Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be absolutely furious at friend

567 replies

JustLyra · 02/12/2021 00:37

Four of us in a friend group.

We all do nice birthday presents for each other, and have done for 10+ years.

One of the group is having a tough time and is in the middle of moving house so we decide to do a small gift and a voucher so that it’s easier with our move.
Two of us also made clear we felt a voucher was a better option atm because friend is going to have to lot a house from top to bottom rather unexpectedly the other agreed. They offered to take the money and sort the voucher and a nice card.

They then decided, without any discussion, that there was “too big a risk” our friend would buy practical and boring stuff and not treat themselves.

So they’ve bought a fucking Costa Coffee voucher. Basically so they can only buy coffees and cakes.

Aibu to think that that’s completely out of order, and a shit present

OP posts:
Swirlywoo · 03/12/2021 18:56

Oh dear, I bought a costa coffee voucher for a relative recently. Didn't realise it was such a crap gift. £80 is a bit much though. Mine was £10 and she is 16.

That aside, why are you all spending so much money on each other every birthday? It seems like a lot to organise four times a year. Who needs the stress of voucher disagreement? Just buy your own gifts for each other in future. I am in a group of four old friends and we sometimes buy for each other, sometimes don't, sometimes do jointly, sometimes separately, and it's all a bit more relaxed than this.

EmotionalSupportBear · 03/12/2021 18:51

this is one of those 'know your audience' presents.

i'd love it, but i get coffee at least twice a week, so it'd save me quite a bit of money in the long run.

If birthday friend isn't a coffee fiend and only goes once in a bluemoon, then its a dumb present.

Voucher buying friend should have stuck to the agreed plan though.

gofg · 03/12/2021 18:50

I love going out for coffee and cake, so that would be an acceptable gift for me. Having said that. I'm not in the UK so haven't a clue what Costa is like!

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 03/12/2021 18:50

I mean I would love to receive a coffee shop voucher, that I could use for multiple coffees / cakes / lunches.. but that was not what you had agreed the money was for, so it’s irrelevant if it’s a “good” gift (which is subjective anyway) voucher buying friend is in the wrong to change the plan without agreement.

Wexone · 03/12/2021 18:50

If i was you i would be also so mad at your friend. If you are friends for so long , i think its poor form of you friend that she doesn't know the birthday girl well enough to know that a costa voucher would not be appreciated by her. I actually like coast ( one of the few that do from this thread) don't drink tea or coffee but love their hot chocolate, always threat myself to one whenever am near one, yes it is expansive but i love it. This voucher i my opinion is up there with vouchers from pennys ( primark), aldi vouchers etc. When you buy something as a present you buy them something or a voucher for somewhere they love to buy from but would never do themselves .Am waiting patiently to hear what your other friend that is away says

PeachCottonTree · 03/12/2021 18:50

That’s nice of your MIL, definitely get the receipt though!

I agree £80 Costa voucher is a rubbish gift for anyone who doesn’t visit regularly and love it. It would take me over 5 years to spend that much there!

fakereview · 03/12/2021 18:46

@Plumbuddle

If someone did that to me and I could be prepared for the fallout, I would tell them I absolutely do not want to give a shabby Costa voucher and they should keep it for their own gradual use, putting the other two friends' money back in a new kitty. Costs tastes horrible and if you wanted a posh treat you most certainly would not go there.
Agree. If I'd contributed I'd kick up big time. £80 for Costa!

At least with M&S you can use it for quite a few things - nice food, chocolate, wine, household stuff, "normal" food if you were short of cash, even knickers and tights!

Nocutenamesleft · 03/12/2021 18:46

That’s a proper shit gift!

And £80?!? Jesus. That would take me about 8 years to get through!

froggybiby · 03/12/2021 18:46

It's not a present I'd personally like...I suspect she had it already as others mentioned...I teach on a Saturday and was given 2 gift cards in June by the parents....about similar amount in John Lewis and experience gift (forgot the name). Just spent the John Lewis one on lovely Radley bag on with black Friday deals. I wouldn't be happy with the decision your friend took.

TitsInAbsentia · 03/12/2021 18:44

@JustLyra

One of the reasons I’m so pissed off is that our friend has had a really, really awful time.

To get such a thoughtless gift (as I’ve said a couple of times - she doesn’t even often go to Costa) from her closest friends at a shit time could be really upsetting.

You're being totally reasonable on this one, if I were your friend I'd be thinking have these people not understood how things are for me right now, so much so that they have gifted me a couple of months of shite coffee?!
Plumbuddle · 03/12/2021 18:43

If someone did that to me and I could be prepared for the fallout, I would tell them I absolutely do not want to give a shabby Costa voucher and they should keep it for their own gradual use, putting the other two friends' money back in a new kitty.
Costs tastes horrible and if you wanted a posh treat you most certainly would not go there.

JustLyra · 03/12/2021 18:42

One of the reasons I’m so pissed off is that our friend has had a really, really awful time.

To get such a thoughtless gift (as I’ve said a couple of times - she doesn’t even often go to Costa) from her closest friends at a shit time could be really upsetting.

OP posts:
Nothing7 · 03/12/2021 18:40

And yes I would be really hacked off - as if I was the voucher buyer and had a bit of a brain fail and thought I had a better idea than the original plan I would have absolutely sense checked with the other people contributing

Nothing7 · 03/12/2021 18:37

Weirdest present ever - why would anyone spend that much money on a voucher for a coffee shop. I agree love to shop voucher which can be used in loads of places and an amount like £80 could be used for more expensive item that will last. Even weirder that it’s been bought for someone that’s not even that fussed over coffee. I would be gutted if a friend bought me that and I like coffee but I wouldn’t want to be fixed to a chain coffee shop to buy £80 worth of coffee. Weird!!!

JustLyra · 03/12/2021 18:37

@mam0918

You are both unreasonable:
  1. mainly because vouchers SUCK as a gift... they get lost, forgotten, have expirey dates and can usually only be spent in certain places, they are the top of all PITA gifts.

I hate cash as I think it's lazy, impersonal and says I couldn't be bothered to put the effort in so do the work of buying your own gift BUT at least it can be used for anything anywhere and doesn't come with terms and bloody conditions.

I agree with your friend it always ends up going on bills and shit you need not 'gifts' but I disagree with the concept of an £80 costa card for someone who doesn't 'LOVE' costa because thats a stupidly high amount to be forced in one place.

  1. Why couldn't you give her £20 for her house if that's what YOU deem best and your friend gives her £20 worth of Costa vouchers and your other friend does as she deems best rather than all this pissing about arguing over which voucher is best.

Grown women doing this weird codependent gifting thing is bizarre (there's not even any reason it's not like you were buying an expensive item, just basically giving cash with rules) especially when you don't even agree with each others gifting ideas.

The point of the voucher we agreed to buy was that it can be used in various places that she currently has treats (hair and nails mainly) but could also be used for other stuff if it was needed.

Vouchers aren’t our normal go to, but the situation the friend is in isn’t normal either.

There’s nothing codependent about celebrating our birthdays. That’s a bizarre thing to say.

As for Why couldn't you give her £20 for her house if that's what YOU deem best and your friend gives her £20 worth of Costa vouchers and your other friend does as she deems best rather than all this pissing about arguing over which voucher is best. - If the voucher buyer had disagreed we’d have either opted for something else or bought our own gifts. The “pissing about” is because someone took other people’s money (more than £20 each) and spent it on something that we would never have agreed on.

OP posts:
cherish123 · 03/12/2021 18:30

I assume it's quite a lot of money. Costa is fairly yuck and the kind of place you go when there's nowhere else.

drpet49 · 03/12/2021 18:29

I wonder if she already had the £80 Costa voucher and was looking to offload it.

mam0918 · 03/12/2021 18:27

You are both unreasonable:

  1. mainly because vouchers SUCK as a gift... they get lost, forgotten, have expirey dates and can usually only be spent in certain places, they are the top of all PITA gifts.

I hate cash as I think it's lazy, impersonal and says I couldn't be bothered to put the effort in so do the work of buying your own gift BUT at least it can be used for anything anywhere and doesn't come with terms and bloody conditions.

I agree with your friend it always ends up going on bills and shit you need not 'gifts' but I disagree with the concept of an £80 costa card for someone who doesn't 'LOVE' costa because thats a stupidly high amount to be forced in one place.

  1. Why couldn't you give her £20 for her house if that's what YOU deem best and your friend gives her £20 worth of Costa vouchers and your other friend does as she deems best rather than all this pissing about arguing over which voucher is best.

Grown women doing this weird codependent gifting thing is bizarre (there's not even any reason it's not like you were buying an expensive item, just basically giving cash with rules) especially when you don't even agree with each others gifting ideas.

Prescottdanni123 · 03/12/2021 18:26

YANBU. If you are buying someone a voucher, it is up to them what they spend it on. It is not for the voucher buying friend to dictate whether or not it is spent on something practical or a treat. And whose is to say that the receiver even views coffee and cake from Costa as a treat?

Lairymary · 03/12/2021 18:23

Holy crap, that's a shit present!!

Mandyjack · 03/12/2021 18:11

@JustLyra

Four of us in a friend group.

We all do nice birthday presents for each other, and have done for 10+ years.

One of the group is having a tough time and is in the middle of moving house so we decide to do a small gift and a voucher so that it’s easier with our move.
Two of us also made clear we felt a voucher was a better option atm because friend is going to have to lot a house from top to bottom rather unexpectedly the other agreed. They offered to take the money and sort the voucher and a nice card.

They then decided, without any discussion, that there was “too big a risk” our friend would buy practical and boring stuff and not treat themselves.

So they’ve bought a fucking Costa Coffee voucher. Basically so they can only buy coffees and cakes.

Aibu to think that that’s completely out of order, and a shit present

Might as well gone with Next or B&Q if they were going down the voucher route
Jaxxy · 03/12/2021 18:10

YANBU…..dreadful present. Certainly for that amount, do you think she had a panic and ran out of time!

MrsWinkly · 03/12/2021 18:09

Ooh no. It's like being given a teabag subscription.
Hardly a treat. £80 is loads, could have spoiled herself a bit with that and if that means buying stuff for her house with a voucher, that's great.
I'm with you OP, voucher would have been better. Lots of choices as opposed to the limited choices you can make standing at the coffee counter.

Orchid876 · 03/12/2021 18:06

That's very nice of your MIL, I'd take her up on that as it's probably the easiest solution. But I'd still be pissed at voucher buying friend for a while, £80 of coffee is a very random shit present. Her judgement may well have been clouded by the recent promotion that PPs suggested, in which case she's a greedy CF as well as a woman of poor present buying judgement. But bottom line she should have bought what you agreed, it's would t have been that bad if you hadn't discussed it and she just make a bad choice, but to unilaterally decide to buy something else with your money is definitely not on.

nocnoc · 03/12/2021 18:02

It’s the worst idea for a present but I wouldn’t kick off about it. I’d just buy another gift to soften the blow for your friend who is probably going to be really upset by being given that crap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread