Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I over reacting or is this kid out of line calling my DD trans?

187 replies

Overreactingmom · 02/12/2021 13:14

DD is 10. Overall she is a lovely kid who gets on well at school but of course she is in year 6 so fall outs are inevitable at this age but had no serious issues, she is happy to go to school and she has no additional needs etc just so as not to drip feed.

There is a boy at school who is very popular in the year group, he is confident, sporty and from a huge family.

He has been making comments about my daughters hair for months now, calling her ginger etc and just generally making fun, always appearance related. We hadn’t really acted as she seemed to be holding her own and telling him to mind his own etc.

Last week she went into school wearing trousers rather than a skirt, cue this kid (and others) commenting that she looks like a boy, why is she wearing trousers, you look like ‘X child’ (who is on the spectrum and has always been the only girl to wear trousers in their year group which is fine ofc but they’re using this child as an insult!) and laughing about it generally. Spoke to school, she was pretty upset and teacher was fab, thought it was sorted.

Yesterday the same boy said to her (about her new school shoes) ‘why are you wearing them, you look like a boy! Are you trans?’ She also admitted he has been saying she’s going to grow up to ‘be a boy’ because of wearing trousers.

Now she’s not particularly upset over the more recent comments. But I am fuming. Aibu?

For the record - I wouldn’t care how she chose to identify as an adult but she is 10 years old and just a happy little ‘tomboy’ who wants to be warm and comfy in this freezing weather!

It’s 2021 ffs not the 50’s why can’t my daughter wear what she feels comfortable in without being picked on? I dread secondary school next year!

OP posts:
Fidgetty · 03/12/2021 13:08

Nasty little prick. I'd bring it up with the school every single time. These future misogynists need taking down early. Give her some harsh comebacks to put him in his place in the meantime.

MollysDolly · 03/12/2021 12:57

Tell your DD that the next time he does it, to find all female teachers and staff wearing trousers.

Simply stand there with the teacher by her side, and DD is to say, in front of "John," but addressing the teacher, "John calls me a boy for wearing trousers. He says it to be nasty. He says this makes me like Jane, making out its awful to be like Jane. You're wearing trousers. So John thinks that about you too. Do you think it's ok to be horrible to girls who wear trousers?" And then glare at John, while the teacher let's him know exactly what she thinks of his opinion, and that he'll be on detention every time he does it again.

IncompleteSenten · 03/12/2021 12:46

MrsBison

Why give people the ammo though?

Just encourage your daughter to wear a skirt. Problem solved."

He also bullied her using her hair colour as an excuse.

I assume your advice is for her to dye it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/12/2021 12:42

They should definitely come down hard on using “X child”‘s name and the word trans as insults. And on bullying your Dd.

My dd’s school were very quick to clamp down on some kids using “lesbian” as an insult. Which is as it should be!

Hankunamatata · 03/12/2021 12:36

Speak to school again. Doesnt matter what this boys topic is - he is bullying your dd

pigsDOfly · 03/12/2021 12:34

The fact that this nasty child is saying OP's DD is trans for wearing trousers or making stupid remarks about the colour of her hair is irrelevant.

If it wasn't those things it would be something else. He's a bully and he will find anything to pick on. It has nothing to do with trousers or hairs colour, it's all about the bullying and it needs to be dealt with strongly by the school

The poster making the ridiculous suggestion that she wears a skirt to appease him is completely missing the point.

Bingbangbongbash · 03/12/2021 08:31

@viques

I don’t think anyone using trans as a slur can be described as woke. But nice try on circling it back to the usual MN transphobia.

OP, if your daughter is strong enough, actually being woke would be my advice. Laugh in his face and tell him it’s not the 1950s so stereotypes of what girls should wear are not cool. (That but less ‘mum’ talk. I assume kids don’t talk about cool 😆)

KatherineJaneway · 03/12/2021 08:18

Wow, are we back here again? In many schools in the 80s girls were forbidden from wearing trousers.

We were forbidden. Same in my first job. No option to wear trousers.

Overreactingmom · 02/12/2021 22:07

@DoubleTweenQueen thank you for raising this point, not sure why this hadn’t occurred to me to do actually! I will make sure going forward though, thanks!

OP posts:
Happy1982ish · 02/12/2021 20:25

[quote Overreactingmom]@Happy1982ish if you read the first post again -

We hadn’t really acted as she seemed to be holding her own and telling him to mind his own etc is what I said in my first post. Of course during this time we also spoke to DD about ways she could handle this.

I then went on to say we contacted school and her teacher was fab and I thought it was sorted. When it began to escalate we did act. We had spoken to school via email and phone calls as contact with staff in person is V limited.

As it has escalated again I have contacted school via email today and will likely have a phone call from her teacher to discuss steps that will be taken going forward.[/quote]
Apologies

DoubleTweenQueen · 02/12/2021 20:13

[quote Overreactingmom]@Happy1982ish if you read the first post again -

We hadn’t really acted as she seemed to be holding her own and telling him to mind his own etc is what I said in my first post. Of course during this time we also spoke to DD about ways she could handle this.

I then went on to say we contacted school and her teacher was fab and I thought it was sorted. When it began to escalate we did act. We had spoken to school via email and phone calls as contact with staff in person is V limited.

As it has escalated again I have contacted school via email today and will likely have a phone call from her teacher to discuss steps that will be taken going forward.[/quote]
Can I suggest that 'in writing' is the best way to go - after a phone convo, write it down in an email - what was covered and what you feel was agreed - and send it to the person you spoke to? Include the school's head of safeguarding too?
Dtq x

2Gen · 02/12/2021 19:38

Your comments are making me wonder if you're taking the piss.
No, we should always teach our children to do what's right, not what's expedient and what's right in this case is to resist caving into bullying! If you give into a bully, it only encourages them! If the young one wants to wear trousers and the school allows it, then the OP should tell her to wear her trousers and tell him to mind his own business!
OP, it's a bit odd that he's got this bee in his bonnet though! Women and girls in the West have worn trousers for decades. Even my late mother, who would be 95 now, started wearing trousers in the early 70s, you know those polyester ones with the elasticated waists from M&S! I wonder where did he get this silly idea from?

Overreactingmom · 02/12/2021 19:11

@Happy1982ish if you read the first post again -

We hadn’t really acted as she seemed to be holding her own and telling him to mind his own etc is what I said in my first post. Of course during this time we also spoke to DD about ways she could handle this.

I then went on to say we contacted school and her teacher was fab and I thought it was sorted. When it began to escalate we did act. We had spoken to school via email and phone calls as contact with staff in person is V limited.

As it has escalated again I have contacted school via email today and will likely have a phone call from her teacher to discuss steps that will be taken going forward.

OP posts:
sheenapunk · 02/12/2021 18:02

The French are about to start jailing school bullies and fining them up to 150k.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 02/12/2021 17:39

Please formally complain ... in writing with at least two people included in the email (teacher, Head) so it can't be buried. And tell them you want it reported to the LEA as well since it's bullying based on homophobia. That is required to be reported by schools

Happy1982ish · 02/12/2021 17:12

Bullying that’s been going on for months
Dad doesn’t seem especially bothered about recent comments
How come you are acting now and not months ago?

TrashyPanda · 02/12/2021 17:10

Contrary13 - huge hugs to your DD

TrashyPanda · 02/12/2021 17:09

[quote MrsBison]@SpeckledHen266

I generally dont go out by myself after 8pm tbh.[/quote]
Not all women have that luxury.

I have been mugged and seriously assaulted - the police officer who arrived said “who the hell did that to you?” - I was literally covered in blood down to my knees. The police decided it was quicker to take me hospital in the back of their Police van than to wait for an ambulance.

And I was with my male partner at the time.

Shit happens.

Im old enough to remember the original “reclaim the night” marches. Women working in solidarity with each other to effect change. Not accepting that they should be dictated to by men.

Chocolatewheatos · 02/12/2021 17:05

He sounds awful. The school need to take this bullying more seriously and talk to his family about the things he's saying.

Overreactingmom · 02/12/2021 16:58

Thank you for all of the replies - I’m glad it’s not just me blowing it out of proportion.

I will 100% not be telling her to wear a skirt instead, not only do I agree with PPs that this is the wrong message entirely, it was bloody -1 walking to school this morning

@Happy1982ish I described her as a tomboy not because of the trousers but because this is how she describes herself - she isn’t into things that are typically seen as ‘girly’…

@Fomofo I just meant that maybe he’s a bit more confident and outspoken than my DD coming from a family with lots of siblings (was just trying to give a full picture as possible - he is one of 6, I used to teach his brother and sister and they are actually very lovely children).

We had a chat this morning before school about how calling someone trans shouldn’t be used as an insult and that even though she’s not particularly upset by the comment another child could be deeply hurt by his name calling if they were feeling unsure of them self.

I had emailed school this morning before I posted it but was worrying maybe I was overthinking it all, harder to judge when it’s your own child etc so i’m glad to see others would do the same and contact school right away.

I guess watch this space to see how they’re going to deal with it

OP posts:
Gumbomambo · 02/12/2021 16:56

Contrary13 bloody hell! What a shite school and what a pair of vile little shits. I’m so sorry for your DD and what she went through. Well done for having her back and a resounding YES from me to this advice. OP show your daughter you will support her no matter what, show her what a strong unapologetic woman looks like. Good luck to you and your DD.

SapphireSeptember · 02/12/2021 16:55

Oh yeah, and for context, primary school I was always in skirts, secondary in trousers, I became an adult and went back to wearing skirts! Now I only wear trousers at work because I have to. In my last job I wore trousers when I was in the cafe, but when that closed and I worked in a different department I switched to skirts.
I was also bullied at school for wearing glasses (couldn't help that) and being a Goth (which I could, but like fuck was I going to give in to the bullies.)

SapphireSeptember · 02/12/2021 16:52

There's always one... Hmm
Since when were trousers solely a male item of clothing? Women in the west have been wearing them since the late 1800s!
kingandallen.co.uk/journal/2016/a-brief-history-of-trousers/#:~:text=By%20the%201880s%2C%20women%20in,allowed%20greater%20freedom%20of%20movement.
OP and her DD should not give in to this sexist, stereotypical bullshit. What year is it again? Oh yes, 2021. What you wear has no bearing on your sex.

BiBabbles · 02/12/2021 16:51

YANBU. Such a rough situation OP. I hope as the school did well before, they can do so again. If there are options, I might consider trying to find out how to make sure she's at a different school for secondary.

Why give people the ammo though?

The OP's daughter has also been teased for being ginger - do you recommend they dye her hair too?

What to do that becomes ammo too? I was bullied bloody for having dyed hair as a kid, but my mother said she coloured it help me make friends so I learned a bunch of fucked up messages.

scottishnames · 02/12/2021 16:48

CaptSkippy
I agree. I can remember the 80s.
Surely, in a rational world, all we need to say is what we said then: that women should wear what makes them feel comfortable and suitably dressed for their (preferred/agreed to) circumstances.
Any problems about how that might be percieved are the fault of the onlookers NOT of the wearer.
Anything less denies respect and autonomy to the wearer. Would a man put up with that? Yes, there are male fahion victims, but on the whole I doubt it.