Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset by piano teacher comments

413 replies

FlibberdyGibbett · 02/12/2021 15:14

My 10 year old son ‘Josh’ has been having piano lessons for six weeks and I have received this text from his teacher.

“Josh seems to be struggling in his lessons. He complains his fingers are tired even after we have just started the lesson. This morning he told me he has been doing too much writing in class beforehand. He seems to talk a lot and doesn’t seem particularly interested. He tells me he practises on his iPad?? I’m not sure the piano is right for Josh, maybe consider a different instrument next term.”

AIBU to feel upset and my son is being unsupported?

OP posts:
Bpickle1 · 02/12/2021 17:21

He can't practise on an iPad and a keyboard isn't much good either. Piano will take lots of practise and discipline and hard work, consider if your son is up to this.

Mortgagetransfer · 02/12/2021 17:19

we are struggling a bit financially- I realise this is not her problem.

Well then why book piano lessons and buy a keyboard for a child that isn’t interested? And his teacher would also be struggling too if she didn’t get paid!

RussianSpy101 · 02/12/2021 17:18

If you’re struggling financially, I would stop the lessons. You don’t doesn’t sound interested at all and he doesn’t have anything to practise on at home.

VodselForDinner · 02/12/2021 17:18

I think that text was very constructive. She’s giving you very straightforward feedback.

Sounds like she wants to put a stop to her time being wasted, and your money.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 17:13

@BertramLacey

You should have bought a piano before starting lessons, pointless otherwise.

Very few people can go out and just buy a piano, doubly so if they don't know how long the child might persist with learning. Honestly, is MN just full of insanely rich people who have know idea what it's like to be on an average income?

OP if you do want to continue and it turns out he is keen, you could hire a piano. Sometimes you can then put the hire cost towards buying it if it turns out the child really is keen to learn. I realise that may also be a push financially and just mention it as a possibility.

And that’s fine. But if you can’t afford a piano there’s no point paying for lessons unless he can arrange to practise in school.

There are cheaper smaller instruments that would be easier to pick up at that age, and potentially could be leant one by the school.

BertramLacey · 02/12/2021 17:13

know no idea.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 17:12

@freezingtoes12

Whoever said 10 is old to learn an instrument - are you okay!???

I started flute at 11 with no experience musically. I got my grade 8 when I was 16.

The flute is a single clef instrument and relatively easy. The two hands of the piano is challenging particularly if you haven’t learnt to sight read either clef yet.

I started 2 instruments when I was 3 which is fairly standard in E.Europe and E.Asia. I would not have wanted to start the piano at 10.

BertramLacey · 02/12/2021 17:12

You should have bought a piano before starting lessons, pointless otherwise.

Very few people can go out and just buy a piano, doubly so if they don't know how long the child might persist with learning. Honestly, is MN just full of insanely rich people who have know idea what it's like to be on an average income?

OP if you do want to continue and it turns out he is keen, you could hire a piano. Sometimes you can then put the hire cost towards buying it if it turns out the child really is keen to learn. I realise that may also be a push financially and just mention it as a possibility.

MrsFin · 02/12/2021 17:07

Playing the keyboard and playing the piano aren't the same thing.
You can learn the notes on a keyboard, but playing requires a completely different technique.

freezingtoes12 · 02/12/2021 17:06

Whoever said 10 is old to learn an instrument - are you okay!???

I started flute at 11 with no experience musically. I got my grade 8 when I was 16.

Skyll · 02/12/2021 17:05

A keyboard isn’t any good for piano practice though?

underneaththeash · 02/12/2021 17:04

You should have bought a piano before starting lessons, pointless otherwise.

Bagamoyo1 · 02/12/2021 17:03

I agree OP that the wording is harsh and abrupt, and the point could have been made more sensitively. But I think the teacher is right. After only 6 weeks it should still be novel and exciting for him, and if he’s making excuses already then it’s not a good sign. If money is tight, I would seriously reconsider buying a keyboard.

BeaMends · 02/12/2021 17:03

Wild stab in the dark, but he's not hypermobile by any chance? How are his handwriting and fine motor skills?

Hypermobile children often find using their hands uncomfortable after any length of time.

Piggy42 · 02/12/2021 17:01

How can he practice without a piano, or at least a keyboard?!

cherrypie66 · 02/12/2021 16:59

The teacher knows he doesn't want to do it. Why are you forcing your child to do a hobby he doesn't enjoy

Shewholovedthethebanhills · 02/12/2021 16:58

You know that the lesson fees are her income, right? You’ve booked her time, she was available, you couldn’t come - if everyone expected to opt out of paying in that situation she wouldn’t be able to pay rent/mortgage etc. If you can’t afford the lessons then just stop. If you can afford them then you’re being incredibly unreasonable to want to skip paying for the ones you miss.

Nowomenaroundeh · 02/12/2021 16:58

I think she's being quite decent. She could just keep taking your money. I am a teacher (not piano) and I would do this too if a student is not engaged. I don't like to see parents wasting money.

A call might have been kinder yes. But I have learned the hard way that some parents put no value on your time and will expect multiple lengthy phonecalls to discuss the same thing.

Miriam101 · 02/12/2021 16:57

WOW totally missed the iPad revelation, sorry. In that case I think it's unfair to judge him ...

Malbecfan · 02/12/2021 16:57

I'm in the "it's good that she's honest and polite camp" but need to state that I teach 5 students an instrument alongside my normal classroom music teaching, so am not necessarily impartial.

Email is by far the easiest way to communicate. If this teacher works in a primary school, she probably isn't allowed to access her phone during the day, so she can't call you then. If she's anything like the majority of visiting music teachers that I've been privileged to work alongside, she almost certainly goes home from school to an evening of a few hours' of private teaching. By the time she has eaten something, it's getting a bit late to start contacting parents by phone. If she phones and you don't pick up, she will then get lots of "I've got a missed call from you"-type messages. Sod it, email is much easier. You can send it when it's convenient and reply when it suits you.

I agree with others about having an instrument to practice on. It's absolutely vital. A few minutes' practice every day is far better than half an hour the night before a lesson. I'm lucky that my 5 are honest with me. 3 of them are y11/12 and life has the habit of getting in the way so if they haven't done a lot of work since the last lesson, they tell me and I change the focus of the lesson accordingly.

OP, talk to Josh. Make it clear that if he really wants to do piano, he has to put some work in, ideally on an actual piano. If he would rather do something else, talk it through and move forward that way.

IncompleteSenten · 02/12/2021 16:56

It's good.
She's telling you he's not really that interested. Don't carry on wasting your money.

TatianaBis · 02/12/2021 16:55

@Couchpotato3

As a piano teacher, I find it incredibly frustrating trying to teach a child who has no instrument to practise on at home. It is an almost impossible task, and no-one can learn a new skill in half an hour a week. The majority of the work goes on BETWEEN lessons. Your son hasn't had a fair chance because you set him up to fail by not providing an instrument from the outset. Every lesson will be like Groundhog Day for him and the teacher because he will have made zero progress from the outset. It doesn't sound as though he is enjoying it at all anyway - the 'my fingers hurt/feel tired' is nonsense - it is just his way of saying that he doesn't want to be there. The teacher has given him a fair try, but after six weeks, it is fair enough to give you the honest feedback that you need. "My son isn't being supported" - that's right - you, yes you, are the one not supporting him. What on earth did you expect? Would you expect a child to learn to play a sport without any equipment or learn to read without any books?
V good post.
Miriam101 · 02/12/2021 16:55

Speaking as someone whose parents diligently paid for a million music lessons when I sincerely didn't want them but didn't have the guts to tell them, I think you're lucky the teacher has been this direct with you. Yes, she could have softened it a bit but maybe politeness isn't her thing: ultimately she's probably doing you a favour and saving you lots of money. Talk to him- maybe there's another instrument that'd suit him better?

User5252727 · 02/12/2021 16:54

I agree it's worded a bit brusquely. But it is honest, which is helpful. I would have a chat with your son about whether he really wants to continue or not.

fromdownwest · 02/12/2021 16:53

As someone who was forced to play the piano as a child, I wish my teacher had seen the absolute lack of enthusiasm I had for the thing!