Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be absolutely furious at friend

567 replies

JustLyra · 02/12/2021 00:37

Four of us in a friend group.

We all do nice birthday presents for each other, and have done for 10+ years.

One of the group is having a tough time and is in the middle of moving house so we decide to do a small gift and a voucher so that it’s easier with our move.
Two of us also made clear we felt a voucher was a better option atm because friend is going to have to lot a house from top to bottom rather unexpectedly the other agreed. They offered to take the money and sort the voucher and a nice card.

They then decided, without any discussion, that there was “too big a risk” our friend would buy practical and boring stuff and not treat themselves.

So they’ve bought a fucking Costa Coffee voucher. Basically so they can only buy coffees and cakes.

Aibu to think that that’s completely out of order, and a shit present

OP posts:
3luckystars · 03/12/2021 21:09

What an asshole! I would hate that ‘gift’, pity you can’t take it back and get a refund.

Doesn’t it feel a bit controlling to buy something so specific. Like I give a gift so the person will enjoy it, not that give them instructions on what they are allowed to spend it on.

LouBan · 03/12/2021 21:07

It's not a great present but more importantly, it's not what was agreed upon. The one buying the voucher should have asked those of you who chipped in before buying it. A shopping centre voucher is always best because the recipient can choose how to spend it and if your friend wants to spend her voucher on practical things why should it bother anyone else?

SplodgeWaddler · 03/12/2021 20:56

OP do you think the one who bought the Costa voucher might have a bit of a prob with the friend who’s moving - it does seem a bit unkind tbh.

Jumpingintochristmas · 03/12/2021 20:54

@SplodgeWaddler

YANBU I f’ing hate Costa coffee. If Costa were sausages they’d be Richmonds Xmas Grin
Exactly!!!
SplodgeWaddler · 03/12/2021 20:53

YANBU I f’ing hate Costa coffee. If Costa were sausages they’d be Richmonds Xmas Grin

IncompleteSenten · 03/12/2021 20:52

I think a voucher that can be used in several places she loves to visit is very thoughtful.
It gives her choices between different things she is known to like.

JustLyra · 03/12/2021 20:52

@Eggshausted

So you don’t want her to spend it on things for her house? She might like to buy some cushions or a mirror or a quilt cover. It’s not a gift if you are buying what you want to receive or control what someone spends a voucher on. You’re just as bad as the person who spends £80 on a Costa coffee gift card! Wtf!
Wtf is exactly what I’m thinking right now? @Eggshausted

The voucher we were buying was chosen precisely because she could spend it on hair, nails, takeaways, curtains, cushions, the weekly shop, Christmas presents etc.

She could have bought something as a “treat” or she could have bought her weekly grocery shop. I wanted her to have exactly that freedom of buying either what she wanted or what she needed.

OP posts:
Eggshausted · 03/12/2021 20:47

So you don’t want her to spend it on things for her house? She might like to buy some cushions or a mirror or a quilt cover. It’s not a gift if you are buying what you want to receive or control what someone spends a voucher on. You’re just as bad as the person who spends £80 on a Costa coffee gift card! Wtf!

grapewine · 03/12/2021 20:39

The voucher we agreed to give her covers her favourite hair place, the place she gets her nails done, several takeaways she likes, plus other shops. It’s also somewhere she goes to regularly.

I'd have loved this! Costa not so much. Hope it gets sorted, perhaps with MIL's help. YANBU.

JustLyra · 03/12/2021 20:38

@Crunchymum The Costa voucher is particular thoughtless because she doesn’t go there.

We already know a voucher isn’t going to be as nice as the gifts the rest of us have had this year. None of us are thick.
This piss take turns a moderately thoughtful (in terms of we sat down for ages and tried to work out how to make the best of a bad situation) gift and turns it into an utterly shit gift that she likely wouldn’t use.

OP posts:
Crunchymum · 03/12/2021 20:36

Although now I'm reading between the lines I assume birthday friend is in some kind of temporary / emergency accommodation which makes vouchers a sensible choice for her.

I'd go back to Costa friend and give her to option to give you receipt / give to your MIL and go back to the original plan.

leawg1986 · 03/12/2021 20:36

I completely agree with you! Your other friend seems to be a bit of a dick, taking over the situation and coming back with a crap, thoughtless “gift”

Crunchymum · 03/12/2021 20:35

@JustLyra

The Costa friend is out of order (but I don't necessarily think they had nefarious intentions) but how was a gift voucher for "somewhere else" not a thoughtless gift?

A voucher that can be used anywhere in the shopping centre isn't special or thoughtful or particularly tailored to your friend having a tough time is it?

It’s not, but it gives her options. Which was the point.
Ideally, right now, we’d have given her cash, but she wouldn’t have taken it.

We’ve got her a small token gift because she can’t have much stuff where she is and we don’t know when she’ll be moving or how much help she’ll have.

The voucher we agreed to give her covers her favourite hair place, the place she gets her nails done, several takeaways she likes, plus other shops. It’s also somewhere she goes to regularly.

Having been in similar situations we (well two of us ou turned out) didn’t think it was helpful to give her a specific voucher for one place when maybe a different one would have been better. And we couldn’t ask her because she’s one of the “oh wherever, no fuss is needed” kind of people.

We rarely do vouchers, but we have occasionally in the past. For example when I lost 8 stone they gave me a similar voucher that could be used in multiple clothes and shoe shops so I could pick whichever one I wanted.

We wanted her to have a choice.

I completely understand your intentions re: the gift voucher that can be used in numerous places and I understand you being pissed of with Costa friend as she went against what was agreed. However bemoaning how thoughtless a Costa voucher is / telling us how wonderful everyone else's birthday gifts were kind of makes any type of gift voucher feel a little crap?

I just think you are convoluting two different issues.

AnAverageMum · 03/12/2021 20:21

I was going to say YABU when I thought it was a £20 voucher but £80!!! I love Costa, I’d appreciate my coffees being covered for a few weeks… but I’d much rather spend £80 on something more substantial for my birthday!

Blondeshavemorefun · 03/12/2021 20:21

Friend didn’t want to get a voucher in caee birthday friend didn’t spend it on treats for herself and more essentials

Sh gets a £80 one for a coffee shop

That’s hardly a treat

JustLyra · 03/12/2021 20:18

The Costa friend is out of order (but I don't necessarily think they had nefarious intentions) but how was a gift voucher for "somewhere else" not a thoughtless gift?

A voucher that can be used anywhere in the shopping centre isn't special or thoughtful or particularly tailored to your friend having a tough time is it?

It’s not, but it gives her options. Which was the point.
Ideally, right now, we’d have given her cash, but she wouldn’t have taken it.

We’ve got her a small token gift because she can’t have much stuff where she is and we don’t know when she’ll be moving or how much help she’ll have.

The voucher we agreed to give her covers her favourite hair place, the place she gets her nails done, several takeaways she likes, plus other shops. It’s also somewhere she goes to regularly.

Having been in similar situations we (well two of us ou turned out) didn’t think it was helpful to give her a specific voucher for one place when maybe a different one would have been better. And we couldn’t ask her because she’s one of the “oh wherever, no fuss is needed” kind of people.

We rarely do vouchers, but we have occasionally in the past. For example when I lost 8 stone they gave me a similar voucher that could be used in multiple clothes and shoe shops so I could pick whichever one I wanted.

We wanted her to have a choice.

OP posts:
Kate0902900908 · 03/12/2021 20:18

Unless this friend is in costa coffee most days then this is outrageous and the voucher should be sold or returned or maybe swapped for a voucher that can be used on something your friend chooses! £80 costa coffee wtf!!! I would be livid and frankly embarrassed to put my name to that gift! I would say to voucher buying friend I'm sorry this is not what was agreed and I don't want to give her a coffee voucher it's impersonal completely impractical and a waste!

IncompleteSenten · 03/12/2021 20:13

It's not on because it's not what was agreed. It's not acceptable to get money collected from a few people for an agreed purchase then unilaterally decide to get something else because you've decided only something you deem worthy can be bought. It's bloody arrogant for a start!

I think since your mil has said she'll buy it you have the perfect response.

Friend will not like this! I don't know why you got it when it wasn't what we agreed. Anyway, my mil says she'll buy it so give it and the receipt and I'll go get the vouchers we agreed on with the money mil will give me.

If your friend has indeed screwed you over, this will be instantly obvious.

Crunchymum · 03/12/2021 20:04

@JustLyra

One of the reasons I’m so pissed off is that our friend has had a really, really awful time.

To get such a thoughtless gift (as I’ve said a couple of times - she doesn’t even often go to Costa) from her closest friends at a shit time could be really upsetting.

The Costa friend is out of order (but I don't necessarily think they had nefarious intentions) but how was a gift voucher for "somewhere else" not a thoughtless gift?

A voucher that can be used anywhere in the shopping centre isn't special or thoughtful or particularly tailored to your friend having a tough time is it?

goose1964 · 03/12/2021 20:03

Costa coffee's coffee is awful so not a treat

HarrisonStickle · 03/12/2021 20:02

@HermioneHere

I wonder if there's any way to find out....!

Probably not but I'd be livid. That's not how you treat a friend. Does she have previous form?

I'd be tempted to be passive aggressive and say something like, "Oh, I thought you'd paid £80 so the voucher was going to be more than that because of the special offer they've had on". See what her face does to that! Grin
shampooing · 03/12/2021 20:01

I'd be raging too.

A costa voucher for a teenager or someone who goes there all the time is a nice gift, but max £20.
It just feels like such a waste of money.
Even my friends who do go to Costa or Starbucks or whatever would agree.
I don't go so would be really peeved but even if it were for a cafe I liked I'd be a bit hmmm.

Justgorgeous · 03/12/2021 20:00

I hate Costa coffee places so yes awful gift. If you are going with a voucher why not John Lewis ?

HarrisonStickle · 03/12/2021 20:00

I'd ask for my share of the money back. Not much says "We don't really care" as much as an £80 coffee voucher!

JustLyra · 03/12/2021 19:57

@thenewduchessofhastings

If you friend was moving house I'd have gotten them a just eat voucher as it would have come in handy in those few days whilst the kitchen was being unpacked
Several of her favourite take away places take the voucher we originally agreed to buy.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread