Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you date a binman?

641 replies

TrishM80 · 02/12/2021 09:17

Inspired by another thread about being a binman as a career.

You meet a guy on a night out or OLD. Seems nice enough and nice looking, all good. Tells you he's a binman.

YABU - immediate turn off
YANBU - give him a chance

OP posts:
EllaPaella · 04/12/2021 07:50

@Kendoddsdadsdogsdadsdead

Binman yes. Tory no.
Haha yes, 100% this
coronafiona · 04/12/2021 07:47

I can't believe someone posted this. It comes across as though you think you're better than 'a binman', snobby and disrespectful. I think you should have a good look at your views.

NinaDefoe · 04/12/2021 07:30

@SnarkyMilarky

Ok, I’m going to be blasted for this opinion but ….

I would not date a bin man , regardless of how “hot/fit” he is. Tbh I wouldn’t consider anyone that is in a job that requires no set of skills eg factory worker, supermarket employee, courier etc etc. Even if you could argue that they could still be very intelligent it means they are aiming stupendously low if they work a job like that.

I don’t expect a prospective partner to be a neurosurgeon or an overtly ambitious and highly successful professional but they need to be gainfully employed in a profession or a career of some sort.

I have a university degree and work in a qualified field so that may have some bearing

I have a university degree and work in a qualified field so that may have some bearing

Some of the most ‘stupendously’ stupid, emotionally stunted, emotionally unintelligent people put on this Earth rise to the top of their profession.

I’m sure many of them have degrees and the like coming out of their backside.

You only have to look at our esteemed PM to see a prime example of that.

SnarkyMilarky · 04/12/2021 07:09

Ok, I’m going to be blasted for this opinion but ….

I would not date a bin man , regardless of how “hot/fit” he is. Tbh I wouldn’t consider anyone that is in a job that requires no set of skills eg factory worker, supermarket employee, courier etc etc. Even if you could argue that they could still be very intelligent it means they are aiming stupendously low if they work a job like that.

I don’t expect a prospective partner to be a neurosurgeon or an overtly ambitious and highly successful professional but they need to be gainfully employed in a profession or a career of some sort.

I have a university degree and work in a qualified field so that may have some bearing

FrenchFancie · 04/12/2021 06:19

I may be biased here but no…. Because the creepiest date I ever had was with a bin man in my twenties and he turned into a bit of a stalker!! Not going there again ever…. (I realise that I am tarring all bin men with the same brush and that’s not fair but….. creepy James the bin man has put me off for life!)

Sheerdetermination · 04/12/2021 06:07

This is an unpleasant, snobby question. I wouldn’t date someone who had these kind of discussions.

Panacotta · 04/12/2021 06:00

Sexy bin men you say? 🤔

Would you date a binman?
Would you date a binman?
Would you date a binman?
Derkle · 04/12/2021 02:34

I'd have to ask a couple of questions. Does he treat me well? Does he like animals? Is he funny and smart? Does he "rev my engine"? Then yes. But that particular questionnaire is for all potential love interests, not just those who happen to be bin men.

CandidClarisse · 04/12/2021 01:06

Some of them are super hot! Also think about it, they are not afraid of hard work or getting stuck in, they get up early, are motivated, physically fit, decent tan from being outdoors, tend to finish early so have more time to spend with you etc. What's not to like!

GodIsAVegan · 04/12/2021 00:40

Ya nonsense. Most people when asked "what does your partner do" would cringe at having to answer "bin man", even if he was the most amazing man in the world to them. You people are lying.

I think that shows your character and what matters to you. I would never be embarrassed of someone doing a job like this, they’re earning money, it’s an important service and it’s not hurting anyone.
The sorts of things I value in people are kindness, compassion for others, loyalty etc. Those traits can be found across most jobs, being a bin man doesn’t automatically rule out any traits that are important to me, it would depend on the individual.
Someone mentioned they couldn’t date someone that worked in an abattoir, I’d agree with that because to me they would lack the sort of compassion for animals that I’d need someone close to me to have.

Fidgetty · 04/12/2021 00:13

Ya nonsense. Most people when asked "what does your partner do" would cringe at having to answer "bin man", even if he was the most amazing man in the world to them. You people are lying.

TonytheDog · 03/12/2021 23:58

So every single person creates waste but most people don't seem to value the people that magically take that waste away, from often very stinky bins, every week/2weeks.
Why?
I couldn't care less if someone was a refuse collector or a heart surgeon if they were kind.

PizzaCrust · 03/12/2021 23:58

Also, to add.

From my single days when I was in my early twenties, I had some of the best chats/connections with men in jobs like these, or retail and the like.

The worst conversations I had were with ‘professionals’. Several doctors were creepy bastards. A lawyer was another creepy bastard. Another man in a professional, very well paid job was also a creepy bastard. On paper they earned a lot of money, had great career potential and whatnot, but they were sleazy and snobby in equal measure.

There was a time with one of them where I had to run out of his house in the early hours because (however naive I may have been), he asked me back for a few drinks and casual chat and within 10 minutes had lured me upstairs under the pretence of showing me something and then tried to get on top of me when I sat on the very end of his bed. And kept insisting/pressuring when I clearly said I wasn’t interested.

That’s exactly why a man’s occupation would rarely put me off. I’ve had enough experiences to know that just because a man is well paid doesn’t mean shit for what he’s like out of the office.

(Disclaimer: of course there will be sleazy bin men and lovely doctors but I will always focus on a man’s behaviour and nature long before what he does for a living. As long as he is working or has a valid reason for not working, it really doesn’t matter to me. I’d much rather have less disposable joint income and a man treat me well than be very well off and have a man treat me like shit).

angelfacecuti75 · 03/12/2021 23:57

If he is sexy and fit....id have a go at it...

PizzaCrust · 03/12/2021 23:44

@Fidgetty

I think many are being disingenuous with their replies

I think so too. There's a stigma attached, rightly or wrongly (wrongly IMO but it still exists) and all this faux "what's not to like?" is a bit 🙄

I don’t think they are.

Someone is earning an honest wage, that’s a pretty good place to start. Much better than half of the wastes of space you read about on here who have grandiose ideas of themselves while they sit at home for years “waiting for their business idea to take off” or refusing to apply for jobs because they’re “beneath” them. I’d much rather date a bin man who goes out to work, earns money and comes home rather than me paying for him to sit at home thinking he’s the fucking shit because he wants to launch a business no one has launched before (for good reason).

Also, purely assumption but bin men tend to start early, so I assume they finish their shifts quite early too? Would be super handy for school pick ups if their dad was done work by 2pm, as an example. Similarly, they seem to get bank holidays off and council work has decent holidays, pay, etc.

The only off putting element would be the smell/clothes, which I presume most bin men get around by having a post work shower and chucking their clothes in the wash when they get in. That really wouldn’t be that difficult.

I grew up on a farm so I’m forever used to properly dirty clothes from the farm and it really isn’t a big deal. Washing machines and showers exist, and I can’t imagine a bin man smells any worse than a farmer after putting out slurry and/or feeding silage to cattle. Similarly, builders etc would have just as dirty clothes.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with it as a job. I’m glad that most posters on this thread can see out of their own arseholes to realise that.

LobsterNapkin · 03/12/2021 23:39

I think I would, theoretically, but then I never had so maybe that is easy to say. Though I did date a guy who worked in a travelling carnival once, some people might consider that a similar social level.

In reality though most people end up dating people of a similar social, income and educational level, and women are less likely to date someone who is supposedly lower in the hierarchy than men are. I don't know that's usually about snobbishness so much as who we relate to most easily.

5128gap · 03/12/2021 23:37

@Fidgetty

I think many are being disingenuous with their replies

I think so too. There's a stigma attached, rightly or wrongly (wrongly IMO but it still exists) and all this faux "what's not to like?" is a bit 🙄

It really depends where you are in life though and what your priorities are. I earn enough to more than adequately support myself, and don't need a man's income. My tastes are not extravagant so its highly unlikely a bin man wouldn't be able to afford to do the things I enjoy, and if he couldn't, I'm perfectly capable of doing them alone or with friends. Experience has taught me that a person's job is not a reflection of their intelligence, wit, warmth, strength of character, capacity to love and have fun, or their level of physical attractiveness, and these are my priorities. I have no interest in avoiding stigma, as I have no interest in the views of people who would stigmatise a job that harms no one and has value to society. So, I'm being entirely honest when I say I wouldn't mind, and am sure I'm not unique in that.
HandforthParishCouncilClerk · 03/12/2021 23:35

No, purely because I cannot do early mornings if I can possibly avoid it. The same applies to milkmen, farmers, hospital doctors, lifeboat crew….. After 5 years of a non-sleeping child, I couldn’t get into a relationship with anyone I knew would have a more than usual chance of disturbing my precious sleep Grin

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/12/2021 23:24

@Fidgetty

I think many are being disingenuous with their replies

I think so too. There's a stigma attached, rightly or wrongly (wrongly IMO but it still exists) and all this faux "what's not to like?" is a bit 🙄

How many people have actually been faced with the situation though? I agree that a lot of people are virtue signalling but really depends on your life situation. When I was younger I wouldn't have cared my only criteria was hot, nice and interesting Grin money was never a problem as i could always find cheap things to do anyway. As I got older I got pickier, using what I'd learnt from previous dating experiences and the path my life would take.

Sometimes though if you meet a person and you're not really looking you just date them and don't really filter compared to OLD

TractorAndHeadphones · 03/12/2021 23:19

[quote Luredbyapomegranate]@5128gap

I wouldn't be wild about being with someone so wealthy what I brought in was irrelevant, and maybe they wouldn't want to date me, come to that. People tend to be in relationships with people with whom they have a fair degree in common.[/quote]
This.
Also however out of touch it may sounds to some people what's a good income depends on your circumstances.
Compared to care/retail/hospitality work 30K a year + short hours is good. Senior waste management professional earning 50K also good.
But if your circle (like a lot of mine) are in accounting, tech etc 30K is a starting salary, after a raft of qualifications/exams etc people top out at at least 70K. You don't necessarily have to work crazy hours after a certain point either if you're comfortable remaining at that level.

Not that I was quite bothered. My concern was about about a profession transferable to my home country (where binmen are on minimum wage with no advancement opportunities). But I can see why people consider income. Especially if you're young and don't realise how much of an advantage etc it is having one parent more suited to staying home already if you're a 'high flier'.

@Weddell I wouldn't want to date a sportsperson either, all the faffing about with meals ... seeing DP eat my cooking makes me happy Grin

Fidgetty · 03/12/2021 23:16

I think many are being disingenuous with their replies

I think so too. There's a stigma attached, rightly or wrongly (wrongly IMO but it still exists) and all this faux "what's not to like?" is a bit 🙄

Mamanyt · 03/12/2021 23:12

Goodness, yes. I have a binman whom, if I were 40 years younger, I would trip and hit the ground before he did. He's drop-dead gorgeous, never fails to have a smile and wave to whomever is out on his route, and appears to be a perfectly nice person. I'd certainly take the time to find out if he's as nice as he appears.

Ddot · 03/12/2021 23:12

I frequented a nightclub that a lot of rich men visited. A plank started to chat me up, he then asked me what I did. I told him I worked on the market, he seemed more interested his eyes lit up. I work in the market to, he scarped quick when I explained I didnt work in stocks but actually on a market stall 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

OhWhyNot · 03/12/2021 22:53

No I wouldn’t be outraged

Do you really believe so many who have replied (given that it’s MN) really wouldn’t care?

Oh please

5128gap · 03/12/2021 22:45

@DerektheGoose

Jeez some of these answers are depressing. Imagine if the roles were reversed. "Would you date a retail assistant/bar maid/care worker?"
They wouldn't be. Most men wouldn't care less about jobs. Their version of this thread would be would you date an unattractive woman. But yeah, imagine the outrage.