Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty about letting this woman go

37 replies

Shouldifeelguilty · 01/12/2021 22:08

I hired a really lovely woman five months ago, provided her with training, and ever since have set her briefs every day. She works from home and we mainly communicate via Slack, video call and phone call.

For the past two months things have been really slipping. We lost two clients due to her being really unresponsive and not completing tasks, we’ve had two clients complain about her, and she will take 3 x longer than anyone else on the team to complete the same task - even those with less experience. This means anyone else working at the same time is having to take on more of the workload.

She ignores my emails (hence the other communication methods) and doesn’t like to do things outside of her own ways.

I’ve checked in multiple times to ask if everything is okay, to check in to see how I can help, to see if there’s anything that she needs help with. She tells me she’s fine and it’s just ‘her way’ of working, but it got to the point where someone else on the team made a complaint, and I decided enough was enough and to let her go.

I’ve been met with comments about her mental health and how this is going to cause her lots of stress and I feel awful and my head is even saying to give her another chance, but I know from previous experience with her (where I have had conversations about the amount of productivity and complaints), that things will go well for a little while and then she will slip into old ways.

So I guess I’m asking AIBU to feel really guilty? Does this feeling ever go away? I’m just trying to do what’s best for others and for the business, but I don’t want to cause distress at the same time.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rangoon · 02/12/2021 09:07

I would have fired her earlier without much guilt. You lost two clients because she didn't do the work and two other clients have complained about her. When she does do something she will take 3 x longer than anyone else on the team to complete the same task. She ignores your emails and likes to do things her own way. Other team members have to pick up the slack for her slowness.

I would feel sorry for the people who had to take on more of the workload because you wouldn't make the hard call. What about their mental health and stress?. Why on earth would you give this lazy woman who is losing you clients and driving your other staff crazy another chance? Frankly if she ignored my emails repeatedly I'd fire her for that alone.

She's only "worked" for you for 5 months so there is no pattern of loyal service to consider because as far as I can see she's been nothing but trouble since the beginning. How many more clients will she offend in another 5 months? You've done everything to help her but there is no sustained improvement. You have to get rid of her to safeguard your business and the jobs of your other staff.

Newestname002 · 02/12/2021 08:31

@Shouldifeelguilty

We lost two clients due to her being really unresponsive and not completing tasks, we’ve had two clients complain about her, and she will take 3 x longer than anyone else on the team to complete the same task - even those with less experience.

I wonder how many other people those clients might have influenced to not giving you their business because of their negative experience?

You've given enough chances to an employee who seems unable or unwilling to work correctly and this will adversely affect your business. 🌹

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 02/12/2021 08:07

I voted YABU basically because you shouldn't have to shoulder the responsibility for her choices over how to work.

In reality, of course YANBU to feel guilt - you are a human being after all - but for your sanity, look at it objectively. She had chances, I presume you were quite clear with her about things going wrong, and she chose to not change.

The mental health comments will be designed to pull at your heart strings and make you feel like the monster. In reality her mental health would probably be lots better if she actually listened to people. I'm a bit Hmm on behalf of people with genuine MH problems, that there are people citing MH for the reason why they should be allowed to be a mini dictatorship.

itchypoopark · 02/12/2021 08:05

I have been in the position of the woman in question. My MH was not good, I had some large scale crises in my personal life, and as a result, my performance at work was inadequate.

I was fully aware that clients, other members of staff and managers were not happy with the way I was working, and I felt enormous stress because I could not focus enough to improve.

I believe, if I had stayed any longer, been given more chances, the stress would have increased.

Being let go from the position gave me the chance to find something much less stressful for a short time, and to focus on getting my mental health and life in order. It was the best thing for me at the time.

Please don't feel guilty. Often, if someone really is not coping, we do them no favours by keeping them in a situation that is simply adding to their pressures.

LethargicActress · 02/12/2021 08:01

Yabu to feel guilty. You don’t owe shit employees a job, but yo do owe your good employees colleagues who will pull their weight. Feel proud of yourself for considering and protecting them instead.

Platax · 02/12/2021 08:00

You can't keep losing your clients through having incompetent staff members. You will feel a whole lot worse if your business goes down the pan.

BurbageBrook · 02/12/2021 07:52

I think if she’s had a formal warning and action steps etc then she’s still not improving then fair enough.

Porcupineintherough · 02/12/2021 07:49

YABU to feel guilty. You have a duty to her colleagues who have to keep picking up the slack, and a duty to your clients to provide a decent service.

ToughTittyWhompus · 02/12/2021 07:48

She’s lost you 2 clients, is endangering relationships with other clients, and is pissing your other employees off.

She also ignores you, refuses to do things a different way despite it fucking the business over.

YABU to feel guilty.

Totalwasteofpaper · 02/12/2021 07:46

@VillanellesOrangeCoat

YABU to feel guilty. Sounds like you’ve put in a lot of effort and support. Ultimately she needs to take responsibility for her own actions which have resulted in having to let her go
This exactly.
MLMshouldbeillegal · 02/12/2021 07:46

She's not working though. You have already lost two clients because of her - how long are you prepared to let that continue?

ProfessorSlocombe · 02/12/2021 07:45

The best way to lose good employees is to keep bad ones.

londonrach · 02/12/2021 07:43

She not doing the job, let her go..you've done your best

girlmom21 · 02/12/2021 07:37

She's proved she can do better than she is but she's choosing not to.

Five months is a long time and if she'd asked for extra support, training etc I would be inclined to give her the benefit of the doubt but it sounds like she didn't.

I'll give people who are struggling as many chances as the business can afford but lazy people don't deserve that

DrSbaitso · 02/12/2021 07:36

@Wintersnuggles10

This is why there is no way I could be a manager. I couldn't fire people. My husband has no problem with it but I would feel horribly guilty and it would play on my mind. You have definitely done the right thing and have all the facts to back up your decision
But if you were working with someone who got paid the same as you or more, while not doing their job and adding to your workload instead, you'd very rightly expect your manager to take action.
Wintersnuggles10 · 02/12/2021 07:35

This is why there is no way I could be a manager. I couldn't fire people. My husband has no problem with it but I would feel horribly guilty and it would play on my mind. You have definitely done the right thing and have all the facts to back up your decision

SoItWas · 02/12/2021 07:29

Yanbu to feel guilty, you'd be unreasonable to bring her back though, not fair on you, the other staff, (or her when you inevitably have to ask her to leave again). It's sad, but she wasn't following your feedback, turned down offers of help, and doesn't seem suited to the job.

simpledeer · 02/12/2021 07:23

OP I have been in a similar position. I assuaged my guilt after speaking to a senior HR person who reminded me that I managed a team, not just one person.

If you don't address this, you are letting down everyone else in the team. They will feel unappreciated, could lose respect for you, might start slacking in their own work.

DrSbaitso · 02/12/2021 07:17

Ultimately, there's a job that needs doing. If your mental health is so poor that you can't do it, even when your employer has taken steps to help you, then they're going to need to make way for someone who can. It's not punitive, but for whatever reason, the job is not within your capabilities.

groovergirl · 02/12/2021 01:49

Her MH issue is not your responsibility -- it's hers.

As one who has WFH these past eight years, and for the five years before that managed freelancers who WFH, let me say that there are few excuses for not meeting deadlines or promptly replying to emails. Serious illness of you or DC, or rush off to help elderly DPs -- OK, as long as you quickly inform your boss. But it seems like your employee had a consistent pattern of wafting off without explanation.

If you as a WFHer have to work overnight or get up early, just bloody well do it.

Five months is plenty of leeway. You're generous, OP; I wouldn't have given it.

user1481840227 · 02/12/2021 01:36

I remember your previous thread (if it wasn't yours then it was the exact same situation but about having to let her go).

You did the right thing. She hasn't given you any other option. This has already had an impact on your business and if you kept her on she would continue to have a negative impact on your business.

I hope you stop feeling guilty soon because you really shouldn't, you were also protecting your other employees mental health, as increased workloads can negatively affect MH too!

QuinceTamarillo · 02/12/2021 00:54

It's natural to feel uncomfortable about firing someone - as my then-boss said the first time I had to do it, someone who actually enjoys firing people probably shouldn't be managing people. I think it's especially hard when it's someone you've personally hired, because you feel like you should have known they'd be a bad fit, or that you could have done something differently.

In this case, though, unless you own the company and can afford to pay another person to do half of the job while this employee does whatever, you have no choice. You've already given her chances and you can't trust her to improve even though it seems she's capable. If MH issues are holding her back, it's best that she gets professional help for them (easier said than done in the current climate, I know). And if she's the one telling you her mental health will be impacted, then she already knows or strongly expects what's coming so better to do it as soon as you can and not give her false hope.

WhereYouLeftIt · 02/12/2021 00:32

"I’ve been met with comments about her mental health and how this is going to cause her lots of stress and I feel awful and my head is even saying to give her another chance, but I know from previous experience with her (where I have had conversations about the amount of productivity and complaints), that things will go well for a little while and then she will slip into old ways.

Have you considered that the comments about her mental health are a pack of lies, and she is deliberately trying to guilt you? That she has found it an effective way to manipulate people so that she can continue to be paid for doing no work? That she is not actually a "really lovely woman" but a plausible and accomplished con-artist?

Lalliella · 02/12/2021 00:22

I think there’s something wrong with your voting options OP. I voted YABU, because I think you’re unreasonable in feeling guilty for letting her go. You should not feel guilty! She can’t do the job, she has to go.

Roisin78 · 02/12/2021 00:07

I've been where you are and I was too soft and bought them back. Huge mistake, they know they can take the piss then. You let her go for good reason, whatever difficulties she's now telling you about she should have addressed with you before, it's too late now. Listen to your gut, you'll regret taking her back