Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....

345 replies

Rissole · 02/12/2021 14:32

.....or whatever time period was deemed appropriate. Wouldn't that rid us of Covid once and for all as it would die out?

All we would have to do is get enough food in for the time period and stay in. A collective whole world self isolation. Job done!

OP posts:
ThePoisonousMushroom · 04/12/2021 10:38

@Dibbydoos

Interesting how most responses are finding reasons why it wouldn't work versus solutions to make this work...

Prob is we have not tried to kill the virus. If we'd done that we might be in a different position now. What we need is operators of enclosed spaces - shops etc - deploying technology to clean the air.
Still I hear there remain idiots with mild Covid still going out etc putting us all at risk cos they're selfish!

No one is ‘finding’ reasons. Those reasons exist, you don’t have to look for them. Tell me again how these people could isolate in their ‘houses’ for 3 weeks (which wouldn’t be enough by the way, as it can take 8 weeks just to get through one family)
What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....
Dibbydoos · 04/12/2021 10:36

Interesting how most responses are finding reasons why it wouldn't work versus solutions to make this work...

Prob is we have not tried to kill the virus. If we'd done that we might be in a different position now. What we need is operators of enclosed spaces - shops etc - deploying technology to clean the air.
Still I hear there remain idiots with mild Covid still going out etc putting us all at risk cos they're selfish!

Mamanyt · 03/12/2021 23:15

IF it were possible, yes it would work. It is not, for all of the reasons that have been listed above. Essential workers, especially. They cannot isolate. Although, in the case of health care workers, some could stay at their jobs for the full three weeks if sleeping arrangements could be made...but my GOD, the overtime!

MoreHairyThanScary · 03/12/2021 22:54

Bloody hell the lack of understanding of how wider society (just in the westernised world alone) functions is astonishing, let alone the impact of those in poorer countries.

Medical care does not just happen in hospitals it happenings in the community too, birthing and dying will not stop for a lockdown.

Plus the multiple hundreds of different aspects of our society that we need to function water treatment personnel, electricity, gas, telecoms the list if not endless is very long

The suggestion displays some fairly simplistic thinking!

Theluggage15 · 03/12/2021 22:53

This is such an unbelievably childish idea. It’s actually offensive, showing zero idea of what so many people’s lives are like. Such a middle class pandemic, wfh, in a nice house with nice garden. Fucks sake, no clue about some people’s lives in this country let alone developing countries. And this virus has animal reservoirs so good luck locking every animal on the planet down.

EberhardtSmallcock · 03/12/2021 22:39

@Rissole

OK so what if, just so we could be rid of it sooner, those that work in hospitals and the National Grid etc. stayed at work. No pain no gain sort of thing.

There are always going to be exceptions but this is an exceptional situation.

I would be happy to stay at my place of work for three weeks wearing full on PPE in case an emergency came in that HAD to be dealt with.

With LFT's and vaccinations and now drugs that stop it fully developing, I think something akin to a world wide lockdown at the same time would work to a degree.

It isn't an exceptional situation, though. It's a virus, like all other viruses, doing what viruses do.

I take it you enjoyed being locked down, and were fortunate enough not to be bankrupted by it.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 03/12/2021 22:36

@Tessabelle1

Apart from nurses, doctors, carers, electricity/gas etc workers, fire service, ambulance staff etc etc. Lovely idea in principle, we couldn't even get the residents of this country to stick to it though so no hope of a global coordination happening
Yeah, the absolute selfish idiots who live in conditions like this, far too selfish to just stay the fuck at home for 3 weeks 🙄
What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....
Tessabelle1 · 03/12/2021 22:31

Apart from nurses, doctors, carers, electricity/gas etc workers, fire service, ambulance staff etc etc. Lovely idea in principle, we couldn't even get the residents of this country to stick to it though so no hope of a global coordination happening

CaptainMerica · 03/12/2021 21:58

They could do it for nits. Get everyone in the world to do nit treatment regularly for 3 weeks and kill the bastards dead. Coronavirus, not so much.

ThanksForAllTheFish · 03/12/2021 21:54

In theory probably. If the whole world isolated completely for 3 weeks and properly cleaned all surfaces etc then the virus would die out.

Practically - no chance. Not just for all the things that need to stay open for survival and things like hospitals and care homes etc. A lot of people wouldn’t stick to the rules and meet other people anyway. So realistically it would never work.

lljkk · 03/12/2021 21:49

new Zealand care homes have super strict rules about visiting, new residents, PPE use, etc. It's not the old normal at all.

Taytocrisps · 03/12/2021 21:24

Can you imagine the mayhem in the supermarkets if you told people they had to stock up for three weeks?

TheKeatingFive · 03/12/2021 20:49

Meanwhile in New Zealand, because of their much stronger, targeted lockdowns, they managed to live as normal (apart from with a lot of security at the border) for over a year.

They only managed that because ...

Seeded cases there were much lower when lockdowns became normalised in the western world, making their initial job much easier than any European nation.

Draconian border restrictions, the likes of which the U.K. simply couldn't enforce.

And even at that Auckland spent a very significant amount of time in strict lockdown conditions, which did not ultimately manage to eliminate cases.

They are now not pursuing a zero covid strategy (despite having the optimal possible conditions to do so) because they know it's pointless.

Thedogscollar · 03/12/2021 20:40

@Rissole

I'm not saying it wouldn't take some massive organising Smile
I nominate Boris to coordinate it all. He has done such a great job in the UK🤣🤣
wannalivelikecommonpeople · 03/12/2021 20:34

Bless you OP Thanks

lljkk · 03/12/2021 20:33

@Nacknick

How we about we just vaccinate the whole world instead? How quickly could that be done with a concerted effort do you think?
^ THAT.

Instead the rich countries are moving quickly to boost their own populations as fast as possible. Poor world can just catch covid freely & breed new variants since most their populations are unvacc'd. That's a very clever strategy, right?

Porcupineintherough · 03/12/2021 20:31

@Comedycook no but I think less people would be dead. Esp if wed locked down at the end of last October to give us a chance to get vaccinations underway.

Chessie678 · 03/12/2021 20:26

But New Zealand just spent over 3 months in lockdown and it’s not now pursuing zero covid anyway.

duffeldaisy · 03/12/2021 20:14

"even with if you could control covid with the measures you are suggesting they would need to be permanent at which point the cure is really worse than the disease."

I remember the first year of Covid, where we were shutting schools, having half-hearted lockdowns without proper support for people, I didn't see relatives for that entire first year (and our family suffered losses during that, like so many others).

Meanwhile in New Zealand, because of their much stronger, targeted lockdowns, they managed to live as normal (apart from with a lot of security at the border) for over a year.

If we get numbers down then we can be freer. NHS staff can get more rest, and they can catch up with 'normal' operations that haven't been doable because of the ICUs being so full, and with staff being ill, etc.

I just want to live more normally. This myth that we have to 'live with it' is not sustainable. We're burning out here. We need a breather from the virus - and the only way to achieve that is to actively fight it and get down the risk.

JojobaFromOctober · 03/12/2021 19:54

If King Canute had got down to the beach as soon as the tide started coming in, he probably wouldn't have got wet at all.

Comedycook · 03/12/2021 19:31

Three reasons Lockdown failed
1. Too little too late by gov

Do you really think that if we'd locked down earlier, we'd be covid free now?

Chessie678 · 03/12/2021 19:28

@duffeldaisy
I don’t really understand this view when there are so many examples of it not working like that. Most European countries did all the things you are suggesting to some degree and their cases are growing exponentially again. We came out of the first lockdown very slowly - we had masks, rule of 6, very limited larger gatherings, no nightclubs, bubbles in schools and social distancing, isolation for close contacts (none of which are sustainable on a permanent basis) and cases still went up to a high level within a couple of months of partial reopening. We also came out of the January lockdown very slowly - it took from January to July for things to reopen fully.

If African countries are doing well it’s generally going to be because they don’t test much and don’t see much serious disease from covid because they have young populations. The Times of India printed a load of articles about how well India was doing due to mask compliance just before delta struck (at which point masks became a drop in the ocean in terms of controlling the spread).

And even with if you could control covid with the measures you are suggesting they would need to be permanent at which point the cure is really worse than the disease.

Vynalbob · 03/12/2021 19:27

In theory yes
in practice no

As for the person saying even our harshest Lockdown didn't work due to the necessary workers that is complete 💩

Three reasons Lockdown failed

  1. Too little too late by gov
  2. The Whole World needs vaccinating
  3. Main reason the bonkers conspiracy theorists that believe any illogical nonsense they read if it suits them, treat the virus as a bogeyman that can be fought off or probably as crackers and wide spread "oh yeah but we're all getting a bit sick of it now aren't we " like it's some type of negotiation that if you explain how hard you've tried / what you've had to put up with Mr Covid will just wave politely and go away.
Madjakelmum · 03/12/2021 19:27

Makes no bloody sense at all. Doctors, nurses, hospitals? The world still has sick people other than covid!!

Tigger1895 · 03/12/2021 19:21

Sounds like a good idea in theory but practically impossible. How can you be sure you won’t need medical assistance or just a pint of milk. Also take into account that there were people who didn’t follow restrictions last April and most certainly won’t now.