Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What if everyone in the world isolated for the same three weeks....

345 replies

Rissole · 02/12/2021 14:32

.....or whatever time period was deemed appropriate. Wouldn't that rid us of Covid once and for all as it would die out?

All we would have to do is get enough food in for the time period and stay in. A collective whole world self isolation. Job done!

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 02/12/2021 19:02

@Stompythedinosaur

I think my patients would probably struggle with no care for three weeks tbh.
Oh, they just have to be HEROIC and think of all the people who lived through wars and suck it up. For the greater good and all that.
Helpstopthepain · 02/12/2021 19:02

@Keepingtheseatwarm sorry, addressing op

ElectraBlue · 02/12/2021 18:59

No. Because it is impossible for everyone to isolate. Hospitals still need to run and so does the food supply chain, utilities, the fire service, ambulances, the police, vets and so on. Plus you cannot control entire populations. Also, are you planning on wiping every surface where the virus might be lurking (good luck with that), not to mention the fact that the damn thing might be airborne.

Cloud cuckoo land. Lockdowns don't work.

JassyRadlett · 02/12/2021 18:58

The trouble is, OP, that with just one of your suggested solutions you’ve already rendered the whole experiment pointless. So you have a hospital full of people to make it work - medical staff and support staff, all sleeping and eating in a building that’s not designed to have that many people living there.

Covid is going to perpetuate in that system. It’s a large enough system that it won’t be done and dusted in three weeks like it might be in a household.

babbi · 02/12/2021 18:51

@ThePoisonousMushroom

Do you realise OP that in a lot of countries, Covid is pretty low down on the list of risks they face every day? They’d be pretty pissed off I imagine if billions of pounds were ploughed into them isolating for 3 weeks to eradicate covid when they haven’t had that same resource given to them to try and fight the famine and disease they face on a daily basis.
@ThePoisonousMushroom Excellent post …. All so often those in the first world have no idea ( or sadly interest ) in the huge challenges that have been long term ongoing in other countries. Even with Covid - so many do not appreciate how good we have it .
Stompythedinosaur · 02/12/2021 18:49

I think my patients would probably struggle with no care for three weeks tbh.

mugoftea456 · 02/12/2021 18:49

Prob would stop the virus.

You just couldn't do it.

People would die in fires.
People would die from accidents
People would starve as they would have no food.
No police means crime.
The list is endless

Keepingtheseatwarm · 02/12/2021 18:48

@Helpstopthepain

We did! I didn’t see my children for the entire lockdown because I was looking after everyone else’s relatives. I wanted to keep my children and my patients safe. I went to work and went home, I’m really sorry for going home to my empty fucking house.

In all of my years as a nurse I’ve never struggled as much as I am now and that’s mostly because of people like you!
I’m burnt out, absolutely had enough. Now I can’t look after my children or my patients because I can’t even look after myself. I’m broken!

What do you do for a living? Work in government?

Thank you for your commitment Flowers Who are you addressing your comment to?
VikingOnTheFridge · 02/12/2021 18:46

@Duckrace

You tell me, *@VikingOnTheFridge* , you clearly have all the answers, if you can manage it without being passive aggressive.
I'll gladly tell you: they'd either not comply, in which case the OPs plan would be useless, or they would comply and they'd die of starvation. Which is why it's such a ridiculous idea. The only people who fail to see that clearly haven't given any thought to the actual global situation. Reeks of western privilege.

Also, you've confused passive aggressive with condescending. They're not the same thing.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 02/12/2021 18:44

I'm due a likely breech baby, who is measuring off the scale big, in 4 weeks, if I went into labour early and was isolated at home we'd both likely die. If I moved into hospital then who would after the children of the doctors, nurses, admin staff, lab staff,porters etc that are needed to keep a hospital open?

MargaretThursday · 02/12/2021 18:42

And half of MN would be rushing out shouting about their human rights.

Duckrace · 02/12/2021 18:39

You tell me, @VikingOnTheFridge , you clearly have all the answers, if you can manage it without being passive aggressive.

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 02/12/2021 18:37

Just in terms of births in the U.K. alone, that would be 10800 women and babies left to fend for themselves.

That’s 2,310,000 women and babies around the world in a 3 week period with no medical care whatsoever. Hopefully a partner who has a clean pair of scissors to cut the umbilical cord. But no 999 services on the phone to talk them through it.

Helpstopthepain · 02/12/2021 18:37

We did! I didn’t see my children for the entire lockdown because I was looking after everyone else’s relatives. I wanted to keep my children and my patients safe. I went to work and went home, I’m really sorry for going home to my empty fucking house.

In all of my years as a nurse I’ve never struggled as much as I am now and that’s mostly because of people like you!
I’m burnt out, absolutely had enough. Now I can’t look after my children or my patients because I can’t even look after myself. I’m broken!

What do you do for a living? Work in government?

Obsidiansphere · 02/12/2021 18:33

I’d love to isolate for 3 weeks but I’m a front line worker so can’t

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 02/12/2021 18:32

It might kill the virus but it would kill way more people than covid ever has done. Heart attack victims left unattended. Women delivering babies on own with no midwife. Sewage and water systems left unchecked. Food unavailable. Fires left un-attended by firemen. Elderly who’ve fallen over left for three weeks.

It’s unthinkable. Way worse than COVID.

JojobaFromOctober · 02/12/2021 18:31

You could never eradicate covid this way and would kill millions trying.

Exactly.

This would be absolute insanity. You'd kill so many people, the death toll would make covid look trivial. And when you'd finished if there was so much as a single infectious case left (which there would be) you'd have achieved fuck all.

XenoBitch · 02/12/2021 18:26

@IncompleteSenten

Yes. If everyone in the entire world had no contact at all with anyone for however long it would take to be sure - 3 weeks, 4, 5 maybe then of course it would be gone. Probably lots of other infectious illnesses too.

It's just that it simply isn't possible to achieve.

Yep, lots of illnesses will be gone.... and also a hell of a lot of lives.
IncompleteSenten · 02/12/2021 18:25

Yes. If everyone in the entire world had no contact at all with anyone for however long it would take to be sure - 3 weeks, 4, 5 maybe then of course it would be gone. Probably lots of other infectious illnesses too.

It's just that it simply isn't possible to achieve.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/12/2021 18:25

Also who's gonna look after the kids if both parents are "essential" and living on hospital grounds? Enforced boarding school?

XenoBitch · 02/12/2021 18:24

@Keepingtheseatwarm

Tbh I think it's what the government and many others had in mind the first lockdown. It took people (like many on this thread) to point out that it's not quite as simple as it seems. My town FB page was full of posts from people being disgusted at seeing cars on the road. There was a story about a woman having the temerity to get into her car every day and drive off in it. Somebody slashed her tyres. She was a district nurse!!
Yep, FB community groups were an absolute cesspit for stuff like this during lockdowns. There were nurses having nasty notes left on their windscreens in my local group. And constant "why is xyz open?", when it was things like solicitors.... the legal system didn't stop during lockdown.
Namenic · 02/12/2021 18:22

OP - I think it would be feasible in a small location (eg island with small population) with lots of external support (eg workers from outside go in and airlift out medical cases). Strict control at borders and quarantine.

Maybe China has come closest to this? I don’t have insight - not having lived there - but I think at the peak of the 1st wave they did get army etc to enforce restriction of movement? On the one hand there were awful scenes that we saw in the media and a lot of suffering, but in such a densely populated place you could argue that tough action likely also saved lives. The scenes from Italy and in U.K. times during the 1st wave where people weren’t able to say goodbye to family members in hospital were also horrific.

I don’t think people would support this in U.K., let alone co-ordinating with other countries. Once you open the borders, it would come in again.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/12/2021 18:22

@StopSkrikin

Can confirm that I am not willing to stay at work in a nursery for 3 weeks, I don't think the kids of the NHS staff, Prison officers and Police we look after would like it either.
Go on Stop, be a hero. They don't need their parents, other kids survived War 🙄
Keepingtheseatwarm · 02/12/2021 18:19

Tbh I think it's what the government and many others had in mind the first lockdown.
It took people (like many on this thread) to point out that it's not quite as simple as it seems.
My town FB page was full of posts from people being disgusted at seeing cars on the road.
There was a story about a woman having the temerity to get into her car every day and drive off in it. Somebody slashed her tyres.
She was a district nurse!!

ThePoisonousMushroom · 02/12/2021 18:18

Do you realise OP that in a lot of countries, Covid is pretty low down on the list of risks they face every day? They’d be pretty pissed off I imagine if billions of pounds were ploughed into them isolating for 3 weeks to eradicate covid when they haven’t had that same resource given to them to try and fight the famine and disease they face on a daily basis.

Swipe left for the next trending thread