Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....

345 replies

Rissole · 02/12/2021 14:32

.....or whatever time period was deemed appropriate. Wouldn't that rid us of Covid once and for all as it would die out?

All we would have to do is get enough food in for the time period and stay in. A collective whole world self isolation. Job done!

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 02/12/2021 17:00

Even theoretically it wouldn’t work. As a pp pointed out there are animal reservoirs.

Added to which, for everyone to isolate would essentially be a purge of the weakest. A lot of people’s sudden illness would go unnoticed in the home (eg. Sudden heart attacks, falls) and I’m pretty certain the worst of our society would take full advantage of no police to loot and do whatever the hell else they’d like.

SpudleyLass · 02/12/2021 16:54

Theoretically, yes a few weeks of literally everybody in isolation would work.

In practice, its incredibly unworkable. People would still die of very many other things. I just about managed to keep my marbles from the first lockdown - I really can't do another. Its not about being selfish, its about being realistic.

Mischievous12 · 02/12/2021 16:45

@HugeAckmansWife

Everyone beat me to it. If someone has a heart attack or falls down stairs do we just leave them nailed in their houses like 14th Century plague victims?
Ah you know it! Just a bit of collateral damage....nothing to see here 😎
festivefuschias · 02/12/2021 16:44

Ignoring the fact that many people wouldn’t be able to, it would have to be for longer because it would still be spreading within households at a staggered pace during that time.

AvocadoAndToast · 02/12/2021 16:40

OP you’ve gone bonkers my love.
I’ve heard some daft ideas in my time but this one has to be the winner!

KittenCatcher · 02/12/2021 16:37

How can a firefighter or ambulance driver stay at home, where would all the millions of health and care workers stay and get fed and watered

Chessie678 · 02/12/2021 16:36

Millions of people live in slums or refugee camps where covid would likely spread faster in a three week shutdown than without it. There are communities which are not even on the map where it would be difficult to communicate the idea of the shutdown to them (one issue in polio eradication is actually knowing that settlements exist and haven’t been vaccinated). At any point in time there are natural disasters somewhere in the world and civil wars which necessitate people moving from their homes. Terrorists groups and criminal would likely take advantage of the shutdown possibly to catastrophic effect.

People in developing countries would starve if not immediately then due to limited farming and distribution taking place for 3 weeks. Distribution chains probably couldn’t supply every person with all they need for three weeks anyway.

You could never eradicate covid this way and would kill millions trying.

TheKeatingFive · 02/12/2021 16:32

Please engage at least one brain cell

This. It's total unworkable.

There are many, many people who need to get their arses into work to keep society going. Not just medical/emergency services but food production & supply chain, energy providers, pharmacists, carers, defense.

Even if you could isolate all those people (you can't), it would take closer to 8 weeks minimum.

Plus you need to do this globally. Barely functioning societies with people living hand to mouth, minimal infrastructure and support, all on board, no exceptions.

It's a ridiculous notion.

VikingOnTheFridge · 02/12/2021 16:21

@Duckrace

It's not a stupid question. I reckon we could get quite near it, if people were willing to be selfless, and have a really strict lockdown. People could be given notice, so they could plan food, part of the arms budget could be diverted to pay for food delivery, and just the emergency and health care in operation, and with precautions. I wonder what a workshop conference of the right people could work out?
Could you tell us more about how the 700 million people in the world who live in extreme poverty could plan? Because it's not immediately obvious. Nor do all individuals on the planet have room to store 3 weeks of food even if it were given to them. If there's one thing we should all have learned by now, it's that this thing is global.

And once the healthcare and emergency workers plus those running the infrastructure they need to keep functioning are out and about, it becomes pointless anyway.

WrongWayApricot · 02/12/2021 16:20

Couldn't get this country to organise a piss up in a brewery. I'm sure some other countries would do marvelously, like Australia did at first and I do wish it were possible.

MadeOfStarStuff · 02/12/2021 16:01

Please engage at least one brain cell

It’s not just a case of “organising things”

Even supposing everyone was compliant (unlikely given the refusal to do something as simple as wear a mask), societies can’t just stop. Essential services have to continue (power, medical, emergency services, all the services which support those services like fuel tanker deliveries),

ThePoisonousMushroom · 02/12/2021 15:56

You’d also need hospital cleaners, porters, pharmacists, cooks, caretakers… where would they sleep?

XenoBitch · 02/12/2021 15:54

@VestaTilley

And where would all the doctors and nurses sleep? There aren’t loads of spare beds in hospitals - that’s half the problem!

Who’d look after the children of medics if all their parents stayed at hospital for two weeks?

Doctors and nurses are also just one part of the running of hospitals. They wont be able to do their jobs without all the other staff there too. So all staff would have to stay in work. They would be shoulder to shoulder.
Duckrace · 02/12/2021 15:53

It's not a stupid question. I reckon we could get quite near it, if people were willing to be selfless, and have a really strict lockdown. People could be given notice, so they could plan food, part of the arms budget could be diverted to pay for food delivery, and just the emergency and health care in operation, and with precautions. I wonder what a workshop conference of the right people could work out?

BogRollBOGOF · 02/12/2021 15:52

How many elderly/ disabled/ vulnerable people would die from things like infected bedsores, forgetting to eat, lack of medication.
How many more would die of abuse and suicide.
How many would die of childbirth, medical emergencies, fires etc.
How many would die of hypothermia, dehydration, contaminated water etc as utilities cut out. (And no zoom or banana bread avaliable)
Many people barely exist in poor conditions as it is. Families in cramped, overcrowded, small flats, houses and emergency accommodation.

The death toll would really put Covid into perspective.

villamariavintrapp · 02/12/2021 15:47

Hmm it's an interesting idea hypothetically. But what about the animal reservoir? All the animals that could carry covid would also have to isolate.. so no, not possible for covid unfortunately. But IF you could do it, you'd probably find a lot of other infections might disappear..? Maybe..?

VestaTilley · 02/12/2021 15:39

And where would all the doctors and nurses sleep? There aren’t loads of spare beds in hospitals - that’s half the problem!

Who’d look after the children of medics if all their parents stayed at hospital for two weeks?

Pumasonsatsumas · 02/12/2021 15:38

I feel like we did that already....

VestaTilley · 02/12/2021 15:37

And who’d look after the patients in hospital, police the streets and care for those in care homes?

Who’d deliver the food and milk the cows etc? Come on, OP.

Skyll · 02/12/2021 15:30

What about all the various types of people on meds that they are only allowed to pick up daily?

DanglingMod · 02/12/2021 15:30

Yeah, another non-starter fact is that 3 weeks isn't long enough unless everyone locks themselves in separate rooms away from family members. I've known it take 7 weeks to go through a family of 6.

VikingOnTheFridge · 02/12/2021 15:30

@Rissole

OK so what if, just so we could be rid of it sooner, those that work in hospitals and the National Grid etc. stayed at work. No pain no gain sort of thing.

There are always going to be exceptions but this is an exceptional situation.

I would be happy to stay at my place of work for three weeks wearing full on PPE in case an emergency came in that HAD to be dealt with.

With LFT's and vaccinations and now drugs that stop it fully developing, I think something akin to a world wide lockdown at the same time would work to a degree.

The billion plus people in the world who live hand to mouth are not an exception. There are almost certainly more people on the planet who can't afford to sustain themselves without working for 3 weeks than who can.

People in the UK for whom this might feasibly be possible and survivable, the likes of you and me, we're the exception.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 02/12/2021 15:29

One more from me....dead people, what do we do with them? I mean Johnson did say (allegedly) "let the bodies pile high" but even so.

HairyToity · 02/12/2021 15:28

DH is a dairy farmer. Whilst he could probably keep two metres from workers, vet, parlour engineer etc. - they'd all be handling same equipment. Would it be foolproof? Cows can't all be dried off for two weeks. They'd need someone to collect the milk, and factories to process it.

Lots of holes to two or three weeks self isolating. What if you had six kids all getting covid asymptomatically - could take weeks to go through them all.

Giveaschitt · 02/12/2021 15:24

And who is manufacturing and delivering all the medicine and equipment needed for the patients in the hospitals? Are we supposed to somehow procure enough for 3 weeks all in one go, and find somewhere in the hospital to store it? Plus we need to make sure that everyone in the world has enough medication to last them as well - so a hefty stock of everyone's blood pressure medicine and insulin and B12 injections and all the other things people need regularly to survive.
What about the food - all very well and good suggesting people just lived in their work place, but how is it transported from the factories and farms to wherever it needs to be (people's houses? Hospitals? ). Even if your suggestion is that we all somehow magically get enough food to last us 3 weeks in advance (and have we all forgotten what happened when people tried to stock up like that...?), including apparently making sure that work places now have the means to feed their entire workforce for 3 weeks, what happens if some people run out earlier? Do we just let them starve?
Ambulances, fire engines etc - how are we powering them? Because they'll need fuel, and mechanics if they break down.. So if they need fuel, we need petrol stations to be manned, petrol tankers to be driving to keep them filled...

That's before we even get in to banks, or the post, or dealing with broken power lines or leaking water pipes or any number of things that could go wrong.

And just before I finish up - what about the people in domestic abuse situations? The abused children? Should we just lock them up with their abusers for 3 weeks with no means of escape?

Swipe left for the next trending thread