Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I am not at all cut out for teaching

62 replies

Cinammonroll123 · 02/12/2021 13:23

I’ve been doing some Cover Supervisor work which is different I suppose.
It’s absolute chaos. The kids like me, but respect me, certainly not.
I follow the behaviour policy but don’t know the pupils and just find it harder.
The lessons I’ve had have been a struggle to get the class to be quiet, the majority of them will do the work but even though I keep insisting on quiet or silence, it never lasts.
I have had teachers from next door coming in to complain about the noise and it’s embarrassing, I just feel like an idiot.
Teaching seems to have some sort of competitiveness about it, about who’s the strictest, who the pupils like the most etc.
I don’t like the way that it’s almost like following a script, every lesson has to follow the exact same formula and the same activities, there’s no room for flexibility.

Having to use certain language too, it’s all about being a ‘positive role model’ and setting the right example.

In the school I’ve been at, the entire class has to give a round of applause every single time someone answers a question, which just takes forever.

I agreed to be a long-term supply teacher but I know it’s not for me. It’s for January, I don’t want to let my agency down but I would much rather do TA work, I don’t think I’m cut out for this at all. Do you think it would be too late to explain to them that I no longer want to do it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mari001 · 19/04/2022 08:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Atemyhat · 03/12/2021 16:45

Yanbu to want to leave teaching.
However the school sounds batty.
Life’s too short tbh, if you’re not happy just quit!

Nowomenaroundeh · 03/12/2021 13:12

It's hard to say if you're cut out for it? Do you like teenagers? Are you passionate about teaching?

It is so hard to control rowdy classes as a substitute. I say that as a teacher who demonstrates consistently good discipline. And skills take time to learn.

So if you really want to do it, stick it out. Use this as an opportunity to trial different strategies. Get from with the other teachers who are interrupting - they are actually undermining you if they're complaining in front of the students. Ask some decent teachers for advice with specific scenarios.

If you don't really really really want to be a teacher then don't.

Goodluckanddontfuckitup · 03/12/2021 12:33

Were you a TA in the same school where you're now doing cover OP? We've had TAs retrain as teachers and stay in the same school and the kids have often behaved badly for them. It seems like they have it fixed in their minds that this person is a TA even if they're not. The misbehaving for anyone other than the class teacher enrages me, but it's very common.

If you want to stay in it absolutely do your NQT year. Have you been told that no one wants to take you on as an NQT? I'd have thought you'd be more desirable than someone fresh off their PGCE because you've got teaching experience abroad.

I've been a class teacher and a cover teacher. I've done cover work in a school where I worked for years and knew the kids, and I found behaviour much harder to manage than as a class teacher. IMO managing behaviour is the hardest to do in the role you're in now.

Happy1982ish · 03/12/2021 11:15

@sjxoxo

You said the op doesn’t owe anything to anyone
I disagree
She owes the children a good education
She’s not delivering that
But it’s a positive she has that naught
So she should leave

coffeeschmoffee · 03/12/2021 10:03

@Liverbird77

If you can possibly do so, leave and don't t look back. It is a terrible job. I hope I will never, ever have to set foot in a classroom again.
THIS

I work for the civil service now. Am much happier in every way

Funnylittlefloozie · 03/12/2021 09:41

What about teaching adults, OP? Slightly less crowd control, and usually a slightly more engaged class.

I taught adults in high-security prison from seven years, believe me, thats when you learn crowd control Smile but its hugely rewarding as well.

Shedmistress · 03/12/2021 09:33

Teaching isn't about teaching any more.

It is behaviour management mainly.

Fuuuuuckit · 03/12/2021 09:30

@Alltheblue

I'm also getting a vibe that you're lazy in your lesson planning as you seem to despise activities that you're required to include. Children don't respect that.
Cover shouldn't need any planning.

Although having done it for 10 years I know that finding a great lesson plan AND seating plan on the desk is like winning the lottery. The whole hour can go to shit if one kid decides they're going to fuck it up.

Cover is brutal. Even when you've been there for ages and got to know the kids, who is the class clown, who you can rely on for sensibility.

Give it a go in January. A good stint at the same school gives you chance to set out your boundaries, get to know the behaviour expectations, and who to complain to if/when the cover is shit.

Prescottdanni123 · 03/12/2021 08:51

I used to work for a supply agency and didn't like it. Being alone a different school each day with the staff expecting me to automatically know everything about the school/kids/where everything was could be incredibly difficult.

I managed to get a permanent position in a secondary school and now I love working in a school environment.

Notmenotme · 03/12/2021 08:21

I was a cover supervisor before I was a teacher and it was by far the hardest job I’ve ever done. Teaching is easy compared to controlling a room of kids you don’t know and they don’t know!!!

I don’t know if you personally are suited to teaching, but you are doing the hardest job in a school. If the kids like you, you are doing a good job. Children do not tend to “respect” cover supervisors as they are very low down in the hierarchy…. Sorry to say!!

I always tell children off if they are being rude to a cover supervisor but the most you can hope for is to be liked and for children to do what you tell them because they like you!!!

HolidayTime2021 · 03/12/2021 08:19

@Fritilleries

No. Plenty of qualified and eager trainees out there.
Ha Ha

There are no teachers out there at all.
Good luck finding one for January

NovemberWitch · 03/12/2021 08:16

One of the good things about working for an agency is that there is no ‘letting them down’ if you are selective about work.
It’s a transaction, they have hundreds on their books and you trade a day of work for a day’s pay. If you say no, that’s their problem to resolve. I work on a daily/weekly basis, there are schools I won’t work in and others that book me months in advance.
Your only responsibility is to be the best you can for the time you’re in the school, and for that you need to be confident.

sjxoxo · 03/12/2021 08:10

@Happy1982ish what don’t you agree with?
You are obligated in any role under contract until you say you no longer want the job.. I think the op is at that point. I think one of the issues today with public sector roles is that it’s been peddled as doing ‘greater good’ and it shouldn’t be a charity service for the public good, it’s op’s career. I think this notion of ‘heroism’ of working in the public sector is a way for our government to undervalue and underpay key workers; teachers & healthcare sectors especially xo

Happy1982ish · 03/12/2021 08:04

@sjxoxo

Do what’s best for you. You don’t owe anyone anything. I’m not a teacher but I don’t understand why anyone would want to do it! Especially today with the pay conditions and stress etc. Xo
I disagree You owe the children you are a teaching a good education And you are not providing them with that But you have the insight and strength to admit that it’s not for you - and that is a positive
sjxoxo · 03/12/2021 08:00

Do what’s best for you. You don’t owe anyone anything. I’m not a teacher but I don’t understand why anyone would want to do it! Especially today with the pay conditions and stress etc. Xo

Happy1982ish · 03/12/2021 07:57

Who cares if you’re letting down the agency
You’re letting down the children
And you’re not happy

Well done for having the insight that not for you
TA role sounds great

Pottedpalm · 03/12/2021 07:55

I wouldn’t be asking questions if there was to a round of applause each time. Can just imagine that being drawn out; excited clapping and cheering.. nah, not for me.
As others have said, it can take time to get established. I did ten years in a difficult school; the first few were hell on earth but after that the pupils realise you are sticking around and save their worst for the new/supply teachers.
It’s all about acting. The old advice was ‘never smile before Christmas’. I have known colleagues who could do this, they came down hard from the start and didn’t relax. They had few problems.

MarieG10 · 03/12/2021 07:51

I have employed someone this last year who left teaching. They were working most evenings and and weekends and realised this was not likely to change so made a life changing decision to leave. I'm really happy as although the job they now do is nothing to do with teaching per-se, their skills are really useful.

I can see a lot of potential in them for promotion in the future but having chatted to them, it is apparent that the lack of development (aside from teaching delivery) has been shocking so managerial skills are limited. But I can see the potential and I have agreed a development programme with them over the next 12 months and I will then look at a promotion (I haven't told them that bit)

ohfook · 03/12/2021 07:30

@Cinammonroll123

I am not lazy in lesson planning as I don’t plan the lessons, I just teach the cover work set for me, but I mean each lesson follows a very rigid way of doing things

The clapping thing is definitely a whole school policy as i have observed other teachers doing it

I am qualified as a classroom teacher and somehow passed the PGCE. The problem is that I qualified years ago and went to teach abroad, I never completed my nqt. So no school will take me on now to do my nqt year as they want teachers who’ve only recently qualified, even supply agencies will only pay me as a cover supervisor.

I appreciate all the advice given, I still don’t think it is for me and that I’d be better in a TA role. I hope my agency Will understand

I was in this exact same situation but found the opposite. The problem is you have to start on an nqt wage and work your way back up. So essentially they're getting a experienced teacher for the price of an nqt. Schools are skint at the minute so it's not a bad proposition for them.
boomshakalacka · 03/12/2021 07:29

Are you employed by one school or doing cover across multiple schools OP?
The thing about behaviour management is that it's all about routines and expectations. Students behave for me because I am clear beyond doubt of what I expect. If I have to cover a lesson for someone else, with students I don't know/teach, this is much harder and I sometimes feel like a crap teacher (I'm not!).
The best cover supervisors I've seen have been those who work exclusively in one school and so can get to know the students and have their own expectations of them- even though they are moving around classrooms. Oh, and if there are behaviour issues, they do their own detentions too so that they are seen as teachers with authority and not just an adult who defers the issue to a more qualified person.

dreamygirl25 · 03/12/2021 07:21

@Cinammonroll123

I am not lazy in lesson planning as I don’t plan the lessons, I just teach the cover work set for me, but I mean each lesson follows a very rigid way of doing things

The clapping thing is definitely a whole school policy as i have observed other teachers doing it

I am qualified as a classroom teacher and somehow passed the PGCE. The problem is that I qualified years ago and went to teach abroad, I never completed my nqt. So no school will take me on now to do my nqt year as they want teachers who’ve only recently qualified, even supply agencies will only pay me as a cover supervisor.

I appreciate all the advice given, I still don’t think it is for me and that I’d be better in a TA role. I hope my agency Will understand

Sorry just seen this - can you contact ewc (or English/Scottish where ever you are version) and ask how you can get QTS? I think I know someone this happened to and I think she had to do a certain amount of catch up to solve it.
ohfook · 03/12/2021 07:19

A round of applause every time someone answer a question isn't usual nor is competitive strictness or popularity. I wonder if it's an issue with the school you're in. It might be worth trying a different school before you make a final decision.

SavoyCabbage · 03/12/2021 07:17

My advice is to leave now and get your NQT year done. Either as a teacher or on supply in a long term placement.

I'm a supply teacher and there is a massive teacher shortage at the moment. I've never known anything like the situation that we are in now. When I get to a school they are almost weeping with joy that someone has come. And scouting you out to see what your availability is and whether you are looking for anything longer term.

You can do your NQT as a supply teacher if the school agrees. There are so many maternity covers at the moment it's terrifying.