Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by piano teacher comments

413 replies

FlibberdyGibbett · 02/12/2021 15:14

My 10 year old son ‘Josh’ has been having piano lessons for six weeks and I have received this text from his teacher.

“Josh seems to be struggling in his lessons. He complains his fingers are tired even after we have just started the lesson. This morning he told me he has been doing too much writing in class beforehand. He seems to talk a lot and doesn’t seem particularly interested. He tells me he practises on his iPad?? I’m not sure the piano is right for Josh, maybe consider a different instrument next term.”

AIBU to feel upset and my son is being unsupported?

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 03/12/2021 10:09

@Arethechildreninbedyet

Stop lessons for now. If he says hes still interested get him the second hand keyboard, see if he has any interested in practicing alone and if he does restart lessons.

If he doesn’t resell the keyboard and look for a new hobby.

I agree with this.

Have the instrument around the house. If the kid’s interested, he’ll start to play it. Then maybe start lessons.

My daughter wanted a guitar for her 15th birthday. My wife said, “Total waste of money. She’ll never play it.”

My attitude was “true - if she’s got it she might not play it. But if she hasn’t got it, she certainly won’t play it.”

It sat in the corner of her bedroom for months, collecting dust. But then, because it was there, she started to pick it up.

She’s nineteen now and writing songs. She has absolutely no music theory and doesn’t even know the names of most of the chords she’s discovered. Maybe she’ll decide to learn the more formal stuff later - but whether she does or not, she plays most days and she enjoys it. And that’s what matters with music

honkytonkheroe · 03/12/2021 08:53

Get him in the bag pipes or a French horn. Ideal starter instruments!

AdmiralCain · 03/12/2021 07:40

@Billybagpuss next you'll be saying you're an old wycliffian!!
i'm greatful to Mrs D's lessons, I still have a piano and I have improved, I like classical, I can play some Debussy, Beethoven Moonlight sonata and Satie. When I retire I'd like to dedicate myself to it way more. How strange 30 years on we should have had the same music teacher!

50ShadesOfCatholic · 03/12/2021 05:55

@Arren12

We can afford tuition just but this would only be school lessons sorry I should have said that above.

We are limited for space so can't get a piano straight away like I mentioned above. I would definitely commit to making space if she showed commitment and promise.

It was a nice thought as I do think she would be good but its not the end of the world.

She has her art. Shes actually a talented drawer and artist as a consequence of her autism.

I just wanted her to have the opportunity to try piano because she needs the outlet as she's not well at the moment and I can see it helps her to have an outlet she enjoys.

This thread has massively put me off or made me see sense. Such is life

It shouldn't put you off. Posters in here are notoriously unpleasant, they go out of their way to try to make others feel inadequate and undeserving of anything nice.

Children are learning, that is indeed the point of being a child. A professional teacher will treat a learner with respect, and fully involve the family. This teacher is obviously somewhat lacking in professionalism. But there are good ones out there.

Robin233 · 03/12/2021 03:57

Josh maybe asking to play an instrument but his actions tell a different story
I learnt piano and looked forward to my lessons
I used to practice over an hour every day and often more.
I even played for fun rather than tv.
I enjoyed it.
I did start off with the recorder and played in assembly at school so I could already easily read music.
How can his fingers get tired?
It really isn't the hobby for him - football?

Robin233 · 03/12/2021 03:39

**grandmother

Robin233 · 03/12/2021 03:32

@Evvyjb

The violin is worse. A million times worse.

I say this as a bloody good musician who with years of lessons, was only ever competent at best at violin. It is HARD.

%^^^
This
My said this abs she played piano to such a standard that she played in church (NEVER play the violin again).

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/12/2021 01:38

@spottybananar

I was a piano teacher before stopping a few years ago. I actually stopped because too many parents these days came into two categories/ the prospective Beethoven's. It didn't matter how bad their dc were at the piano (and yes you can just be bad unfortunately) they expected their dc to be the best at piano regardless. And the second category, the annoying parents who insisted their dc should keep trying.

It really is not a skill that you desperately need to have. It should always be a skill you want to have. A good piano teacher in my humble opinion will be honest and say if piano just isn't for you/your dc. We know pretty much by lesson 2 if you've got a natural aptitude and by lesson 6 if the dc is constantly moaning or unhappy forget it, it's a painful experience on both sides.

No one failed anywhere, the right thing to do is either try another teacher if you really believe the next Beethoven is in your dc or listen and try another hobby.
Think about it, it's not exactly in the piano teachers interests to point out you need to stop paying them.
I taught for nearly two decades and over that time parents went from being respectful, to extremely demanding. I don't know why but it was definitely a trend and not a good one. You're better off finding something your dc absolutely loves and can't wait to turn up for, you'll all be a lot happier.

Hah! Now I know why the piano teacher DD has likes me. I said, "she's not going to be Mozart but she's improving". And if she doesn't practice, her teacher will cancel her in a heartbeat.

He's old school. I like it and bizarrely, DD does too.

Music isn't for being Beethoven. As far as I'm concerned it's a good discipline that teaches you that work makes beauty. You put in the time, you will get literally applauded. And that's a virtuous circle.

SD1978 · 03/12/2021 00:06

Missed lesson make ups are of the teacher is unable to attend, not your child. He doesn't have a keyboard, so can't be practising much and complains from early on in the lesson that he's got tired fingers........I'd say the feedback is reasonable. Maybe buy the keyboard first and then find a different teacher, as they obviously don't feel your son is motivated.

ImNotReallyHere · 02/12/2021 23:47

Oh and just read pps comments about sitting with them for practice. I always did that. When DD was ur son's age, we had a little busking box next to her violin. when we saw her practising we'd throw in coppers usually but the odd 50p. It did help encourage her to practice.

ImNotReallyHere · 02/12/2021 23:38

I'm surprised by the amount of people saying that 10 is too old OP. It's never too late.

Violin is hard though. DD14 started at around 6 at her request and had lessons until lockdown. As lessons got cancelled she borrowed a guitar and taught herself that and started playing on her Toys r us keyboard. One year on and she's doing really well and started GCSE music playing the guitar and keyboard. Just bought an electric piano and despite not having lessons, I think the years of violin have helped her develop a sense of tone. Sometimes kids need to try a few instruments until they figure out what suits them. And that changes as they get older too

Rinoachicken · 02/12/2021 23:35

@Arren12

Could you look at hiring a piano for now? Digital pianos take less space and it’s less important where they are placed in the house (you can wear headphones and they won’t go out of tune with temp and humidity etc so can go anywhere).

Then if she doesn’t keep it up then it just goes back and no one has lost out - she’s had a nice opportunity but you aren’t out of pocket. If she does persevere then you may be able to buy it after a certain amount of time, or you’ll know it’s worth investing in one.

Bellie710 · 02/12/2021 23:35

My DD10 plays the guitar, she was advised to play 15 minutes 3 or 4 times a week to start with but plays over an hour every day, she absolutely loves it. At her last lesson she played him lots of songs she had printed off and learned herself.
His response to this was to tell me how amazing it was that she was so keen and playing so much as most of the kids he taught didn't want to be there and had no interest in learning an instrument.
I think the teacher is trying to tell you he isn't interested, god knows how he gets tired hands playing piano? I played both violin and piano and violin is so much harder than piano and your fingers actually hurt!

Dancingonmoonlight · 02/12/2021 23:30

I'd thank a piano teacher who said this to me. One of my children insists they want to learn. Four years later and still hasn't managed Grade 1. I feel like I'm throwing money away every term. I've pleaded with DC to quit but DC is insistent they want to play. Not helped by the current piano teacher praising them.

BertramLacey · 02/12/2021 23:08

Just to add to the above, for 2 of my students the piano was set up in the parents bedroom. In one house it was set up in the hallway. I've also seen some creative living room configurations to make it work (involving wheels)!

My OH got rid of a sofa to accommodate a piano Grin. Tbh the piano looks nicer than the grotty old sofa and the piano stool is more comfortable than it was, so it was a bit of a win really. Plus there is another sofa.

Dimondsareforever · 02/12/2021 23:08

Hurrah! A teacher being honest rather than taking your money. Move onto something he is interested in. If he is not interested in 6 weeks then what are you expecting??
Or would you rather she say nothing, take your money and your child take no interest and no progress?

CMeredithC · 02/12/2021 23:06

@Arren12 don’t give up. This thread might seem quite negative, but it’s also been a space where many parents who have seen their children through decades of music lessons, have shared their views on how time- and resource-consuming it all is.

The music education system in the UK is flawed, to start with, and it’s perfectly normal to feel overwhelmed when reading how difficult or expensive it could be to start.

I do not believe every child needs to own an instrument before starting lessons. What they need is access to one regularly, so there can be practice between the lessons, which will give a much better idea about the child’s potential on that instrument.

I didn’t have an instrument at the beginning, I practised at school and later on at music school. Then we rented an instrument for a year. If you have a music service or hub in your county, they might rent the practice rooms during the week, or have recommendations about churches who might let you go in, eg for 15 mins each day on the way back from school, to practise a bit on their piano or keyboard.

There are ways around it. Or there should be ways around it. Music remains an elitist hobby in the UK but this shouldn’t put anyone off giving their child the opportunity. If you’re happy to encourage your daughter and give this a try, there are ways around it that don’t involve spending thousands on instruments just yet.

In the country I come from, music education is free for everybody, up until the age of 18. Each little village and town has a (national curriculum-regulated) music school where young kids start, and at about 12 they all move up to the closest city or large town. There are between 6 and 16 hours of tuition a week, according to the level, and it’s all paid by the state, free for everybody. Kids practise there and it’s not unusual to see them leave the music school at about 9pm on half the weekdays, because it’s their space and they’re encouraged to spend as much time as they want there.

My mum was a part-time cleaner, and I’ve become a professional musician thanks to an amazing system that gives all kids equal opportunity. I so wish the UK - and all other countries - will adopt such a system soon. I so wish this will happen during my lifetime. Not just music, but arts and sports and everything kids should have access to, regardless of their parents’ income.

So don’t give up. Give it a go, see if your daughter likes it, take it one step at a time. It doesn’t have to be expensive, although I guess it will always be a daunting world, this music one!

milkyaqua · 02/12/2021 23:04

@FlibberdyGibbett

Not sure why so many people are assuming I’m pushing my child into learning a musical (piano or violin)? We talked earlier and it’s what HE wants!! Why shouldn’t he have an opportunity?
Oh my god. It's what he says he wants. Her very kind email suggests strongly the facts are otherwise.

I'll give you a free tip: he doesn't want to learn the violin either.

If his fingers are 'too tired' to engage in piano lessons, then there is no way his fingers, his concentration, or his intention will manage with the far more strenuous learning of the violin.

spottybananar · 02/12/2021 22:59

I was a piano teacher before stopping a few years ago. I actually stopped because too many parents these days came into two categories/ the prospective Beethoven's. It didn't matter how bad their dc were at the piano (and yes you can just be bad unfortunately) they expected their dc to be the best at piano regardless.
And the second category, the annoying parents who insisted their dc should keep trying.

It really is not a skill that you desperately need to have. It should always be a skill you want to have. A good piano teacher in my humble opinion will be honest and say if piano just isn't for you/your dc. We know pretty much by lesson 2 if you've got a natural aptitude and by lesson 6 if the dc is constantly moaning or unhappy forget it, it's a painful experience on both sides.

No one failed anywhere, the right thing to do is either try another teacher if you really believe the next Beethoven is in your dc or listen and try another hobby.
Think about it, it's not exactly in the piano teachers interests to point out you need to stop paying them.
I taught for nearly two decades and over that time parents went from being respectful, to extremely demanding. I don't know why but it was definitely a trend and not a good one. You're better off finding something your dc absolutely loves and can't wait to turn up for, you'll all be a lot happier.

Beachbreak2411 · 02/12/2021 22:58

6 weeks is a fairly long time in a kids life. If he’s practising on an iPad 🤔 why sign him up if you can’t provide the instrument? My dd had violin lessons for 3 years and she decided it wasn’t for her.. she’s just started flute and absolutely adores it, practises every night and would never say her hands hurt (even when they do!) she does strengthening exercises to help her play. Your sons teacher sounds totally reasonable not wanting to waste your money and her time on a child who isn’t interested and parents who haven’t got him something to practise on!

MyDogLovesBiscuits · 02/12/2021 22:52

Don't know if it's been mentioned at all as I've only read OP replies for the most part but, you don't have to be a fully qualified teacher to be able to teach music well.

I know a few musicians who are very good at what they do and know all the technical stuff as they were properly trained in music schools who teach as spare income. Their students normally do very well from what I understand.

At that age learning new things sounds really exciting till you actually start doing it. Then they realise that it is harder than expected and sore for the guitar or violin because you need to build up callouses. I did have a little lol at thinking violin would be the easier instrument to play, sorry!

It actually sounds like he isn't really that interested in learning to play an instrument as much as it sounds like a vague it would be nice if I could play kind of sentiment.

If you are struggling financially I would kindly suggest you park the music lessons for now, they really are only worth it if your child is committed to them off their own back. If you or the teacher are having to keep pulling their attention back to leaning it's obviously not for him.

Also if he is participating in a group lesson and he is chatting instead of paying attention or playing, I expect it is disrupting the other child who shares the lesson time too. That's not really very fair to anyone IMO, your boy wants to be doing something else, the teacher wants to spend her time on children who actively want to learn and the other child wants to learn Piano not talk about iPads or whatever the topic of the week is.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 22:52

@Arren12

Do you know anyone whose piano she could practice on for the first few weeks?

As she’s keen it’s worth looking around for someone good rather than taking pot luck with whoever happens to teach at school. She’s much more likely to enjoy and progress if you find someone good.

SlavineRichter · 02/12/2021 22:47

@Arren12

We can afford tuition just but this would only be school lessons sorry I should have said that above.

We are limited for space so can't get a piano straight away like I mentioned above. I would definitely commit to making space if she showed commitment and promise.

It was a nice thought as I do think she would be good but its not the end of the world.

She has her art. Shes actually a talented drawer and artist as a consequence of her autism.

I just wanted her to have the opportunity to try piano because she needs the outlet as she's not well at the moment and I can see it helps her to have an outlet she enjoys.

This thread has massively put me off or made me see sense. Such is life

I honestly wouldn't just give up, @Arren12 I'm drastically limited for space, and my entire sitting room is taken up by a piano. But a small upright wouldn't take a huge amount of space, and it would give your DD chance to play around a bit with it and you could see if her interest persists. If it didn't, you could re-sell it/give it away. The main thing would be not to spend a fortune in the first place, as you're not sure.
CaribouCarafe · 02/12/2021 22:45

Just to add to the above, for 2 of my students the piano was set up in the parents bedroom. In one house it was set up in the hallway. I've also seen some creative living room configurations to make it work (involving wheels)!

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/12/2021 22:43

OP - why does he want to learn to play?
My mother forced me to learn the piano - I persevered wasn’t really the best but there was a moment where it clicked and I wanted to practice. I loved the way it made me feel, I can’t explain it. Every note, every touch every tone.

Many kids want an instrument because it looks cool but they haven’t really been awakened yet. Try letting your son get a feel for music first

Swipe left for the next trending thread