Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....

345 replies

Rissole · 02/12/2021 14:32

.....or whatever time period was deemed appropriate. Wouldn't that rid us of Covid once and for all as it would die out?

All we would have to do is get enough food in for the time period and stay in. A collective whole world self isolation. Job done!

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 22:43

@ThePoisonousMushroom

I don’t think it’s that interesting though, because it’s so preposterous (and I’m not particularly talking about the U.K. here, but globally) it’s not actually worth thinking through properly.
Sure! All the threads here are optional. If it doesn't interest you, don't read/post. I think it's interesting hence my several posts on this thread. I don't mind preposterous when it comes to hypotheticals.
ThePoisonousMushroom · 02/12/2021 22:40

I don’t think it’s that interesting though, because it’s so preposterous (and I’m not particularly talking about the U.K. here, but globally) it’s not actually worth thinking through properly.

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 22:38

@Bluntness100

It’s totally impossible, what if your house floods, the power goes out, a tree comes down on your house, where will all the electricians and plumbers stay, the tree surgeons, the emergency services, think of all the things you could possibly need in an emergency, how could all those people isolate.

Then think of all the peoooe who would refuse. The folks who think Covid is a conspiracy, that bill gates is trying to micro chip them, the people who would go out and loot, vandalise, it’s simply impossible. The drug addicts needing their fix, the alchoholics needing theirs.

The tree-house people would just have to make the best of it. No-one is coming out. It's a global lockdown.

But yes, of course it's absolutely impossible. It's nothing more than an interesting hypothetical.

expat101 · 02/12/2021 22:37

I said this repeatedly to my extended family o/s.

But I have people in my family who feel they shouldn't have to stop living how they want to, and that its a crime how Aussie & NZ have ''locked'' up their citizens etc, so I figure if I can't get my family to agree, how on earth would all of the World's Govts agree to the same concept?

VikingOnTheFridge · 02/12/2021 22:37

Shitloads more. See water discussions.

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 22:36

There is more to life than food. No utilities would mean no one could cook or store lots of food.
And no utilities would mean people would die because they could not run C-PAP machines or nebulisers at home. Or they would not be allowed to get the medication that they can only get daily or weekly. Or the meds that needed to be in the fridge would be dangerous to use.
Feeling suicidal? Well, the Samaritans you would usually call were forced to stay at home.

I think the key workers would have to isolate at work to keep the utilities running as well as possible. I don't know how realistic that is though.

Medications would have to be given out in three week supplies.

The Samaritans can work from home surely, they're only on the phone.

People would die, but would it be more or less than have/will die from Covid? That's the calculation I suppose.

XenoBitch · 02/12/2021 22:29

I understand some/most people would die if literally starved for three weeks, but realistically surely basic rations could be handed out? You don't need a full, normal shop to get through three weeks. A billion people with literally nothing is quite a lot

There is more to life than food. No utilities would mean no one could cook or store lots of food.
And no utilities would mean people would die because they could not run C-PAP machines or nebulisers at home. Or they would not be allowed to get the medication that they can only get daily or weekly. Or the meds that needed to be in the fridge would be dangerous to use.
Feeling suicidal? Well, the Samaritans you would usually call were forced to stay at home.

VikingOnTheFridge · 02/12/2021 22:29

1 billion possibly is too low yeah.

Also, people who don't have sufficient access to clean water for the 3 weeks aren't going to just stay in and accept that, steadfastly watching their under 5s die off. They're going to get out there and try to get clean water from someone else.

Bluntness100 · 02/12/2021 22:28

It’s totally impossible, what if your house floods, the power goes out, a tree comes down on your house, where will all the electricians and plumbers stay, the tree surgeons, the emergency services, think of all the things you could possibly need in an emergency, how could all those people isolate.

Then think of all the peoooe who would refuse. The folks who think Covid is a conspiracy, that bill gates is trying to micro chip them, the people who would go out and loot, vandalise, it’s simply impossible. The drug addicts needing their fix, the alchoholics needing theirs.

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 22:23

[quote Chessie678]@NuffSaidSam
No idea if 1 billion is plausible but 821m people in the world are hungry according to unicef and 150m children are stunted. These people don’t have enough food at the best of times. If they started a three week lockdown starving it could well kill them or leave them so weak they were unable to work to sustain themselves afterwards. Plus the affect of no wages for three weeks in developing countries would kill a lot more. Even pausing routine preventative healthcare like vaccinations and administration of anti parasitics for three weeks could kill millions if repeated across the whole world.[/quote]
It would have to involve wealthy countries supporting others through it. But obviously some of those people are in areas where aid just can't get through (and that's the reason why we all know it would never actually work because that kind of agreement is impossible, at least until we all live under one global dictatorship anyway).

Pedalpushers · 02/12/2021 22:22

Sounds like the concept to the next Purge film.

lljkk · 02/12/2021 22:21

1 billion might be too low.

People without safe drinking water live in countries where the govt is unaccountable. Those governments certainly couldn't organise mass food & water deliveries to last 3 weeks; the elite would trouser the money in Swiss bank accounts & feck off to leave masses to their fate. The masses live in shanties too small to hold 3 weeks worth of supplies.

There may not be enough small sterilised water containers in the world to hold 3 weeks of drinking water supplies for everyone. The logistical operation to get the supplies to everyone -- would take years of planning assuming corruption didn't consume most the budget.

What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....
DockOTheBay · 02/12/2021 22:19

We wouldn't have water, electricity, refuse collection, internet, police force, emergency medical services, fire services.... sounds great

Chessie678 · 02/12/2021 22:18

@NuffSaidSam
No idea if 1 billion is plausible but 821m people in the world are hungry according to unicef and 150m children are stunted. These people don’t have enough food at the best of times. If they started a three week lockdown starving it could well kill them or leave them so weak they were unable to work to sustain themselves afterwards. Plus the affect of no wages for three weeks in developing countries would kill a lot more. Even pausing routine preventative healthcare like vaccinations and administration of anti parasitics for three weeks could kill millions if repeated across the whole world.

Arethechildreninbedyet · 02/12/2021 22:10

It wouldn’t work, regardless of child care, essential workers etc but that three weeks simply wouldn’t be long enough to kill off a worldwide virus.

There will be cases where incubation will exceed three weeks.

Say a household of four went into this isolation, ABCD.

A has Covid on day one, A infects B will Covid on day eight. B infects C with Covid on day fifteen, C infects D on day 20. The household are all a symptomatic.

The 21 day lifts and D carries on their merry way coming into contact and reinfecting those around them.

After three weeks of NO external exposure the public’s immune systems are on the floor and Covid once again spreads like wild fire.

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 22:09

*You live in a place with no running water.

The electricity stopped working so even if you have running water, the procedures to filter & chlorinate it have stopped working correctly. No one has a clue if your water is full of E.Coli & cryptosporidium since all the testing has stopped.

Now does it make sense why you won't last 3 weeks?

And some people couldn't last more than 5-8 days without calories. Small children for instance, or elderly fragile.*

I think the water people and other essential services would have to isolate at work. Plus everyone is issued with a supply of bottled water.

I understand some/most people would die if literally starved for three weeks, but realistically surely basic rations could be handed out? You don't need a full, normal shop to get through three weeks. A billion people with literally nothing is quite a lot.

lljkk · 02/12/2021 22:04

No electricity so no point in having most health professionals at the hospital. Let 'em go home.

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 22:04

@PickAChew

Imagine doing that and something like storm Arwen landing in the middle of it.
And as it's a global lockdown it would be likely that somewhere was experiencing a storm/flood/wildfire etc at the time.
XenoBitch · 02/12/2021 22:03

@OhPeeQueue

Maybe not leave homes, but not leave their local towns? I think that would work.
How would that work? Does Covid see the border of a town and suddenly stop and go "nope!"?
lljkk · 02/12/2021 22:03

@NuffSaidSam

A billion people in three weeks? That can't be right.

You might be hungry but you're unlikely to starve to death in three weeks unless you had absolutely nothing and even then I think you could survive three weeks.

(I'm not suggesting that we should let people nearly starve btw)

You live in a place with no running water.

The electricity stopped working so even if you have running water, the procedures to filter & chlorinate it have stopped working correctly. No one has a clue if your water is full of E.Coli & cryptosporidium since all the testing has stopped.

Now does it make sense why you won't last 3 weeks?

And some people couldn't last more than 5-8 days without calories. Small children for instance, or elderly fragile.

PickAChew · 02/12/2021 22:01

Imagine doing that and something like storm Arwen landing in the middle of it.

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 21:59

So drs and nurses can work, cool, how do they get to work? On the bus? So bus drivers can work. But what about fuel for said buses? Tankers you say? So tanker drivers can work, and fuel station workers.

No, I think they'd have to isolate at the hospital. So no buses needed. No fuel for buses needed. No service stations.

Now, let’s assume that everyone has the facilities to store enough food for three weeks (ridiculous assumption, but let’s run with it). Lots of it would be frozen, so better not let the power go out, so power workers can work. Oh and water, can’t go without water, so water workers can work.

No, the food would have to be dried/tinned I think. Water is tricky. I think the water workers would also have to isolate at work. Everyone is issued with an emergency supply of bottled water.

We’ve all bought three weeks worth of food, so supermarkets can close, but, once they open, there’s gonna be bit of demand, so we’ll be needing food factory workers to make sure stocks are available. And farmers will have to work cos we can’t just let the animals die.

Farmers normally live in their farms right? So that's fine. I think we'd have to accept short term shortages after the global lockdown...not sure how that would work.

Speaking of animals, what about vets!

They're closed. Animals would have to wait or die.

Oh, and all these people working, who’ll be looking after their kids?

This would have to pre-arranged and the kids isolate with whoever is looking after them if their parents are isolating at work.

I could go on, but you get the idea. This is a ridiculous idea.

Of course it is! We can't even get people to follow rules around masks in one country! But it's an interesting hypothetical though.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/12/2021 21:54

What about those households with say 6 people. One has covid and the rest get it one by one. It's going to be more than 3 weeks and if they are asymptomatic they wont know they've got it and wont be able to do a test to know or not. I know people that have come down with symptoms on the last day of their partners 10 day isolation. So youd in theory have to do 10 days for every individual in a household

NuffSaidSam · 02/12/2021 21:52

@canary1

It’s like the OP is in March 2020, three weeks to flatten the curve, everyone 😂😂😂
Tbf, impossible though it is, if there had been a worldwide total lockdown we would have been over it by end of April 2020.
Aposterhasnoname · 02/12/2021 21:51

Speechless, absolutely speechless.

So drs and nurses can work, cool, how do they get to work? On the bus? So bus drivers can work. But what about fuel for said buses? Tankers you say? So tanker drivers can work, and fuel station workers.

Oh but, tanker drivers need to pee, so service stations can open, and they will need staff of course.

Now, let’s assume that everyone has the facilities to store enough food for three weeks (ridiculous assumption, but let’s run with it). Lots of it would be frozen, so better not let the power go out, so power workers can work. Oh and water, can’t go without water, so water workers can work.

We’ve all bought three weeks worth of food, so supermarkets can close, but, once they open, there’s gonna be bit of demand, so we’ll be needing food factory workers to make sure stocks are available. And farmers will have to work cos we can’t just let the animals die.

Speaking of animals, what about vets!

Oh, and all these people working, who’ll be looking after their kids?

I could go on, but you get the idea. This is a ridiculous idea.

Swipe left for the next trending thread