Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....

345 replies

Rissole · 02/12/2021 14:32

.....or whatever time period was deemed appropriate. Wouldn't that rid us of Covid once and for all as it would die out?

All we would have to do is get enough food in for the time period and stay in. A collective whole world self isolation. Job done!

OP posts:
BHX3000 · 03/12/2021 19:07

It's not a stupid question. I reckon we could get quite near it, if people were willing to be selfless, and have a really strict lockdown. People could be given notice, so they could plan food, part of the arms budget could be diverted to pay for food delivery, and just the emergency and health care in operation, and with precautions

And whilst you eat your 3 weeks' worth of food supplies provided by the government for free, who is manufacturing, packing and shipping all the food you will need to buy once we're out of this 3 week lockdown? It takes weeks for food to reach a supermarket.

Who is keeping the gas and oil industries up and running, so you can have electricity, heating, and all that food can get to your local supermarket, in time for your return to the streets in 3 weeks' time?

Who's taking single mothers who don't drive to the hospital, to give birth? People who have a stroke or die in their sleep, how are these people taken to hospital or the morgue when they don't have cars?

How are people paying their rent and (increased) bills during those 3 weeks, if they can't work from home?

I'm not an essential worker but my job can only be done in person. If the business isn't open we don't get paid. If I don't get paid I can't afford rent or bills. Is the army also going to give me vouchers for rent and the water bill? Me and the millions of people in the UK who work in this industry?

It's a lovely idea. Completely unrealistic.

nannykatherine · 03/12/2021 18:54

People will still have to give birth
Have heart attacks
Strokes
Babies get sick amd need to see doctors
Etc
Etc
People will die
Are you going to live with a dead body in your house because no one will collect it because the mortuary is shut ???
In fact
Thinking about it this is the daftest idea of the pandemic yet

TheKeatingFive · 03/12/2021 18:50

Why would numbers have to rise so dramatically again?

Because that's happened literally everywhere, every time since this began.

If we really tried to battle it and also put ventilation measures into schools, kept with masks in crowded areas, had financial support to isolate from government then we can keep the numbers right down

If you think that's going to keep numbers down, your naiveity is shocking. Plenty of the European nations have had all of these things, but their cases still skyrocketed. We're now dealing with far more transmissible variants, compounding the issue.

It's been under good control in many countries in Africa since the start, because they have excellent medical approaches with masks and so on because of having dealt with SARS.

Again, astonishing naiveity. They just have much bigger problems than covid.

notoldjustpastyoung · 03/12/2021 18:41

Isn't that what everyone mostly in the world did in lockdowns. We werent the only ones/

duffeldaisy · 03/12/2021 18:33

"It would need to be global....how are you going to make it work in Africa? Afghanistan? in the slums in India?"

It's been under good control in many countries in Africa since the start, because they have excellent medical approaches with masks and so on because of having dealt with SARS. You can't lump a whole continent together.

Richer countries have to 1. Make the vaccine recipe freely available (sorry, I can't remember the proper name - but recipe will do!) so that other countries who don't have it can replicate it, and 2. help out where they can.

Of course if you look at the entire world it looks impossible. But if you can get each area to take measures locally, then you can calm this thing down. It's like saying 'how can we get all of the retail sector to comply?!', when individual shops are all doing lots of things to make it less dangerous, and where, if they were given help with that, they could do it quicker.

I guess if the new version does turn out to be vaccine resistant and deadlier, then there will be more urgent need, so more people will pitch in to solve problems as they arise.

duffeldaisy · 03/12/2021 18:27

Why would numbers have to rise so dramatically again?
It's not kicking the can down the road, it's preventing the thing spreading.

The reason we had such a rise and the reason why we're just accepting 40-50k infections a day is because we went from very loose lockdown to no mitigation measures whatsoever, especially in schools.

If we really tried to battle it and also put ventilation measures into schools, kept with masks in crowded areas, had financial support to isolate from government then we can keep the numbers right down. We don't have to live like this.

godmum56 · 03/12/2021 18:26

@MorningStarling

It could be done, it's just there isn't the will to do it. Some people would flatly refuse to comply and it would be impossible to contain them.

Most "reasonable" objections could be overcome though. Doctors/nurses etc could stay in hospitals. If the fire service are called out, they and all involved are subject to another three weeks quarantine. I genuinely don't believe the argument that anybody doesn't have the room to store a three week supply of food - not the food they might like, but tinned and dried goods will suffice. If people can't afford to buy three weeks food in advance just provide every adult with three week's worth of benefit payments in advance. Would be cheaper than Covid.

It would need to be global....how are you going to make it work in Africa? Afghanistan? in the slums in India?
ThePoisonousMushroom · 03/12/2021 18:15

@Mummabear89

I said this at the very beginning of the pandemic 😂
And it wouldn’t have worked then, either.
Silveryspark · 03/12/2021 18:08

@TheKeatingFive

We've gotten numbers low before. But all low numbers do is eventually grow to large ones.
Indeed! Does anyone the stress and anxiety in the early days when one poor bugger was accused of being a super spreader because he'd caught it at a meeting in Singapore or somewhere? Anybody would think he was single handedly responsible for bringing covid into the country. Meanwhile travellers were coming in from all corners of the globe. None of it made any sense at all
Turquoisesol · 03/12/2021 18:07

I think too many countries live day to day for food supplies and it just isn’t possible to get enough food to keep them in for 3 weeks. I suppose richer countries could supply and coordinate food supply beforehand? But then the whole world would need to accept no medical treatment for the next 3 weeks even if you have heart attack or go in to labour you are on your own

Bitofachinwag · 03/12/2021 18:06

I am guessing the OP intended for this to be a "light-hearted"thread!

Mirw · 03/12/2021 18:03

So what about the police, firies, paramedics, carers, dentists, doctors, nurses, lab technicians, cleaners, porters, cooks, etc etc etc. What about their families? Oh, we had a lockdown where most people were in isolation. And what happened...?

TheKeatingFive · 03/12/2021 18:02

We've gotten numbers low before. But all low numbers do is eventually grow to large ones.

TheKeatingFive · 03/12/2021 18:00

We might not be able to get it down to zero all in one go, but we could dramatically reduce illness and death.

Delay, not reduce. All you'd be doing is kicking cans down roads.

Exhausteddog · 03/12/2021 17:59

The first lock down was pretty severe with lots of people at home (on furlough) but there are so many people who have to go to work to keep the country functioning at literally the most basic level. It goes so much further than emergency services and teachers and farmers.

TheKeatingFive · 03/12/2021 17:59

It wouldn't be possible to completely destroy it, but it could get it down to NZ levels, where it's then possible to only ask a few people to isolate, rather than the whole country.

NZ has had to implement incredibly stringent border policies and long, strict local lockdowns to maintain low figures. It wouldn't be possible here, numbers would be suppressed and then skyrocket again.

duffeldaisy · 03/12/2021 17:56

@Mummabear89

Me too!

I do think that if people felt that something properly co-ordinated was going on where they wouldn't lose money, would be less likely to lose their health or loved ones, and could actually see some kind of end to all this, and less of a threat of vaccine-resistant illness, they would all pull together. We might not be able to get it down to zero all in one go, but we could dramatically reduce illness and death. And who doesn't want that?

NowWhatUsernameShallIHave · 03/12/2021 17:53

OP are you 5 years old??

This is the way a child would look at it in such simplistic terms

Mummabear89 · 03/12/2021 17:50

I said this at the very beginning of the pandemic 😂

duffeldaisy · 03/12/2021 17:47

It would have to be incredibly well-organised. I think we could get cases right down to countable levels in the UK with a huge preparation beforehand:
Send 3 weeks' worth of tests and heavy duty masks to every household in the country. Pay everyone a flat fee, well above minimum wage, to financially cover the three weeks.

All emergency and other workers who have to go could be supplied with well-fitting PPE (or just good masks for those working outdoors).
Any emergency patients, eg those ill or needing to give birth, would then at least have good masks to wear on the way.

Make vaccinations more available for those trying to get them.

Close the borders only to vital services and for vital trips - anyone else (eg couriers with urgent supplies or people visiting sick relatives) can distance as much as possible and wear good quality masks/ppe.

It wouldn't be possible to completely destroy it, but it could get it down to NZ levels, where it's then possible to only ask a few people to isolate, rather than the whole country.

But in countries where it is possible to reduce cases that drastically, there should be a huge campaign to build more vaccine factories and distribution centres. A huge campaign to train more people in giving vaccines (would obv take time). A bit like how in war, munitions factories suddenly sprung up. We urgently need to get vaccines, masks, PPE to other countries. Our economy would be way better because there wouldn't be all the illness and reservation about going to the shops, and so we'd have more money to donate to other countries to do the same.

It's not easy, but with a bit of will - and surely the end of all of this would do it?! - we could make things so much better.

Lalalablahblahblah · 03/12/2021 17:46

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Fizbosshoes · 03/12/2021 17:44

The issue is that many privileged people had an equally privileged experience of lockdown. But they haven't the faintest notion what it would be like if we did strip services right down to the bone.

Limited power, no wifi, no broadcasting, nothing but basic food packages, very limited essential services, restricted policing, etc, etc. Most of the most pro-lockdown types wouldn't last two minutes if we stripped right back to actual 'essentials'.

And that's before we get to convincing developing nations (who have far more pressing concerns than covid) of this great plan.

Yes all those who could wfh (ignoring the enormous number of people who had to go to work to make their wfh arrangements possible) telling others to STAY AT HOME unless you're my ocado or amazon delivery person and even now all those saying its ridiculous and selfish that close contacts or house hold members are not still isolating, again forgetting that not everyone can wfh or live without wages for 2 weeks.

TheKeatingFive · 03/12/2021 11:59

I do think it must be nice to live in @rissole land though. Every one has enough money and space to buy in and store a months worth of food. Everyone lives in a secure and safe home without fear of violence. Everyone HAS a home. No one is ill apart from covid. People rarely die. Countries worth of people don't have to go out daily to collect even just water. It seems like a nice place.

Yup

SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 11:41

I do think it must be nice to live in @rissole land though. Every one has enough money and space to buy in and store a months worth of food. Everyone lives in a secure and safe home without fear of violence. Everyone HAS a home. No one is ill apart from covid. People rarely die. Countries worth of people don't have to go out daily to collect even just water. It seems like a nice place.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/12/2021 11:38

@BlackAmericanoNoSugar

There are two types of people that mean this couldn't happen, those who are desperately poor and live hand to mouth and would starve (quite a large proportion of world population sadly) and those who don't believe Covid exists or that aggressive self-confidence will defeat it (looking at you America but other countries too).
And what about those who need to leave isolation to Get medical treatment for long term conditions / accidents / emergencies / labour Treat the above or collect them in ambulances Support staff for the above Put out fires Get all those people to work Ensure the power stays on