead horse -unless, of course you’re being paid to?

Daphnise · 02/12/2021 19:47

The piano is not for your son.

Not even if he had one to play....

Which from what you say he doesn't.

Winter2020 · 02/12/2021 19:45

Hi OP,
I have read your posts and updates and I see that your son has decided to try violin. I hope it goes well.

I just wanted to say if you have an ipad and can get hold of a keyboard then you could give your son the opportunity to try learning with "simply piano". You use it with a keyboard or piano but the ipad and app is the teaching aid. It starts you off right at the beginning (learning one/two notes) but there are backing tracks and pop songs throughout making it fun for kids to learn. My son was very self motivated to learn as the app is such fun

I'm not sure how much it costs now but I think there is a free trial. When my son used it a year subscription was £80 odd which I figured was only a few lessons cost. I think you can also subscribe monthly.

Simply Piano provided a great foundation for my son, he worked his way through it and when he started professional lessons he was pretty much ready to learn his grade 1 pieces. A couple of years on now and he is preparing his pieces to take his grade 8 in spring and playing "Moon River" as I type.

If your son has had a few lessons and no instrument at home I don't think he has had a fair chance. Starting out learning the piano doesn't have to be repeated practice of boring pieces and scales. Perhaps he could play around with teaching himself piano while learning the violin in his lessons. He could even go on to prove his teacher wrong.

Good luck

CMeredithC · 02/12/2021 19:40

@Arren12 is renting a keyboard or piano an option? Could you enquire in some local shops to see if they offer this service? Or if she were to take lessons in school or the local music hub, do they have an instrument she could practise on?

She sounds quite able and she should absolutely give it a go. No reason why her writing should influence her musical skills, not in theory anyway.

For both the OP and everybody else, it is true that knowing a little bit of music yourself helps your kids progress on their respective instruments. But this really shouldn’t be a disadvantage for those children whose parents have no idea about music whatsoever. My family are totally non-musical (except for my mum’s odd church choir outing) and me and my siblings have all become, or are becoming, professional musicians.

The best thing you can do as a non-musical parent is support and encourage your child’s development. Read and learn about what they’re doing and how this whole music world works. Talk to them and ask them questions about their lessons and classes. Ask them to teach you a few things if they want. Praise them on how well they’re working, and inspire them to practise regularly by showing a good work ethic yourself, with things that you struggle or are unfamiliar with.

dropthevipers · 02/12/2021 19:35

@FlibberdyGibbett

Hi thank you for the replies! He was using my sisters piano to practise a couple of times a week until we got our own keyboard sorted.

With regards to the missed lessons he has ‘group tuition’ with another child so I don’t see how the teacher could fill that slot with anyone else I think she should carry them over, but I will pay because that’s the rules!

We’ve decided the piano is not for him, so he is switching to violin which should be a bit easier to learn.

Only problem is it’s the same teacher, she teaches both instruments so not sure how this will pan out! I may give her a call later to have a chat. I have her mobile number from the text message.

As a cello graduate of the Guildhall School of Music and Drama, (and for clarification you also needed to be able to play the piano to grade eight standard to get in, as well as being damn good on your main instrument) I can tell you learning a string instrument is way harder than piano (at least initially). What also rings alarm bells with your post is saying "We have decided....." Are you sure your little lad actually wants to learn an instrument at all, because it does not sound much like it.
Arren12 · 02/12/2021 19:33

Sorry to hijack your thread op.

Can I ask teachers or anyone who might know. My dd has shown an interest in piano for most of her life. She is 8 now. She begged for a keyboard but we only got her a toy one. She messes about with it a few times a week. She has taught herself to read a couple of notes.
There was an electrical piano at a playgroup we recently attended. All the kids were making a din pressing the keys and dd went over and played a pretty decent tune out of nowhere. All the parents were a bit taken aback. I have no enquired about lessons. Not heard back from the company yet.

Thing is we don't have a piano. I had one in my home as a child but my mum gave it away. I'm willing to get one but reluctant before she has had actual lessons because she has form for giving things up. She has tried a few activities and has not enjoyed them as much as she expected. Usually after we have shelled out gor the equipment.

She has stuck at art which she is quite talented at and attends an art school.
She loves singing and has stuck at choir.
Il add she is autistic so won't always understand when I explain. She says it will be fun and she says she knows she will be good at it.
Also to add her writing is poor (although she has worked extremely hard to improve this to an ok level) will this mean she will struggle.
I'm totally non musical, I was forced to play the clarinet as a child and was crap at it. I can't read music. I don't want to waste our money we are not well off.

SlavineRichter · 02/12/2021 19:33

@CaribouCarafe Also I'd like to add that being a good performer doesn't necessarily translate translate being a good teacher

Absolutely!

DickMabutt73962 · 02/12/2021 19:31

Don't be like Josh's mum

SlavineRichter · 02/12/2021 19:31

One of mine started the piano at their request and did a couple of grades but basically didn't like it (didn't do much practice, which was a giveaway). They switched to a big, loud orchestral instrument, and loved it. However, we are a musical family generally, and most children at their school played more than one instrument to a high standard, so learning an instrument was the norm. That also helps. I think it's much harder if you don't play an instrument, read music etc yourself (do you, OP?), as you can't really have any idea of whether Josh is or isn't musically inclined or whether it's just a passing whim. The other thing I'd say is that with a younger child, you have to supervise practice actively, which is much harder if you don't really know what's going on. It's also time consuming, and you both have to be really dedicated. At the start, the majority of children left to practise on their own will just reinforce mistakes - they tend to play the pieces over and over again, but don't improve despite the amount of time spent. Real practice sometimes means playing the same few bars over and over again until they're right; practising the piece backwards; starting mid bar on the second page; practising only the scale passages or trills; and so on. My DC who's now a pianist outstripped me years ago, but for a long time, the fact that I was competent made a very big difference to their rate of progress.

turnaroundtime · 02/12/2021 19:30

@FlibberdyGibbett

I’ve got an old violin he can use. I just phoned the teacher, she was really nice. She told me the violin is a bit harder though, but we’ll give it a go. She also said she would let me off the two lessons in December as a gesture of goodwill, so that’s very kind of her. She mentioned she was currently studying herself something called the LRSM performance Diploma - does this mean she’s not qualified? I thought I’d ask as a couple of music have posted and therefore might know what this means?
I rarely think or say this but OP, you sound like really hard work. First you criticise the teacher for being rude and harsh. Then you complain that she is charging you for sessions when your dc was unable to attend even though you accept that she wouldn't be able to fill them and would therefore lose income. After speaking with her you realise she is actually really nice and she even lets you off paying the 2 sessions but now you launch into questioning her ability to teach. I would rather not teach any of your dc tbh
dancinfeet · 02/12/2021 19:29

I have kids who do this in dance class- spend most of the lesson procrastinating, trying to avoid actually doing anything etc and complaining about trivial stuff. If he is not interested in learning the piano then the teacher is 100% right.