Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you date a binman?

641 replies

TrishM80 · 02/12/2021 09:17

Inspired by another thread about being a binman as a career.

You meet a guy on a night out or OLD. Seems nice enough and nice looking, all good. Tells you he's a binman.

YABU - immediate turn off
YANBU - give him a chance

OP posts:
Panacotta · 04/12/2021 16:36

@CaliforniaDrumming I'm also a post grad. Love some muscles though 🤷🏻‍♀️

Panacotta · 04/12/2021 16:33

@PWYP76

Bin man: Yep.

Tory: Get f_cked!

This 100%
Bluesparkled · 04/12/2021 15:38

@wheresmyshoe

Yes, in fact I follow a binman on Twitter. He's in ridiculously good physical shape, always immaculately dressed and.... he's a highly respected amateur botanist with a zest for life that is utterly inspirational. The man is pure joy.
Me too, amazing guy and seems to really love his job.
Marinerscove · 04/12/2021 14:32

Anyone else think of Roz in Frasier?

liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 14:25

understand how you feel though. I wouldn’t date the male equivalent of you, for instance. Mostly because every time I’ve met someone who holds similar views, they’ve turned out to be a massive snotty nosed arsehole who genuinely believes that what they do for eight hours a day defines them as a person and that they are somehow more worthy and valuable to society because they’ve been to university.

I don't think it's about what they do for 8 hours but surely more what they earn and how that impacts on lifestyle. If someone earns a high income and enjoys 5 star holidays to the Maldives , expensive restaurants and ski trips to St Moritz and lives in a large house, they are likely to want someone who they can enjoy these things with. Surely that doesn't make them a bad person or necessarily dull or snotty nosed?

Personally I'd be thrilled to meet a bin man as I'd assume they have early nights and personally I struggle to stay up past 10.
I think we'd be quite compatible 😆

RachaelN · 04/12/2021 12:41

Yes! I did. He is now an engineer and we are engaged. What a weird thing to question!

Sn0tnose · 04/12/2021 11:41

@SnarkyMilarky

Ok, I’m going to be blasted for this opinion but ….

I would not date a bin man , regardless of how “hot/fit” he is. Tbh I wouldn’t consider anyone that is in a job that requires no set of skills eg factory worker, supermarket employee, courier etc etc. Even if you could argue that they could still be very intelligent it means they are aiming stupendously low if they work a job like that.

I don’t expect a prospective partner to be a neurosurgeon or an overtly ambitious and highly successful professional but they need to be gainfully employed in a profession or a career of some sort.

I have a university degree and work in a qualified field so that may have some bearing

My DH works in a supermarket. He is, without a doubt, the best person I have ever met and I’m bloody lucky to have him.

I understand how you feel though. I wouldn’t date the male equivalent of you, for instance. Mostly because every time I’ve met someone who holds similar views, they’ve turned out to be a massive snotty nosed arsehole who genuinely believes that what they do for eight hours a day defines them as a person and that they are somehow more worthy and valuable to society because they’ve been to university.

OP, why Binmen? Why not middle management? It’s almost as though what you’re really asking is whether people would date someone poor and working class, but you haven’t quite got the nerve to come out and say it in case you get accused of snobbery.

MumUndone · 04/12/2021 11:33

No I wouldn't.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/12/2021 11:28

@KingaBee

That was not the question. Bin men can also be geeks with glasses and a masters in philosophy. Especially if they are immigrants.

Intellectual connection is important to me too but because I’m not silly enough to assume that the job the man is doing has anything to do with his intellectual capabilities, I have dated men doing all kinds of jobs. Honestly the only people I have never connected with were hedge fund managers.

I'm a non-EU immigrant and we can't stay in Britain unless we have a professional jobs that sponsors visas. Plenty of us manage. Yes, even those of us with degrees with history, politics and philosophy. Gone are the days when educated people from Commonwealth countries had to drive taxis, if they're recent immigrants they're here on a spousal visa (in which case off limits). Or refugees which is a very small number.

Someone who has a degree and can enter unsponsored is either British or from the EU. Most likely white. If they can work at any employer across the whole country and STILL can't find a more relevant job I'd bit a bit Hmm.

PWYP76 · 04/12/2021 11:19

Bin man: Yep.

Tory: Get f_cked!

SnarkyMilarky · 04/12/2021 11:05

@KingaBee

That was not the question. Bin men can also be geeks with glasses and a masters in philosophy. Especially if they are immigrants.

Intellectual connection is important to me too but because I’m not silly enough to assume that the job the man is doing has anything to do with his intellectual capabilities, I have dated men doing all kinds of jobs. Honestly the only people I have never connected with were hedge fund managers.

But my point being is that you can have a charming, intelligent man and take your example he has a Masters in Philosophy and is an immigrant. He is aiming low if works a job that requires no set of skills. A person like that could easily find a path in a more skilled job eg marketing, project management etc etc.

I value kindness and intelligence plus I guess an equal in terms of their income or employment. The MN’s that harp on about how if he was fit they’d have a go are equally as shallow as me who would be looking for someone with a skilled job or career.

womaninatightspot · 04/12/2021 11:01

Bin men do ok. Tend to work long hours normally a 3 day one week and 4 days the next where I am. I think people are a bit weird about peole who do manual work tbh.

liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 10:59

This thread has a massive number of masters grads who are also binmen, but I do not see this IRL. It's a reach. Very dishonest thread.

Also a lot of master grads who absolutely would (however don't) date a binman

CaliforniaDrumming · 04/12/2021 10:09

@KingaBee

That was not the question. Bin men can also be geeks with glasses and a masters in philosophy. Especially if they are immigrants.

Intellectual connection is important to me too but because I’m not silly enough to assume that the job the man is doing has anything to do with his intellectual capabilities, I have dated men doing all kinds of jobs. Honestly the only people I have never connected with were hedge fund managers.

This thread has a massive number of masters grads who are also binmen, but I do not see this IRL. It's a reach. Very dishonest thread.
iloveruby · 04/12/2021 10:07

No I wouldn't look at a binman as a potential life partner because I would want to be with someone who had a similar lifestyle.

Rightly or wrongly binmen arent well paid - I wouldn't be happy in a partnership with someone where we were worrying about money, struggling to afford to pay the mortgage etc.

KingaBee · 04/12/2021 09:52

That was not the question. Bin men can also be geeks with glasses and a masters in philosophy. Especially if they are immigrants.

Intellectual connection is important to me too but because I’m not silly enough to assume that the job the man is doing has anything to do with his intellectual capabilities, I have dated men doing all kinds of jobs. Honestly the only people I have never connected with were hedge fund managers.

liveforsummer · 04/12/2021 09:51

@SnarkyMilarky

Ok, I’m going to be blasted for this opinion but ….

I would not date a bin man , regardless of how “hot/fit” he is. Tbh I wouldn’t consider anyone that is in a job that requires no set of skills eg factory worker, supermarket employee, courier etc etc. Even if you could argue that they could still be very intelligent it means they are aiming stupendously low if they work a job like that.

I don’t expect a prospective partner to be a neurosurgeon or an overtly ambitious and highly successful professional but they need to be gainfully employed in a profession or a career of some sort.

I have a university degree and work in a qualified field so that may have some bearing

I think you are one of the few people on this thread who is being honest - either that or the title has attracted comments from people outside of the usual mn demographic, which I guess is possible.
themagicnumberthree · 04/12/2021 09:41

My husband works as a waste water process operator i.e. sewage. So yes. Showers and washes his clothes at work, never smells of poo. Starts work at 7 so on the days I work he can pick our son up from school. Works well for all of us

CaliforniaDrumming · 04/12/2021 09:17

@Panacotta

Sexy bin men you say? 🤔
I don't find these men attractive. Is that allowed on this prescriptive thread? 🙂 I don't like overmuscled types. I like a nice geek with glasses and a postgrad degree. Because I am a geek with glasses and a postgrad degree.
weller34 · 04/12/2021 09:07

👏🏻

burnoutbabe · 04/12/2021 08:26

No as I really don't think we'd have much in common when I have worked in professional jobs all my life and have done extra course etc. I just can't see how we'd have many shared goals /values?

5128gap · 04/12/2021 08:21

@Panacotta

Sexy bin men you say? 🤔
Those are WC fetish images. Fantasy fodder for people who typically wouldn't consider RL men with those jobs as partners.
feelsobadfeltsogood · 04/12/2021 08:10

Just like to add our bin men - 2 out the 4 are really nice looking
They work hard and are always polite

What an awful thing to discriminate against

backtolifebacktoreality · 04/12/2021 07:59

@Kendoddsdadsdogsdadsdead

Binman yes. Tory no.

This

5128gap · 04/12/2021 07:52

@LobsterNapkin

I think I would, theoretically, but then I never had so maybe that is easy to say. Though I did date a guy who worked in a travelling carnival once, some people might consider that a similar social level.

In reality though most people end up dating people of a similar social, income and educational level, and women are less likely to date someone who is supposedly lower in the hierarchy than men are. I don't know that's usually about snobbishness so much as who we relate to most easily.

Who we relate to most most is a smokescreen to cover a desire for a man who makes a lot of money, and who consequently they see as the best provider. High earning men are not a homogenous mass with the same interests, values and beliefs and avguarantee yiu will get on with them. Its just that the people arguing this are also at pains to stress how educated and successful they themselves are, and the idea of desiring a man's income doesn't sit well with that.