Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school policy is outrageous?

91 replies

wonderstuff · 01/12/2021 19:05

Ds came home yesterday and told me he’d spent the day in isolation because he had forgotten his planner twice. Turns out he’d lost it. The planner is used to record times the kids have forgotten equipment or infringed uniform expectations.

Sent email to school as surely this was wrong, had my son intact sworn or been disruptive? School replied that it is indeed policy to isolate for a day for forgetting a planner twice.

I’m raging. All the missed schooling and they’re happy to exclude a child from more schooling for forgetting something. He’s very forgetful, I have adhd and suspect he has too, he’s not trying to be difficult or subvert the system. He’s in year 7.

I’ve been a teacher 20 years and never know isolation to be used for such a minor infringement. The same punishment for fighting and forgetting a book seems mad?

I’m not sure what to do, this is our local school, we live rurally so not many alternatives. I work at a great, inclusive school and could put him on the waiting list there but it’s 40 minutes away.

The school he’s had recently set for core subjects and he’s in bottom sets as well I’m worried this school is going to break him.

OP posts:
Wolfiefan · 01/12/2021 20:20

If his difficulties are so serious he can’t take a planner to school I would expect primary to have initiated an assessment years ago.
Does seem draconian but some schools come down hard on minor infringements with the hope it improves all other issues.
TBH I would be more concerned with the sets. Is that what you would expect based on previous info from primary?

walnutfalling · 01/12/2021 20:18

Research has said for years that this sort of punishment doesn't work and has a negative impact on kids. I'd be worried that isolation would not only be demotivating, it would have a very negative impact on MH for most kids. It wouldn't be enough to get special dispensation for my dc, they would be surrounded by other kids affected by the policies, it would not make for a positive learning environment generally. I think you need to try to get the policies changed completely or move. The head's head needs a wobble.

Akire · 01/12/2021 20:16

Does seem Overkill. So not only are you bored all day and on own, you then have try catch up on work in my day that was copying friends books. No
Idea how they do that now. Then probable get in more trouble when he can’t understand or fails to do homework he didn’t know about. Next time he notices it’s missing why not just bunk off school for the day instead? What’s the punishment for that? Presumable happy for them
Miss a day in isolation room but not at local shopping centre!

Santaischeckinglists · 01/12/2021 20:16

School policies are crazy ime. Ds was put in isolation due to his school shoes falling apart when the shoe shops were shut mid Covid.. I went and brought him home. After they had tried to take his phone off him for texting me.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 01/12/2021 20:15

@cansu

To me it seems excessive but I assume you knew the behaviour policy when you signed him up? I don't think you can moan about it now.

Many secondary schools have very strict systems now.

Meanwhile in the real world, most people don't have a true choice of secondary schools in their area. It's the catchment school or find the impossible way to get them to a different school that is difficult to get to at start/end times.
echt · 01/12/2021 20:13

@Franklyfrost

I wouldn’t want my son taught by anyone who enforced such that policy. It might be down on paper that a student forgets their planner twice and are put in isolation but what sort of teacher would then go ahead an enforce that? It demonstrates a poor understanding of both eleven year olds and education.
The punishment was downright silly, detention at the most, I'd have thought.

But, teachers don't get to pick and choose which aspects of discipline they enforce, and those that do this make life very hard for those who follow the school's rules.

This needs to be taken up at a higher level.

Doona · 01/12/2021 20:11

But cansu, even if a child was just disorganised, they could still benefit from extra help with planning and being made to sit quietly near the teacher, which is all you get with adhd diagnosis anyway. Better than isolating them for the day.

riceuten · 01/12/2021 20:11

Is this Michaela School ? They'd can you for even thinking about forgetting your planner. So many people love Ms Birbalsingh, but love her a lot less when their child is given isolation for wearing the wrong coloured socks

RandomLondoner · 01/12/2021 20:10

To me it seems excessive but I assume you knew the behaviour policy when you signed him up? I don't think you can moan about it now

I'd guess the majority of families in the country only realistically have access to one state secondary school. (My definition of being realistic includes not paying thousands in moving costs.) I put the nearest secondary (here in London) as fifth choice and that's were DD would have gone, had she not gone private. Even families with more than one option are not going to have plethora of choices.

It's not like OP foolishly rejected 9 other schools with behaviour policies more to her liking.

Sirzy · 01/12/2021 20:08

That seems very excessive.

But now it’s been highlighted it’s an issue then can you help him from home to make sure everything goes in? Ds is in year 7 and is has complex needs so I know he isn’t ready to take over organising his bag completely so I check after school and pack with him in the mornings so I know everything is at least going into school (and homework in a folder marked “finished homework” type stuff) I can then communicate to school if something has gone missing at their end!

Over time he will hopefully be able to take over more of the responsibilities but it stops forgotten things being an issue at least

Moonface123 · 01/12/2021 20:08

Kids are terrified now of making mistakes,.its all wrong, mistakes are part of learning.
Then they try and blame parents for school anxiety and panic epidemic, its a very damaging enviroment.

cansu · 01/12/2021 20:06

Foxivy - I haven't heard that the OP has actually asked the school for adjustments or a support plan before now. I would assume the school would have to have some evidence of need other than the parent's say so. In my own school, the SENCo would gather evidence of the need through assessment and discussions with parents, staff and child themselves. It isn't a case of parents say he might have ADHD so that's that.

cansu · 01/12/2021 20:04

Doona
Whilst many parents are reasonable and honest, some are not. While I am sure the OP has genuine concerns and has no doubt already consulted a professional about her son's difficulties, some parents would tell the school their child has a disorder as an excuse for not following rules or behaving in an acceptable way. ASD, ADHD are medical disorders which need to be diagnosed by a doctor. I have two dc with ASD but that doesn't make me qualified to diagnose anyone else! If the OP has consulted a medical professional and is awaiting an assessment then she could of course approach the school to discuss adjustments for her son. What can't happen is parent dislikes punishment so decides child has condition that excuses them from rules.

FoxIvy · 01/12/2021 20:03

@cansu

Suspecting adhd and actually having already requested an assessment are two different things. You can't accuse them of discrimination if you have not seen the GP and been referred for an assessment. School cannot go on parents' suspicions.
This is incorrect. Funding and support for children with SEND is based on need not diagnosis. To act otherwise could be discriminatory. I'm a SENCO.
Candycotton · 01/12/2021 20:01

that is absolutely ridiculous

PinkMochi · 01/12/2021 20:00

Isolation should only be for behaviour! This punishment was too extreme for forgetting a school planner. What is the punishment for serious offences?

Wondergirl100 · 01/12/2021 20:00

I have ADHD and as a child it was almost impossible to have the things I needed for lessons. I was constantly in trouble.

The modern education system sadly does seem intended to break young people - remove all their autonomy, make them compliant and meak - I have been looking at secondary schools for one of my children and they are all 'silent' 'compliant' schools where not a minute of disruption chat or conversation is allowed.

Franklyfrost · 01/12/2021 19:57

I wouldn’t want my son taught by anyone who enforced such that policy. It might be down on paper that a student forgets their planner twice and are put in isolation but what sort of teacher would then go ahead an enforce that? It demonstrates a poor understanding of both eleven year olds and education.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 01/12/2021 19:57

Is he on the waiting list for an appointment/been seen by a GP while awaiting an appointment?

As long as he’s awaiting assessment the can have a care plan on place, as a teacher I’m concerned your not aware of this?

Peppercorn9 · 01/12/2021 19:56

To me it seems excessive but I assume you knew the behaviour policy when you signed him up? I don't think you can moan about it now.

Of course parents can - and should - question rules/policies that are damaging, ableist and downright batshit. Especially in the state system, which our taxes pay for.

YANBU at all OP. I hope your DS is OK. As the mum of autistic DC I’d be complaining and referring to their SEND policy.

itsgettingwierd · 01/12/2021 19:51

What do they do for an actual serious misdemeanour?

Kids loose stuff. Punishment is meant to be teaching. Much better to give him a job around school to earn a new one.

I'd suggest drawing up a small list of things to check each lesson, laminate and put in blazer pocket.

Fullyhuman · 01/12/2021 19:50

It’s a good question

Yika · 01/12/2021 19:50

I find that totally appalling. What on earth is happening in schools, they seem to have become so draconian.

Fullyhuman · 01/12/2021 19:50

I would move him. I think you’re right about the streaming being extremely bad for him. Children deserve an inclusive and effective education in their local communities, but many don’t get that.

Doona · 01/12/2021 19:47

@cansu

Suspecting adhd and actually having already requested an assessment are two different things. You can't accuse them of discrimination if you have not seen the GP and been referred for an assessment. School cannot go on parents' suspicions.
Why can't they? Serious question.